Montana Case Commentaries

“No-Waiver Veto”: The Supreme Court of Montana Affirms an Absolute Parental Veto over ICWA Transfer Requests

Date: Aug 7, 2025

“No-Waiver Veto”: The Supreme Court of Montana Affirms an Absolute Parental Veto over ICWA Transfer Requests Introduction In Matter of J.B., YINC, 2025 MT 170 (DA 24-0516), the Supreme Court of...

State v. Alford (2025 MT 171): Montana Supreme Court Affirms the Constitutionality of Mandatory Minimum Custodial Sentences for 4th-and-Subsequent DUI Offenses

Date: Aug 7, 2025

State v. Alford (2025 MT 171): Montana Supreme Court Affirms the Constitutionality of Mandatory Minimum Custodial Sentences for 4th-and-Subsequent DUI Offenses 1. Introduction The Montana Supreme...

Montana Supreme Court Reaffirms Need for Notice and Hearing Before Trial-Court Determination of Ineffective Assistance

Date: Aug 7, 2025

Montana Supreme Court Reaffirms Need for Notice and Hearing Before Trial-Court Determination of Ineffective Assistance Introduction Case: State v. B. Kelsey (2025 MT 173N, DA 23-0230) – non-citable...

State v. Vaska (2025): Consolidating Reasonable-Time Probable-Cause Determinations and Re-Anchoring the “Ability-to-Pay” Rule for Criminal Fines

Date: Aug 7, 2025

State v. Vaska (Mont. 2025): Consolidating Reasonable-Time Probable-Cause Determinations and Re-Anchoring the “Ability-to-Pay” Rule for Criminal Fines 1. Introduction In State v. Harlan G. Vaska,...

“Scrupulous & Meticulous”: The Montana Supreme Court’s Re-affirmation of Ability-to-Pay Findings and Accurate Credit for Time Served in State v. M. Sullivan

Date: Aug 7, 2025

“Scrupulous & Meticulous”: The Montana Supreme Court’s Re-affirmation of Ability-to-Pay Findings and Accurate Credit for Time Served in State v. M. Sullivan 1. Introduction The appeal in State v....

State v. Keech (2025): Revocation Sentences, Concurrent–Consecutive Designations, and the “Facial Illegality” Escape Hatch from Res Judicata

Date: Aug 7, 2025

State v. Keech (2025): Revocation Sentences, Concurrent–Consecutive Designations, and the “Facial Illegality” Escape Hatch from Res Judicata Introduction State v. Keech, 2025 MT 169, is a sweeping...

Brandt v. R&R Mountain Escapes, LLC (2025): Broad Commercial-Use Bans in Restrictive Covenants Unambiguously Prohibit Short-Term Rentals

Date: Jul 23, 2025

Brandt v. R&R Mountain Escapes, LLC (2025): Broad Commercial-Use Bans in Restrictive Covenants Unambiguously Prohibit Short-Term Rentals Introduction Brandt v. R&R Mountain Escapes, LLC, 2025 MT 155,...

Mandating Particularized Explanations: Del Duca v. Skydancer Reinforces Montana Rule 52(a)(3) Duties in Rule 12(b)(6) Dismissals

Date: Jul 23, 2025

Mandating Particularized Explanations: Del Duca v. Skydancer Reinforces Montana Rule 52(a)(3) Duties in Rule 12(b)(6) Dismissals 1. Introduction The Supreme Court of Montana’s 2025 opinion in Del...

“Silence Is Not Consent” & the Objective Test for Attorney Conduct: A Commentary on Marriage of Roadarmel (2025 MT 157N)

Date: Jul 23, 2025

“Silence Is Not Consent” & the Objective Test for Attorney Conduct: A Comprehensive Commentary on Marriage of Roadarmel (Sup. Ct. Mont. 2025) I. Introduction In Marriage of Roadarmel, the Montana...

HomeRiver v. Anders Business Solutions: Reaffirming the Strict Majority-Member Exception for LLC Self-Representation in Montana Justice Courts

Date: Jul 16, 2025

HomeRiver v. Anders Business Solutions: Reaffirming the Strict Majority-Member Exception for LLC Self-Representation in Montana Justice Courts Supreme Court of Montana – 2025 MT 154N Appeal No. DA...

