Policy-Making Participation Under Section 5(24)(m)(i): A Lower Threshold Than Section 29A Control for CoC Exclusion
Case: ECL FINANCE LTD. v. ABHINAV MUKHERJEE
Citation: 2026 INSC 1159
Court: Supreme Court of India
Date: 27 October 2026
Bench: J. B. Pardiwala and K. Vinod Chandran, JJ.
Judgment delivered by: K. Vinod Chandran, J.
1. Introduction
This judgment examines when a financier’s contractual involvement in a corporate debtor’s affairs makes it a “related party” and consequently disqualifies it from participating in the Committee of Creditors (CoC) under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (IBC).
The Supreme Court distinguished between two statutory standards: the positive or proactive “control” relevant to resolution-applicant disqualification under Section 29A, and participation in a corporate debtor’s policy-making processes under Section 5(24)(m)(i). The latter does not require the creditor to occupy the corporate “driving seat”; a sufficiently substantial role in directing or navigating policy can attract related-party exclusion.
The appeals concerned ECL Finance Limited (ECL), acting both as debenture holder and lender, and IDBI Trusteeship Services Limited (ITSL), acting as debenture trustee. Both challenged their exclusion from the CoC of Palm Developers Private Limited, the corporate debtor. The judgment also addresses uninvoked corporate guarantees, an individual homebuyer’s right to challenge CoC composition, and assignments allegedly designed to circumvent related-party restrictions.
2. Background and Issues
2.1 The financing arrangements
Saha Infratech Private Limited (SIPL) raised finance through two arrangements supported by guarantees and securities provided by Palm Developers:
- Debenture financing: SIPL proposed non-convertible debentures aggregating ₹160 crore. Only the first tranche of ₹110 crore was subscribed, and ECL ultimately held all the issued debentures. ITSL acted as trustee. Security included Palm Developers’ unconditional corporate guarantee, a mortgage over the Project Encore property, hypothecation of project receivables, and an escrow arrangement.
- Loan financing: A facility agreement dated 22 September 2017 documented a ₹90 crore credit facility extended by ECL to SIPL. Palm Developers participated as a guarantor and obligor, supported by additional security arrangements.
Palm Developers therefore guaranteed obligations owed to ECL in two separate capacities: as debenture holder and as lender.
2.2 Insolvency proceedings and the challenge
The corporate insolvency resolution process (CIRP) of Palm Developers commenced on 27 January 2020. ITSL submitted a claim of approximately ₹131.17 crore in its trustee capacity, while ECL claimed approximately ₹139.03 crore under the loan facility.
Both were initially included in the CoC. An individual homebuyer challenged their inclusion. The National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) accepted the challenge, holding both that the claims did not constitute financial debt and that the appellants were related parties. The National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT) maintained their exclusion, although its reasoning differed on aspects of financial debt and guarantee invocation.
2.3 Principal questions
- Can a corporate guarantee support financial-creditor status where the corporate debtor did not directly receive the financing?
- Must the guarantee have been invoked before CIRP commenced?
- Can an individual homebuyer challenge CoC composition without proceeding through the authorised representative of the class?
- When do contractual governance rights amount to participation in policy-making under Section 5(24)(m)(i)?
- Can a trustee, a separate lending capacity, or an assignment overcome the resulting disqualification?
3. Summary of the Judgment
The Supreme Court dismissed the appeals but corrected important parts of the reasoning adopted below.
- Financial debt: The absence of direct disbursal to the corporate guarantor did not, by itself, prevent the guarantee obligation from constituting financial debt.
- Prior invocation: Failure to invoke the guarantee before CIRP was not a sufficient ground to reject financial-creditor status or the claim.
- Individual standing: The homebuyer could independently challenge the inclusion of allegedly related parties in the CoC.
- Related-party relationship: ECL’s extensive contractual rights over governance, budgets, management, project execution, sales and revenues established participation in the corporate debtor’s policy-making processes.
- Trustee and dual capacity: ITSL could not represent the interests of the sole debenture holder when that holder was disqualified. ECL could not avoid exclusion by relying on its separate status as lender.
- Assignment: The subsequent assignment of the facility debt did not overcome the restriction because the Court found it lacked bona fides in the circumstances.
The Court found no basis to interfere with the ultimate exclusion ordered below. It closed the contempt petitions and rejected pending applications.
