Equitable Settlement of Assigned Debt: A Fact-Specific Remedy Without Deciding NPA or Assignment Validity
Case: ATIBIR INDUSTRIES CO. LTD v. STATE BANK OF INDIA
Citation: 2026 INSC 1156
Court: Supreme Court of India
Date: 26 October 2026
Bench: Surya Kant, CJI; Joymalya Bagchi and V. Mohana, JJ.
Judgment delivered by: V. Mohana, J.
1. Introduction
This judgment concerns the intersection of non-performing asset classification, assignment of bank debt to an asset reconstruction company, and the Supreme Court’s power to fashion equitable relief. Its distinguishing feature is that the Court resolved the financial dispute without deciding the principal questions concerning the legality of the NPA classification or the assignment.
Atibir Industries Co. Ltd., a manufacturer of sponge iron, pig iron and allied products, borrowed through a consortium led by State Bank of India. Its facilities included cash credit, term loans and letters of credit. They were supported by securities over business assets and immovable property, together with personal and corporate guarantees.
After defaults, SBI classified the borrower’s account as a non-performing asset with retrospective effect from 16 October 2020. Atibir disputed that classification, relying principally on the Reserve Bank of India’s COVID-19 relief circulars and a revised repayment schedule. SBI subsequently assigned the debt to the second respondent, an asset reconstruction company, for ₹250 crore.
The litigation initially raised substantial questions about moratorium protection, borrower-wise asset classification, and the relationship between assignment under Section 5 of the SARFAESI Act and enforcement under Section 13. Before the Supreme Court, however, the proceedings increasingly focused on the amount necessary to discharge the assigned debt.
The judgment’s central significance is therefore limited but important: it demonstrates a court-fashioned, conditional settlement of assigned debt in exceptional circumstances. It does not establish that an asset reconstruction company’s recoverable entitlement is generally restricted to its acquisition price plus a reasonable return.
2. Background and Procedural History
2.1 Default, pandemic relief and NPA classification
SBI maintained that the account had been irregular since 17 January 2020. Atibir’s own resolution proposals acknowledged substantial cash-credit exposure: against a sanctioned limit of ₹155 crore, outstanding cash credit stood at ₹278.56 crore on 31 March 2020 and approximately ₹302 crore on 6 June 2020.
Atibir relied on RBI circulars dated 27 March, 17 April and 23 May 2020 extending pandemic-related repayment relief up to 31 August 2020. SBI subsequently revised the term-loan repayment schedule, fixing the first instalment for 30 September 2020. Payments followed in November and December 2020.
By its communication dated 5 April 2021, SBI informed Atibir that its account had been classified as NPA on 31 March 2021 with effect from 16 October 2020. SBI referred to the Supreme Court’s lifting of the blanket restraint on NPA classification in the pandemic litigation.
2.2 Recovery proceedings and assignment
SBI pursued recovery through several mechanisms:
- A recall notice dated 17 January 2022;
- An application before DRT-I, Kolkata, under Section 19 of the Recovery of Debts and Bankruptcy Act, 1993;
- A Section 7 application under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016, before NCLT, Kolkata; and
- A demand notice under Section 13(2) of the SARFAESI Act, followed by a Section 13(4) notice that was subsequently withdrawn.
Meanwhile, Atibir made successive one-time settlement proposals, ultimately offering ₹238 crore in February 2023. None was accepted. The borrower also paid approximately ₹25 crore to SBI during the broader period of settlement discussions.
SBI advertised the stressed exposure for transfer through a web notice dated 10 February 2023. Following an initial writ petition, an interim deferment and withdrawal of that petition with liberty to file afresh, SBI advanced the auction process through a corrigendum dated 23 March 2023. The debt was assigned to the second respondent on 24 March 2023 for ₹250 crore.
2.3 Conflicting decisions in the High Court
The Single Judge accepted Atibir’s challenge. On that reasoning, the moratorium shifted the relevant repayment date beyond 31 August 2020, and SBI had to await the applicable 90-day period before treating the term-loan account as NPA. Classification with effect from 16 October 2020 was therefore premature. The Single Judge consequently set aside the classification and the ensuing transfer-related actions.
