Arizona Case Commentaries

Affirmation of Death Sentence in the Context of 'Especially Cruel' Aggravating Factors: State v. Chappell

Date: Aug 4, 2010

Affirmation of Death Sentence in the Context of 'Especially Cruel' Aggravating Factors: State v. Chappell Introduction State of Arizona v. Derek Don Chappell, 225 Ariz. 229 (2010), adjudicated by the...

Abandoning the Sole Motivation Requirement: STATE v. KING Establishes New Standards for Self-Defense in Arizona

Date: Jul 8, 2010

Abandoning the Sole Motivation Requirement: STATE v. KING Establishes New Standards for Self-Defense in Arizona Introduction The Supreme Court of Arizona, in the landmark case of State of Arizona v....

Affirmation of Termination of Parental Rights Due to Chronic Substance Abuse: Raymond F. v. Arizona Department of Economic Security

Date: May 21, 2010

Affirmation of Termination of Parental Rights Due to Chronic Substance Abuse: Raymond F. v. Arizona Department of Economic Security Introduction The case of Raymond F. v. Arizona Department of...

Arizona Supreme Court Establishes Economic Loss Doctrine in Construction Defect Litigation

Date: Feb 13, 2010

Arizona Supreme Court Establishes Economic Loss Doctrine in Construction Defect Litigation Introduction In the landmark case of Flagstaff Affordable Housing Limited Partnership v. Design Alliance,...

Reevaluating Parental Rights Termination: The Jordan v. Arizona Department of Economic Security Case

Date: Nov 11, 2009

Reevaluating Parental Rights Termination: The Jordan v. Arizona Department of Economic Security Case Introduction The case of Jordan C., Jesse C., Kailynn C., and Michele C. v. Arizona Department of...

Sole Custody Affirmed Amid Significant Domestic Violence: Analysis of In re the Marriage of Hurd v. Hurd

Date: Oct 28, 2009

Sole Custody Affirmed Amid Significant Domestic Violence: Analysis of In re the Marriage of Hurd v. Hurd Introduction The case of In re the Marriage of Heber J. Hurd, Petitioner-Appellant, v....

Arizona Supreme Court Clarifies Limits on Aggravating Circumstances in Death Penalty Cases

Date: Jul 25, 2009

Arizona Supreme Court Clarifies Limits on Aggravating Circumstances in Death Penalty Cases Introduction The case of State of Arizona v. Paul Bradley Speer (221 Ariz. 449) presents a pivotal moment in...

State v. Moore: Reversing Premeditated Murder Convictions Due to Jury Instruction Error on Premeditation

Date: Jul 25, 2009

State v. Moore: Reversing Premeditated Murder Convictions Due to Jury Instruction Error on Premeditation Introduction In the landmark case State of Arizona v. Julius Jarreau Moore, the Supreme Court...

STATE of Arizona v. Patrick Wade BEARUP: Upholding Felony Murder and Capital Sentencing Standards

Date: Jul 18, 2009

STATE of Arizona v. Patrick Wade BEARUP: Upholding Felony Murder and Capital Sentencing Standards Introduction STATE of Arizona v. Patrick Wade BEARUP (221 Ariz. 163) is a pivotal case adjudicated by...

Reaffirming the Standards for Jury Instructions on Burden of Proof: Analysis of STATE v. VALVERDE

Date: Jun 4, 2009

Reaffirming the Standards for Jury Instructions on Burden of Proof: Analysis of State of Arizona v. Jesus Valverde, Jr. Introduction In the landmark case of State of Arizona v. Jesus Valverde, Jr....

State v. Brian Jeffrey Dann: Affirmation of Death Sentences and Capital Sentencing Standards

Date: May 20, 2009

State v. Brian Jeffrey Dann: Affirmation of Death Sentences and Capital Sentencing Standards Introduction State of Arizona, Appellee, v. Brian Jeffrey Dann. Supreme Court of Arizona, 2009. In the...

Duty of Care in Independent Medical Examinations: Analysis of Ritchie v. Krasner

Date: Apr 22, 2009

Duty of Care in Independent Medical Examinations: Analysis of Ritchie v. Krasner Introduction The case of William Ritchie, sur (221 Ariz. 288) adjudicated by the Court of Appeals of Arizona on April...

Clarifying "Significant Change in Law" for Post-Conviction Relief: State v. Shrum

Date: Mar 20, 2009

Clarifying "Significant Change in Law" for Post-Conviction Relief: State v. Shrum Introduction State of Arizona v. John Herbert Shrum (220 Ariz. 115, 2009) is a landmark decision by the Supreme Court...

SEISINGER v. SIEBEL: Upholding Judicial Rule-Making in Medical Malpractice Cases

Date: Mar 14, 2009

SEISINGER v. SIEBEL: Upholding Judicial Rule-Making in Medical Malpractice Cases Introduction The case of Laura Seisinger v. Scott Siebel, M.D., decided by the Supreme Court of Arizona on March 13,...

Lifetime Probation for Attempted Child Molestation Unavailable: Analysis of STATE of Arizona v. Gary Douglas Peek

Date: Nov 4, 2008

Lifetime Probation for Attempted Child Molestation Unavailable: Analysis of STATE of Arizona v. Gary Douglas Peek Introduction The case of STATE of Arizona v. Gary Douglas Peek (219 Ariz. 182)...

Bocharski v. State: Reduction of Death Sentence to Natural Life Imprisonment

Date: Aug 9, 2008

Bocharski v. State: Reduction of Death Sentence to Natural Life Imprisonment Introduction In the landmark case of State of Arizona v. Phillip Alan Bocharski, the Supreme Court of Arizona addressed...

Strict Scrutiny on Admissibility of Prior Bad Acts Evidence: Insights from STATE of Arizona v. Da

Date: Jul 29, 2008

Strict Scrutiny on Admissibility of Prior Bad Acts Evidence: Insights from STATE of Arizona v. Da Introduction STATE of Arizona v. Da is a pivotal case adjudicated by the Supreme Court of Arizona on...

Arizona Supreme Court Reaffirms Notice Pleading Standard under Rule 8 in Response to Twombly

Date: Jul 26, 2008

Arizona Supreme Court Reaffirms Notice Pleading Standard under Rule 8 in Response to Twombly Introduction The case of Michael Cullen and Jana Coronado v. Auto-Owners Insurance Company serves as a...

State v. Moreno-Medrano: Affirming Miranda Waiver by Conduct and Standards for Fundamental Error in Fee Imposition

Date: Jun 18, 2008

State v. Moreno-Medrano: Affirming Miranda Waiver by Conduct and Standards for Fundamental Error in Fee Imposition Introduction State of Arizona v. Luis Alberto Moreno-Medrano, 218 Ariz. 349 (2008),...

Affirmation of Sixth Amendment Rights and Interrogation Standards in Capital Cases: STATE v. Boggs

Date: Jun 17, 2008

Affirmation of Sixth Amendment Rights and Interrogation Standards in Capital Cases: STATE v. Boggs Introduction STATE of Arizona, Appellee, v. Steve Alan Boggs, 218 Ariz. 325 (2008), is a significant...