Florida Case Commentaries

Insurer's Duty in Settlement Offers: Insights from Boston Old Colony Ins. Co. v. Gutierrez

Date: Sep 5, 1980

Insurer's Duty in Settlement Offers: Insights from Boston Old Colony Ins. Co. v. Gutierrez Introduction The case of Boston Old Colony Insurance Company v. Raul Gutierrez, adjudicated by the Supreme...

JENKINS v. STATE of Florida: Limiting Supreme Court Jurisdiction Over Per Curiam Decisions

Date: Jun 27, 1980

JENKINS v. STATE of Florida: Limiting Supreme Court Jurisdiction Over Per Curiam Decisions Introduction The case of Philip H. JENKINS v. STATE of Florida, 385 So. 2d 1356 (Fla. 1980), presented a...

Right to Evidentiary Hearing under Rule 3.850 for Ineffective Assistance Claims: MEEKS v. STATE of Florida

Date: May 20, 1980

Right to Evidentiary Hearing under Rule 3.850 for Ineffective Assistance Claims: MEEKS v. STATE of Florida Introduction MEEKS v. STATE of Florida (382 So.2d 673, 1980) is a pivotal Supreme Court of...

Establishing Criteria for State-Funded Legal Representation in Juvenile Dependency Proceedings

Date: May 17, 1980

Establishing Criteria for State-Funded Legal Representation in Juvenile Dependency Proceedings Introduction The Supreme Court of Florida's decision in In the Interest of D.B. and D.S. (1980)...

AFFIRMATION OF FLORIDA'S HABITUAL OFFENDER STATUTE UNDER DUE PROCESS: Eutsey v. State of Florida (1980)

Date: Apr 25, 1980

Affirmation of Florida's Habitual Offender Statute under Due Process: Eutsey v. State of Florida (1980) Introduction Case: Eutsey v. State of Florida, 383 So.2d 219 (Fla. 1980) Court: Supreme Court...

Florida Supreme Court Reaffirms Alimony Discretion and Clarifies 'Special Equity' in CANAKARIS v. CANAKARIS

Date: Mar 28, 1980

Florida Supreme Court Reaffirms Alimony Discretion and Clarifies 'Special Equity' in CANAKARIS v. CANAKARIS Introduction CANAKARIS v. CANAKARIS, 382 So. 2d 1197 (Fla. 1980), is a seminal case in...

Defining 'Special Equity' and 'Exclusive Possession' in Divorce Proceedings: Insights from DUNCAN v. DUNCAN

Date: Feb 1, 1980

Defining 'Special Equity' and 'Exclusive Possession' in Divorce Proceedings: Insights from DUNCAN v. DUNCAN Introduction Dorothy Nell Duncan v. Tommy David Duncan, 379 So.2d 949 (Fla. 1980), is a...

Consent After Unlawful Intrusion: Establishing Boundaries in Norman v. Florida

Date: Jan 25, 1980

Consent After Unlawful Intrusion: Establishing Boundaries in Norman v. Florida Introduction The legal landscape surrounding search and seizure under the Fourth Amendment has undergone significant...

Shevin v. Byron: Defining Public Records and Privacy Rights in Florida

Date: Jan 18, 1980

Shevin v. Byron: Defining Public Records and Privacy Rights in Florida Introduction In Robert L. Shevin, Etc. v. Byron, Harless, Schaffer, Reid and Associates, Inc., Etc. (379 So. 2d 633, Supreme...

Lucas v. State: Clarifying Discovery Obligations and Aggravating Factors in Florida Capital Sentencing

Date: Dec 6, 1979

Lucas v. State: Clarifying Discovery Obligations and Aggravating Factors in Florida Capital Sentencing Introduction Lucas v. State, 376 So.2d 1149 (Fla. 1979), is a pivotal case decided by the...

Dispositive Legal Issues in Conditional Nolo Contendere Pleas: The Brown v. Florida Decision

Date: Nov 28, 1979

Dispositive Legal Issues in Conditional Nolo Contendere Pleas: The Brown v. Florida Decision Introduction Edward J. Brown v. State of Florida is a pivotal Supreme Court of Florida decision delivered...

Double Jeopardy Protections in Felony Murder: Insights from State of Florida v. Pinder

Date: Nov 1, 1979

Double Jeopardy Protections in Felony Murder: Insights from State of Florida v. Pinder Introduction State of Florida v. Alfred Jerome Pinder, 375 So.2d 836 (Fla. 1979), is a seminal case addressing...

No Right to Common Law Indemnity Without Special Relationship: Houdaile Industries v. Edwards

Date: Sep 29, 1979

No Right to Common Law Indemnity Without Special Relationship: Houdaile Industries, Inc. v. Edwards Introduction The case of Houdaile Industries, Inc. v. Eddie Edwards, Sr. (374 So. 2d 490)...

Limits on Appellate Rights Following a Guilty Plea: Robinson v. State of Florida

Date: Jul 27, 1979

Limits on Appellate Rights Following a Guilty Plea: Robinson v. State of Florida Introduction Robinson v. State of Florida is a seminal case decided by the Supreme Court of Florida on July 26, 1979....

Unilateral Search Conditions in Probation Orders: GRUBBS v. STATE of Florida

Date: Jul 27, 1979

Unilateral Search Conditions in Probation Orders: GRUBBS v. STATE of Florida Introduction GRUBBS v. STATE of Florida, 373 So. 2d 905 (Fla. 1979), is a landmark case adjudicated by the Supreme Court...

Florida Supreme Court Limits on Waiver of Sovereign Immunity Under Section 768.28

Date: Jul 10, 1979

Florida Supreme Court Limits on Waiver of Sovereign Immunity Under Section 768.28 Introduction In the landmark decision of Commercial Carrier Corporation et al. v. Indian River County et al. and...

Florida Supreme Court Limits Mandated Counsel for Death Row Post-Conviction Relief

Date: Jun 23, 1979

Florida Supreme Court Limits Mandated Counsel for Death Row Post-Conviction Relief Introduction The case of Graham et al. v. State of Florida pertains to a petition filed on behalf of nine condemned...

Coram Nobis Limitation in Capital Cases: Analysis of HALLMAN v. STATE

Date: Jun 22, 1979

Coram Nobis Limitation in Capital Cases: Analysis of HALLMAN v. STATE 1. Introduction HALLMAN v. STATE, 371 So. 2d 482 (Fla. 1979), is a landmark case adjudicated by the Supreme Court of Florida that...

Supreme Court of Florida Establishes Precedence of Public Records Act Over Appellate Rules and Limits Exemptions to Statutory Provisions

Date: Jun 22, 1979

Supreme Court of Florida Establishes Precedence of Public Records Act Over Appellate Rules and Limits Exemptions to Statutory Provisions Introduction The case of B.W. Wait, III, as Director of...

Excelsior Insurance Co. v. Pomona Park Bar Package Store: Clarifying Exclusions in Insurance Contracts Involving Alcohol-Related Liabilities

Date: May 5, 1979

Excelsior Insurance Co. v. Pomona Park Bar Package Store: Clarifying Exclusions in Insurance Contracts Involving Alcohol-Related Liabilities Introduction The landmark case of Excelsior Insurance...