1st Circuit Case Commentaries

First Circuit Affirms Dismissal in Political Discrimination Claims under Section 1983

Date: Jun 21, 2007

First Circuit Affirms Dismissal in Political Discrimination Claims under Section 1983 Introduction The case of Enid Marrero-Gutierrez and Alejandro Bou Santiago v. Esperanza Molina et al., decided by...

Strict Pleading Standards for Scienter under PSLRA Affirmed in Rodríguez-Ortiz v. Margo Caribe

Date: Jun 19, 2007

Strict Pleading Standards for Scienter under PSLRA Affirmed in Rodríguez-Ortiz v. Margo Caribe Introduction In the landmark case of Rodríguez-Ortiz v. Margo Caribe, Inc.; Michael J. Spector, decided...

Impact of Fed.R.Civ.P. 68 on Attorney's Fee Awards in §1983 Civil Rights Litigation

Date: Jun 13, 2007

Impact of Fed.R.Civ.P. 68 on Attorney's Fee Awards in §1983 Civil Rights Litigation Introduction Albertha Bogan, Individually and as Guardian and Next Friend of Tyla Bogan, Eryn Bogan and Chad Bogan...

Jian Pan v. Gonzalez: Reinforcing the One-Year Deadline and Strict Credibility Assessment in Asylum Claims

Date: Jun 8, 2007

Jian Pan v. Gonzalez: Reinforcing the One-Year Deadline and Strict Credibility Assessment in Asylum Claims Introduction In the landmark case of Jian Pan v. Alberto R. Gonzalez, the United States...

Younger Abstention Applied to Mechanics' Lien Proceedings: Rossi v. Gemma

Date: Jun 1, 2007

Younger Abstention Applied to Mechanics' Lien Proceedings: Rossi v. Gemma Introduction Rossi v. Gemma, 489 F.3d 26 (1st Cir. 2007), is a pivotal case that explores the application of Younger...

Affirmation of Security Release Under Fed.R.Civ.P. 65(c) in Global NAPs, Inc. v. Verizon New England, Inc.

Date: May 31, 2007

Affirmation of Security Release Under Fed.R.Civ.P. 65(c) in Global NAPs, Inc. v. Verizon New England, Inc. Introduction The case of Global NAPs, Inc. v. Verizon New England, Inc., decided on May 30,...

Integrated-Enterprise Liability and Hostile Work Environment: Torres-Negrón v. Merck Company

Date: May 24, 2007

Integrated-Enterprise Liability and Hostile Work Environment: Torres-Negrón v. Merck Company Introduction In the case of Kathleen Torres-Negrón v. Merck Company, Inc., the United States Court of...

United States v. Muñoz-Franco et al.: A Landmark Ruling on Bank Fraud and Misapplication of Funds

Date: May 23, 2007

United States v. Muñoz-Franco et al.: A Landmark Ruling on Bank Fraud and Misapplication of Funds Introduction United States of America v. Lorenzo Muñoz-Franco, Francisco Sánchez-Arán, Ariel...

Telecorp Communications v. Hoyos: Establishing Federal Procedural Supremacy and Upholding Summary Judgment in Employment Discrimination Claims

Date: May 19, 2007

Telecorp Communications v. Hoyos: Establishing Federal Procedural Supremacy and Upholding Summary Judgment in Employment Discrimination Claims Introduction Case Overview: The case of Omar Hoyos,...

Affirmation of Federal Death Penalty: Comprehensive Analysis of Sampson v. USA

Date: May 8, 2007

Affirmation of Federal Death Penalty: Comprehensive Analysis of Sampson v. USA Introduction Sampson v. USA is a landmark case adjudicated by the United States Court of Appeals for the First Circuit...

Enforceability of Employment Release Agreements in Discrimination Cases: Cabán Hernández v. Philip Morris USA

Date: May 2, 2007

Enforceability of Employment Release Agreements in Discrimination Cases: Cabán Hernández v. Philip Morris USA Introduction Cabán Hernández v. Philip Morris USA is a pivotal case adjudicated by the...

Clarifying the Exhaustion Requirement for Habeas Petitions under AEDPA: CLEMENTS v. MALONEY

Date: May 1, 2007

Clarifying the Exhaustion Requirement for Habeas Petitions under AEDPA: CLEMENTS v. MALONEY Introduction The case of Jason Clements, Petitioner, Appellant, v. Michael T. Maloney, Respondent, Appellee...

Reinforcing the High Standard for Deliberate Indifference: First Circuit's Ruling in Ruiz-Rosa v. Rullán

Date: Apr 25, 2007

Reinforcing the High Standard for Deliberate Indifference: First Circuit's Ruling in Ruiz-Rosa v. Rullán Introduction In the case of Angelina Ruiz-Rosa v. Johnny Rullán, the United States Court of...

First Circuit Establishes Immunity Protections for State Officials in Takings Claims: Flores Galarza v. JUA

Date: Apr 19, 2007

First Circuit Establishes Immunity Protections for State Officials in Takings Claims: Flores Galarza v. JUA Introduction The case of ASOCIACION DE SUBSCRIPCION CONJUNTA DEL SEGURO DE RESPONSABILIDAD...

Freadman v. Metropolitan Property and Casualty Insurance Company: Affirmation of Summary Judgment in ADA Discrimination Claim

Date: Apr 19, 2007

Freadman v. Metropolitan Property and Casualty Insurance Company: Affirmation of Summary Judgment in ADA Discrimination Claim Introduction In the landmark case of Michele R. Freadman v. Metropolitan...

Owens v. United States: Affirming Counsel's Duty to Advise on Testimony Rights and Upholding the Right to a Public Trial

Date: Apr 13, 2007

Owens v. United States: Affirming Counsel's Duty to Advise on Testimony Rights and Upholding the Right to a Public Trial Introduction Owens v. United States, 483 F.3d 48 (1st Cir. 2007), is a pivotal...

RLUIPA and the Limits of Inmate Religious Activities: Insights from Spratt v. Rhode Island Department of Corrections

Date: Apr 7, 2007

RLUIPA and the Limits of Inmate Religious Activities: Insights from Spratt v. Rhode Island Department of Corrections Introduction Spratt v. Rhode Island Department of Corrections, 482 F.3d 33 (1st...

First Circuit Affirms Dismissal of Claims Due to Insufficient Pleading on COI Rate Increases in FPAL Policies

Date: Mar 24, 2007

SunAmerica Life Assurance Company’s COI Rate Increases: First Circuit Upholds Dismissal of Breach of Contract and Unfair Practice Claims Introduction In the case of Nancy Brooks, Trustee of the...

Limitations on Ancillary Jurisdiction for Expungement Motions: United States v. Coloian

Date: Mar 21, 2007

Limitations on Ancillary Jurisdiction for Expungement Motions: United States v. Coloian Introduction United States of America v. Artin H. Coloian, 480 F.3d 47 (1st Cir. 2007), is a pivotal case...

Equitable Tolling Not Applicable for Attorney’s Error in Federal Habeas Petitions under AEDPA: An Analysis of Trapp v. Spencer

Date: Mar 2, 2007

Equitable Tolling Not Applicable for Attorney’s Error in Federal Habeas Petitions under AEDPA: An Analysis of Trapp v. Spencer Introduction Trapp v. Spencer, 479 F.3d 53 (1st Cir. 2007), is a pivotal...