4. Statutory Framework
4.1 Financial debt and financial-creditor status
Section 5(8) defines financial debt and includes specified guarantee and indemnity liabilities. Section 5(7) identifies a financial creditor by reference to a financial debt owed to that person.
The judgment distinguishes these concepts from “default” under Section 3(12). Default is material when a financial creditor seeks to initiate CIRP under Section 7. It is not an additional universal ingredient of financial debt for participation in an insolvency process that has already commenced.
4.2 Related-party participation in policy-making
Section 5(24)(m)(i) treats a person associated with the corporate debtor through “participation in policy making processes” as a related party. This is the particular statutory limb applied in the case; the judgment does not replace the other independent grounds of related-party status.
4.3 Exclusion from the CoC
Section 21(2) generally provides for a CoC comprising the corporate debtor’s financial creditors. Its first proviso denies a related-party financial creditor or the specified authorised representative rights of representation, participation and voting in CoC meetings.
Section 21(6A)(a) recognises representation through a trustee or agent where the financial debt takes the form of securities or deposits and the financing terms provide for such representation. That mechanism does not create an independent entitlement to represent an otherwise disqualified creditor.
5. Precedents Cited and Their Influence
5.1 Anuj Jain, Interim Resolution Professional for Jaypee Infratech Ltd. v. Axis Bank Limited and Others
Citation: (2020) 8 SCC 401.
The NCLT relied on this decision to deny financial-debt status because Palm Developers was not the principal borrower and had not directly received the funds. The Supreme Court held that this was a misreading.
The relevant passage itself recognised that financial debt may include liability arising from a guarantee or indemnity concerning the transactions identified in Section 5(8). The precedent therefore did not support a blanket rule excluding a corporate guarantor’s liability merely because disbursal had been made to another entity.
Its significance here is corrective: the legal character of the actual obligation must be examined rather than treating the absence of direct disbursal as conclusive.
Citation: (2025) 7 SCC 729.
This decision supplied the principal reasoning against requiring pre-CIRP invocation of the guarantee. It concerned deeds of hypothecation under which group companies, including the corporate debtor, pooled assets to secure borrowings.
The Court explained that Section 5(8) does not require a default before an obligation can qualify as financial debt. A person to whom such a debt is owed can be a financial creditor even without a payment default. Default becomes specifically relevant when initiating CIRP under Section 7.
The precedent also addressed a contingent shortfall obligation whose triggering calculation could not occur because the moratorium prevented sale of the secured assets. That procedural obstacle did not eliminate the underlying financial debt or prevent submission of a claim.
Applying this reasoning, the Court rejected non-invocation before CIRP as a sufficient reason to deny the appellants’ claims. This concerns recognition within an existing CIRP, not an unrestricted right to commence insolvency proceedings without satisfying Section 7.
5.3 Phoenix ARC Private Limited v. Spade Financial Services Limited and Others
Citation: (2021) 3 SCC 475.
This precedent influenced both procedural standing and the treatment of assignments.
On standing, the earlier case held that creditors could challenge the inclusion of allegedly related parties despite a previous order permitting those entities to resubmit their claims. The challenging creditors had not been heard when that order was made, so the objection was not barred by res judicata. The present Court applied that reasoning to uphold the individual homebuyer’s challenge.
On assignments, the precedent distinguished legitimate transfers from arrangements intended to undermine the related-party exclusion. A genuine assignee is not automatically disqualified merely because the debt originated with a related party. Conversely, a transfer undertaken in bad faith to influence the CoC may leave the assignee subject to equivalent exclusion.
The judgment also referred to the Insolvency Law Committee Report, 2020, which recommends verification of the assignee’s independence and scrutiny of transfers made with fraudulent intent to vitiate insolvency proceedings.
5.4 Aashray Social Welfare Society & Ors. v. Saha Infratech Pvt. Ltd. & Ors.
Reference: Company Appeal (AT) (Insolvency) No. 904 of 2021.
The NCLAT relied on this decision to explain the role of an authorised representative of creditors in a class. Representation for attending CoC meetings and voting does not extinguish an individual homebuyer’s right to participate in adjudication affecting the lawfulness of the committee’s composition.
The resulting distinction is between collective representation within the CoC and individual access to adjudication. The judgment does not establish a right to disregard the statutory framework for class voting.