When Guardianship Leaves the Wallet Closed: Montana Supreme Court Confirms the Primacy of a Durable Power of Attorney in Selecting a Conservator – Commentary on Conservatorship of S.H.C. (2025 MT 151N)

Date: Jul 10, 2025

When Guardianship Leaves the Wallet Closed: Montana Supreme Court Confirms the Primacy of a Durable Power of Attorney in Selecting a Conservator Commentary on Conservatorship of S.H.C., 2025 MT 151N...

Probate Courts May Approve Estate-Related Settlements and Are Reviewed for Abuse of Discretion: A Commentary on Estate of Elliot, 2025 MT 149

Date: Jul 10, 2025

Probate Courts May Approve Estate-Related Settlements and Are Reviewed for Abuse of Discretion: A Comprehensive Commentary on Estate of Elliot, 2025 MT 149 Introduction Estate of Elliot is the...

Equitable Rescission in Grantor-Support Agreements Clarified: Commentary on Helvik v. Tuscano (2025 MT 150)

Date: Jul 10, 2025

Equitable Rescission in Grantor-Support Agreements Clarified: Comprehensive Commentary on Helvik v. Tuscano, 2025 MT 150 Introduction Helvik v. Tuscano is the Montana Supreme Court’s most significant...

Colver Estate Jurisdiction Rule: Probate Courts Cannot Determine Third-Party Equitable Ownership of Estate Property

Date: Jul 10, 2025

Colver Estate Jurisdiction Rule: Probate Courts Cannot Determine Third-Party Equitable Ownership of Estate Property 1. Introduction In In the Matter of the Estate of Rosemary E. Colver, 2025 MT 146,...

Ragner v. State: Reinforcing the Strickland Prejudice Threshold for Omitted-Witness Ineffective-Assistance Claims

Date: Jul 10, 2025

Ragner v. State: Reinforcing the Strickland Prejudice Threshold for Omitted-Witness Ineffective-Assistance Claims 1. Introduction Shelby Ragner was convicted by a Gallatin County jury of Sexual...

“Private Words, Public Peace” – State v. Baertsch and the Public-Disturbance Threshold for Disorderly Conduct

Date: Jul 10, 2025

“Private Words, Public Peace” – State v. Baertsch and the Public-Disturbance Threshold for Disorderly Conduct 1. Introduction State v. Douglas Baertsch, 2025 MT 143, is a high-profile decision of the...

Schultz and the “Fictional Victim” Rule: Mandatory-Minimum Enhancements Require an Actual Child Victim

Date: Jul 10, 2025

Schultz and the “Fictional Victim” Rule: Mandatory-Minimum Enhancements Require an Actual Child Victim Introduction State v. Schultz, 2025 MT 142, arises from an Internet sting in which David Ray...

“Failing the PSI”: How Non-Compliance with Presentence Investigation Requirements Constitutes a Material Breach that Releases the State from Its Plea-Agreement Sentencing Recommendation — Commentary on State v. N. Huff, 2025 MT 152N

Date: Jul 10, 2025

“Failing the PSI”: How Non-Compliance with Presentence Investigation Requirements Constitutes a Material Breach that Releases the State from Its Plea-Agreement Sentencing Recommendation — Commentary...

“Two Paths for Victim-Violence Evidence”: Clarifying Rule 404(a)(2) & 405(a) After State v. Donahue (2025 MT 144)

Date: Jul 10, 2025

“Two Paths for Victim-Violence Evidence” Clarifying Rule 404(a)(2) & 405(a) in Self-Defense Cases — Commentary on State v. R. Donahue, 2025 MT 144 1. Introduction In State v. Donahue the Montana...

Illustrative Evidence vs. Testimonial Content: The Montana Supreme Court’s Clarification on Jury Access to Child-Witness Drawings in State v. Walks (2025 MT 147)

Date: Jul 10, 2025

Illustrative Evidence vs. Testimonial Content: The Montana Supreme Court’s Clarification on Jury Access to Child-Witness Drawings in State v. Walks (2025 MT 147) Introduction State v. Stephen Eric...