1st Circuit Case Commentaries

Broad Immunity under CDA Section 230 Upheld in Universal Communication Systems, Inc. v. Lycos, Inc.

Date: Feb 24, 2007

Broad Immunity under CDA Section 230 Upheld in Universal Communication Systems, Inc. v. Lycos, Inc. Introduction In the landmark case of Universal Communication Systems, Inc.; Michael J. Zwebner v....

Strengthening the Burden of Proof for Corporate Veil Piercing in Personal Jurisdiction Cases

Date: Feb 10, 2007

Strengthening the Burden of Proof for Corporate Veil Piercing in Personal Jurisdiction Cases Introduction The case of Ivis L. Negrón-Torres v. Verizon Communications, Inc. examines the complexities...

Court Affirms Preemption and Denies Private Right of Action in Airline Fee Refunds

Date: Feb 8, 2007

Court Affirms Preemption and Denies Private Right of Action in Airline Fee Refunds 1. Introduction Court Case: Craig BUCK et al. v. AMERICAN AIRLINES, INC., et al. Court: United States Court of...

Class Action Ineligibility for Rescission Claims under TILA: McKENNA v. FIRST HORIZON HOME LOAN CORP.

Date: Jan 30, 2007

Class Action Ineligibility for Rescission Claims under TILA: McKENNA v. FIRST HORIZON HOME LOAN CORP. Introduction The case of Ralph McKenna et al. v. First Horizon Home Loan Corp., decided by the...

Exhaustion of State Remedies in Mixed Habeas Corpus Petitions: Analysis of Josselyn v. Dennahy

Date: Jan 20, 2007

Exhaustion of State Remedies in Mixed Habeas Corpus Petitions: Analysis of Josselyn v. Dennahy Introduction The appellate decision in Josselyn v. Dennahy addresses significant procedural questions...

Preserving Diversity Jurisdiction Amid Nondiverse Intervention: Insights from IN RE OLYMPIC MILLS CORP.

Date: Jan 18, 2007

Preserving Diversity Jurisdiction Amid Nondiverse Intervention: Insights from IN RE OLYMPIC MILLS CORP. 1. Introduction The case of IN RE OLYMPIC MILLS CORPoration presents a significant examination...

Revising the Burden-Shifting Framework Under USERRA: Insights from Velázquez v. Horizon Lines

Date: Jan 5, 2007

Revising the Burden-Shifting Framework Under USERRA: Insights from Velázquez v. Horizon Lines Introduction The case of Carlos VELÁZQUEZ-GARCÍA v. HORIZON LINES OF PUERTO RICO, INC. (473 F.3d 11) was...

Establishing Claimant Prejudice in ERISA Benefit Denials Due to Plan Ambiguities and Procedural Failures

Date: Dec 20, 2006

Establishing Claimant Prejudice in ERISA Benefit Denials Due to Plan Ambiguities and Procedural Failures 1. Introduction The case of Paul Bard v. Boston Shipping Association; International...

Protection of Informant Privacy in FOIA Requests: Carpenter v. U.S. Dept. of Justice

Date: Dec 13, 2006

Protection of Informant Privacy in FOIA Requests: Carpenter v. United States Department of Justice Introduction In Carpenter v. United States Department of Justice, 470 F.3d 434 (1st Cir. 2006), the...

Reaffirming Summary Judgment Standards and Pleading Requirements under Section 1983 in Calvi v. Knox County

Date: Dec 12, 2006

Reaffirming Summary Judgment Standards and Pleading Requirements under Section 1983 in Calvi v. Knox County Introduction Calvi v. Knox County, 470 F.3d 422 (1st Cir. 2006), is a notable decision by...

First Circuit Establishes Express Language Requirement for Indemnity in Inter Se Litigation

Date: Dec 9, 2006

First Circuit Establishes Express Language Requirement for Indemnity in Inter Se Litigation Introduction In the landmark case of Caldwell Tanks, Inc. v. Haley Ward, Inc. (471 F.3d 210, 1st Cir....

Strengthened Standards for Proving Past Persecution in Asylum Cases: Alibeaj v. Gonzales

Date: Nov 23, 2006

Strengthened Standards for Proving Past Persecution in Asylum Cases: Alibeaj v. Gonzales Introduction The case of Violeta Alibeaj v. Alberto Gonzales, Attorney General, 469 F.3d 188 (1st Cir. 2006),...

Administrative Record Rule in CDP Hearing Appeals: Murphy v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue

Date: Nov 21, 2006

Administrative Record Rule in CDP Hearing Appeals: Murphy v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue Introduction Murphy v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue, 469 F.3d 27 (1st Cir. 2006), is a pivotal case...

Establishing Qualified Immunity in Warrantless Entry Cases: Buchanan v. State of Maine

Date: Nov 17, 2006

Establishing Qualified Immunity in Warrantless Entry Cases: Buchanan v. State of Maine Introduction Buchanan v. State of Maine is a pivotal case adjudicated by the United States Court of Appeals for...

Presumed vs. Actual Prejudice in Ineffective Assistance of Counsel Claims: Insights from United States v. Theodore

Date: Nov 16, 2006

Presumed vs. Actual Prejudice in Ineffective Assistance of Counsel Claims: Insights from United States v. Theodore Introduction United States of America v. Thomas Ronald Theodore, 468 F.3d 52 (1st...

Enhancement of Sentencing Guidelines in Illegal Reentry Cases: Analysis of United States v. Turbides-Leonardo

Date: Nov 15, 2006

Enhancement of Sentencing Guidelines in Illegal Reentry Cases: Analysis of United States v. Turbides-Leonardo Introduction The case of United States of America v. Rafael Turbides-Leonardo (468 F.3d...

In Pari Delicto Doctrine Affirmed in Bankruptcy Context: Nisselson v. Lernout et al.

Date: Nov 9, 2006

In Pari Delicto Doctrine Affirmed in Bankruptcy Context: Nisselson v. Lernout et al. Introduction The case of Alan Nisselson, Trustee of the Dictaphone Litigation Trust, Plaintiff, Appellant, v. Jo...

Burel ORELIEN v. Alberto GONZALES: Establishing Stringent Criteria for Asylum Claims

Date: Nov 4, 2006

Burel ORELIEN v. Alberto GONZALES: Establishing Stringent Criteria for Asylum Claims Introduction Burel ORELIEN v. Alberto GONZALES is a seminal case adjudicated by the United States Court of Appeals...

Judicial Estoppel and Excessive Force Claims: Insights from Thore v. Howe et al.

Date: Oct 28, 2006

Judicial Estoppel and Excessive Force Claims: Insights from Thore v. Howe et al. Introduction In Charles Thore v. Jeffrey Howe et al., the United States Court of Appeals for the First Circuit...

Deliberate Indifference in Correctional Medical Care: Feeney v. Correctional Medical Services, Inc.

Date: Oct 3, 2006

Deliberate Indifference in Correctional Medical Care: Feeney v. Correctional Medical Services, Inc. Introduction The case of James M. Feeney v. Correctional Medical Services, Inc., decided by the...