Minnesota Case Commentaries

No Interlocutory Appeals Under Rule 103.03(b) for Trust Code Orders Restoring Property or Removing a Trustee

Date: Sep 25, 2025

No Interlocutory Appeals Under Rule 103.03(b) for Trust Code Orders Restoring Property or Removing a Trustee Introduction In this precedential decision, the Minnesota Supreme Court clarifies a...

“Received” Means Where Any Recipient Takes Possession: Minnesota Supreme Court Clarifies Service-Receipt Sourcing Is Not Limited to Direct Customers

Date: Sep 25, 2025

“Received” Means Where Any Recipient Takes Possession: Minnesota Supreme Court Clarifies Service-Receipt Sourcing Is Not Limited to Direct Customers Introduction In Humana MarketPoint, Inc., Relator...

Waiver-by-Acceptance Applies Equally to Publicly Subsidized and Private Tenancies; “Acceptance” Is a Fact Question Assessed by the Totality of Circumstances

Date: Sep 25, 2025

Waiver-by-Acceptance Applies Equally to Publicly Subsidized and Private Tenancies; “Acceptance” Is a Fact Question Assessed by the Totality of Circumstances Introduction In Hook & Ladder Apartments,...

Two-Track Specificity for Restitution Challenges: Minnesota Supreme Court Requires Offenders to Specify “Item” versus “Amount” under Minn. Stat. § 611A.045, subd. 3(a) — State v. Seeman (2025)

Date: Sep 25, 2025

Two-Track Specificity for Restitution Challenges: Minnesota Supreme Court Requires Offenders to Specify “Item” versus “Amount” under Minn. Stat. § 611A.045, subd. 3(a) Introduction In State of...

When Legal Error Becomes Judicial Misconduct: Minnesota Supreme Court Adopts “Clear and Determined Law + Egregiousness” Test and Holds Rule 2.3(A) Requires Actual Bias

Date: Sep 23, 2025

When Legal Error Becomes Judicial Misconduct: Minnesota Supreme Court Adopts “Clear and Determined Law + Egregiousness” Test and Holds Rule 2.3(A) Requires Actual Bias Introduction In Inquiry into...

“At Any Time” Means At Any Time: Minnesota High Court Allows Unlimited Window to Seek Withdrawal of TPR Admissions and Imposes Prima Facie Hearing Threshold

Date: Sep 18, 2025

“At Any Time” Means At Any Time: Minnesota High Court Allows Unlimited Window to Seek Withdrawal of TPR Admissions and Imposes Prima Facie Hearing Threshold Decision: In the Matter of the Welfare of...

No Duty to Plead Around Affirmative Defenses: Minnesota Adopts “Unrebuttable Defense” Standard for Rule 12 Dismissals and Vacates Early Fee Awards

Date: Sep 11, 2025

No Duty to Plead Around Affirmative Defenses: Minnesota Adopts “Unrebuttable Defense” Standard for Rule 12 Dismissals and Vacates Early Fee Awards Introduction In Doug Hoskin v. Josh Krsnak, the...

Bright-Line Ban on Extra-Record Fact-Finding in Postconviction Proceedings: Structural Error Under the Minnesota Constitution (State v. Duol)

Date: Sep 4, 2025

Bright-Line Ban on Extra-Record Fact-Finding in Postconviction Proceedings: Structural Error Under the Minnesota Constitution Introduction In State of Minnesota v. Buay David Duol (Minn. Sept. 3,...

DuPont v. Commissioner: Minnesota Endorses Net-Income Apportionment for Hedging Receipts and Allows Denominator-Only Distortion Showing Under § 290.20

Date: Aug 28, 2025

DuPont v. Commissioner: Minnesota Endorses Net-Income Apportionment for Hedging Receipts and Allows Denominator-Only Distortion Showing Under § 290.20 Introduction In E. I. duPont de Nemours and...

State v. Lerma: Defendant-Requested Mistrial Precludes a Double Jeopardy Bar Absent Intentional Government Provocation; Judges Count as “Government” and No Implied Withdrawal

Date: Aug 28, 2025

Consent Controls: Minnesota Supreme Court Clarifies Double Jeopardy After Defendant-Requested Mistrials Introduction In State of Minnesota v. Johnnie Lerma, the Minnesota Supreme Court addressed when...

