Arizona Case Commentaries

Strict Adherence to Procedural Rules in Party Substitution: Carranza v. Madrigal

Date: Jul 23, 2015

Strict Adherence to Procedural Rules in Party Substitution: Carranza v. Madrigal Introduction The case of Al Carranza v. Mario A. Madrigal, adjudicated by the Supreme Court of Arizona on July 22,...

Arizona Supreme Court Upholds Death Penalty in Johnathan Burns Case, Reinforcing Standards on Evidence and Procedure in Capital Trials

Date: Mar 11, 2015

Arizona Supreme Court Upholds Death Penalty in Johnathan Burns Case, Reinforcing Standards on Evidence and Procedure in Capital Trials Introduction The case of The STATE of Arizona v. Johnathan Ian...

Admissibility of General Expert Testimony: Insights from STATE of Arizona v. Martin Salazar–Mercado

Date: May 30, 2014

Admissibility of General Expert Testimony: Insights from STATE of Arizona v. Martin Salazar–Mercado Introduction In the landmark case of STATE of Arizona v. Martin Salazar–Mercado, decided by the...

Arizona Supreme Court Upholds Pension Clause Protection Against Legislative Diminishment

Date: Feb 21, 2014

Arizona Supreme Court Upholds Pension Clause Protection Against Legislative Diminishment Introduction The State of Arizona Supreme Court's decision in The Honorable Kenneth FIELDS (ret.) and The...

Affirmation of Death Sentences in Shawna Forde Case: Reinforcing Standards for Capital Sentencing and Procedural Fairness

Date: Jan 18, 2014

Affirmation of Death Sentences in Shawna Forde Case: Reinforcing Standards for Capital Sentencing and Procedural Fairness Introduction The case of Shawna Forde versus State of Arizona (315 P.3d 1200)...

Affirmation of Death Sentences Upholding Aggravating Factors and Evidentiary Decisions in State v. Payne

Date: Nov 22, 2013

Affirmation of Death Sentences Upholding Aggravating Factors and Evidentiary Decisions in State v. Payne Introduction The case of The State of Arizona v. Christopher Mathew Payne (314 P.3d 1239)...

Disbarment of Lisa M. Aubuchon: Reinforcing Ethical Standards in Legal Practice

Date: Oct 26, 2013

Disbarment of Lisa M. Aubuchon: Reinforcing Ethical Standards in Legal Practice Introduction The case titled In the Matter of a Member of the State Bar of Arizona, Lisa M. Aubuchon, Attorney No....

Enforcing Voter Mandates: Legislative Compliance under the Voter Protection Act in Cave Creek Unified School District v. Ducey

Date: Sep 27, 2013

Enforcing Voter Mandates: Legislative Compliance under the Voter Protection Act in Cave Creek Unified School District v. Ducey Introduction Cave Creek Unified School District et al. v. Doug Ducey et...

State v. Parker: Comprehensive Analysis of Speedy Trial, Hearsay Exceptions, and Confrontation Clause in Capital Sentencing

Date: Mar 14, 2013

State v. Parker: Comprehensive Analysis of Speedy Trial, Hearsay Exceptions, and Confrontation Clause in Capital Sentencing Introduction In the landmark case of State of Arizona v. Steven John...

Direct Appeal Review of Guilty Pleas in Capital Cases: Insights from STATE of Arizona v. Manuel Ovante, Jr.

Date: Jan 12, 2013

Direct Appeal Review of Guilty Pleas in Capital Cases: Insights from STATE of Arizona v. Manuel Ovante, Jr. Introduction State of Arizona v. Manuel Ovante, Jr., 291 P.3d 974 (2013), is a significant...

Tattooing as Protected Speech: Coleman v. City of Mesa Establishes Landmark Precedent

Date: Sep 8, 2012

Tattooing as Protected Speech: Coleman v. City of Mesa Establishes Landmark Precedent Introduction Coleman v. City of Mesa, 284 P.3d 863 (2012), adjudicated by the Supreme Court of Arizona,...

Arizona Supreme Court Upholds Death Sentence: Reinforcement of Batson and Felony Murder Doctrine

Date: Aug 17, 2012

Arizona Supreme Court Upholds Death Sentence: Reinforcement of Batson and Felony Murder Doctrine Introduction The case of STATE of Arizona v. Rodney Eugene Hardy (283 P.3d 12) adjudicated by the...

State of Arizona v. Dale Shawn Hausner: Upholding Capital Sentences and Addressing Emergency Wiretap Standards

Date: Jul 12, 2012

State of Arizona v. Dale Shawn Hausner: Upholding Capital Sentences and Addressing Emergency Wiretap Standards Introduction In the landmark case of State of Arizona v. Dale Shawn Hausner (280 P.3d...

Arizona Supreme Court Holds Beneficiaries Not Required to Prove Note Ownership for Non-Judicial Foreclosures

Date: Jul 12, 2012

Arizona Supreme Court Holds Beneficiaries Not Required to Prove Note Ownership for Non-Judicial Foreclosures Introduction In the landmark case of John F. Hogan v. Washington Mutual Bank, N.A.;...

Clarifying Procedural Requirements for Favorable Postconviction DNA Testing: State v. Gutierrez

Date: Jun 28, 2012

Clarifying Procedural Requirements for Favorable Postconviction DNA Testing: State v. Gutierrez Introduction State of Arizona v. Phil Osuna Gutierrez, 229 Ariz. 573 (2012), is a landmark decision by...

Arizona Supreme Court Clarifies Intrinsic Evidence in Sexual Offense Cases

Date: Apr 12, 2012

Arizona Supreme Court Clarifies Intrinsic Evidence in Sexual Offense Cases Introduction In the landmark case of State of Arizona v. Patrick M. Ferrero (229 Ariz. 239), the Arizona Supreme Court...

Non-Retroactive Application of Padilla v. Kentucky in Post-Conviction Relief: Insights from State of Arizona v. Gerardo Poblete

Date: Jul 29, 2011

Non-Retroactive Application of Padilla v. Kentucky in Post-Conviction Relief: Insights from State of Arizona v. Gerardo Poblete Introduction State of Arizona v. Gerardo Poblete (260 P.3d 1102) is a...

The Unified Standard for Pre-Verdit and Post-Verdit Motions: Analysis of STATE of Arizona v. Randall D. West and Penny A. West

Date: May 13, 2011

The Unified Standard for Pre-Verdit and Post-Verdit Motions: Analysis of STATE of Arizona v. Randall D. West and Penny A. West Introduction In STATE of Arizona v. Randall D. West and Penny A. West,...

Arizona Supreme Court Upholds Trifurcated Jury Sentencing Process in Death Penalty Cases: Analysis of STATE v. PRINCE

Date: May 7, 2011

Arizona Supreme Court Upholds Trifurcated Jury Sentencing Process in Death Penalty Cases: Analysis of STATE v. PRINCE Introduction State of Arizona v. Wayne Benoit Prince, 226 Ariz. 516 (2011), is a...

Affirmation of Death Sentence in STATE of Arizona v. Mike Peter Gallardo: Reinforcing Standards for Aggravating Factors and Prosecutorial Conduct

Date: Dec 1, 2010

Affirmation of Death Sentence in STATE of Arizona v. Mike Peter Gallardo: Reinforcing Standards for Aggravating Factors and Prosecutorial Conduct Introduction In the landmark case of STATE of Arizona...