California Case Commentaries

Iloff v. LaPaille: Employers Must Make a Reasonable Legal Inquiry to Invoke the §1194.2 Good‑Faith Defense; Paid Sick Leave Claims Are Cognizable in Berman Appeals

Date: Aug 22, 2025

Iloff v. LaPaille: Employers Must Make a Reasonable Legal Inquiry to Invoke the §1194.2 Good‑Faith Defense; Paid Sick Leave Claims Are Cognizable in Berman Appeals Introduction In Iloff v. LaPaille,...

No Parole Revocation Fine When Sentence Is Death Plus Only Indeterminate Terms: People v. Alvarez (Cal. 2025)

Date: Aug 19, 2025

No Parole Revocation Fine When Sentence Is Death Plus Only Indeterminate Terms People v. Alvarez, Supreme Court of California (Aug. 18, 2025) Introduction People v. Alvarez is a capital case arising...

Cannon’s Rule: Rational Basis Governs Equal Protection Challenges to SVPA Jury Waiver Procedures; the Jury Decision Rests with the Defendant

Date: Aug 19, 2025

Cannon’s Rule: Rational Basis Governs Equal Protection Challenges to SVPA Jury Waiver Procedures; the Jury Decision Rests with the Defendant Introduction In People v. Cannon (Cal. Aug. 18, 2025), the...

Holland v. Silverscreen Healthcare, Inc.: MICRA § 1295 Arbitration Does Not Reach Wrongful Death Claims Predicated on Custodial Neglect at Skilled Nursing Facilities

Date: Aug 15, 2025

Holland v. Silverscreen Healthcare, Inc.: MICRA § 1295 Arbitration Does Not Reach Wrongful Death Claims Predicated on Custodial Neglect at Skilled Nursing Facilities Introduction In Holland v....

Deterring Strategic Nonpayment Without Automatic Forfeiture: California Supreme Court Upholds CCP § 1281.98 Against FAA Preemption by Incorporating Relief-from-Forfeiture Doctrines

Date: Aug 12, 2025

Deterring Strategic Nonpayment Without Automatic Forfeiture: California Supreme Court Upholds CCP § 1281.98 Against FAA Preemption by Incorporating Relief-from-Forfeiture Doctrines Introduction In...

Abrogating Greyhound Deference: California Supreme Court Aligns CPUC Review with Yamaha and Code of Civil Procedure § 1094.5

Date: Aug 8, 2025

Abrogating Greyhound Deference: California Supreme Court Aligns CPUC Review with Yamaha and Code of Civil Procedure § 1094.5 Case: Center for Biological Diversity, Inc. v. Public Utilities...

No Warrant-Based Carveout: California Supreme Court Holds ICWA Extended-Family Initial Inquiry Duty Applies in All Temporary Custody Cases, and AB 81 Is a Clarifying Amendment (In re Ja.O.)

Date: Aug 5, 2025

No Warrant-Based Carveout: California Supreme Court Holds ICWA Extended-Family Initial Inquiry Duty Applies in All Temporary Custody Cases, and AB 81 Is a Clarifying Amendment (In re Ja.O.)...

Remand, Not Reinstatement: California Supreme Court Clarifies Appellate Remedies for Erroneous Romero Dismissals (People v. Dain)

Date: Aug 5, 2025

Remand, Not Reinstatement: California Supreme Court Clarifies Appellate Remedies for Erroneous Romero Dismissals Commentary on People v. Dain, Supreme Court of California (Aug. 4, 2025) Introduction...

When MICRA Stops at the Curb: California Supreme Court Limits §340.5 to Professional Duties Owed in Rendering Medical Care (Gutierrez v. Tostado)

Date: Aug 1, 2025

When MICRA Stops at the Curb: California Supreme Court Limits §340.5 to Professional Duties Owed in Rendering Medical Care Commentary on Gutierrez v. Tostado, Supreme Court of California (July 31,...

Retroactive Two‑Year Probation Cap Reaches Nonfinal Revocation Cases and Unwinds Executed Sentences: Commentary on People v. Faial (Cal. 2025)

Date: Aug 1, 2025

Retroactive Two‑Year Probation Cap Reaches Nonfinal Revocation Cases and Unwinds Executed Sentences: Commentary on People v. Faial (Cal. 2025) Introduction In People v. Faial, the California Supreme...

