Oklahoma Case Commentaries

Settlement Agreements with Tribes Are “Intergovernmental Cooperative Agreements” Requiring Approval Under 74 O.S. § 1221(D)(1)

Date: Jun 2, 2026

Settlement Agreements with Tribes Are “Intergovernmental Cooperative Agreements” Requiring Approval Under 74 O.S. § 1221(D)(1) Case: STATE OF OKLAHOMA ex rel. STITT v. CITY OF TULSA Citation: 2026 OK...

Unverified AI-Generated Citations as “Knowing” False Statements Under ORPC 3.3 (Reciprocal Discipline Under RGDP 7.7)

Date: May 28, 2026

Unverified AI-Generated Citations as “Knowing” False Statements Under ORPC 3.3 (Reciprocal Discipline Under RGDP 7.7) I. Introduction STATE OF OKLAHOMA ex rel. OBA v. REEVES, 2026 OK 37, is an...

State Courts Lack Subject-Matter Jurisdiction Over Intratribal Leadership Disputes; Contested Tribal Waivers Cannot Supply Jurisdiction

Date: May 22, 2026

State Courts Lack Subject-Matter Jurisdiction Over Intratribal Leadership Disputes; Contested Tribal Waivers Cannot Supply Jurisdiction I. Introduction ANDERSON v. PARRISH, 2026 OK 36 is an original...

Anderson v. Parish (2026 OK 36) Commentary

Date: May 22, 2026

Purported Tribal Waiver Cannot Create Oklahoma State-Court Jurisdiction When Tribal Leadership Is Contested (Intratribal Governance Disputes Are Nonjusticiable) Introduction ANDERSON v. PARISH, 2026...

Ford v. Oklahoma State Department of Education (2026 OK 35) — Commentary

Date: May 13, 2026

When an Appeal Becomes Moot, Oklahoma Appellate Courts Should Reverse Merits Dismissals and Direct Dismissal Without Prejudice to Avoid Preclusive Effects I. Introduction In FORD v. THE OKLAHOMA...

Post-Accident Consumption to Obscure a DUI Investigation as “Prejudicial to the Administration of Justice” Supporting Attorney Discipline

Date: May 6, 2026

Post-Accident Consumption to Obscure a DUI Investigation as “Prejudicial to the Administration of Justice” Supporting Attorney Discipline 1. Introduction In STATE OF OKLAHOMA ex rel. OBA v. NEWMAN,...

Reinstatement Without Re-Examination: Active Out-of-State Practice Can Rebut Rule 11.5(c)’s Five-Year Presumption

Date: May 6, 2026

Reinstatement Without Re-Examination: Active Out-of-State Practice Can Rebut Rule 11.5(c)’s Five-Year Presumption I. Introduction In the Matter of the Reinstatement of Brian Keith Melton, 2026 OK 33...

Pattern of Violence, Threats, and Harassment—Even While “Retired” and Pro Se—Establishes Unfitness and Warrants Disbarment

Date: May 5, 2026

Pattern of Violence, Threats, and Harassment—Even While “Retired” and Pro Se—Establishes Unfitness and Warrants Disbarment 1. Introduction In STATE OF OKLAHOMA ex rel. OBA v. KELLY JOHN BARLEAN, the...

Nurse Experts Cannot Establish Physician Standard of Care or Medical Causation in Oklahoma Medical Malpractice Claims

Date: May 3, 2026

Nurse Experts Cannot Establish Physician Standard of Care or Medical Causation in Oklahoma Medical Malpractice Claims Introduction In BEAN v. ST. FRANCIS HOSPITAL, 2026 OK 27, the Oklahoma Supreme...

GANN v. STATE OF OKLAHOMA (2026 OK 24) — Issue Exhaustion Required for All Rate-Order Appeals; Public Comments Do Not Preserve Appellate Issues

Date: Apr 23, 2026

GANN v. STATE OF OKLAHOMA (2026 OK 24): Issue Exhaustion Required for All Oklahoma Corporation Commission Rate-Order Appeals—Including Non-Parties; Public Comments Do Not Preserve Issues I....