The Division Bench reversed. Its reasoning included three propositions:
- Asset classification was borrower-wise rather than confined to an individual facility, making default in the cash-credit account relevant to the borrower’s other facilities.
- A transfer under Section 5 of the SARFAESI Act was distinct from an enforcement measure under Section 13(4).
- For the transfer in question, the account’s status on the date of the web notice was material, rather than necessarily the historical NPA date stated in the Section 13(2) notice.
The Division Bench also permitted the borrower-wise classification argument to be raised in appeal despite its not having been advanced before the Single Judge. The Supreme Court did not finally determine the correctness of these propositions.
3. Summary of the Supreme Court’s Decision
3.1 The proceedings shifted towards financial resolution
In September 2024, the Supreme Court considered a proposal for Atibir to pay ₹250 crore in instalments. Crucially, the Court did not initially accept that ₹250 crore represented the entire liability. It left the disputed additional liability for further determination.
On 9 December 2024, the Court requested former Supreme Court judge Justice Anil R. Dave to examine the claim for interest and other amounts above ₹250 crore. His report was subject to the Supreme Court’s consideration; it was not a self-executing settlement or an arbitral award.
Although Atibir missed some instalment deadlines and obtained extensions, the Court ultimately recorded that the second respondent had received the full ₹250 crore.
3.2 Justice Dave’s report
The report recorded that the assigned debt was approximately ₹453.83 crore at the time of assignment, comprising principal and interest. Nevertheless, it approached the dispute by reference to the assignee’s ₹250 crore investment and an adequate commercial return on that investment.
Justice Dave rejected Atibir’s suggested 7.5% return as insufficient for a business transaction. Calculations, allowing for payments made up to 1 March 2025, produced returns of approximately:
| Annual rate |
Calculated return |
| 13% | ₹57.74 crore |
| 14% | ₹62.18 crore |
| 15% | ₹66.62 crore |
These figures were not the total outstanding liability: approximately ₹100 crore of the ₹250 crore amount remained unpaid at the calculation date. The report contemplated further adjustments for later payments and suggested ₹50 lakh towards expenses.
3.3 Final directions
The Supreme Court accepted the report with modification and fixed a further ₹125 crore payable to the second respondent. The operative arrangement was:
- Atibir must pay ₹125 crore within 12 weeks of the judgment, in addition to the ₹250 crore already paid.
- The additional payment constitutes full and final settlement of the second respondent’s claims against Atibir towards the assigned debt.
- Within four weeks of receiving that payment, the respondents must together return the title deeds and release all other securities and guarantees held by them.
- The identified Section 7 proceedings before NCLT, Kolkata, and recovery proceedings before DRT-I, Kolkata, stand disposed of.
- If Atibir fails to comply with the payment direction and deadline, the respondents may revive proceedings, and Atibir loses the benefit of the judgment.
Thus, the Supreme Court’s arrangement required aggregate payments of ₹375 crore to the assignee. That figure describes the court-directed arrangement, not every payment made throughout the earlier lending relationship. The final directions do not separately add the report’s proposed ₹50 lakh costs to the ₹125 crore.
4. Analysis: Precedents Cited
4.1 Small Scale Industrial Manufacturers Association v. Union of India — (2021) 8 SCC 511
This authority entered the case through SBI’s explanation for classifying the account after the pandemic-related restraint on NPA classification had been lifted. It supplied the procedural background to the bank’s action.
Its role must not be overstated. The lifting of a general restraint on NPA classification did not, by itself, resolve whether Atibir’s account satisfied the applicable classification requirements on the particular effective date selected by SBI. That required examination of the RBI circulars, repayment schedule, defaults and treatment of the different credit facilities.
The Supreme Court left those questions open. Accordingly, the judgment cannot be read as holding that this earlier decision automatically validated SBI’s retrospective classification.
The Court cited this decision for the complementary character of remedies under the debt-recovery legislation and the SARFAESI Act. Withdrawal of an original application before the DRT is not a precondition to invoking SARFAESI remedies.
