Unsubstantiated Bar Hostility Does Not Justify Transfer; In-Camera Trial May Safeguard Fairness

Case: Dakoju Venkat Rao v. State of Odisha

Court: Orissa High Court

Coram: Justice Sanjay Kumar Mishra

Date: 11 September 2026

Citation: 2026:OHC:124

1. Introduction

The decision concerns a request by two accused persons to transfer S.T. Case No.41 of 2025 from the Court of the Session Judge, Gajapati at Parlakhemundi, to the Court of the Session Judge, Berhampur, Ganjam. The prosecution arose from an acid-attack case in which the victim was an advocate and a member of the Parlakhemundi Bar Association.

The petitioners alleged that local advocates were obstructing the trial, intimidating them and refusing to cooperate. They contended that the presence and influence of members of the local Bar created an atmosphere prejudicial to a fair trial. The State and the informant—who had been Secretary and was then President of the Parlakhemundi Bar Association—disputed these allegations.

The principal issues were whether the alleged hostility of the local Bar justified transfer of the criminal trial and, if not, whether alternative safeguards could protect the accused’s right to defend themselves fairly while preserving the requirement of an expeditious acid-attack trial.

2. Summary of the Judgment

  • The High Court refused to transfer S.T. Case No.41 of 2025 to Berhampur.
  • The official report of the Registrar, Civil Courts, Gajapati did not support the allegations of obstruction, intimidation or non-cooperation.
  • The record showed that advocates from the Parlakhemundi Bar Association were representing the accused and that an advocate from Visakhapatnam was also appearing.
  • No prior complaint about obstruction or intimidation had been submitted to the trial court.
  • Because the victim was a local advocate and the presence of numerous Bar members could create an intimidating atmosphere, the High Court directed that the remaining trial be conducted in camera.
  • The President and Secretary of the Parlakhemundi Bar Association were directed to ensure that its members did not hinder the trial.
  • The Session Judge was directed to conclude the proceeding at the earliest, following the timelines governing acid-attack cases and the Supreme Court’s directions on continuous examination of witnesses and avoidance of unnecessary adjournments.

3. Analysis

3.1 Transfer Requires Credible Material, Not Mere Apprehension

The Court treated transfer of the trial as unnecessary because the petitioners’ allegations were not supported by the objective record. The Registrar reported that proceedings were taking place smoothly, without external pressure, and that no complaint concerning intimidation or obstruction had previously been made to the trial court.

The petitioners’ assertion that they could not obtain representation from the local Bar was also contradicted by the record. Advocate A.K. Parida of the Parlakhemundi Bar Association had represented one accused since 5 June 2025, while Advocate S.K. Pal had initially acted as State Defence Counsel for the other. Later, advocates from Visakhapatnam also entered appearance.

The decision therefore indicates that a criminal trial will not ordinarily be transferred solely on a general allegation that the local Bar is hostile. The apprehension of prejudice must have a reasonable and verifiable foundation. Representation by members of the same Bar and the absence of contemporaneous complaints were significant factors against transfer.

3.2 Balancing Fair Trial and Speedy Trial

Although transfer was refused, the Court did not dismiss the petitioners’ concerns altogether. It recognized that the victim’s status as an advocate and the attendance of numerous local Bar members could produce a “scary atmosphere” inside the courtroom. Such an atmosphere could inhibit effective defence even if no actual obstruction had yet been proved.

The Court balanced two competing interests:

  1. the accused’s right to a fair and uninhibited trial; and
  2. the victim’s and the public’s interest in the timely conclusion of a serious acid-attack prosecution.

Transfer to Berhampur could have inconvenienced local prosecution witnesses and delayed a trial in which six of twenty-five witnesses had already been examined. An in-camera trial was therefore selected as a narrower and more proportionate remedy.

3.3 In-Camera Proceedings as a Protective Alternative

The central practical principle emerging from the judgment is that an in-camera trial may be used as an alternative to transfer where courtroom attendance or local sensitivities create a genuine concern about atmosphere, but the evidence does not establish institutional bias or actual obstruction.

This approach preserves the existing forum, avoids disruption of witness attendance and protects the accused from an intimidating public or professional presence. It also demonstrates that courts should consider less disruptive procedural safeguards before relocating an ongoing criminal trial.

3.4 Responsibility of the Bar

The direction to the President and Secretary of the Parlakhemundi Bar Association is significant. The Court placed an affirmative responsibility on the Bar’s leadership to ensure that members did not obstruct or hinder the proceeding.

The order reflects the principle that advocates, as participants in the administration of justice, must not allow professional solidarity with a victim to interfere with the accused’s right to legal representation or with the orderly conduct of a criminal trial.

