Florida Case Commentaries

Admissibility of Similar Fact Evidence in Capital Cases: Analysis of Swafford v. State

Date: Dec 3, 1988

Admissibility of Similar Fact Evidence in Capital Cases: Analysis of Swafford v. State Introduction Swafford v. State, 533 So. 2d 270 (Fla. 1988), is a pivotal case in Florida's legal landscape,...

Clarifying Split Sentence Sentencing: POORE v. STATE and Its Impact on Florida Law

Date: Sep 23, 1988

Clarifying Split Sentence Sentencing: POORE v. STATE and Its Impact on Florida Law Introduction POORE v. STATE, 531 So. 2d 161 (1988), adjudicated by the Supreme Court of Florida, stands as a pivotal...

Harmless Error and Limitations on Victim Impact Statements in Death Penalty Sentencing: A Comprehensive Analysis of Grossman v. State

Date: May 26, 1988

Harmless Error and Limitations on Victim Impact Statements in Death Penalty Sentencing: A Comprehensive Analysis of Grossman v. State Introduction The case of Martin Grossman v. State of Florida (525...

Waiver of the Right to Testify: Not a Fundamental Right Requiring On-Record Waiver

Date: May 25, 1988

Waiver of the Right to Testify: Not a Fundamental Right Requiring On-Record Waiver Introduction The case of Oscar Torres-Arboledo v. State of Florida (524 So. 2d 403) presents a comprehensive...

Guarding Due Process in Insanity Defense and Penal Proceedings: Garron v. State of Florida

Date: May 20, 1988

Guarding Due Process in Insanity Defense and Penal Proceedings: Garron v. State of Florida Introduction In Joseph Henry Garron v. State of Florida (528 So. 2d 353, 1988), the Supreme Court of Florida...

Florida Supreme Court Abolishes Interspousal Tort Immunity for Deceased Spouses and Upholds Lex Loci Contractus in Automobile Insurance Claims

Date: May 17, 1988

Florida Supreme Court Abolishes Interspousal Tort Immunity for Deceased Spouses and Upholds Lex Loci Contractus in Automobile Insurance Claims Introduction In the landmark case of Josephine Sturiano...

Hardwick v. State of Florida: Upholding First-Degree Murder Conviction and Death Sentence

Date: Apr 9, 1988

Hardwick v. State of Florida: Upholding First-Degree Murder Conviction and Death Sentence Introduction John Gary Hardwick, Jr. v. State of Florida is a landmark case adjudicated by the Supreme Court...

Equitable Tolling in Administrative Proceedings: MACHULES v. DEPARTMENT OF ADMINistration

Date: Apr 1, 1988

Equitable Tolling in Administrative Proceedings: MACHULES v. DEPARTMENT OF ADMINistration Introduction The case of John J. MACHULES v. DEPARTMENT OF ADMINistration, decided by the Supreme Court of...

Clarifying the State's Authority to Seek Certiorari Review of Non-Final Criminal Orders in Florida

Date: Mar 17, 1988

Clarifying the State's Authority to Seek Certiorari Review of Non-Final Criminal Orders in Florida Introduction The case of State of Florida v. George Pettis (520 So. 2d 250, 1988) addresses a...

Florida Supreme Court Reinforces Strict Standards Against Racial Discrimination in Jury Selection

Date: Mar 11, 1988

Florida Supreme Court Reinforces Strict Standards Against Racial Discrimination in Jury Selection Introduction The landmark case of State of Florida v. Charles Slappy, decided on March 10, 1988, by...

DuBoise v. State of Florida: Upholding Forensic Odontology Evidence and Addressing Jury Sentencing Recommendations

Date: Feb 5, 1988

DuBoise v. State of Florida: Upholding Forensic Odontology Evidence and Addressing Jury Sentencing Recommendations Introduction The case of Robert Earl DuBoise v. State of Florida (520 So.2d 260,...

Mutual Exclusivity of Principal and Accessory After the Fact Convictions: Insights from STATEN v. STATE

Date: Feb 5, 1988

Mutual Exclusivity of Principal and Accessory After the Fact Convictions: Insights from STATEN v. STATE Introduction STATEN v. STATE, 519 So. 2d 622 (Fla. 1988), marks a significant precedent in...

Promissory Estoppel in Insurance Coverage: CROWN LIFE INSURANCE CO. v. McBRIDE

Date: Jan 30, 1988

Promissory Estoppel in Insurance Coverage: CROWN LIFE INSURANCE CO. v. McBRIDE Introduction The case of Crown Life Insurance Company v. Steven Patrick McBride, decided by the Supreme Court of Florida...

Supreme Court of Florida Limits Dual Convictions: Overruling STATE v. GIBSON in HALL v. STATE

Date: Jan 8, 1988

Supreme Court of Florida Limits Dual Convictions: Overruling STATE v. GIBSON in HALL v. STATE Introduction Robert Lee HALL v. STATE of Florida, 517 So. 2d 678 (Fla. 1988), is a landmark decision by...

Florida Supreme Court Establishes Strict Interpretation for Double Jeopardy in Multiple Offense Convictions

Date: Dec 11, 1987

Florida Supreme Court Establishes Strict Interpretation for Double Jeopardy in Multiple Offense Convictions Introduction In the landmark case of Dion Michael CARAWAN v. STATE of Florida, the Supreme...

Economic Loss Rule Reinforced in Florida Power Light Co. v. Westinghouse Electric Corp.

Date: Sep 4, 1987

Economic Loss Rule Reinforced in Florida Power Light Co. v. Westinghouse Electric Corp. Introduction Florida Power Light Co. v. Westinghouse Electric Corp., 510 So.2d 899 (Fla. 1987), is a landmark...

Rogers v. State: Evaluating Aggravating Factors and Mitigation in Capital Sentencing

Date: Sep 3, 1987

Rogers v. State: Evaluating Aggravating Factors and Mitigation in Capital Sentencing Introduction Rogers v. State, 511 So. 2d 526 (Fla. 1987), is a pivotal case adjudicated by the Supreme Court of...

Ensuring Due Consideration of Mitigating Evidence in Capital Sentencing: Craig v. State of Florida

Date: Sep 1, 1987

Ensuring Due Consideration of Mitigating Evidence in Capital Sentencing: Craig v. State of Florida Introduction Citation: Robert Patrick Craig, Appellant, v. State of Florida, Appellee. (510 So. 2d...

Affirmation of Procedural Bars and Ineffective Assistance Claims in Post-Conviction Relief: BLANCO v. STATE

Date: Jul 11, 1987

Affirmation of Procedural Bars and Ineffective Assistance Claims in Post-Conviction Relief: BLANCO v. STATE Introduction BLANCO v. STATE is a seminal case adjudicated by the Supreme Court of Florida...

Appellate Review of Interlocutory Orders in Punitive Damages Claims

Date: Jul 10, 1987

Appellate Review of Interlocutory Orders in Punitive Damages Claims Introduction The case of Martin-Johnson, Inc. v. Tommie Savage, adjudicated by the Supreme Court of Florida in 1987, addressed a...