Montana Case Commentaries

“Restoring the Road”: Stephenson v. Lone Peak – 2025 MT 148 and the Refined Status-Quo Test for Preliminary Injunctions in Easement Disputes

Date: Jul 10, 2025

“Restoring the Road”: Stephenson v. Lone Peak – 2025 MT 148 and the Refined Status-Quo Test for Preliminary Injunctions in Easement Disputes Introduction Stephenson v. Lone Peak, 2025 MT 148, is the...

“No Emergency of One’s Own Making” – The Montana Supreme Court Clarifies Timeliness and Factual Sufficiency for Original Jurisdiction Petitions

Date: Jul 4, 2025

“No Emergency of One’s Own Making” – The Montana Supreme Court Clarifies Timeliness and Factual Sufficiency for Original Jurisdiction Petitions 1. Introduction On 1 July 2025, the Supreme Court of...

Settlement Offers Do Not Waive Contractual Conditions Precedent – A Commentary on Kratzer Construction v. Hardy Construction (2025 MT 140)

Date: Jul 4, 2025

Settlement Offers Do Not Waive Contractual Conditions Precedent Commentary on Kratzer Construction v. Hardy Construction Co., Inc., 2025 MT 140 Introduction In Kratzer Construction v. Hardy...

Testimony by Non-Presiding Judges and the Discretionary Weight of GAL Recommendations in Montana Parenting-Plan Litigation

Date: Jul 4, 2025

Testimony by Non-Presiding Judges and the Discretionary Weight of Guardian Ad Litem Recommendations in Montana Parenting-Plan Litigation 1. Introduction Case: In re the Marriage of Kahl & Sperano,...

Stipulations and Harmless Error: The Montana Supreme Court Refines Right-to-Counsel Violations, Tribal Transfer Motions, and ICWA Placement in In re I.R.S. & M.W.A.H.

Date: Jul 4, 2025

Stipulations and Harmless Error: The Montana Supreme Court Refines Right-to-Counsel Violations, Tribal Transfer Motions, and ICWA Placement in In re I.R.S. & M.W.A.H. Introduction On 1 July 2025 the...

“More Than a Question”: The Montana Supreme Court Clarifies that a Mere Inquiry Is Not a Motion to Transfer under MICWA § 41-3-1310 and Re-confirms the Narrow Scope of Relative Intervention in Indian Child Guardianships

Date: Jul 4, 2025

“More Than a Question”: The Montana Supreme Court Clarifies that a Mere Inquiry Is Not a Motion to Transfer under MICWA § 41-3-1310 and Re-confirms the Narrow Scope of Relative Intervention in Indian...

State v. Warr: Mandatory Second-Chance Withdrawal after Rejection of a Binding Plea Agreement under § 46-12-211(4), MCA

Date: Jul 4, 2025

State v. Warr: Mandatory Second-Chance Withdrawal after Rejection of a Binding Plea Agreement under § 46-12-211(4), MCA Introduction In State v. J. Warr, 2025 MT 138, the Montana Supreme Court...

State v. Welzel: Clarifying “Under the Order of the Court” for Credit on Time Spent in Residential Treatment Facilities

Date: Jul 4, 2025

State v. Welzel: Clarifying “Under the Order of the Court” for Credit on Time Spent in Residential Treatment Facilities Introduction State v. Welzel, 2025 MT 136, is a decision of the Supreme Court...

Expanding Fee-Shifting under Montana’s UDJA: A Commentary on Upper Missouri Waterkeeper v. DNRC (2025)

Date: Jul 4, 2025

Expanding Fee-Shifting under Montana’s UDJA: A Detailed Commentary on Upper Missouri Waterkeeper v. Broadwater County & DNRC (2025 MT 137) 1. Introduction Upper Missouri Waterkeeper, several local...

“Speculation Is Not a Fact” – The Montana Supreme Court’s Clarification of Due-Process Limits on Victim-Impact Statements in State v. C. Jacob

Date: Jun 25, 2025

“Speculation Is Not a Fact” – The Montana Supreme Court’s Clarification of Due-Process Limits on Victim-Impact Statements in State v. C. Jacob I. Introduction On 24 June 2025, the Supreme Court of...

