Michigan Case Commentaries

City of Zeeland Not Liable as an Intended Third-Party Beneficiary: Comprehensive Review of Brunsell v. City of Zeeland

Date: Sep 25, 2002

City of Zeeland Not Liable as an Intended Third-Party Beneficiary: Comprehensive Review of Brunsell v. City of Zeeland Introduction The case of Eleanor Brunsell v. City of Zeeland, adjudicated by the...

Linda MACK v. CITY OF DETROIT: Reaffirming Governmental Immunity and Its Implications

Date: Aug 1, 2002

Linda MACK v. CITY OF DETROIT: Reaffirming Governmental Immunity and Its Implications Introduction Linda MACK v. CITY OF DETROIT, 467 Mich. 186 (2002), is a pivotal case decided by the Supreme Court...

Clarification of 'Duty to Retreat' and the 'Castle Doctrine' in Michigan Self-Defense Law

Date: Aug 1, 2002

Clarification of 'Duty to Retreat' and the 'Castle Doctrine' in Michigan Self-Defense Law Introduction The case of People of the State of Michigan v. Marcel R. Riddle (467 Mich. 116) serves as a...

Michigan Supreme Court Upholds Enforceability of Restrictive Covenants Prohibiting Commercial Uses in Residential Subdivisions

Date: Jul 26, 2002

Michigan Supreme Court Upholds Enforceability of Restrictive Covenants Prohibiting Commercial Uses in Residential Subdivisions Introduction The case of Janice Terrien, Thomas Hagen, and Janet Thomas...

Allocution Opportunity Satisfied Through General Inquiry: Michigan Supreme Court Overrules Specific Inquiry Requirement

Date: Jul 18, 2002

Allocution Opportunity Satisfied Through General Inquiry: Michigan Supreme Court Overrules Specific Inquiry Requirement Introduction People of the State of Michigan v. Linda Petit, 466 Mich. 624...

Examination Under Oath Provisions in No-Fault Auto Insurance: Harmonizing Contract Terms with Statutory Mandates

Date: Jul 18, 2002

Examination Under Oath Provisions in No-Fault Auto Insurance: Harmonizing Contract Terms with Statutory Mandates Introduction The case of Peter Cruz, Jr. v. State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance...

Silver v. People: Establishing the Necessity of Lesser Included Offense Instructions

Date: Jun 26, 2002

Silver v. People: Establishing the Necessity of Lesser Included Offense Instructions 1. Introduction Silver v. People is a landmark case decided by the Supreme Court of Michigan on June 25, 2002. The...

Overruling the 'No Inference on an Inference' Doctrine: Implications of People v. Hardiman

Date: Jun 26, 2002

Overruling the 'No Inference on an Inference' Doctrine: Implications of People v. Hardiman Introduction In the landmark case People v. Hardiman, the Supreme Court of Michigan confronted pivotal...

Clarifying Lesser Included Offense Instructions: Michigan Supreme Court Sets New Precedent in People v. Cornell

Date: Jun 19, 2002

Clarifying Lesser Included Offense Instructions: Michigan Supreme Court Sets New Precedent in People v. Cornell Introduction In the landmark case of People of the State of Michigan v. Adam Keith...

Coordination of Unemployment Benefits with Pension Funds: A Comprehensive Analysis of Koonz v. Ameritech Services, Inc.

Date: Jun 13, 2002

Coordination of Unemployment Benefits with Pension Funds: A Comprehensive Analysis of Koonz v. Ameritech Services, Inc. Introduction Nancy Koontz, the plaintiff-appellee, initiated legal proceedings...

Strict Adherence to Notice Requirements Under MCL 600.2912b for Tolling Statute of Limitations in Medical Malpractice Claims

Date: Apr 25, 2002

Strict Adherence to Notice Requirements Under MCL 600.2912b for Tolling Statute of Limitations in Medical Malpractice Claims Introduction The case of Lisa ROBERTS v. MECOSTA COUNTY GENERAL HOSPITAL...

Michigan Supreme Court Restricts Governmental Immunity: Overruling the Trespass-Nuisance Exception

Date: Apr 3, 2002

Michigan Supreme Court Restricts Governmental Immunity: Overruling the Trespass-Nuisance Exception Introduction In the landmark case Pohutski et al. v. City of Allen Park, the Supreme Court of...

Reaffirmation of Effective Assistance of Counsel Standards in People v. LeBlanc

Date: Mar 13, 2002

Reaffirmation of Effective Assistance of Counsel Standards in People v. LeBlanc Introduction People of the State of Michigan, Plaintiff-Appellant, Cross-Appellee, v. William Emery LeBlanc,...

Michigan Supreme Court Limits Public Duty Doctrine to Police Protection

Date: Jul 28, 2001

Michigan Supreme Court Limits Public Duty Doctrine to Police Protection Introduction In NICOLE M. BEAUDRIE v. PAULINE HENDERSON (465 Mich. 124), the Michigan Supreme Court addressed the scope of the...

Knowledge of Quantity as an Element in Conspiracy to Deliver Offenses: Insights from PEOPLE v. MASS

Date: Jul 6, 2001

Knowledge of Quantity as an Element in Conspiracy to Deliver Offenses: Insights from PEOPLE v. MASS Introduction In the landmark case of People of the State of Michigan v. Jimmy Mass (464 Mich. 615),...

Blossom J. Hazle v. Ford Motor Company: Application of McDonnell Douglas Burden-Shifting in Race Discrimination Claims under MCRA

Date: Jul 4, 2001

Blossom J. Hazle v. Ford Motor Company: Application of McDonnell Douglas Burden-Shifting in Race Discrimination Claims under MCRA Introduction Blossom J. Hazle v. Ford Motor Company and Ford-UAW...

Michigan Supreme Court Reaffirms 'Open and Obvious Danger' Doctrine in Odis Lugo v. Ameritech Corporation, Inc.

Date: Jul 4, 2001

Michigan Supreme Court Reaffirms 'Open and Obvious Danger' Doctrine in Odis Lugo v. Ameritech Corporation, Inc. Introduction The case of Odis Lugo v. Ameritech Corporation, Inc. brought before the...

Michigan Supreme Court Upholds Exclusion of Diminished Capacity Defense in Carpenter Case

Date: Jun 13, 2001

Michigan Supreme Court Upholds Exclusion of Diminished Capacity Defense in Carpenter Case Introduction In the landmark case of People of the State of Michigan v. James A. Carpenter, the Supreme Court...

Reckless Drag Racing and Legal 'Involvement' in Fatal Accidents: A Commentary on PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF MICHIGAN v. ALDRICH

Date: May 19, 2001

Reckless Drag Racing and Legal 'Involvement' in Fatal Accidents: A Commentary on PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF MICHIGAN v. ALDRICH Introduction In the pivotal case of People of the State of Michigan v. Kris...

Affirming the Strickland Standard Application in Alibi Defense: Carbin v. People

Date: Apr 4, 2001

Affirming the Strickland Standard Application in Alibi Defense: Carbin v. People Introduction In the case of People of the State of Michigan v. Steve Carbin (463 Mich. 590), the Supreme Court of...