4. Precedents Cited

4.1 Shaheen Malik Vs. Union of India

The informant relied on the Supreme Court’s directions in W.P.(C) No.1112 of 2025, Shaheen Malik Vs. Union of India, concerning the expeditious investigation, trial and rehabilitation of acid-attack cases.

Pursuant to those directions, the Orissa High Court had issued Circular No.XI-49/2025/7188(30), dated 1 May 2026, prescribing the following indicative timelines:

  • charges should be framed within fifteen days of filing the charge-sheet;
  • evidence and arguments should be completed within six months; and
  • judgment should be delivered within the applicable period under Rule 109 of the G.R. & C.O. (Criminal), Volume I.

This precedent influenced the refusal to transfer because relocation could delay the proceeding and make attendance more difficult for local witnesses. It also supported the directions to the Session Judge and Bar Association to secure an uninterrupted and timely trial.

4.2 The Central Bureau of Investigation Vs. Mir Usman alias Ara alias Mur Usman Ali; 2025 SCC OnLine SC 2066

The High Court also relied on paragraph 37 of this Supreme Court decision, which requires criminal inquiries and trials to proceed expeditiously. Its principal directions include:

  • once examination of witnesses begins, it should continue from day to day;
  • witnesses who are present should ordinarily be examined rather than sent away because of an adjournment;
  • adjournments should not be granted merely for an advocate’s convenience;
  • where counsel deliberately obstructs the trial, the court may appoint an amicus curiae, impose costs or consider action affecting bail, depending on the circumstances;
  • courts should prepare advance schedules for examination of witnesses; and
  • the Public Prosecutor may assist in serving process upon witnesses according to that schedule.

These directions supplied the procedural framework for the High Court’s order that the remaining witnesses, including the victim, be examined promptly and that avoidable adjournments not derail the trial.

5. Legal Reasoning

  1. Verification of allegations: The Court compared the transfer petition with the Registrar’s official report and the informant’s objection.
  2. Absence of proof: No resolution of the Bar Association refusing representation was established, and no earlier complaint of intimidation had been made.
  3. Existing legal representation: Local advocates had represented the petitioners, contradicting the allegation of collective non-cooperation.
  4. Risk of delay: Six witnesses had already been examined, while most remaining witnesses belonged to the locality. Transfer could impede attendance and prolong the case.
  5. Recognition of residual concern: The victim’s professional connection with the local Bar and the presence of many advocates could still affect the courtroom environment.
  6. Proportionate remedy: An in-camera trial, combined with directions to the Bar and the trial judge, adequately addressed that concern without transferring the case.

6. Complex Concepts Simplified

Transfer petition
A request to move a case from one competent court to another, usually because a fair trial is said to be difficult at the original venue.
In-camera trial
A proceeding conducted without general public access. Only persons whose presence is necessary or permitted by the court may attend.
Vakalatnama
A written authority by which a litigant appoints an advocate to represent him or her.
State Defence Counsel
A lawyer provided through the legal-aid system to defend an accused who cannot afford private representation.
Amicus curiae
A lawyer appointed to assist the court and, where necessary, to protect a party’s interests when regular counsel is unavailable or non-cooperative.
Day-to-day trial
Continuous recording of evidence on consecutive working days, subject only to exceptional reasons recorded by the court.
Proportionate remedy
A judicial measure no broader than necessary to solve the identified problem. Here, restricted courtroom access was preferred over transferring the entire case.

7. Potential Impact

The judgment provides guidance for transfer applications founded on alleged hostility from a local Bar. Courts are likely to examine contemporaneous complaints, actual representation, official reports and specific incidents rather than accept generalized apprehensions.

It also establishes a useful procedural model for sensitive prosecutions: where the perceived threat arises mainly from courtroom presence rather than demonstrated judicial bias, an in-camera trial and strict courtroom management may sufficiently protect fairness.

For acid-attack cases, the decision reinforces priority listing, continuous evidence, limited adjournments and compliance with fixed timelines. Bar Associations may also be called upon to prevent collective conduct that interferes with legal representation or the administration of justice.

8. Conclusion

The Orissa High Court held that unsupported allegations of local Bar hostility were insufficient to transfer an ongoing criminal trial, particularly when the official record showed that local advocates were representing the accused and proceedings were functioning normally.

At the same time, the Court recognized that the victim’s association with the local Bar could create an intimidating atmosphere. Its direction for an in-camera, closely managed and expedited trial represents a balanced response—protecting the accused’s right to a fair defence without sacrificing the prompt adjudication required in acid-attack cases.