Arizona Case Commentaries

Upholding Capital Murder Conviction and Death Sentence Under Aggravating Factors: State v. Cruz

Date: Apr 22, 2008

Upholding Capital Murder Conviction and Death Sentence Under Aggravating Factors: State of Arizona v. John Montenegro Cruz Introduction State of Arizona v. John Montenegro Cruz is a landmark decision...

Clarifying Standards for Constructive Possession in Arizona: STATE v. COX

Date: Dec 22, 2007

Clarifying Standards for Constructive Possession in Arizona: STATE v. COX Introduction State of Arizona, Appellee, v. Gary Edward Cox, 217 Ariz. 353 (2007), is a pivotal case adjudicated by the...

Preclusion of Post-Conviction Claims: Insights from State of Arizona v. Swoopes

Date: Sep 20, 2007

Preclusion of Post-Conviction Claims: Insights from State of Arizona v. Swoopes Introduction State of Arizona v. Samuel Wayne Swoopes, 216 Ariz. 390 (2007), is a pivotal case from the Court of...

Severability of Aggravating Circumstances in Death Penalty Sentencing: STATE v. PANDELI

Date: Jul 13, 2007

Severability of Aggravating Circumstances in Death Penalty Sentencing: STATE v. PANDELI Introduction State of Arizona v. Darrel Peter Pandeli is a landmark judgment delivered by the Supreme Court of...

Affirmation of Death Penalty Sentencing Standards in Ruben Garza Case

Date: Jun 30, 2007

Affirmation of Death Penalty Sentencing Standards in Ruben Garza Case Introduction The case of STATE of Arizona v. Ruben Garza revolves around the conviction and sentencing of Ruben Garza for two...

State v. Cory Deonn Morris: Affirmation of Death Sentence and Validation of Corpus Delicti Doctrine

Date: Jun 19, 2007

State v. Cory Deonn Morris: Affirmation of Death Sentence and Validation of Corpus Delicti Doctrine Introduction The case of State of Arizona v. Cory Deonn Morris (215 Ariz. 324) represents a...

State of Arizona v. Tucker: Affirming Capital Sentencing Standards and Harmless Error Doctrine

Date: Jun 14, 2007

State of Arizona v. Tucker: Affirming Capital Sentencing Standards and Harmless Error Doctrine Introduction The case State of Arizona, Appellee, v. Eugene Robert Tucker, Appellant (215 Ariz. 298)...

Legislative Authority in Restitution Payments: Insights from STATE v. HANSEN

Date: May 31, 2007

Legislative Authority in Restitution Payments: Insights from STATE v. HANSEN Introduction State of Arizona v. Karen Marie Hansen, 215 Ariz. 287 (2007), addressed a significant conflict between...

Ensuring Voluntary Admissions: The Imperative of Plea-Type Colloquy Under Arizona Rule 17.6 in Stipulated Prior Convictions

Date: May 9, 2007

Ensuring Voluntary Admissions: The Imperative of Plea-Type Colloquy Under Arizona Rule 17.6 in Stipulated Prior Convictions Introduction The case of State of Arizona v. Mauricio Morales represents a...

Reynaga v. Rayes: Establishing Boundaries for Reinstatement of Expired Plea Offers

Date: Mar 21, 2007

Reynaga v. Rayes: Establishing Boundaries for Reinstatement of Expired Plea Offers Introduction Reynaga v. Rayes, decided by the Supreme Court of Arizona on March 20, 2007, addresses a pivotal issue...

Deer Valley Unified SD No. 97 v. McDonald: Enforcing Specific Settlement Amounts in Notice of Claim Letters

Date: Feb 27, 2007

Deer Valley Unified SD No. 97 v. McDonald: Enforcing Specific Settlement Amounts in Notice of Claim Letters Introduction Deer Valley Unified School District No. 97 v. McDonald is a landmark case...

Establishing Duty of Care in Prescription Drug Distribution: Insights from GIPSON v. KASEY

Date: Jan 23, 2007

Establishing Duty of Care in Prescription Drug Distribution: Insights from GIPSON v. KASEY Introduction The Supreme Court of Arizona in Susan Gipson, Individually and as Surviving Parent of Nathan...

Ineffective Assistance of Appellate Counsel: Bennett v. State of Arizona Establishes New Precedent

Date: Nov 10, 2006

Ineffective Assistance of Appellate Counsel: Bennett v. State of Arizona Establishes New Precedent Introduction In State of Arizona v. Donna Jean Bennett (213 Ariz. 562, 2006), the Supreme Court of...

Proper Service of Notice of Claim on Chief Executive Officers of Public Entities: Insights from Guadalupe FALCON v. MARICOPA COUNTY

Date: Oct 27, 2006

Proper Service of Notice of Claim on Chief Executive Officers of Public Entities: Insights from Guadalupe FALCON v. MARICOPA COUNTY Introduction The case of Guadalupe Falcon, Deceased, by and through...

State of Arizona v. Tracy Allen Hampton: Upholding Death Sentences in Multiple Homicides

Date: Aug 16, 2006

State of Arizona v. Tracy Allen Hampton: Upholding Death Sentences in Multiple Homicides Introduction State of Arizona v. Tracy Allen Hampton is a pivotal case decided by the Supreme Court of Arizona...

Affirmation of Rebuttal Hearsay Admissibility in Capital Sentencing: State v. McGill (213 Ariz. 147)

Date: Aug 15, 2006

Affirmation of Rebuttal Hearsay Admissibility in Capital Sentencing: State v. McGill (213 Ariz. 147) Introduction Case Overview: State of Arizona v. Leroy Dean McGill, 213 Ariz. 147 (2006), is a...

State v. Frank Silva Roque: Clarifying Expert Testimony Disclosure and Aggravating Circumstances in Capital Sentencing

Date: Aug 15, 2006

State v. Frank Silva Roque: Clarifying Expert Testimony Disclosure and Aggravating Circumstances in Capital Sentencing Introduction In the landmark case of State v. Frank Silva Roque, the Supreme...

State of Arizona v. Charles Ellison: Affirmation of Death Sentence and Upholding of Post-Ring II Sentencing Procedures

Date: Aug 10, 2006

State of Arizona v. Charles Ellison: Affirmation of Death Sentence and Upholding of Post-Ring II Sentencing Procedures Introduction State of Arizona v. Charles David Ellison is a pivotal case...

Proportionate Sentencing in Child Pornography Cases: An Analysis of STATE v. BERGER

Date: May 11, 2006

Proportionate Sentencing in Child Pornography Cases: An Analysis of State of Arizona v. Morton Robert Berger Introduction The case of State of Arizona v. Morton Robert Berger, decided by the Supreme...

Affirmation of Capital Sentence in STATE of Arizona v. Johnson: Establishing Witness Elimination as a Sufficient Aggravating Factor

Date: May 10, 2006

Affirmation of Capital Sentence in STATE of Arizona v. Johnson: Establishing Witness Elimination as a Sufficient Aggravating Factor Introduction In STATE of Arizona v. Ruben Myran Johnson (212 Ariz....