People v. Dunn (Cal. 2025): Rejecting Localized Juror Exclusion, Clarifying Miranda’s “Interrogation” in Medical Settings, and Endorsing Victim‑Impact Audio at Capital Sentencing

Date: Jul 25, 2025

People v. Dunn (Cal. 2025): Rejecting Localized Juror Exclusion, Clarifying Miranda’s “Interrogation” in Medical Settings, and Endorsing Victim‑Impact Audio at Capital Sentencing Introduction In...

California Supreme Court Clarifies That Differences in Jury-Trial Availability Do Not Invalidate Forum-Selection Clauses: EpicentRx, Inc. v. Superior Court (2025)

Date: Jul 22, 2025

Forum-Selection Clauses Are Not Void Simply Because the Chosen Forum Lacks Civil Jury Trials: EpicentRx, Inc. v. Superior Court (Cal. 2025) Introduction In EpicentRx, Inc. v. Superior Court, the...

People v. Choyce: Harmless Use of Disapproved “Assume the Penalty Will Be Carried Out” LWOP Instruction; Reaffirmed Limits on Heat‑of‑Passion and Live‑Victim Rape Rules

Date: Jul 22, 2025

People v. Choyce: Harmless Use of Disapproved “Assume the Penalty Will Be Carried Out” LWOP Instruction; Reaffirmed Limits on Heat‑of‑Passion and Live‑Victim Rape Rules Introduction In People v....

People v. Oyler: Clarifying Witherspoon–Witt Voir Dire After Leon and Applying Chapman Harmless Error to SB 1437 Instructional Omissions

Date: Jul 18, 2025

People v. Oyler: Clarifying Witherspoon–Witt Voir Dire After Leon and Applying Chapman Harmless Error to SB 1437 Instructional Omissions Introduction People v. Oyler is a capital case arising from a...

In re Bradshaw: Undisclosed Trustee Self-Dealing and “Common Dishonesty” Under § 6106 Require Disbarment

Date: Jul 4, 2025

In re Bradshaw: Undisclosed Trustee Self-Dealing and “Common Dishonesty” Under § 6106 Require Disbarment Court: Supreme Court of California Date: July 3, 2025 Proceeding: Attorney discipline review...

Reassessing California’s “Prior Conviction” Sentencing Exception After Erlinger: Jury Findings Required for “Increasing Seriousness” and “Unsatisfactory Probation Performance” Under Penal Code § 1170(b)

Date: Jun 27, 2025

Reassessing California’s “Prior Conviction” Sentencing Exception After Erlinger: Jury Findings Required for “Increasing Seriousness” and “Unsatisfactory Probation Performance” Under Penal Code §...

“Imposed” in Penal Code § 1172.75 Means “Imposed and Executed”: No Full Resentencing for Stayed § 667.5(b) Enhancements (People v. Rhodius)

Date: Jun 27, 2025

“Imposed” in Penal Code § 1172.75 Means “Imposed and Executed”: No Full Resentencing for Stayed § 667.5(b) Enhancements (People v. Rhodius) 1. Introduction People v. Rhodius (People v. Rhodius (2023)...

People v. Barrett (2025): No Per Se Implied Bias for CDCR Employees; Forfeiture of Jury-Bias Claims Without Exhausting Peremptories and Individual Challenges

Date: Jun 24, 2025

People v. Barrett (2025): No Per Se Implied Bias for CDCR Employees; Forfeiture of Jury-Bias Claims Without Exhausting Peremptories and Individual Challenges 1. Introduction In People v. Barrett...

People v. Jasso (2025): Refining Declarations-Against-Interest and Confrontation Rules When Witnesses Refuse to Testify

Date: Jun 18, 2025

People v. Jasso (2025): A Supreme Court of California Blueprint for Handling Recalcitrant Witnesses, Declarations Against Penal Interest, and Post-SB 1437 Felony-Murder Issues 1. Introduction On...

Felony–Murder Rule Refined: Reckless Indifference Requirement for Non-Killer Accomplices

Date: Jun 3, 2025

Felony–Murder Rule Refined: Reckless Indifference Requirement for Non-Killer Accomplices Introduction In People v. Emanuel (S280551), the Supreme Court of California re-examined the contours of the...