Women’s Doubles Teams Require a Proper Event-Specific Selection Process and Cannot Be Formed Merely from Singles Selections
Case: DR RAJALAKSHMI SHANKAR JANARDHANA MURTHY v. THE SECRETARY REPBY UNION OF INDIA
Court: High Court of Karnataka at Bengaluru
Case No.: Writ Petition No. 26896 of 2026 (GM-RES)
Date: 16 September 2026
Judge: Hon’ble Mr. Justice C.M. Poonacha
Introduction
The case concerned the selection of India’s women’s para table tennis team for the Aichi-Nagoya 2026 Asian Para Games. The petitioner, Dr Rajalakshmi Shankar Janardhana Murthy, is an orthodontist, academic and wheelchair-bound para table tennis player with an 80% permanent disability. She had represented India internationally and was listed in the International Table Tennis Federation rankings.
The petitioner sought a writ of mandamus requiring consideration of her appeal and candidature for the Games. Although she did not satisfy the prescribed ranking benchmark for the women’s singles event, she and her doubles partner were acknowledged by the Union Government to satisfy the eligibility criterion applicable to women’s doubles.
The central issue was whether the Paralympic Committee of India could fill all six women’s slots solely on the basis of singles rankings and then permit those players to choose doubles partners only from among themselves, without conducting a proper selection process for the notified women’s doubles events.
Policy and Factual Background
Selection criteria
The Ministry of Youth Affairs and Sports had issued a policy dated 24 September 2025 governing selection for the 2026 Asian Para Games and other multi-sport competitions.
-
For non-measurable individual events, an athlete ordinarily had to finish sixth or better in the relevant Senior Asian Championship or be among the top six Asian athletes in the international rankings.
-
For team sports and team events, including doubles, the team had to finish within the top eight at the relevant Asian Championship or rank within the top eight among Asian countries shortly before the entry deadline.
-
Where participation in an Asian Championship event was low, stricter standards applied. If fewer than six countries participated, only the top two positions qualified through that competition.
The petitioner’s record
The petitioner relied on achievements including:
- Bronze medal in Doubles, Class 5, at the ITTF Para Asian Championships, Beijing 2025;
- Bronze medal in Singles, Class 1–2, at the ITTF Kazakhstan Para Open 2024; and
- Bronze medal in Singles, Class 1–2, at the ITTF Egypt Para Open 2024.
Singles and doubles eligibility
In singles, the petitioner was ranked eleventh in Asia on the relevant cut-off date and therefore failed to meet the top-six benchmark. Her bronze medal in the 2025 doubles event also did not independently qualify her through the Asian Championship route because only four countries had participated and the low-participation rule required a top-two finish.
Nevertheless, the Union Government expressly accepted that the petitioner and her doubles partner were ranked sixth in their category and therefore met the top-eight eligibility criterion under Clause 4.1(III)(a) of the policy.
Summary of the Judgment
The High Court found that the Paralympic Committee of India had selected six women players exclusively on the basis of singles rankings. Those players were then expected to choose doubles partners from within that group, subject to the applicable classification combinations.
The Court held that this approach was ex facie inconsistent with accepted norms governing doubles selection. A doubles pair ordinarily consists of players accustomed to competing together, and selection must account for compatibility, combination requirements and event-specific performance.
The Court also noted that the Committee’s affidavit did not disclose any genuine selection exercise for the various women’s doubles events notified by the Asian Paralympic Committee. It further recorded the petitioner’s allegation that men’s doubles teams had been selected while no comparable process had been followed for women’s doubles.
The Court accordingly:
- Directed the concerned respondents to reconsider the selection of teams for the women’s doubles table tennis events;
- Required them specifically to consider whether the petitioner was entitled to selection;
- Ordered completion of the exercise within one week of receiving the order;
- Directed that an endeavour be made to recommend eligible athletes before the final participation deadline; and
- Directed the Ministry and the Sports Authority of India to take corrective measures so that future selection processes conform to established norms.
The Court did not directly select the petitioner, nor did it finally determine which respondent had ultimate responsibility for completing the selection process.
Analysis
Precedents Cited
The judgment did not cite or rely upon any previous judicial decision. Its conclusion was based on the governing selection policy, the affidavits filed by the respondents, the Asian Paralympic Committee’s event structure and the requirements of a fair and rational selection process.
