Alabama Case Commentaries

Ex parte Tanner: Extending Ford’s “Relate-To” Specific Jurisdiction to Cross‑Border Health Systems; AMLA Venue Applicability to Out‑of‑State Malpractice Unresolved

Date: Sep 13, 2025

Ex parte Tanner: Extending Ford’s “Relate-To” Specific Jurisdiction to Cross‑Border Health Systems; AMLA Venue Applicability to Out‑of‑State Malpractice Unresolved Introduction This commentary...

No State Exhaustion Bar to § 1983 Due‑Process Delay Claims; Alabama Supreme Court Remands for Fact‑Finding on Mootness After SCOTUS Reversal

Date: Sep 13, 2025

No State Exhaustion Bar to § 1983 Due‑Process Delay Claims; Alabama Supreme Court Remands for Fact‑Finding on Mootness After SCOTUS Reversal Introduction This commentary analyzes the Alabama Supreme...

Post-Notice Rule 54(b) Certifications Are Nullities; Foster Remand Is Discretionary When Finality and Intertwined Issues Are Unclear

Date: Sep 13, 2025

Post-Notice Rule 54(b) Certifications Are Nullities; Foster Remand Is Discretionary When Finality and Intertwined Issues Are Unclear 1. Introduction In Richard D. Gaynor, as personal representative...

No Presumption from Criminal Stand‑Your‑Ground Immunity: Alabama Supreme Court Reaffirms Rule 56 Burdens in Subsequent Civil Cases

Date: Sep 9, 2025

No Presumption from Criminal Stand‑Your‑Ground Immunity: Alabama Supreme Court Reaffirms Rule 56 Burdens in Subsequent Civil Cases Introduction In Arethea Hurbert, an incompetent person, by and...

Municipal Immunity Does Not Automatically Defeat Fraud Claims: Alabama Supreme Court Clarifies § 11-47-190 and Limits Mandamus Review to Preserved Immunity Grounds

Date: Aug 30, 2025

Municipal Immunity Does Not Automatically Defeat Fraud Claims: Alabama Supreme Court Clarifies § 11-47-190 and Limits Mandamus Review to Preserved Immunity Grounds Introduction In Ex parte City of...

Absent Transcript, Appellate Deference Controls: Circuit Courts May Not Recalculate Probate Administrator ad Litem Fees on Appeal Under § 12-22-20

Date: Aug 30, 2025

Absent Transcript, Appellate Deference Controls: Circuit Courts May Not Recalculate Probate Administrator ad Litem Fees on Appeal Under § 12-22-20 Introduction This commentary examines the Alabama...

Franklin Structures v. Williams: Ratification by Warranty Service Binds Homebuyers to Mediation-First Arbitration; Trial Courts Must Compel Mediation Before Arbitration

Date: Aug 30, 2025

Franklin Structures v. Williams: Ratification by Warranty Service Binds Homebuyers to Mediation-First Arbitration; Trial Courts Must Compel Mediation Before Arbitration Introduction In Franklin...

Relative-Hardship Over Breach: Alabama Supreme Court Clarifies Clean-Hands Limits and Balancing in Restrictive Covenant Injunctions

Date: Aug 30, 2025

Relative-Hardship Over Breach: Alabama Supreme Court Clarifies Clean-Hands Limits and Balancing in Restrictive Covenant Injunctions Case: Rodney G. Englund, Dyann K. Englund, and Georgetown...

Tracing to a “Specific Drug Transaction” Not Required for Currency Forfeiture under Former § 20-2-93; Ore Tenus Deference Reaffirmed — Ex parte State of Alabama ex rel. Broussard (Ala. 2025)

Date: Aug 30, 2025

Tracing to a “Specific Drug Transaction” Not Required for Currency Forfeiture under Former § 20-2-93; Ore Tenus Deference Reaffirmed Ex parte State of Alabama ex rel. Robert Broussard, District...

No Stand‑Your‑Ground, No Prior‑Crimes: Alabama Supreme Court Limits 404(b) Use To Prove “Unlawful Activity” When Self‑Defense Proceeds Under the Common Law

Date: Aug 30, 2025

No Stand‑Your‑Ground, No Prior‑Crimes: Alabama Supreme Court Limits 404(b) Use To Prove “Unlawful Activity” When Self‑Defense Proceeds Under the Common Law Case: Ex parte Corey Lee Walton, Supreme...

