Long-Term Full-Time Employment Cannot Be Disguised as Stipendiary Training: Equal Wages and Age Relaxation for Nurses Performing Regular Duties
Case: MYSORE MEDICAL COLLEGE AND RESEARCH INSTITUTE v. State of KARNATAKA
Court: Karnataka High Court, Division Bench
Bench: Anu Sivaraman and T.P. Vivekananda, JJ.
Date: 1 September 2026
Citation: 2026:KHC:47674-DB
1. Introduction
This batch of writ appeals concerned nurses engaged by the Mysore Medical College and Research Institute under the description “stipendiary nurses.” The Institute and the State of Karnataka challenged a common order dated 22 July 2021 by which a Single Judge had protected the nurses from arbitrary discontinuance and directed payment of wages under the Government Order dated 26 February 2019.
The Institute maintained that the respondents were merely trainees appointed for six months and were therefore entitled only to a stipend. The nurses contended that the label did not reflect the reality: many were fully qualified in General Nursing and Midwifery, had worked continuously for several years from 2009 onwards, and were performing the full duties of staff nurses against posts necessary for running the hospital.
The principal issues were:
- whether prolonged engagement could still be treated as short-term stipendiary training;
- whether the nurses were entitled to equal wages despite being called stipendiary nurses;
- whether they could be continued until regular recruitment; and
- how their claims should be reconciled with the constitutional requirement of recruitment under the applicable Cadre and Recruitment Rules.
2. Background and Rival Contentions
Institute and State
The appellants argued that the nurses had been engaged only for limited periods as part of training. According to them, the Government Order dated 26 February 2019 applied to contractual employees in autonomous institutions and not to stipendiary trainees.
They relied upon the Government Order dated 27 July 2020 fixing a monthly payment of ₹12,445 for stipendiary nurses and the subsequent Government Order dated 20 May 2026 increasing it to ₹15,556. They also argued that compulsory continuation would obstruct genuine short-term nursing training and encroach upon posts meant to be filled through regular recruitment.
Nurses
The nurses pointed out that the State and Institute had not filed objections before the Single Judge. Appointment orders, experience certificates and the Institute’s communication dated 3 October 2017 showed that several nurses had served for five years or more. They were already qualified nurses rather than students completing a brief training requirement.
It was therefore argued that the Institute was using the expression “stipendiary nurse” to obtain continuous service from qualified personnel without paying the remuneration attached to the work actually performed.
3. Summary of the Judgment
The Division Bench substantially affirmed the Single Judge. It held that the essential directions did not require interference because the documentary material supported the finding that the respondents were not genuine short-term trainees. They had been engaged for long periods, worked full-time and performed the duties of staff nurses required for the functioning of the hospital.
The Court approved the conclusion that the description “stipendiary nurses” was misleading and that the respondents were, in substance, contractual or temporary employees. They were consequently entitled to the wage protection contemplated by the Government Order dated 26 February 2019 and the principle of equal pay for equal work.
The Court, however, clarified that:
- the Institute remains free to engage genuine stipendiary nurses for limited periods of training;
- regular recruitment under the Cadre and Recruitment Rules must be undertaken at the earliest and without undue delay;
- the respondent nurses must be considered in that recruitment in accordance with law; and
- they must receive age relaxation corresponding to the service rendered in the Institution.
The appeals were disposed of with these modifications. The judgment did not order automatic regularisation or appointment to permanent posts.
4. Analysis
4.1 Substance Prevails Over Employment Labels
The central principle is that an employer cannot determine legal rights merely by choosing a particular designation. A genuine stipendiary engagement is ordinarily short, instructional and connected with training. By contrast, the respondents were already qualified, had worked for years and were used to meet the hospital’s recurring staffing requirements.
The Court therefore examined the actual nature, duration and purpose of the engagement. Long and continuous service, performance of ordinary staff-nurse duties and deployment against the hospital’s regular requirements demonstrated that the relationship was contractual or temporary employment rather than training.
4.2 Importance of the Evidentiary Record
The conclusion was fact-sensitive. The nurses produced their qualifications, appointment orders, experience certificates and institutional communications. Some documents showed service extending beyond five years. The appellants had neither filed objections before the Single Judge nor produced material in appeal sufficient to displace those findings.
Thus, the Court did not hold that every person described as a stipendiary nurse is necessarily an employee. It held that, on the evidence in this case, the description was inconsistent with the real employment arrangement.
4.3 Government Order dated 26 February 2019
The appellants’ textual argument was that the Government Order applied only to contractual employees and did not expressly mention stipendiary nurses. The Court effectively answered this by recharacterising the respondents according to the true nature of their service. Once their work was found to be contractual or temporary employment rather than training, the absence of the word “stipendiary” from the Government Order was not decisive.
The later stipend orders could govern genuine trainees, but they could not defeat the respondents’ claim when the underlying arrangement was found not to be a genuine training engagement.