5.5 Arcelor Mittal India Private Limited v. Satish Kumar Gupta and Others
Citation: (2019) 2 SCC 1.
This decision concerned resolution-applicant ineligibility under Section 29A. It distinguished legally conferred control from effective factual control and explained that the relevant control must be positive or proactive. A power merely to block a special resolution would not, by itself, meet that standard.
The present Court did not reject that reasoning. Instead, it declined to transplant its full rigour into Section 5(24)(m)(i). Participation in policy-making is a different statutory inquiry from whether a person controls the company for Section 29A purposes.
The distinction is central: a creditor need not possess the full authority required to qualify as the corporate driving force before its policy-making involvement creates a disqualifying relationship.
5.6 Subhkam Ventures (I) Private Limited v. Securities and Exchange Board of India
Citation: 2010 SCC OnLine SAT 35.
This Securities Appellate Tribunal decision was discussed through its approval in the preceding Supreme Court authority. Its driving metaphor distinguishes a person who directs corporate movement from one who can merely prevent a particular action.
The present judgment adapted the metaphor: although occupying the driving seat may be necessary for the relevant Section 29A inquiry, a role in navigation can suffice for policy-making participation under Section 5(24)(m)(i). This expresses the lower threshold without suggesting that every protective lending covenant automatically creates related-party status.
6. Analysis of the Court’s Reasoning
6.1 Financial-creditor status does not guarantee CoC participation
The Court separated the existence of financial debt from the right to exercise governance powers in insolvency. Its rejection of the lower tribunals’ objections to the guarantees did not resolve the distinct related-party question in the appellants’ favour.
A creditor may hold a financial claim while remaining excluded from CoC representation, participation and voting. Related-party exclusion is therefore not equivalent to extinguishing the underlying debt. The judgment did not finally determine the quantum recoverable under the claims.
6.2 The contractual arrangements went beyond passive protection
The Court examined the combined effect of the articles of association, debenture documentation, sanction terms, facility agreement and powers of attorney. The significant rights included:
| Contractual right |
Relevance to policy-making participation |
| Appointment of a nominee director following default |
Provided a route into board-level governance. |
| Final determination of board or shareholder deadlocks |
Conferred authority to resolve substantive corporate decisions. |
| Approval and revision of quarterly construction budgets |
Connected financial oversight to project priorities and implementation. |
| Consent rights over key managerial personnel and replacement staffing |
Enabled influence over those responsible for business execution. |
| Appointment of observers, consultants and examining professionals |
Supported continuing managerial and operational supervision. |
| Appointment of selling agents and extensive project-related powers of attorney |
Extended involvement to construction, approvals, purchasers and sales. |
| Control of revenues and escrow arrangements |
Linked implementation of business decisions to control of project funds. |
These provisions were assessed cumulatively. The decision should not be reduced to a proposition that an escrow account, inspection right or nominee-director clause alone necessarily establishes a related-party relationship.
6.3 Contractual authority mattered even without demonstrated exercise
The Court rejected the argument that the relevant control had never actually been put into operation. It regarded policy implementation and business activity as subject to ECL’s overall supervision under the financing architecture.
This makes the substance of contractual entitlements important. A financier cannot necessarily avoid related-party scrutiny merely by asserting that it did not formally exercise an extensive package of governance rights.
Nevertheless, the conclusion rested on unusually pervasive arrangements. The judgment does not eliminate the need to distinguish genuine participation in policy-making from ordinary creditor monitoring.
6.4 A lower threshold, but strong facts
The Court held that Section 5(24)(m)(i) does not require the same degree of proactive control as Section 29A(c) and (g). It nevertheless found that ECL’s rights were not merely negative or restrictive: they amounted to all-pervasive supervision.
The case therefore establishes a lower legal threshold on facts that showed substantial influence. Future disputes involving narrower protective covenants will still require close examination of their actual scope and combined effect.
6.5 A trustee could not neutralise the sole holder’s disqualification
ECL held all the debentures, and ITSL acted to protect ECL’s interests. Once ECL was disqualified, allowing ITSL to participate on its behalf would have defeated the statutory restriction.
This is a representative consequence, not a finding that every professional trustee independently becomes related to every corporate debtor. The judgment’s immediate setting was a trustee representing a single, disqualified debenture holder.
