Florida Case Commentaries

Severability and Constitutional Boundaries in Child Exploitation Statutes: SCHMITT v. STATE of Florida

Date: Nov 15, 1991

Severability and Constitutional Boundaries in Child Exploitation Statutes: SCHMITT v. STATE of Florida Introduction SCHMITT v. STATE of Florida, 590 So. 2d 404 (Fla. 1991), is a pivotal case...

Prosecutorial Conduct in Sentencing: Perry Alexander Taylor v. State of Florida

Date: Aug 21, 1991

Prosecutorial Conduct in Sentencing: Perry Alexander Taylor v. State of Florida Introduction Perry Alexander Taylor v. State of Florida, 583 So. 2d 323 (Fla. 1991), is a landmark case adjudicated by...

Single Subject Requirement in Workers' Compensation Law: Martinez v. Scanlan Analysis

Date: Aug 14, 1991

Single Subject Requirement in Workers' Compensation Law: Martinez v. Scanlan Analysis Introduction The case of Martinez, et al. v. Scanlan, et al. (582 So. 2d 1167) adjudicated by the Supreme Court...

Florida Supreme Court Refines Anders Doctrine: Preserving Indigent Appellants' Pro Se Rights in Appeals with Minimal Sentencing Errors

Date: May 31, 1991

Florida Supreme Court Refines Anders Doctrine: Preserving Indigent Appellants' Pro Se Rights in Appeals with Minimal Sentencing Errors Introduction In the landmark decision of IN RE Appellate Court...

BEASLEY v. STATE: Establishing Due Process Standards for Imposing Costs on Indigent Defendants

Date: May 10, 1991

BEASLEY v. STATE: Establishing Due Process Standards for Imposing Costs on Indigent Defendants Introduction In the landmark case of State of Florida v. Gary Stephen Beasley, the Supreme Court of...

Trotter v. State of Florida: Resentencing Due to Improper Consideration of Community Control

Date: Apr 5, 1991

Trotter v. State of Florida: Resentencing Due to Improper Consideration of Community Control Introduction Trotter v. State of Florida, 576 So. 2d 691 (Fla. 1991), is a landmark case decided by the...

Terminating Parental Rights Based on Prior Abuse: Padgett v. Department of Health and Rehabilitative Services

Date: Mar 29, 1991

Terminating Parental Rights Based on Prior Abuse: Padgett v. Department of Health and Rehabilitative Services Introduction In Padgett v. Department of Health and Rehabilitative Services (577 So. 2d...

Professional Goodwill Recognized as Marital Asset in Divorce Proceedings: THOMPSON v. THOMPSON

Date: Mar 27, 1991

Professional Goodwill Recognized as Marital Asset in Divorce Proceedings: THOMPSON v. THOMPSON Introduction The case of William deForest Thompson v. Tobitha Thompson, 576 So. 2d 267 (Fla. 1991),...

Insurance Carrier Standing in Attorney Conflict of Interest: State Farm Mutual Auto Ins. Co. v. K.A.W.

Date: Mar 19, 1991

Insurance Carrier Standing in Attorney Conflict of Interest: State Farm Mutual Auto Ins. Co. v. K.A.W. Introduction The case State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company v. K.A.W., etc., et al....

Strict Construction of 'Forcible Felony' in Self-Defense Claims: Florida Supreme Court Establishes Precedent

Date: Mar 15, 1991

Strict Construction of 'Forcible Felony' in Self-Defense Claims: Florida Supreme Court Establishes Precedent Introduction The case of MARCUS PERKINS, ET AL., PETITIONERS, v. STATE OF FLORIDA,...

Substantial Mitigation Renders Death Penalty Disproportional: NIBERT v. STATE of Florida

Date: Mar 7, 1991

Substantial Mitigation Renders Death Penalty Disproportional: NIBERT v. STATE of Florida Introduction Billy Ray Nibert, Appellant v. State of Florida, Appellee is a seminal case decided by the...

Defendant's Knowledge in Drug Trafficking Cases: New Precedent from DELVA v. STATE

Date: Feb 22, 1991

Defendant's Knowledge in Drug Trafficking Cases: New Precedent from DELVA v. STATE Introduction The landmark case of State of Florida v. Batraville Vincent Delva, decided by the Supreme Court of...

Operational Accountability in Juvenile Detention: Insights from Department of Health Rehabilitative Services v. Whaley

Date: Feb 21, 1991

Operational Accountability in Juvenile Detention: Insights from Department of Health Rehabilitative Services v. Whaley Introduction The case of Department of Health Rehabilitative Services v. Whaley,...

Florida Supreme Court Establishes Standards for Excusable Homicide Instructions and Admissibility of Prior Inconsistent Statements in STATE v. SMITH

Date: Feb 13, 1991

Florida Supreme Court Establishes Standards for Excusable Homicide Instructions and Admissibility of Prior Inconsistent Statements in STATE v. SMITH Introduction In the landmark case of State of...

Affirming Denial of Postconviction Relief: An In-Depth Analysis of Pedro MEDINA v. STATE of Florida

Date: Feb 12, 1991

Affirming Denial of Postconviction Relief: An In-Depth Analysis of Pedro MEDINA v. STATE of Florida Introduction Pedro MEDINA v. STATE of Florida (573 So. 2d 293) is a pivotal case decided by the...

Pleading Requirements for Attorney's Fees Claims under Contract and Statute: Florida Supreme Court Clarifies Standards

Date: Feb 1, 1991

Pleading Requirements for Attorney's Fees Claims under Contract and Statute: Florida Supreme Court Clarifies Standards Introduction In Ann W. Stockman v. George Downs et al., 573 So.2d 835 (Fla....

Reevaluating Capital Sentencing in Felony Murder: The JACKSON v. STATE Decision

Date: Jan 19, 1991

Reevaluating Capital Sentencing in Felony Murder: The JACKSON v. STATE Decision Introduction Clinton Lamar JACKSON v. STATE of Florida, 575 So. 2d 181 (Fla. 1991), is a pivotal case addressing the...

Holton v. State of Florida: Refinement of Peremptory Challenge Standards and Sentencing Procedure

Date: Jan 16, 1991

Holton v. State of Florida: Refinement of Peremptory Challenge Standards and Sentencing Procedure Introduction In Rudolph Holton v. State of Florida, 573 So.2d 284 (Supreme Court of Florida, 1991),...

Florida Supreme Court Expands Restitution Guidelines Beyond Fair Market Value

Date: Jan 4, 1991

Florida Supreme Court Expands Restitution Guidelines Beyond Fair Market Value Introduction In the landmark case of State of Florida v. Dennis Hawthorne, decided on January 3, 1991, the Supreme Court...

Affirmation of First-Degree Murder Conviction and Death Sentence in Occhicone v. State of Florida

Date: Dec 27, 1990

Affirmation of First-Degree Murder Conviction and Death Sentence in Occhicone v. State of Florida Introduction Occhicone v. State of Florida is a pivotal case adjudicated by the Supreme Court of...