Rogers v. Cedar Bluff: Alabama Supreme Court Clarifies Municipal Vicarious Immunity for Volunteer Firefighters and the Status of Municipal Volunteer Fire Departments

Date: Aug 30, 2025

Rogers v. Cedar Bluff: Alabama Supreme Court Clarifies Municipal Vicarious Immunity for Volunteer Firefighters and the Status of Municipal Volunteer Fire Departments Introduction In Carol Rogers, as...

“Truthful-but-Misleading” Communications, Limited Proximate Cause, and Line-and-Scope Constraints: The New Framework from Flickinger v. King (Ala. 2025)

Date: Aug 25, 2025

“Truthful-but-Misleading” Communications, Limited Proximate Cause, and Line-and-Scope Constraints: The Alabama Supreme Court’s New Framework for Tortious Interference in Flickinger v. King (2025)...

Supreme Court of Alabama Clarifies Enforceability of Text-Message Settlements: Definiteness and the Mirror-Image Rule Remain Paramount

Date: Aug 25, 2025

Supreme Court of Alabama Clarifies Enforceability of Text-Message Settlements: Definiteness and the Mirror-Image Rule Remain Paramount Introduction In iWTNS, Inc.; Leveraged, LLC; and Bradley Lewis...

CBS Holdings, LLC v. Hexagon US Federal, Inc.: A New Benchmark for Documentary Support and Peebles-Factor Analysis in Alabama Attorney-Fee Awards

Date: Jul 12, 2025

CBS Holdings, LLC v. Hexagon US Federal, Inc.: The Supreme Court of Alabama Demands Transparent, Substantiated Fee Petitions and Explicit Peebles-Factor Findings 1. Introduction CBS Holdings, LLC v....

The “Depicted-Access Facilities” Doctrine: Alabama Supreme Court Clarifies When Easement Alterations Require Unanimous Consent

Date: Jul 9, 2025

The “Depicted-Access Facilities” Doctrine: Alabama Supreme Court Clarifies When Easement Alterations Require Unanimous Consent Introduction 790 Montclair, LLC v. The Station at Crestline Heights, LLC...

“Express Survivorship” & “Alternative Devise” Defeat Alabama’s Antilapse Statute – A Commentary on Johnson v. Mayers (2025)

Date: Jun 30, 2025

“Express Survivorship” & “Alternative Devise” Defeat Alabama’s Antilapse Statute – Comprehensive Commentary on Timothy Brian Johnson & Phillip Barnes v. Judith Mayers, SC-2025-0297 I. Introduction In...

“Accident Location Alone Is Not Enough” – Alabama Supreme Court Strengthens the Dual-Nexus Test for Interest-of-Justice Venue Transfers

Date: Jun 30, 2025

“Accident Location Alone Is Not Enough” – Alabama Supreme Court Strengthens the Dual-Nexus Test for Interest-of-Justice Venue Transfers 1. Introduction In Ex parte Nathan Nash, the Supreme Court of...

Extending Engquist to Academia: The Alabama Supreme Court Refines Class-of-One Claims and § 14 Immunity in Ex parte Roberts

Date: Jun 30, 2025

Extending Engquist to Academia: The Alabama Supreme Court Refines Class-of-One Claims and § 14 Immunity in Ex parte Roberts 1. Introduction This commentary unpacks the Supreme Court of Alabama’s...

Passive Online Disclosures & Unsworn Declarations: Ex parte GBC International Bank Clarifies Specific Jurisdiction in Alabama

Date: Jun 30, 2025

Passive Online Disclosures & Unsworn Declarations: Ex parte GBC International Bank Clarifies Specific Jurisdiction in Alabama Introduction On 27 June 2025, the Supreme Court of Alabama handed down Ex...

Beyond § 30-2-57(c): Alabama Supreme Court Affirms Ongoing Common-Law Authority to Reserve Jurisdiction for Future Periodic Alimony

Date: Jun 30, 2025

Beyond § 30-2-57(c): Alabama Supreme Court Affirms Ongoing Common-Law Authority to Reserve Jurisdiction for Future Periodic Alimony Introduction In Ex parte Edward Conant Gartrell, Jr., the Supreme...