5. Analysis
5.1 Precedents Cited
The petitioner relied principally on this decision, reported as 2026 SCC OnLine SC 1401. It recognizes that granting or refusing sanction is an administrative function requiring application of mind. Although an express statutory power of review is not always necessary for reconsideration of an administrative decision, a mere change of opinion on the same material is not a lawful basis for reversing an earlier decision.
The High Court accepted this general principle but applied it against the petitioner. The decisive question was not merely whether G.O.Rt.No.763 was supported by new factual evidence; it was whether G.O.Ms.No.63 had lawfully withdrawn an existing sanction. Since that withdrawal itself arose from a fresh appreciation of the same evidence after prosecution had commenced, its cancellation restored the legally sustainable position.
State of Punjab V. Mohd. Iqbal Bhatti
This authority, reported as (2009) 17 SCC 92, states that administrative sanction decisions may be reconsidered, but an earlier refusal cannot ordinarily be reversed merely because the authority later forms a different opinion on identical material. Reconsideration is permissible where fresh material unavailable at the earlier stage is collected and duly considered.
Its influence was twofold: it confirmed that sanction decisions are not absolutely immune from review, while preventing repetitive re-evaluation of unchanged evidence. The Court treated the withdrawal under G.O.Ms.No.63 as the impermissible same-material reassessment.
State of H.P. V. Nishant Sareen
Reported as (2010) 14 SCC 527, this case involved an earlier refusal of sanction that was later reversed following a different opinion from the Vigilance Department, without fresh evidence. The Supreme Court found the later sanction vitiated by non-application of mind and extraneous influence.
The petitioner invoked the decision to argue that G.O.Rt.No.763 merely reflected the ACB’s changed opinion. The High Court distinguished the present situation in substance: the challenged order did not initiate prosecution after an earlier refusal but corrected an intervening administrative withdrawal made after cognizance and on evidence already before the prosecuting court.
W.A.No.203 of 2020
The Division Bench decision emphasized that sanction cannot be granted or refused mechanically. The order must demonstrate consideration of the relevant facts and material. A cryptic administrative memorandum directing departmental proceedings was held not necessarily to constitute a proper refusal of sanction, while a later reasoned order granting sanction could not automatically be characterized as an impermissible review.
This precedent supported the State’s argument that the legal character of an order depends upon its contents, reasons and demonstrated application of mind rather than its chronological position alone.
W.P.Nos.934 & 935 of 2022
These decisions stressed that grant of permission or sanction must be ascertainable from the official record and should not be left to inference. They also criticized administrative inaction in corruption matters and emphasized institutional responsibility in processing sanction requests. The judgment notes that the special leave petitions against those decisions were dismissed.
The High Court used these decisions to reinforce the proposition that sanction is a structured administrative responsibility and cannot be manipulated to substitute another administrative course once prosecution is properly underway.
Other authorities mentioned
Respondent No.2 also relied upon M. Veeraiah Chowdary v. State of Andhra Pradesh, Balwant Singh v. State of Bihar, Rajender Kumar Jain v. State of Haryana, K.V. Joseph v. State of Gujarat and Bairam Muralidhar v. State of Andhra Pradesh. The judgment records these authorities as supporting the proposition that the executive cannot frustrate pending criminal proceedings by withdrawing sanction after cognizance. As their facts and ratios were not separately reproduced, the Court treated them as cumulative support rather than undertaking an individual analysis.
The quoted passage from W.P.Nos.934 & 935 of 2022 also referred to Subramanian Swamy's case and Vineet Narain's case as authorities emphasizing administrative accountability and timely, lawful decisions in corruption prosecutions.
5.2 Legal Reasoning
A. Sanction is administrative, but not arbitrary
A decision under Section 19 is administrative rather than judicial. Nevertheless, the authority must examine the investigative record and independently decide whether prosecution should proceed. The power cannot be exercised mechanically or repeatedly merely because a different view of the same evidence later appears preferable.
B. The “fresh material” rule applies in both directions
The petitioner argued that fresh material was necessary before the Government could cancel the withdrawal. The Court focused instead on the legality of the intervening withdrawal itself. If sanction cannot be granted after an earlier refusal merely on a changed opinion, a valid sanction likewise cannot be withdrawn on an unchanged record merely because the authority later recalculates the evidence differently.
C. Cognizance transfers adjudicatory questions to the criminal court
Once sanction was granted, a charge sheet filed and cognizance taken, the prosecution entered the judicial domain. Whether loans, rents, bonds, agricultural income, sale proceeds or assets held by relatives were correctly treated are evidentiary questions. They bear on guilt and must ordinarily be tested through evidence before the Special Court.
An administrative determination that the disproportion was below 20% could not displace the criminal court’s function or terminate the prosecution indirectly.
D. Restoration did not prejudge guilt
Upholding the restoration of sanction did not amount to a finding that the petitioner possessed disproportionate assets. It merely allowed the pending trial to continue. The petitioner retained every defence concerning income, expenditure, asset ownership and calculation of disproportion.
E. Article 14 challenge
Although arbitrariness under Article 14 was pleaded, the Court found that the impugned order followed a detailed ACB report, relevant governmental instructions and judicial precedents. It therefore disclosed a rational legal basis and could not be characterized as arbitrary or unsupported by application of mind.