Locally Selected Guest Faculty: No Automatic Pay Parity or Regularization, but Nearest Available Subject-Post Offers on Displacement
Case: Dr. Abha Agrawal v. The State Of Madhya Pradesh
Court: Madhya Pradesh High Court, Jabalpur
Bench: Chief Justice Alpesh Y. Kogje and Justice Vivek Jain
Decision: 6 October 2026; judgment delivered by Justice Vivek Jain
Proceedings: Writ Petition No. 16358 of 2024, with Writ Petition No. 24961 of 2023 and Writ Petition No. 24402 of 2024, as identified in the cause title.
1. Introduction
This judgment addresses the relationship between temporary academic engagement, remuneration under University Grants Commission norms, and access to permanent public employment. Three groups of guest faculty members working in government degree and postgraduate colleges in Madhya Pradesh challenged aspects of the State’s guest-faculty policy and regular recruitment arrangements.
The petitioners sought remuneration comparable to regularly appointed Assistant Professors, regularization of their services, protection against displacement, and relief from having to compete repeatedly in recruitment conducted through the Madhya Pradesh Public Service Commission (“MPPSC”). Their principal challenge concerned Clause 6.1 of the State’s policy dated 5 October 2023, which prescribed an honorarium of ₹2,000 per day, subject to a monthly ceiling of ₹50,000.
The High Court rejected the principal claims. It held that the petitioners’ local, academic-merit-based engagement differed from the competitive recruitment procedure applicable to regular Assistant Professors. They therefore could not invoke Clause 13.0 of the UGC Regulations, 2018 to claim the remuneration guaranteed to contractual teachers appointed through the regular selection procedure.
Nevertheless, the Court granted an important, limited protection: when the petitioners are displaced by regular incumbents, the State must offer them engagement at the nearest place where a position in their subject is available. The judgment thus combines deference to recruitment policy with a targeted safeguard against avoidable hardship in alternative placement.
2. Background and Questions Before the Court
2.1 The challenged policy framework
The dispute involved three related measures:
-
Policy dated 5 October 2023: It regulated guest-faculty engagement and increased the daily honorarium from ₹1,500 to ₹2,000, while retaining a ₹50,000 monthly ceiling.
-
Circular dated 6 October 2023: It provided recruitment concessions for serving guest faculty, including 25% horizontal reservation across vertical categories, experience-related bonus marks, and age relaxation of one year for each academic session served, subject to a maximum of ten years.
-
Amendment dated 31 December 2024: It substituted Rule 11(8) of the M.P. Education Service (Collegiate Branch) Recruitment Rules, 1990. The judgment records statutory provision for horizontal reservation and age relaxation, with the concessions operating for the next three recruitment advertisements.
The substituted rule extended the reservation benefit to guest faculty who had completed at least one academic year of teaching in government colleges. These concessions facilitated participation in regular recruitment; they did not provide automatic absorption.
2.2 The petitioners’ case
The petitioners relied principally on Clause 13.0 of the UGC Regulations, 2018, which requires that contractual teachers receive fixed emoluments not below the monthly gross salary of a regularly appointed Assistant Professor. They argued that the State’s remuneration ceiling conflicted with this requirement.
They also submitted that long service, the continuing need for their work, and performance of teaching duties justified regularization. Some relied on their performance in the 2017 MPPSC examination, although they had not attained the selection cut-off. They further challenged displacement when regular teachers joined, particularly where alternative engagement was unavailable or offered at an impractically distant location.
2.3 The State’s response
The State distinguished guest faculty from contractual teachers covered by Clause 13.0. It relied on the separate UGC circular dated 28 January 2019, which prescribed guest-faculty honorarium of ₹1,500 per lecture, subject to a maximum of ₹50,000 per month.
It also emphasized that the petitioners had not been selected through the process applicable to regular Assistant Professors. Their local merit-based engagement, according to the State, could not create a right to regular remuneration or permanent appointment. Recruitment policy, it argued, remained primarily an executive responsibility.
2.4 Central issues
- Did the ₹50,000 ceiling conflict with Clause 13.0 of the UGC Regulations, 2018?
- Could the petitioners claim regularization or exemption from fresh MPPSC selection?
- Could they insist on remaining at their existing posts after regular incumbents joined?
- Should the recruitment advertisements or concessions be disturbed?
- What protection, if any, was appropriate when displaced guest faculty sought alternative engagement?