Consequently, the ruling’s significance lies principally in its application of administrative-law standards to sports selection rather than in its interpretation of an earlier precedent.
Legal Reasoning
1. Eligibility and selection are distinct
The judgment implicitly distinguishes between being eligible for consideration and possessing an automatic right to selection. The petitioner did not qualify in singles, but she satisfied the doubles eligibility benchmark. This entitled her to proper consideration under a valid doubles-selection process, not automatic nomination.
2. Doubles selection must be event-specific
The Ministry’s policy separately recognized individual and team events. The Court therefore treated doubles as a distinct competitive category rather than as an incidental extension of singles. A federation cannot effectively eliminate the doubles eligibility route by filling every available women’s slot through singles rankings alone.
3. Pair compatibility is a relevant selection consideration
Doubles performance depends upon coordination, familiarity, complementary skills and valid class combinations. The Court found that permitting singles players to choose partners only after their selection ignored these material considerations. A technically rational process must assess the pair as a competitive unit.
4. Sports expertise does not exclude judicial review
The Court did not substitute its own sporting assessment for that of the responsible authorities. Instead, it reviewed whether the process was consistent with the governing policy and established norms. Judicial intervention was justified because the disclosed procedure failed to demonstrate meaningful selection for women’s doubles.
5. Administrative discretion must operate within the policy
National Sports Federations possess technical discretion in composing teams, but that discretion cannot defeat an express eligibility category. Once the policy recognizes doubles rankings and the Government accepts that a pair satisfies those criteria, the federation must genuinely consider the pair through a rational procedure.
6. Time-sensitive relief was essential
Sports-selection disputes can become meaningless if decided after a tournament’s entry deadline. The one-week time limit preserved the practical value of the remedy and reflected the urgency associated with international competition schedules.
Nature of the Principle Established
The decision establishes that where a sports policy separately prescribes eligibility for doubles or team events, the selecting federation must undertake a genuine, event-specific selection exercise. It cannot rely exclusively on singles rankings and confine doubles participation to players already selected for singles if that method excludes otherwise eligible doubles pairs without relevant technical assessment.
Impact
-
Greater procedural scrutiny: Sports bodies may be required to demonstrate how selection criteria were applied to each event category.
-
Protection for specialist doubles players: Athletes who qualify as a pair cannot be excluded merely because they do not independently satisfy singles benchmarks.
-
Transparent slot allocation: Federations should publish how limited athlete quotas will be distributed between singles, doubles and other events.
-
Attention to gender parity: Although the Court did not finally decide a discrimination claim, its reasoning discourages unexplained differences between men’s and women’s doubles-selection procedures.
-
Limited judicial substitution: Courts may require reconsideration and procedural correction while leaving the ultimate technical selection to sporting authorities.
-
Institutional accountability: The Ministry and Sports Authority of India must supervise federations sufficiently to ensure that selections comply with policy and established norms.
Complex Concepts Simplified
- Writ of mandamus
-
A court order directing a public authority to perform a legal or public duty. Here, the petitioner sought an order requiring the authorities to consider her candidature.
- Eligibility versus selection
-
Eligibility means an athlete qualifies to be considered. Selection is the later decision choosing the athlete for the final team.
- Ex facie
-
“On the face of it.” The Court considered the defects in the disclosed doubles-selection procedure apparent without requiring an extensive factual trial.
- National Sports Federation
-
The recognized sporting body responsible for administering a discipline and ordinarily recommending athletes for international competitions.
- Low-participation rule
-
A stricter qualification standard used where very few countries competed in a championship, preventing a medal won in a small field from automatically establishing eligibility.
- Judicial review of sports selection
-
Courts generally do not decide which athlete is technically superior. They may intervene where the process is arbitrary, contrary to policy, discriminatory or based on irrelevant considerations.
Conclusion
The Karnataka High Court recognized that doubles competition requires more than assembling players selected for singles. Where policy creates a separate eligibility pathway for doubles, eligible pairs must receive genuine and technically informed consideration.
The ruling does not confer an automatic right on the petitioner to represent India. Its importance lies in requiring a fair, event-specific and policy-compliant reconsideration while preserving the sporting authorities’ power to make the final technical decision. It also places supervisory responsibility on the Ministry and the Sports Authority of India to prevent similarly defective selection processes in future international competitions.