Georgia Case Commentaries

No Categorical “Police Power” Exemption from Georgia’s Just Compensation Clause

Date: Sep 12, 2026

No Categorical “Police Power” Exemption from Georgia’s Just Compensation Clause 1. Introduction Blue 42 Organics, LLC v. Georgia Department of Public Safety (Supreme Court of Georgia, Sept. 9, 2026)...

Green v. State: Personal-Observation Video Testimony Is Not Hearsay; “Grave Suspicion” Charge Not Required Where Reasonable-Doubt Instructions Suffice

Date: Sep 12, 2026

Green v. State: Personal-Observation Video Testimony Is Not Hearsay; “Grave Suspicion” Charge Not Required Where Reasonable-Doubt Instructions Suffice 1. Introduction In Green v. State (Supreme Court...

Reciprocal Discipline in Georgia: Substantially Similar Suspension Required Unless GRPC 9.4(b)(3) Is Proven; Foreign “Disciplinary Authority” Rules Do Not Defeat Reciprocity

Date: Sep 12, 2026

Reciprocal Discipline in Georgia: Substantially Similar Suspension Required Unless GRPC 9.4(b)(3) Is Proven; Foreign “Disciplinary Authority” Rules Do Not Defeat Reciprocity 1. Introduction In the...

Refusal to Admit Wrongdoing Is Not an Aggravator; Knowing Client Neglect Across Multiple Matters Warrants a 12‑Month Suspension (Ga.)

Date: Sep 12, 2026

Refusal to Admit Wrongdoing Is Not an Aggravator; Knowing Client Neglect Across Multiple Matters Warrants a 12‑Month Suspension (Ga.) Case: In the Matter of Terri Sharonda Herron (Supreme Court of...

Kitchens v. State (Ga. 2026) — Unrecorded Oral Witness Statements Are Not Discoverable Under OCGA § 17-16-7; Deferential Review of Barker Remand and Gang-Act Sufficiency

Date: Sep 12, 2026

Unrecorded Oral Witness Statements Are Not Discoverable Under OCGA § 17-16-7; Deferential Review Governs Barker Remand Balancing and Gang-Act Sufficiency Case: Kitchens v. State, Supreme Court of...

Objective “Serious Provocation” Reaffirmed: No Voluntary Manslaughter Charge Where the Victim Withdraws and the Defendant Shoots Through a Closed Door; Domestic-Violence Expert Error Deemed Harmless on Overwhelming Evidence

Date: Sep 12, 2026

Objective “Serious Provocation” Reaffirmed: No Voluntary Manslaughter Charge Where the Victim Withdraws and the Defendant Shoots Through a Closed Door; Domestic-Violence Expert Error Deemed Harmless...

Prejudice Required for Guilty-Plea Ineffectiveness Claims Despite Alleged Discovery Withholding or Failure to Advise of Term-of-Court Plea Withdrawal

Date: Sep 12, 2026

Prejudice Required for Guilty-Plea Ineffectiveness Claims Despite Alleged Discovery Withholding or Failure to Advise of Term-of-Court Plea Withdrawal 1. Introduction In Orsborn, Warden v. Long...

Reynolds v. State: Harmless-Error Affirmance When Expert Is Barred from “Motive/Plan/Concealment” Labels but Gives Substantively Equivalent Insanity Testimony

Date: Sep 12, 2026

Reynolds v. State: Harmless-Error Affirmance When Expert Is Barred from “Motive/Plan/Concealment” Labels but Gives Substantively Equivalent Insanity Testimony 1. Introduction In Reynolds v. State...

State v. Downing: Physical Evidence Is Not “Fruit” of a Miranda Violation Absent an Involuntary (Coerced) Statement

Date: Sep 12, 2026

State v. Downing: Physical Evidence Is Not “Fruit” of a Miranda Violation Absent an Involuntary (Coerced) Statement Court: Supreme Court of Georgia | Date: September 9, 2026 | Posture: State appeal...

Williams v. State: No Sua Sponte Limiting Instruction for Felon-Status Proof Absent Request; Victim’s Contemporaneous Naming of Shooter Admissible as Present Sense Impression

Date: Sep 12, 2026

Williams v. State: No Sua Sponte Limiting Instruction for Felon-Status Proof Absent Request; Victim’s Contemporaneous Naming of Shooter Admissible as Present Sense Impression 1. Introduction In...