Betts v. Toyota: Statute of Repose in Oklahoma Product-Liability Conflicts Governed by Restatement § 145 (Not § 146), Typically by the State of Registration/Garage

Date: Apr 17, 2026

Betts v. Toyota: Statute of Repose in Oklahoma Product-Liability Conflicts Governed by Restatement § 145 (Not § 146), Typically by the State of Registration/Garage 1. Introduction Case: BETTS v....

Oklahoma Original Jurisdiction Procedure: Mandatory Combined Application/Petition, Modernized Service, and Repeal of Form 14 (Rule 1.191)

Date: Apr 15, 2026

Oklahoma Original Jurisdiction Procedure: Mandatory Combined Application/Petition, Modernized Service, and Repeal of Form 14 (Rule 1.191) 1. Introduction In In re: AMENDMENTS TO RULE 1.191 OF THE...

Article XXIII, §12 “Exclusive Purpose” Precludes Legislatively Imposed Anti-ESG Divestment Regimes for OPERS

Date: Apr 9, 2026

Article XXIII, §12 “Exclusive Purpose” Precludes Legislatively Imposed Anti-ESG Divestment Regimes for OPERS Case: DON KEENAN v. TODD RUSS, in his capacity as the Treasurer of the State of Oklahoma...

Oklahoma Rule 15 Amendment: “Overruled of Record” Defined and Trial-Judge Authority Stayed Upon a Formal Disqualification/Recusal Motion

Date: Apr 7, 2026

Oklahoma Rule 15 Amendment: “Overruled of Record” Defined and Trial-Judge Authority Stayed Upon a Formal Disqualification/Recusal Motion Introduction In In re: AMENDMENT OF RULE 15 OF THE RULES FOR...

Immediate Adoption of Amended Oklahoma Supreme Court Rule 1.6: Uniform Motion Practice, Page Limits, and Restricted Extensions

Date: Mar 24, 2026

Immediate Adoption of Amended Oklahoma Supreme Court Rule 1.6: Uniform Motion Practice, Page Limits, and Restricted Extensions Case: In re: AMENDMENTS TO RULE 1.6 OF THE OKLAHOMA SUPREME COURT RULES,...

Overbroad Discovery Under 12 O.S. § 3226: Proponent Must Show Claim-or-Defense Relevance When Relevance Is Not Apparent

Date: Mar 13, 2026

Overbroad Discovery Under 12 O.S. § 3226: Proponent Must Show Claim-or-Defense Relevance When Relevance Is Not Apparent Case: CHICK-FIL-A v. THE HONORABLE RICHARD OGDEN & LOZADA Citation: 2026 OK 13...

Oklahoma Derivative-Suit Demand Must Be Specific and Allow a Reasonable Time to Investigate; Three Days Is Unreasonable

Date: Feb 23, 2026

Oklahoma Derivative-Suit Demand Must Be Specific and Allow a Reasonable Time to Investigate; Three Days Is Unreasonable 1. Introduction Howard and Howard v. The Barrington Homeowners Association,...

Reciprocal Discipline Denied When Out-of-Jurisdiction Sanction Adequately Addresses Isolated Misconduct

Date: Feb 13, 2026

Reciprocal Discipline Denied When Out-of-Jurisdiction Sanction Adequately Addresses Isolated Misconduct Case: STATE OF OKLAHOMA ex rel., OBA v. LILE, 2026 OK 6 (Okla. Feb. 10, 2026) Proceeding:...

AWCA § 56(B): One Mandatory Change of Treating Physician, Additional Changes Permitted at the ALJ’s Discretion

Date: Feb 10, 2026

AWCA § 56(B): One Mandatory Change of Treating Physician, Additional Changes Permitted at the ALJ’s Discretion Introduction In ST. ANTHONY v. GOODWIN and the WORKERS’ COMPENSATION COMMISSION (2026 OK...

When a Referendum Petition Voluntarily Includes a Gist Under the Local Development Act, It Must Accurately State TIF Duration Triggers and Maximum Public Assistance

Date: Feb 10, 2026

When a Referendum Petition Voluntarily Includes a Gist Under the Local Development Act, It Must Accurately State TIF Duration Triggers and Maximum Public Assistance Case: ALLISON v. MCCOY-POST, 2026...