6.6 ECL’s separate lending capacity did not provide an escape
The Court recognised that ECL’s debenture holding and loan facility generated distinct claims. Nevertheless, the same creditor possessed extensive rights over the corporate debtor through the overall financing arrangements. It could not compartmentalise its position to obtain CoC participation as lender while remaining disqualified as debenture holder.
The observation in paragraph 24 about a hypothetical lender-only position must be read in this factual context. It should not be understood as a general exemption for direct lenders: the first proviso to Section 21(2) expressly addresses related-party financial creditors as well as specified representatives.
6.7 The assignment was rejected on the circumstances, not timing alone
ECL assigned its facility rights to the second appellant in its appeal after CIRP had commenced. Although the point had not been specifically argued, the Court examined it through the principles governing bona fide assignments.
The Court considered both the recent timing and the forensic audit material noticed by the NCLAT. That material described alleged misuse of the corporate debtor to transfer funds to promoter-controlled entities and alleged diversion connected with the project.
On that combination of circumstances, the assignment was treated as intended to defeat the CoC restriction. The decision does not establish that every post-CIRP assignment, or every assignment of related-party debt, is invalid. Nor should reliance on the forensic report for this issue be equated with a separate criminal conviction of any participant.
7. Potential Impact
7.1 Financing documentation will receive closer scrutiny
Real-estate and structured-finance transactions frequently combine budget approvals, escrow controls, management covenants and project intervention rights. Their cumulative effect may now assume particular importance when determining CoC eligibility.
The relevant question is not simply whether a covenant protects repayment, but whether the contractual package also associates the financier with corporate policy-making.
7.2 Resolution professionals must examine substance
Admitting a financial claim and determining CoC eligibility are separate exercises. Resolution professionals must examine governance documents, amendments, guarantees and representative arrangements rather than relying solely on the creditor’s formal designation.
The same substantive approach applies to assignees: independence and commercial legitimacy matter more than the existence of a transfer document alone.
7.3 Creditor oversight of CoC composition is strengthened
The recognition of an individual homebuyer’s standing provides a means to challenge allegedly conflicted participation even where the authorised representative has not initiated proceedings. This protects the integrity of CoC composition without displacing the representative structure for meetings and voting.
7.4 The judgment preserves important limits
It does not establish that every secured lender is a related party, that every trustee is disqualified, or that every recent assignment is abusive. Each conclusion depends on the relevant statutory relationship and the evidence. Nor does the decision determine ECL’s eligibility as a resolution applicant under Section 29A; that provision was considered to distinguish its legal standard.
8. Complex Concepts Simplified
- Financial debt and default
- Financial debt describes the obligation. Default describes failure to pay when payment is due. A financial debt can exist before default, although initiating CIRP under Section 7 requires satisfaction of its default requirement.
- Corporate guarantee
- A company’s promise to answer for another borrower’s obligations. The guarantor need not have directly received the borrowed money for the guarantee liability to qualify as financial debt.
- Positive and negative control
- Positive control enables a person to direct corporate action. Negative control ordinarily allows that person to block an action. The judgment distinguishes both from the broader question of participation in policy-making.
- De jure and de facto control
- De jure control arises from legal rights, such as appointment powers. De facto control concerns effective influence in practice.
- Noscitur a sociis
- A principle under which a word’s meaning is informed by surrounding words. In the Section 29A discussion, “management” and “control” helped explain each other.
- Res judicata
- A rule against reopening matters already conclusively adjudicated between the relevant parties. The earlier order discussed in the precedent did not prevent a later challenge by creditors who had not been heard.
- Bona fide assignment
- A genuine transfer of debt, rather than a device to bypass insolvency restrictions or improperly influence the CoC.
9. Conclusion
The judgment’s central contribution is its distinction between control sufficient for Section 29A disqualification and participation in policy-making sufficient for related-party exclusion under Section 5(24)(m)(i).
ECL’s extensive governance and operational rights crossed the latter threshold. Neither representation through its debenture trustee, reliance on a separate lending capacity, nor the assignment found lacking in bona fides restored CoC participation.
At the same time, the Court preserved the distinction between a valid financial claim and eligibility to govern the insolvency process. The broader lesson is that CoC independence depends on the substance of a creditor’s relationship with the corporate debtor, not merely its contractual label.