3. Summary of the Judgment
| Issue |
Decision |
| Validity of Clause 6.1 and the monthly ceiling |
Upheld. The Court found no conflict with the applicable UGC guest-faculty framework. |
| Remuneration under Clause 13.0 |
Denied because the petitioners had not undergone the selection procedure applicable to regularly appointed teachers. |
| Regularization and permanent appointment |
Denied. No vested right was established, particularly when regular recruitment opportunities were being provided. |
| Reliance on the 2017 MPPSC examination |
Did not justify bypassing subsequent recruitment or securing appointment without selection. |
| Continuation after a regular incumbent joins |
Denied. Guest-faculty continuation remains subject to replacement by a regular incumbent and the continuing requirement for teaching work. |
| Challenge to regular recruitment |
Rejected. The reservation and relaxation arrangements were considered reasonable and non-discriminatory. |
| Alternative engagement following displacement |
The State must offer the petitioners the nearest available position in their respective subjects. |
The petitions were therefore disposed of with limited relief, rather than dismissed without qualification. All relief other than the direction concerning nearest available placement was refused.
4. Precedents Cited and Their Influence
The Court cited this decision for the proposition that writ courts should not interfere with policy decisions unless arbitrariness is demonstrated. It supplied the starting point for reviewing the State’s guest-faculty framework: disagreement with the policy’s consequences was insufficient without a legally recognizable defect.
This decision provided the principal service-law framework for institutional restraint. The quoted passage places creation and abolition of posts, cadre organization, recruitment sources, qualifications, and selection criteria primarily within the employer’s domain.
Judicial review remains available where an employer acts contrary to constitutional or statutory provisions, with patent arbitrariness, or through mala fides. However, courts cannot substitute their own recruitment methodology or comparative assessment of candidates. This directly supported the refusal to exempt the petitioners from MPPSC selection or require appointment on the strength of earlier unsuccessful participation.
The judgment relied on this authority to distinguish review of a policy’s legality from review of its wisdom. Courts may examine arbitrariness or legal incompatibility, but ordinarily should not weigh policy advantages and disadvantages merely to substitute a more beneficial arrangement.
The cited passage also recognizes that policy reflects factual circumstances, expert advice, and resource constraints. Its significance here was not to immunize the remuneration ceiling from scrutiny, but to require a legal basis for invalidating it.
This authority reinforced the executive’s freedom to reconcile competing interests in policy formation. The Court used it to explain why judicial preference for a different employment arrangement does not justify directing the Government to adopt that arrangement.
Together, these four decisions established that the Court’s task was to identify illegality, arbitrariness, or constitutional infirmity—not to redesign the guest-faculty system.
The petitioners cited this decision to argue that UGC Regulations form part of the statutory framework under the UGC Act, 1956 and prevail over conflicting State provisions. They invoked Article 254 and the concurrent legislative field of education.
The High Court did not separately undertake an extended analysis of that precedent. Instead, it resolved the dispute at an earlier stage: it held that Clause 13.0 did not cover these petitioners and that the State’s ceiling aligned with the separate UGC guest-faculty circular.
Consequently, the judgment should not be read as authorizing State policy to override applicable UGC Regulations. Its conclusion was that the alleged conflict had not arisen on the facts.
The petitioners relied on this authority to contend that long-serving employees performing indispensable, perennial work should not indefinitely remain temporary merely because of the description attached to their initial engagement.
The High Court recorded that submission but did not give a separate, detailed analysis of the precedent. Its answer emerges from its findings that regular recruitment was being conducted, the petitioners had opportunities to compete, and no vested right to absorption had been established.
Accordingly, it would overstate the judgment to say that it expressly rejected every regularization argument associated with this authority. The decision is narrower: these guest faculty members did not establish entitlement within the recruitment arrangements before the Court.
This was the most directly discussed remuneration precedent. As described by the High Court, the Supreme Court awarded contractually appointed Assistant Professors the minimum pay scale admissible to regular Assistant Professors after finding equivalence in the recruitment method. The comparison concerned recruitment through public advertisement against sanctioned posts.
The High Court distinguished the present petitioners because regular recruitment in Madhya Pradesh required MPPSC competitive selection, whereas their guest-faculty engagement rested on local academic-merit assessment and applicable bonus marks.
The distinction was therefore not simply between technical colleges and general colleges. It concerned equivalence of recruitment processes. The judgment treated that equivalence as material to the claimed remuneration entitlement.
This Supreme Court decision concerned guest faculty in Madhya Pradesh government colleges. It permitted the appellants to continue until replaced by regularly selected candidates, subject to sufficient students being available in the relevant courses. It also preserved their then-existing honorarium of ₹1,000 per hour.
The High Court relied on its continuation principle to reject a right to remain after regular incumbents joined. The precedent protects against premature displacement within the temporary arrangement; it does not convert temporary service into permanent tenure.
The historical hourly rate quoted from that case was not adopted as the remuneration governing the present petitioners.