State v. Matthews: Re-defining the Weight of Officer Testimony versus Dash-Cam Evidence in Particularized Suspicion Analysis

Date: Jun 25, 2025

State v. Matthews: Re-defining the Weight of Officer Testimony versus Dash-Cam Evidence in Particularized Suspicion Analysis Introduction State v. T. Matthews, 2025 MT 129, presented the Montana...

Waiver-by-Mootness: The Montana Supreme Court Clarifies Jurisdiction After Insurer’s Post-Payment “Reservation of Rights” (Commentary on Perea v. AmTrust Ins., 2025 MT 130)

Date: Jun 25, 2025

Waiver-by-Mootness: The Montana Supreme Court Clarifies Jurisdiction After Insurer’s Post-Payment “Reservation of Rights” Commentary on Perea v. AmTrust Insurance Co., 2025 MT 130 Introduction Perea...

“No Live Case, No Power to Hear”: Hawkins v. State (2025) and the Jurisdictional Pre-Condition for Interlocutory Appeals from the Montana Tax Appeal Board

Date: Jun 25, 2025

“No Live Case, No Power to Hear”: Hawkins v. State, 2025 MT 134 — Cementing the Rule that District Court Interlocutory Jurisdiction under § 15-2-305, MCA, Requires an Active MTAB Proceeding...

Distinct Penetrations, Distinct Crimes: State v. Foster Establishes Clear Test for Multiple Sexual-Offense Charges and Limits on Presence-of-Defendant Error

Date: Jun 25, 2025

Distinct Penetrations, Distinct Crimes: State v. Foster Establishes Clear Test for Multiple Sexual-Offense Charges and Limits on Presence-of-Defendant Error Introduction State v. Donald Edward...

“Rebutting the Fit-Parent Presumption” – Grandchild Visitation of A.L.U. (2025 MT 131)

Date: Jun 25, 2025

“Rebutting the Fit-Parent Presumption” – Grandchild Visitation of A.L.U. (Supreme Court of Montana, 2025 MT 131) Introduction In In re the Grandparent–Grandchild Visitation of A.L.U., 2025 MT 131,...

Harris Estate v. Reilly: Montana Supreme Court Requires Sanctions for Last-Minute Voluntary Dismissals under Rule 41(a)(2)

Date: Jun 20, 2025

Harris Estate v. Reilly: Montana Supreme Court Requires Sanctions for Last-Minute Voluntary Dismissals under Rule 41(a)(2) Introduction In Estate of William Harris III v. Reilly, 2025 MT 126, the...

Knudsen v. University of Montana: 2025 MT 125 – Clarifying the Use of Regulatory Compliance Experts and the Scope of a University’s Fiduciary Duty

Date: Jun 20, 2025

Knudsen v. University of Montana: 2025 MT 125 – Clarifying the Use of Regulatory Compliance Experts and the Scope of a University’s Fiduciary Duty 1. Introduction Knudsen v. University of Montana...

Caldwell v. Caldwell: Judicial Duty to Verify Property Valuations Despite Parties’ Settlement Agreements

Date: Jun 20, 2025

Caldwell v. Caldwell: Judicial Duty to Verify Property Valuations Despite Parties’ Settlement Agreements 1. Introduction In Marriage of: Caldwell, 2025 MT 127N, the Supreme Court of Montana addressed...

“Similar Means Similar”: The Majority-Outcome Test for Out-of-State DUI Enhancements after State v. Lapointe

Date: Jun 20, 2025

“Similar Means Similar”: The Majority-Outcome Test for Out-of-State DUI Enhancements after State v. Lapointe Introduction In State v. C. Lapointe, 2025 MT 124, the Supreme Court of Montana confronted...

Forcible-Felony Instruction as a De Facto “Defense-of-Others” Charge: Commentary on State v. C. Rossbach (2025)

Date: Jun 20, 2025

Forcible-Felony Instruction as a De Facto “Defense-of-Others” Charge: A Comprehensive Commentary on State v. C. Rossbach, 2025 MT 128N Introduction State v. Cavey Little Rossbach, 2025 MT 128N, is a...