4.4 Equal Pay Without Automatic Regularisation
The judgment distinguishes remuneration from status. A temporary or contractual employee performing the same work as a regular employee may claim wage equality, subject to the applicable legal standards. That does not automatically confer permanent status or bypass competitive recruitment.
The nurses obtained wage protection and continued engagement pending lawful recruitment, but not an unconditional right to absorption. Their entitlement in the regular process is to lawful consideration and age relaxation, not guaranteed selection.
4.5 Balancing Employee Protection and Public Recruitment
The Court adopted a middle course. It prevented continued exploitation through rolling temporary engagements while preserving the State’s obligation to fill public posts under recruitment rules. It also protected the Institute’s ability to conduct genuine short-term training programmes.
This balance avoids two extremes: permitting an institution to indefinitely underpay workers by calling them trainees, and converting irregular temporary service directly into permanent public employment.
5. Precedents Cited
The State of Punjab & Others v. Jagjit Singh & Others
This was the principal authority on equal pay for equal work. The Supreme Court recognised that temporary, daily-wage or contractual status does not by itself justify inferior wages where employees perform substantially the same duties as regular employees.
The precedent supported the finding that the respondents could not be denied appropriate wages merely because the Institute called them stipendiary nurses. Their actual duties, qualifications and responsibilities were more significant than the formal description of their engagement.
State of Haryana & Others v. Piara Singh & Others
This decision addresses long-term ad hoc and temporary employment and the need for regular recruitment. It also supports the general proposition that one set of temporary employees should not ordinarily be replaced merely by another set of temporary employees when the work is continuing.
The Single Judge relied upon this principle while protecting the nurses until regular appointments were made. The Division Bench retained the essential protection but directed the authorities to commence regular recruitment without undue delay.
State of Karnataka v. Umadevi
This authority establishes that public employment must ordinarily be filled through a lawful recruitment process and that courts cannot routinely regularise temporary or irregular appointees in disregard of constitutional requirements and recruitment rules.
The present judgment remains consistent with that restriction. It does not order regularisation. Instead, it directs recruitment under the Cadre and Recruitment Rules, permits the respondents to participate, and grants age relaxation for their years of institutional service. The precedent therefore defines the boundary of the relief: protection against exploitation, but no bypassing of lawful selection.
6. Ratio and Limits of the Decision
Ratio: Where qualified nurses are continuously employed for years, work full-time against the recurring staffing requirements of a public hospital and perform the duties of regular staff nurses, the employer cannot avoid equal wage obligations merely by designating them as “stipendiary” trainees.
Limits:
- The ruling does not invalidate genuine, short-term stipendiary training.
- It does not grant automatic regularisation or permanent appointment.
- Equal wages depend upon the actual similarity of work, duties and responsibilities.
- Final appointment remains subject to the Cadre and Recruitment Rules.
- Age relaxation facilitates participation but does not guarantee selection.
7. Complex Concepts Simplified
- Stipendiary nurse
- A nurse engaged primarily for a limited training period and paid a stipend rather than a regular salary.
- Equal pay for equal work
- Workers performing substantially identical duties cannot ordinarily be paid less solely because they are described as temporary or contractual.
- Nomenclature
- The formal name given to a position. Courts may disregard that name when the actual work arrangement is different.
- Regularisation
- Conversion of temporary or irregular service into permanent employment. The Court did not grant this relief.
- Cadre and Recruitment Rules
- The statutory or administrative rules governing sanctioned posts, qualifications, selection and appointment.
- Age relaxation
- An extension of the normal upper age limit so that long-serving temporary employees are not excluded from regular recruitment because they became overage while serving the institution.
- Mandamus
- A judicial direction requiring a public authority to perform a legal duty.
8. Potential Impact
- Public hospitals: Institutions must distinguish genuine training from employment used to meet permanent staffing needs.
- Contract workers: Long duration, qualifications, actual duties and institutional necessity may establish employment rights despite restrictive labels.
- Government bodies: Repeated temporary engagement cannot become a substitute for timely recruitment to sanctioned posts.
- Future litigation: Documentary evidence such as experience certificates, duty records and appointment orders will be crucial in determining whether a traineeship is genuine.
- Recruitment policy: Age relaxation may provide an equitable bridge between protection of long-serving workers and compliance with regular recruitment rules.
9. Conclusion
The Karnataka High Court affirmed that employment rights are determined by the reality of the work performed, not merely by the designation chosen by the employer. Qualified nurses used continuously for years to discharge regular hospital functions could not be treated as short-term trainees and denied equal wages.
At the same time, the Court preserved the constitutional discipline of public recruitment. The respondents were granted continued protection, lawful consideration and age relaxation, but not automatic permanency. The decision is therefore significant for combining the principle of equal pay, protection against disguised contractual exploitation and adherence to recruitment rules.