Montana Case Commentaries

No Ex Post Facto Relief Where Duty Pre‑Existed 2007 SVORA: Waiver by Unconditional Plea and Direct‑Appeal Bar Reaffirmed (Benton v. State, Mont. 2025) – Nonprecedential

Date: Aug 31, 2025

No Ex Post Facto Relief Where Duty Pre‑Existed 2007 SVORA: Waiver by Unconditional Plea and Direct‑Appeal Bar Reaffirmed Benton v. State, 2025 MT 191N (Mont. Aug. 26, 2025) — Memorandum opinion,...

Girasole v. Paws Up: Inherent Risk Defines Duty—No Liability Without Atypical Hazards or Statutory Exception Under Montana’s Equine Activities Act

Date: Aug 31, 2025

Girasole v. Paws Up: Inherent Risk Defines Duty—No Liability Without Atypical Hazards or Statutory Exception Under Montana’s Equine Activities Act Introduction In Girasole v. Paws Up, the Supreme...

Logical Inferences Must Be Record‑Rooted: Montana Supreme Court Clarifies the “Some Evidence” Threshold for Self‑Defense Jury Instructions in State v. Holcomb (2025 MT 190)

Date: Aug 31, 2025

Logical Inferences Must Be Record‑Rooted: Montana Supreme Court Clarifies the “Some Evidence” Threshold for Self‑Defense Jury Instructions in State v. Holcomb (2025 MT 190) Introduction In State v....

Email Notice Counts: Montana Supreme Court Clarifies PFO Notice “Given” Need Not Be Filed by the Omnibus Deadline and Minor Tardiness Does Not Mandate Reversal Absent Prejudice

Date: Aug 31, 2025

Email Notice Counts: Montana Supreme Court Clarifies PFO Notice “Given” Need Not Be Filed by the Omnibus Deadline and Minor Tardiness Does Not Mandate Reversal Absent Prejudice Case Comment: State v....

The Temple Clarification on Cross-Jurisdiction Brady Obligations

Date: Aug 25, 2025

The Temple Clarification on Cross-Jurisdiction Brady Obligations Introduction In G. Temple v. State, 2025 MT 185, the Supreme Court of Montana addressed whether a state prosecutor’s constitutional...

Boeshans v. Boeshans: Conditioning Parenting Rights on Court-Ordered Evaluations and Clarifying Ownership of Professional Limited Liability Companies

Date: Aug 25, 2025

Boeshans v. Boeshans: Conditioning Parenting Rights on Court-Ordered Evaluations and Clarifying Ownership of Professional Limited Liability Companies Introduction The Supreme Court of Montana, in In...

Silence Isn’t Golden: Waiver of the Right to Compel Arbitration When Setting-Aside a Default — Commentary on Monarch Heating & Cooling, LLC v. Petra, Inc.

Date: Aug 25, 2025

Silence Isn’t Golden: Waiver of the Right to Compel Arbitration When Setting-Aside a Default — Commentary on Monarch Heating & Cooling, LLC v. Petra, Inc. I. Introduction The Supreme Court of...

State v. Barrus: Distinguishing “Knowing” from “Appreciating” Criminality in Post-Conviction Mental-Health Sentencing

Date: Aug 25, 2025

State v. Barrus: Distinguishing “Knowing” from “Appreciating” Criminality in Post-Conviction Mental-Health Sentencing 1. Introduction State v. L. Barrus (2025 MT 183) required the Supreme Court of...

State v. Walton ‑ Prosecutorial Limits on Parole-Restriction Recommendations When Plea Agreements Are Asymmetrical

Date: Aug 25, 2025

State v. Walton (2025 MT 186): Prosecutorial Limits on Parole-Restriction Recommendations When Plea Agreements Are Asymmetrical Introduction In State v. M. Walton the Supreme Court of Montana...

Safeguarding the Residential Status Quo: Byron v. Rainbow Estates HOA and the Stringent Application of Montana’s Preliminary-Injunction Test in Covenant–Enforcement Disputes

Date: Aug 15, 2025

Safeguarding the Residential Status Quo: Byron v. Rainbow Estates HOA and the Stringent Application of Montana’s Preliminary-Injunction Test in Covenant–Enforcement Disputes 1. Introduction Byron v....

