Florida Case Commentaries

Nondelegation Doctrine Affirmed in Reubin O'D. ASKEW v. CROSS KEY WATERWAYS

Date: Feb 16, 1979

Nondelegation Doctrine Affirmed in Reubin O'D. ASKEW v. CROSS KEY WATERWAYS Introduction Reubin O'D. Askew et al. v. Cross Key Waterways et al., 372 So. 2d 913 (Fla. 1979), is a landmark decision by...

Strict Adherence to Statutory Aggravating and Mitigating Factors in Capital Sentencing: Riley v. State

Date: Jan 31, 1979

Strict Adherence to Statutory Aggravating and Mitigating Factors in Capital Sentencing: Riley v. State Introduction Warded Riley v. State of Florida is a pivotal case adjudicated by the Supreme Court...

Retroactive Application of Insurance Statute: Dewberry v. Auto-Owners Insurance Company

Date: Nov 29, 1978

Retroactive Application of Insurance Statute: Dewberry v. Auto-Owners Insurance Company Introduction In Dewberry v. Auto-Owners Insurance Company, 363 So. 2d 1077 (Fla. 1978), the Supreme Court of...

Florida Supreme Court Mandates Timely Objections to Silence-Related Comments for Appeal Preservation

Date: Nov 9, 1978

Florida Supreme Court Mandates Timely Objections to Silence-Related Comments for Appeal Preservation Introduction The case of James Francis Clark, et al. v. State of Florida and State of Florida v....

Insurer's Duty to Defend Limited to Allegations Within Policy Coverage: National Union Fire Insurance Co. v. Lenox Liquors, Inc.

Date: Jun 6, 1978

Insurer's Duty to Defend Limited to Allegations Within Policy Coverage National Union Fire Insurance Company v. Lenox Liquors, Inc. (Supreme Court of Florida, 358 So. 2d 533, 1978) Introduction In...

Reaffirmation of the Cloud Rule: Standards for Appellate Review of New Trial Orders in Punitive Damage Awards

Date: May 25, 1978

Reaffirmation of the Cloud Rule: Standards for Appellate Review of New Trial Orders in Punitive Damage Awards Introduction The Wackenhut Corporation et al., Petitioners, v. Richard Canty, Respondent...

Clarifying 'Arising Out of Employment' in Workmen's Compensation: McCook v. Southern Bell

Date: Apr 6, 1978

Clarifying 'Arising Out of Employment' in Workmen's Compensation: McCook v. Southern Bell Introduction Southern Bell Telephone and Telegraph Company v. Virginia G. McCook is a pivotal case...

Jurisdictional Limits of Statewide Grand Juries: Comprehensive Analysis of McNamara v. State of Florida

Date: Apr 1, 1978

Jurisdictional Limits of Statewide Grand Juries: Comprehensive Analysis of McNamara v. State of Florida Introduction McNamara v. State of Florida, 357 So. 2d 410 (Fla. 1978), is a pivotal case...

No Presumption of Probable Cause from Prosecutor's Filing of Information in Malicious Prosecution Actions

Date: Feb 28, 1978

No Presumption of Probable Cause from Prosecutor's Filing of Information in Malicious Prosecution Actions Introduction The case of Colonial Stores, Inc. v. Doyle Wayne Scarbrough addresses...

Mandatory Venue in Tort Actions Against State Agencies: Carlile v. Game Fresh Water Fish Commission

Date: Feb 23, 1978

Mandatory Venue in Tort Actions Against State Agencies: Carlile v. Game Fresh Water Fish Commission Introduction The case of Patrick L. Carlile v. Game Fresh Water Fish Commission of the State of...

McArthur v. State: Establishing the Necessity of Sufficient Circumstantial Evidence to Eliminate Reasonable Doubts

Date: Dec 7, 1977

McArthur v. State: Establishing the Necessity of Sufficient Circumstantial Evidence to Eliminate Reasonable Doubts Introduction McArthur v. State, decided by the Supreme Court of Florida on December...

Supreme Court of Florida Establishes Limits on Indemnity Claims Against Treating Physicians

Date: Nov 29, 1977

Supreme Court of Florida Establishes Limits on Indemnity Claims Against Treating Physicians Introduction The case of FRANK M. STUART, M.D., P.A., AND UNDERWRITERS AT LLOYDS v. THE HERTZ CORPORATION...

Enforcement of Limitation of Liability Clauses in Bills of Lading: Insights from ALLIED VAN LINES, INC. v. BRATTON and McKnab

Date: Nov 22, 1977

Enforcement of Limitation of Liability Clauses in Bills of Lading: Insights from ALLIED VAN LINES, INC. v. BRATTON and McKnab Introduction The landmark case ALLIED VAN LINES, INC. v. BRATTON and...

Reaffirmation of Summary Judgment Standards in Negligence Cases: Wills v. Sears, Roebuck Company

Date: Nov 15, 1977

Reaffirmation of Summary Judgment Standards in Negligence Cases: Wills v. Sears, Roebuck Company Introduction The case of Helen E. Wills and Howard A. Wills v. Sears, Roebuck Company addresses...

Punitive Damages Must Not Shock Judicial Conscience: Florida Supreme Court Sets New Precedent

Date: Sep 21, 1977

Punitive Damages Must Not Shock Judicial Conscience: Florida Supreme Court Sets New Precedent Introduction The case of Earl Lowell Lassitter v. International Union of Operating Engineers, decided by...

Jury Discretion in Punitive Damages Affirmed: Florida Supreme Court Overturns Fixed Relation Rule

Date: Sep 14, 1977

Jury Discretion in Punitive Damages Affirmed: Florida Supreme Court Overturns Fixed Relation Rule Introduction The case of Dorthy Bould and Edward Simonson, Jr., as Administrators of the Estates of...

Elimination of Assumption of Risk as a Distinct Defense in Florida Tort Law

Date: Jul 28, 1977

Elimination of Assumption of Risk as a Distinct Defense in Florida Tort Law Introduction The case of Blackburn, Jr., et al. v. Dorta, et al. adjudicated by the Supreme Court of Florida on July 27,...

Defining the Scope of Prohibition Writ in Media Access: Florida Supreme Court in Carey English v. McCrary

Date: Jul 14, 1977

Defining the Scope of Prohibition Writ in Media Access: Florida Supreme Court in Carey English v. McCrary Introduction The case of Carey English v. Robert L. McCrary, Jr., reported in 348 So. 2d 293...

Elledge v. State of Florida: Clarifying the Scope of Aggravating Factors in Death Penalty Sentencing

Date: Jul 1, 1977

Elledge v. State of Florida: Clarifying the Scope of Aggravating Factors in Death Penalty Sentencing Introduction The case of William Duane Elledge versus the State of Florida represents a pivotal...

Florida Supreme Court Establishes Procedural Safeguards in Criminal Contempt Proceedings

Date: Jun 10, 1977

Florida Supreme Court Establishes Procedural Safeguards in Criminal Contempt Proceedings Introduction The case of Rocco Pugliese v. Tina Pugliese (347 So. 2d 422, Supreme Court of Florida, 1977)...