Florida Case Commentaries

Judicial Review of Administrative Findings: Substantial Evidence and Agency Discretion in Banking Charters - McDonald v. Department of Banking and Finance

Date: Jun 1, 1977

Judicial Review of Administrative Findings: Substantial Evidence and Agency Discretion in Banking Charters Introduction In the landmark case of Raymond O. McDonald, Jr., et al. v. Department of...

Limitations on Judicial Discretion in Capital Sentencing: Provence v. State of Florida

Date: Oct 12, 1976

Limitations on Judicial Discretion in Capital Sentencing: Provence v. State of Florida Introduction Provence v. State of Florida, 337 So. 2d 783 (Supreme Court of Florida, 1976), is a pivotal case...

Establishing Precedent on Capital Punishment under Florida Statute 921.141

Date: Sep 29, 1976

Establishing Precedent on Capital Punishment under Florida Statute 921.141 Introduction The Supreme Court of Florida, in the landmark case of Vernon Ray Cooper v. State of Florida (336 So. 2d 1133,...

Establishment of Strict Liability for Manufacturers in Florida Products Liability: West v. Caterpillar Tractor Company

Date: Jul 22, 1976

Establishment of Strict Liability for Manufacturers in Florida Products Liability: West v. Caterpillar Tractor Company Introduction WEST v. CATERPILLAR TRACTOR COMPANY, INC. is a seminal case decided...

Appellate Review of Alimony and Marital Asset Division: Gerald B. Shaw v. Jean A. Shaw

Date: Jul 17, 1976

Appellate Review of Alimony and Marital Asset Division: Gerald B. Shaw v. Jean A. Shaw Introduction In the landmark case of Gerald B. Shaw v. Jean A. Shaw, 334 So. 2d 13 (Fla. 1976), the Supreme...

Limitations on Impeaching Witness Credibility with Pending Charges: Insights from FULTON v. STATE of Florida

Date: Jul 9, 1976

Limitations on Impeaching Witness Credibility with Pending Charges: Insights from FULTON v. STATE of Florida Introduction The case of Fred FULTON v. STATE of Florida, adjudicated by the Supreme Court...

Statute of Limitations in Medical Malpractice: Insights from Nardone v. Reynolds

Date: May 20, 1976

Statute of Limitations in Medical Malpractice: Insights from Nardone v. Reynolds Introduction Nicholas Nardone v. David H. Reynolds et al., decided by the Supreme Court of Florida on May 19, 1976, is...

Ensuring Due Process in Interim Rate Decisions: Analysis of CITIZENS OF FLORIDA v. MAYO

Date: May 6, 1976

Ensuring Due Process in Interim Rate Decisions: Analysis of CITIZENS OF FLORIDA v. MAYO Introduction The case of The Citizens of the State of Florida, Petitioners, v. William T. Mayo, Chairman, et...

Florida Supreme Court Defines Trial Court Authority in Split Sentence Probation Cases

Date: Mar 10, 1976

Florida Supreme Court Defines Trial Court Authority in Split Sentence Probation Cases Introduction The case of State of Florida v. Johnnie Lee Jones, adjudicated by the Supreme Court of Florida on...

WILLIAMS v. STATE of Florida: Jurisdiction Vesting Through Timely Notice of Appeal Independent of Filing Fee Payment

Date: Dec 4, 1975

WILLIAMS v. STATE of Florida: Jurisdiction Vesting Through Timely Notice of Appeal Independent of Filing Fee Payment Introduction WILLIAMS v. STATE of Florida, 324 So.2d 74 (Fla. 1975), is a landmark...

BAILEY v. STATE of Florida: Redefining Consent in Illegal Searches and Seizures

Date: Oct 18, 1975

BAILEY v. STATE of Florida: Redefining Consent in Illegal Searches and Seizures Introduction BAILEY v. STATE of Florida, 319 So. 2d 22 (Fla. 1975), is a pivotal case adjudicated by the Supreme Court...

WILLIAMS v. STATE: Affirming Prejudice Requirement in Rule 3.170(j) Guilty Plea Procedures

Date: Aug 29, 1975

WILLIAMS v. STATE: Affirming Prejudice Requirement in Rule 3.170(j) Guilty Plea Procedures Introduction WILLIAMS v. STATE is a landmark case decided by the Supreme Court of Florida on August 28,...

Miranda Protections Reinforced: BENNETT v. STATE Establishes Strict Adherence to Self-Incrimination Rights

Date: Aug 1, 1975

Miranda Protections Reinforced: BENNETT v. STATE Establishes Strict Adherence to Self-Incrimination Rights Introduction BENNETT v. STATE of Florida (316 So. 2d 41, Supreme Court of Florida, 1975) is...

Upholding Premeditation and Plain View Exceptions: Florida Supreme Court in Spinkellink v. State (1975)

Date: May 9, 1975

Upholding Premeditation and Plain View Exceptions: Florida Supreme Court in Spinkellink v. State (1975) Introduction The case of John A. Spinkellink v. State of Florida (313 So. 2d 666, Supreme Court...

Florida Supreme Court Upholds Constitutionality of Loitering Statute Section 856.021

Date: May 1, 1975

Florida Supreme Court Upholds Constitutionality of Loitering Statute Section 856.021 Introduction The Supreme Court of Florida, in the consolidated cases of State of Florida, County of Dade, et al....

Comprehensive Commentary on Harvey Campbell v. Government Employees Insurance Company

Date: Feb 14, 1975

Establishing Precedents for Insurance Bad Faith and Punitive Damages in Florida: An Analysis of Harvey Campbell v. Government Employees Insurance Company Introduction The case of Harvey Campbell v....

Enhanced Interpretation of Speedy Trial Rights in Negron v. State of Florida

Date: Feb 5, 1975

Enhanced Interpretation of Speedy Trial Rights in Negron v. State of Florida Introduction In the landmark case of Ozzie Joseph Negron and Teresa Negron v. State of Florida, decided by the Supreme...

S.L.T. Warehouse Co. v. Wilmott Webb: Finality and Appealability of Dismissed Counterclaims under Florida Law

Date: Nov 28, 1974

S.L.T. Warehouse Co. v. Wilmott Webb: Finality and Appealability of Dismissed Counterclaims under Florida Law Introduction S.L.T. Warehouse Company v. Wilmott Webb, 304 So. 2d 97 (Fla. 1974), is a...

Polygraph Test References and the Reversible Error Doctrine: A Commentary on Sullivan v. Florida

Date: Nov 28, 1974

Polygraph Test References and the Reversible Error Doctrine: A Commentary on Sullivan v. Florida Introduction The case of Robert Austin Sullivan v. The State of Florida, 303 So. 2d 632 (Fla. 1974),...

Blackhawk v. Data Lease: Enforcing Ambiguous Contract Terms through Specific Performance

Date: Nov 23, 1974

Blackhawk v. Data Lease: Enforcing Ambiguous Contract Terms through Specific Performance Introduction The case of Blackhawk Heating Plumbing Co., Inc. v. Data Lease Financial Corp. (302 So. 2d 404)...