Montana Supreme Court Clarifies Curative Effect of Post-Hearing Findings on Premature Ex Parte Third-Party Parenting Orders – Commentary on In re Parenting of D.C.S., 2025 MT 179

Date: Aug 15, 2025

Montana Supreme Court Clarifies Curative Effect of Post-Hearing Findings on Premature Ex Parte Third-Party Parenting Orders A Commentary on In re Parenting of D.C.S., 2025 MT 179 (DA 24-0547) 1....

Jackson v. Jackson: Montana High Court Confirms Right to Discovery & Hearing Once “Changed Circumstances” Are Plausibly Alleged in Child-Support Modifications

Date: Aug 15, 2025

Jackson v. Jackson: Montana High Court Confirms Right to Discovery & Hearing Once “Changed Circumstances” Are Plausibly Alleged in Child-Support Modifications 1. Introduction The Montana Supreme...

“Public-Interest Override” After the 2017 Amendments – Matter of B.J.B. and the Court’s Discretion to Impose Lifetime Sex-Offender Registration on Juveniles

Date: Aug 15, 2025

“Public-Interest Override” After the 2017 Amendments – Supreme Court of Montana Clarifies Judicial Discretion to Require Lifetime Sex-Offender Registration for Juveniles 1. Introduction The Supreme...

Matter of S.W. & D.W.: Clarifying Montana’s “No-Reunification Efforts” Exception Where Prior Terminations and Chronic, Severe Neglect Co-Exist

Date: Aug 15, 2025

Matter of S.W. & D.W. (2025 MT 178): Clarifying Montana’s “No-Reunification Efforts” Exception Where Prior Terminations and Chronic, Severe Neglect Co-Exist 1. Introduction The Supreme Court of...

2025 MT 178 – When “No Reasonable Efforts” Meets Prior Terminations: The Supreme Court of Montana Sharpens the Boundaries of § 41-3-423, MCA

Date: Aug 15, 2025

2025 MT 178 – When “No Reasonable Efforts” Meets Prior Terminations: Clarifying the Department’s Obligation and Defining “Chronic, Severe Neglect” Introduction In Matter of S.W. & D.W., 2025 MT 178,...

State v. Songer (2025 MT 176): Re-affirming the Unavailability Requirement for Remote Testimony and the Necessity of Re-Sentencing When Dependent Convictions Are Vacated

Date: Aug 15, 2025

State v. Songer (2025 MT 176): Re-affirming the Unavailability Requirement for Remote Testimony and the Necessity of Re-Sentencing When Dependent Convictions Are Vacated Introduction In State v. J....

The “Songer Standard” – Mandatory Proof of Witness Unavailability Before Playing Preserved Testimony

Date: Aug 15, 2025

The “Songer Standard” – Mandatory Proof of Witness Unavailability Before Playing Preserved Testimony Introduction State v. J. Songer, 2025 MT 176, is a multi-issue decision from the Montana Supreme...

State v. Songer: Montana Supreme Court Demands Strict Proof of Witness “Unavailability” Before Video Testimony Is Admitted

Date: Aug 15, 2025

State v. Songer: Montana Supreme Court Demands Strict Proof of Witness “Unavailability” Before Video Testimony Is Admitted Introduction In State v. Jory Jerae Songer, 2025 MT 176, the Supreme Court...

Assignment-as-Cancellation Doctrine: Montana Supreme Court Redefines Policy Transfers in Victory Insurance v. State (2025 MT 180)

Date: Aug 15, 2025

Assignment-as-Cancellation Doctrine: Montana Supreme Court Redefines Policy Transfers in Victory Insurance v. State (2025 MT 180) 1. Introduction Victory Insurance Company (“Victory”), a Montana...

“No Lay Representation & No Straw-Man”: Skurdal v. Walker and the Supreme Court of Montana’s Firm Reaffirmation of Judicial Immunity and Rejection of Sovereign-Citizen Arguments

Date: Aug 13, 2025

“No Lay Representation & No Straw-Man”: Skurdal v. Walker and the Supreme Court of Montana’s Firm Reaffirmation of Judicial Immunity and Rejection of Sovereign-Citizen Arguments 1. Introduction In R....