Finality Triggered by Dismissal of Remaining Claims: Appeal Clock Runs When the Case Is No Longer Pending Below

Date: Sep 12, 2026

Finality Triggered by Dismissal of Remaining Claims: Appeal Clock Runs When the Case Is No Longer Pending Below Case: NEELY v. PARSELL (Supreme Court of Georgia, Sept. 9, 2026) Posture: Writ of...

Continuance Denials Require a Concrete Showing of Harm (Especially When Late-Disclosed Expert Material Is Not Used at Trial)

Date: Aug 24, 2026

Continuance Denials Require a Concrete Showing of Harm (Especially When Late-Disclosed Expert Material Is Not Used at Trial) 1. Introduction In Hensley v. The State (Supreme Court of Georgia, Aug....

Bio-Lab, Inc. v. Tartt: Equitable Relief Requires a Cognizable Injury and Traditional Equity Prerequisites; Scope of Injunction in Federal Diversity Likely Governed by Federal Equity

Date: Aug 24, 2026

Bio-Lab, Inc. v. Tartt: Equitable Relief Requires a Cognizable Injury and Traditional Equity Prerequisites; Scope of Injunction in Federal Diversity Likely Governed by Federal Equity Court: Supreme...

Transferred Intent Sustains Malice Murder; Trial Concessions and Requested Charges Constitute Affirmative Waiver

Date: Aug 24, 2026

Transferred Intent Sustains Malice Murder; Trial Concessions and Requested Charges Constitute Affirmative Waiver Simmons v. State Supreme Court of Georgia Decided: August 18, 2026 1. Introduction In...

Barker v. State: Appellate Non-Reviewability of “General Grounds” New-Trial Claims Absent Discretion Error; Jury-Disbelief Defeats Justification on Sufficiency Review

Date: Aug 22, 2026

Barker v. State: Appellate Non-Reviewability of “General Grounds” New-Trial Claims Absent Discretion Error; Jury-Disbelief Defeats Justification on Sufficiency Review 1. Introduction In Barker v....

Brittain v. State: A Prospective Juror’s Bare Statement “He’s Guilty” Does Not Require Striking the Entire Venire, and a 911 Call Is Admissible Under Rule 403 When It Probatively Explains the Crime and Investigation

Date: Aug 22, 2026

Brittain v. State: A Prospective Juror’s Bare Statement “He’s Guilty” Does Not Require Striking the Entire Venire, and a 911 Call Is Admissible Under Rule 403 When It Probatively Explains the Crime...

Prior Domestic-Violence “Prior Difficulties” as Intrinsic Context Evidence in Homicide Trials (Rule 404(b) Bypassed)

Date: Aug 22, 2026

Prior Domestic-Violence “Prior Difficulties” as Intrinsic Context Evidence in Homicide Trials (Rule 404(b) Bypassed) 1. Introduction In Collins v. State (Supreme Court of Georgia, Aug. 18, 2026),...

Greene v. State (Ga. 2026): “Aggregate” juror irregularities do not compel mistrial or IAC absent proof of a fair-trial threat; counsel not deficient for skipping inadmissible hearsay witness

Date: Aug 22, 2026

Greene v. State (Ga. 2026): “Aggregate” juror irregularities do not compel mistrial or IAC absent proof of a fair-trial threat; counsel not deficient for skipping inadmissible hearsay witness 1....

Mitigation May Reduce Presumptive Disbarment to a Three-Year Suspension for Trust-Account Misuse and Intentional Concealment Absent Client Loss

Date: Aug 22, 2026

Mitigation May Reduce Presumptive Disbarment to a Three-Year Suspension for Trust-Account Misuse and Intentional Concealment Absent Client Loss 1. Introduction Case: In the Matter of Fiame Michelle...

McNeil v. State (Ga. 2026): Record Preservation and Prejudice as Gatekeepers—Waiver Without a Complete Record and No Plain-Error Relief for Omitted Accomplice-Corroboration Charge Absent Likely Effect on the Verdict

Date: Aug 22, 2026

McNeil v. State (Ga. 2026): Record Preservation and Prejudice as Gatekeepers—Waiver Without a Complete Record and No Plain-Error Relief for Omitted Accomplice-Corroboration Charge Absent Likely...