4.9 Pradeep Kumar Yadav v. State of M.P & Ors. — W.P. No. 6159/2022
This Division Bench decision similarly permitted guest faculty to continue until regular appointments, while preserving the State’s power to discontinue teachers who were unfit to teach or no longer required because of student numbers.
Its contribution was to clarify the conditional character of continuation: teaching competence, actual workload, and the absence of regular replacement remain relevant. The current judgment adopted that understanding rather than recognizing unconditional job security.
4.10 Sujata Nema v. State of M.P & Ors. — W.P. No. 11080/2025
This Division Bench ruling addressed challenges to Clauses 2.4 and 10.4 of the same 2023 guidelines. It upheld those clauses and protected existing guest faculty until a regular permanent employee joined through recruitment or transfer, including certain existing teachers who lacked the qualifications prescribed by the new guidelines.
However, guest faculty already declared “fallen out” could not claim benefits without possessing the prescribed qualifications. The present judgment used this authority to reinforce the distinction between temporary continuation and entitlement to future engagement.
4.11 Vipin Singh Rajput & Ors. Vs. State of M.P & Ors. — SLP (Civil) Diary No. 11922/2026
The High Court described the preceding Division Bench judgment as having been confirmed by the Supreme Court. The quoted Supreme Court order granted limited liberty to approach the Higher Education Department for age relaxation and reservation, emphasizing that eligibility policy should ordinarily be determined at governmental level.
Its relevant contribution was support for judicial restraint in rewriting eligibility conditions. The quoted order should not be treated as a separate, comprehensive ruling on the remuneration and regularization questions presented in this case.
5. Legal Reasoning
5.1 Policy deference did not eliminate legal scrutiny
The Court characterized the 5 October 2023 policy as executive action within the State’s constitutional sphere, issued in the Governor’s name under Article 162 read with Article 166(1). That characterization explained its administrative foundation; it did not place the policy above statutory or constitutional requirements.
The Court therefore examined whether the challenged honorarium provision conflicted with UGC requirements or otherwise displayed arbitrariness. Its refusal to intervene followed its finding that the asserted legal defects had not been established.
5.2 Clause 13.0 was treated as a conditional remuneration guarantee
Clause 13.0 is not simply a pay provision. It regulates contractual appointments by requiring necessity, limiting their proportion to 10% of faculty positions, prescribing qualifications and selection procedures equivalent to regular appointments, and providing for academic review before renewal. Its remuneration guarantee operates within that framework.
The decisive requirement here was equivalent selection procedure. Regular Assistant Professors had to undergo MPPSC competitive selection. The petitioners had been engaged locally by reference to academic merit and applicable bonus marks, without the corresponding competitive examination.
The Court consequently held that these petitioners could not claim coverage under Clause 13.0. The reasoning makes recruitment method—not merely the performance of teaching work—central to the particular regulatory entitlement.
The judgment does not establish that equivalent recruitment would, by itself, satisfy every condition of Clause 13.0. Nor does it undertake a comprehensive comparison of the petitioners’ duties with those of regular faculty. Its conclusion rests on the recruitment difference it considered decisive.
5.3 The separate UGC guest-faculty framework supported the ceiling
The Court treated the UGC circular dated 28 January 2019 as evidence that UGC itself distinguished guest faculty from contractual teachers. That circular provided a ₹50,000 monthly ceiling, excluded regular-teacher allowances and retirement benefits, and prescribed separate incidents of guest-faculty engagement.
On that basis, the Court found the State’s ₹50,000 ceiling consistent with the UGC guest-faculty framework and rejected the alleged conflict with Clause 13.0.
Two limits to this reasoning deserve attention. First, the UGC circular fixes payment per lecture, whereas the State policy fixes payment per day. The Court upheld the challenged arrangement, but did not undertake a detailed workload-based comparison of those payment units.
Second, the quoted 2019 circular itself states that guest-faculty selection procedure should be the same as that for regular Assistant Professors, while prescribing a selection committee. The judgment does not separately reconcile that requirement with the local selection process it describes. Its decision should therefore not be expanded into blanket approval of every aspect of guest-faculty recruitment.
5.4 Regularization could not replace the prescribed recruitment route
The Court emphasized that the State was issuing successive recruitment advertisements through MPPSC. This was not, on its findings, a situation in which guest faculty were retained indefinitely without opportunities to seek regular appointment.
The existing recruitment concessions were also significant. Reservation, experience benefits, and age relaxation recognized guest-faculty service while preserving competitive selection. The Court considered this accommodation reasonable and found no arbitrariness, discrimination, or failure of proportionality warranting intervention.
Participation in the 2017 examination did not alter the result. The petitioners’ own case acknowledged that they had not achieved the cut-off required for selection. Earlier examination performance could not operate as a continuing entitlement to appointment in future recruitment rounds.
