Florida Case Commentaries

Supreme Court of Florida Rulings on Habitual Felony Offender Statute and Life Felonies

Date: Dec 25, 1992

Supreme Court of Florida Rulings on Habitual Felony Offender Statute and Life Felonies Introduction The Supreme Court of Florida delivered a pivotal judgment on December 24, 1992, addressing the...

Establishing Workers' Compensation Immunity for General Contractors Through Deduction of Insurance Premiums from Independent Contractors

Date: Oct 9, 1992

Establishing Workers' Compensation Immunity for General Contractors Through Deduction of Insurance Premiums from Independent Contractors Introduction The case of Anthony Mandico v. Taos Construction,...

Peters Forsythe v. Longboat Key Beach Erosion Control District: Defining Independent vs. Dependent Special Districts in Florida Law

Date: Sep 24, 1992

Peters Forsythe v. Longboat Key Beach Erosion Control District: Defining Independent vs. Dependent Special Districts in Florida Law Introduction In the landmark case of Peters Forsythe, et al.,...

Retroactive Application of 'POPE v. STATE' in Sentencing Departures

Date: Jun 17, 1992

Retroactive Application of 'POPE v. STATE' in Sentencing Departures Introduction The case Rhoda Smith v. State of Florida (598 So. 2d 1063) was adjudicated by the Supreme Court of Florida on June 16,...

Florida Supreme Court Establishes Qualified Privilege for Defamatory Statements Made to Law Enforcement

Date: Jun 10, 1992

Florida Supreme Court Establishes Qualified Privilege for Defamatory Statements Made to Law Enforcement Introduction The Florida Supreme Court, in the landmark case of Anthony Steven Fridovich v....

Retirement as a Change of Circumstance in Alimony Modification: PIMM v. PIMM

Date: May 29, 1992

Retirement as a Change of Circumstance in Alimony Modification: PIMM v. PIMM Introduction The landmark case of Maurice C. Pimm v. Carolyn M. Pimm, decided by the Supreme Court of Florida on May 28,...

TRAYLOR v. STATE of Florida: Reinforcement of Counsel Rights and Self-Incrimination Protections under the Florida Constitution

Date: May 21, 1992

TRAYLOR v. STATE of Florida: Reinforcement of Counsel Rights and Self-Incrimination Protections under the Florida Constitution Introduction The case of John Edward TRAYLOR v. STATE of Florida,...

Breedlove v. Singletary: Reinforcing Procedural Barriers in Habeas Corpus Petitions

Date: Apr 2, 1992

Breedlove v. Singletary: Reinforcing Procedural Barriers in Habeas Corpus Petitions Introduction In the landmark case McArthur Breedlove v. Harry K. Singletary, decided by the Supreme Court of...

Florida Supreme Court Upholds Section 45.061: Balancing Legislative Statutes and Court Procedural Rules

Date: Mar 28, 1992

Florida Supreme Court Upholds Section 45.061: Balancing Legislative Statutes and Court Procedural Rules Introduction The case of Denise G. Leapai v. James Dean Milton (595 So. 2d 12) before the...

Admissibility of Child Victim’s Prior Consistent Statements Under Florida Statutes: Pardo v. State

Date: Mar 27, 1992

Admissibility of Child Victim’s Prior Consistent Statements Under Florida Statutes: Pardo v. State Introduction James Antonio Pardo, etc., Petitioner v. State of Florida, Respondent (596 So. 2d 665)...

Florida Supreme Court Clarifies Habitual Felony Offender Definition: No Requirement for Sequential Convictions

Date: Mar 26, 1992

Florida Supreme Court Clarifies Habitual Felony Offender Definition: No Requirement for Sequential Convictions Introduction In the landmark case of State of Florida v. Anthony T. Barnes, 595 So.2d 22...

Supreme Court of Florida Upholds Permissive Life Sentencing Under Habitual Felony Offender Statute

Date: Mar 26, 1992

Supreme Court of Florida Upholds Permissive Life Sentencing Under Habitual Felony Offender Statute Introduction In the landmark case of Billy BURDICK v. STATE of Florida, 594 So. 2d 267 (Fla. 1992),...

Clarifying the Scope of Rule 3.800(a) in Habitual Offender Sentencing Procedures

Date: Mar 21, 1992

Clarifying the Scope of Rule 3.800(a) in Habitual Offender Sentencing Procedures Introduction In the case of Gilbert Judge v. State of Florida, the District Court of Appeal of Florida's Second...

Foreseeability in Duty and Proximate Causation: Insights from McCain v. Florida Power Corporation

Date: Mar 5, 1992

Foreseeability in Duty and Proximate Causation: Insights from McCain v. Florida Power Corporation Introduction Case: Thomas McCain, Petitioner, v. Florida Power Corporation, Respondent. Court:...

Collateral Consequences Prevent Mootness in Involuntary Commitment Appeals: GODWIN v. STATE

Date: Mar 4, 1992

Collateral Consequences Prevent Mootness in Involuntary Commitment Appeals: GODWIN v. STATE Introduction Shirley Godwin, the petitioner, was involuntarily committed to the Florida State Hospital...

REYNOLDS v. STATE: Guidelines on Handcuff Use and Consent During Investigatory Stops

Date: Feb 26, 1992

REYNOLDS v. STATE: Guidelines on Handcuff Use and Consent During Investigatory Stops Introduction REYNOLDS v. STATE, 592 So.2d 1082 (Fla. 1992), adjudicated by the Supreme Court of Florida, addresses...

Revisiting Postconviction Relief Standards: The JONES v. STATE Decision

Date: Feb 1, 1992

Revisiting Postconviction Relief Standards: The JONES v. STATE Decision 1. Introduction In Leo Alexander JONES v. STATE of Florida, 591 So. 2d 911 (Fla. 1992), the Supreme Court of Florida addressed...

Florida Supreme Court Establishes Limitation on Victim-Injury Points in Sexual Offense Sentencing

Date: Jan 17, 1992

Florida Supreme Court Establishes Limitation on Victim-Injury Points in Sexual Offense Sentencing Introduction The Florida Supreme Court's decision in KARCHESKY v. STATE, 591 So.2d 930 (Fla. 1992),...

Establishment of the Mailbox Rule for Pro Se Inmates under Florida Rule 3.850

Date: Jan 3, 1992

Establishment of the Mailbox Rule for Pro Se Inmates under Florida Rule 3.850 Introduction The case of James J. HAAG v. STATE of Florida, decided by the Supreme Court of Florida on January 2, 1992,...

Upholding the Florida Contraband Forfeiture Act with Due Process Safeguards

Date: Dec 3, 1991

Upholding the Florida Contraband Forfeiture Act with Due Process Safeguards Introduction The case of Department of Law Enforcement v. Real Property, Etc., decided by the Supreme Court of Florida on...