No Due Process Bar from Post-Discharge Statutory Change; Mens Rea Under Minn. Stat. § 624.713, subd. 1(2) Requires Knowledge of Prior Conviction, Not Knowledge of Status

Date: Aug 28, 2025

No Due Process Bar from Post-Discharge Statutory Change; Mens Rea Under Minn. Stat. § 624.713, subd. 1(2) Requires Knowledge of Prior Conviction, Not Knowledge of Status Introduction In Joel Armen...

Judicial Factfinding Permitted for § 609.035 Arson–Concealment Exception; Clarified Standards for “Significant Relationship” and “Past Pattern” in Minnesota First-Degree Domestic‑Abuse Murder

Date: Aug 21, 2025

Judicial Factfinding Permitted for § 609.035 Arson–Concealment Exception; Clarified Standards for “Significant Relationship” and “Past Pattern” in Minnesota First-Degree Domestic‑Abuse Murder...

Tribal Courts Recognized as “Jurisdictions” for Reciprocal Discipline; Minnesota Clarifies the RLPR 12(d) Analysis and Rejects Comity Weighting — In re Martins

Date: Aug 14, 2025

Tribal Courts Recognized as “Jurisdictions” for Reciprocal Discipline; Minnesota Clarifies the RLPR 12(d) Analysis and Rejects Comity Weighting Introduction In In re Petition for Disciplinary Action...

Preverdict Interest Under Minn. Stat. § 549.09: Settlement Offers Do Not Excuse the Two‑Year Commencement Rule; Interest Runs on the Net Judgment Excluding Collateral Sources

Date: Aug 14, 2025

Preverdict Interest Under Minn. Stat. § 549.09: Settlement Offers Do Not Excuse the Two‑Year Commencement Rule; Interest Runs on the Net Judgment Excluding Collateral Sources Introduction In Lee...

No Group Frisk Without Particularized Suspicion: Minnesota Supreme Court Clarifies Terry Limits in In re Welfare of C.T.B. (2025)

Date: Aug 14, 2025

No Group Frisk Without Particularized Suspicion: Minnesota Supreme Court Clarifies Terry Limits in In re Welfare of C.T.B. (2025) Introduction In In the Matter of the Welfare of: C.T.B., 24 N.W.3d...

Direct Employee Recovery of Health-Insurer-Paid Medical Expenses and Extinguishment of Non‑Intervening Insurers’ Interests under Minnesota’s Workers’ Compensation Act

Date: Aug 7, 2025

Direct Employee Recovery of Health-Insurer-Paid Medical Expenses and Extinguishment of Non‑Intervening Insurers’ Interests under Minnesota’s Workers’ Compensation Act Introduction In Paula Kay...

No State Serial-Number Crime for Ghost Guns Absent a Federal Mandate: Minnesota Supreme Court Limits Minn. Stat. § 609.667(3) to Firearms Requiring Serial Numbers Under Federal Law

Date: Aug 7, 2025

No State Serial-Number Crime for Ghost Guns Absent a Federal Mandate: Minnesota Supreme Court Limits Minn. Stat. § 609.667(3) to Firearms Requiring Serial Numbers Under Federal Law Introduction In...

State v. Nyonteh: Sleeping Jurors Are Not Juror Misconduct; Abuse-of-Discretion Standard Governs Removal

Date: Jul 31, 2025

State v. Nyonteh: Sleeping Jurors Are Not Juror Misconduct; Abuse-of-Discretion Standard Governs Removal Introduction In State of Minnesota v. James Nyonteh, 24 N.W.3d 271 (Minn. 2025), the Minnesota...

Speak Now or Forfeit: Minnesota Supreme Court Reaffirms Strict Preservation for Restitution Challenges and Narrows Use of the “Legal Authority” Exception

Date: Jul 31, 2025

Speak Now or Forfeit: Minnesota Supreme Court Reaffirms Strict Preservation for Restitution Challenges and Narrows Use of the “Legal Authority” Exception Introduction In State of Minnesota v. Erick...

Setting the Standard: Abuse-of-Discretion Review for Preliminary Denials Under Minnesota’s 2023 Aiding-and-Abetting Felony-Murder Relief Act

Date: Jul 31, 2025

Setting the Standard: Abuse-of-Discretion Review for Preliminary Denials Under Minnesota’s 2023 Aiding-and-Abetting Felony-Murder Relief Act Case: State of Minnesota v. Diamond Lee Jamal Griffin...