5.5 Continuation was conditional, not permanent
The Court rejected the contention that guest faculty should remain at the same posts after regular incumbents joined through appointment or transfer. The guest engagement met a temporary staffing requirement; when a regular incumbent occupied the post, that requirement ordinarily ended.
Continuation also remained dependent on teaching need and student strength. The decision thus preserves protection against unjustified replacement within the temporary system without permitting that protection to obstruct regular staffing.
5.6 The nearest-available-position direction addressed deployment, not absorption
The Court accepted that alternative offers at distant places could create serious hardship, especially for petitioners approaching the retirement age applicable to regular faculty. It therefore directed the State to ensure that displaced petitioners received an offer at the nearest place where a position in their subject was available.
This was a carefully bounded remedy. It did not require creation of posts, displacement of regular employees, permanent appointment, or retention at the original college. Nor did it guarantee a position in the petitioners’ hometowns.
The direction instead constrained the administration’s choice among available subject-specific positions. It introduced a concrete placement safeguard without restructuring recruitment or changing the petitioners’ employment status.
6. Potential Impact
6.1 Recruitment records will be central to remuneration disputes
Future claimants relying on Clause 13.0 will need to establish why their appointment falls within its framework. Qualifications, duration of service, or similarity of teaching duties may not answer the separate question whether the prescribed selection procedure was followed.
Conversely, employers cannot safely rely only on the label “guest faculty.” The judgment’s own reasoning examines the actual recruitment method and applicable UGC instruments.
6.2 Recruitment concessions are distinguished from absorption
The decision supports the use of reservation, experience recognition, and age relaxation to accommodate long-serving temporary teachers within regular recruitment. It does not treat those benefits as equivalent to a right of appointment.
Its regularization conclusion is nevertheless fact-sensitive: recurring recruitment opportunities were an express part of the Court’s reasoning. The judgment should not be generalized without qualification to materially different employment arrangements.
6.3 Alternative-placement decisions become more accountable
The operative direction gives the petitioners a concrete basis to question a distant offer where a nearer subject-specific position is available. Effective implementation will depend on accurate vacancy information and a defensible identification of the nearest available placement.
Although the reasoning may influence comparable disputes, the express direction concerns these petitioners. It should not be restated as an unconditional employment guarantee for all displaced guest faculty.
6.4 Important questions remain outside the decision
The Court did not prescribe a placement timetable, define how distance must be measured, or establish priority rules where several displaced teachers seek the same vacancy. It also did not decide every possible claim based on different recruitment facts or a different remuneration framework.
These limits matter: the judgment resolves the challenges presented, while leaving implementation details and materially distinct claims for appropriate future consideration.
7. Complex Concepts Simplified
- Judicial review of policy
-
Courts check whether government policy is lawful and non-arbitrary. They do not ordinarily replace it merely because another policy appears fairer or more effective.
- Regularization
-
Recognition of an employee within the regular service structure. Continued temporary work does not automatically produce that result.
- Vested right
-
An existing, legally enforceable entitlement, rather than a hope or expectation arising from long service.
- Horizontal reservation
-
Reservation operating across vertical categories. Here, the guest-faculty benefit cuts across categories such as general, Scheduled Caste, Scheduled Tribe, and Other Backward Classes; it does not itself create additional posts.
- Repugnancy
-
In the argument presented, an incompatibility between State and Central legal requirements. The Court found no operative conflict because it held that the provision invoked by the petitioners did not govern their appointments.
- Minimum pay scale and monthly gross salary
-
These are not necessarily identical measures. Clause 13.0 refers to monthly gross salary, while the cited remuneration precedent was described as awarding the minimum pay scale. The judgment treated the recruitment comparison as relevant but did not establish that every component of these measures is interchangeable.
- “Fallen out”
-
The expression used for guest faculty losing their existing engagement, including when a regular teacher joins. It does not necessarily imply misconduct or poor performance.
- Proportionality
-
A method of considering whether a measure imposes an excessive burden relative to its purpose. The Court rejected the proportionality objection to the recruitment concessions without setting out an extensive separate analysis.
8. Conclusion
The judgment distinguishes three matters that cannot be treated as interchangeable: temporary continuation, remuneration entitlement, and permanent appointment. These petitioners’ guest-faculty service did not establish a right to regular pay, absorption, or exemption from MPPSC recruitment, particularly because their selection process differed from regular recruitment and competitive opportunities remained available.
Its distinctive remedial contribution lies in alternative placement. Regular recruitment may displace guest faculty, but the State must offer these petitioners the nearest available position in their respective subjects. The result preserves the regular recruitment system while imposing a practical safeguard against avoidable hardship in redeployment.