This precedent matters because the Court expressed concern about SBI’s sequence of recovery, insolvency and assignment-related steps. Its criticism cannot properly be converted into a general prohibition on pursuing more than one recovery avenue. The Court expressly acknowledged the established availability of complementary DRT and SARFAESI remedies.
Equally, the proposition discussed from Transcore v. Union Of India and Another concerned DRT and SARFAESI remedies. The judgment did not use it to formulate a comprehensive new rule governing every interaction between those remedies and insolvency proceedings.
This was the principal authority addressing debt assignment. The quoted passage recognises that a debt owed to a bank is an asset belonging to the bank and may be transferred. Upon assignment, the borrower becomes indebted to the assignee instead of the assignor; the transfer does not itself impair the borrower’s rights.
The precedent supplies an important distinction between the price paid for a debt and the debt being transferred. A discounted acquisition does not, simply because of that discount, rewrite the borrower’s liability.
The second respondent relied on the assigned contractual rights to claim principal, interest and penal interest rather than merely a return on its purchase price. The Supreme Court acknowledged the assignment precedent but expressly declined to decide whether the final amount should be calculated by reference to debt value or acquisition value.
The resulting ₹375 crore arrangement must therefore be understood as exceptional equitable relief, not an overruling of ordinary assignment principles.
4.4 Bijnor Urban Cooperative Bank Limited, Bijnor And Others v. Meenal Aggarwal and Others — (2023) 2 SCC 805
The second respondent cited this decision for the principle that a High Court cannot issue a writ of mandamus compelling a bank or financial institution to grant a borrower the benefit of a one-time settlement. Eligibility depends on the governing scheme and applicable guidelines.
This principle qualified Atibir’s reliance on its repeated settlement offers. The existence of negotiations or an offer did not establish an enforceable right to acceptance.
The Supreme Court did not declare that SBI had been legally obliged to accept the ₹238 crore proposal. Its final arrangement was a judicially fashioned resolution of the pending dispute, not enforcement of an accepted OTS or recognition of a general borrower entitlement to one.
5. Analysis: Legal Reasoning
5.1 An express decision not to determine the underlying statutory disputes
Paragraph 40 is central to the judgment’s proper interpretation. The Court expressly kept open:
- The validity of the NPA classification;
- The validity of the assignment; and
- Compliance of the transfer with Section 5 of the SARFAESI Act.
Paragraph 42 similarly avoided deciding whether compensation should be based on debt value or acquisition value. The Court therefore selected a financial endpoint rather than resolving the competing statutory and contractual theories.
This limits the judgment’s precedential reach. Neither the Single Judge’s moratorium analysis nor the Division Bench’s borrower-wise classification reasoning became a Supreme Court holding merely because both were discussed in the procedural history.
5.2 The factual basis for equitable intervention
The Court considered several circumstances cumulatively:
- The continuing challenge to NPA classification;
- The sequence and timing of the bank’s recovery and assignment steps;
- The history of settlement proposals and payments;
- The allegation that a business competitor had financed the acquisition;
- The assignee’s failure to supply requested financial statements and borrowing-rate information;
- Atibir’s status as a running industrial concern and the livelihood interests of its employees; and
- The borrower’s own failures to meet some court-approved payment deadlines.
The Court noted the absence of a denial of the competitor-funding allegation. Nevertheless, it did not finally declare the assignment fraudulent, collusive or contrary to RBI requirements. Those allegations formed part of the equitable context, not a concluded finding of illegality.
5.3 Debt value and acquisition value remained distinct
The assignee objected that the report had overlooked the legal difference between the amount of debt acquired and the price paid to acquire it. That objection went to the core of the commercial model for distressed-debt purchases.
The Court did not resolve the objection by declaring acquisition price to be the legal ceiling. Instead, it ordered a lump-sum settlement while expressly withholding an opinion on the correct valuation basis.
Accordingly, neither the ₹250 crore acquisition price nor the report’s 13%–15% calculations supplies a general recovery formula for future ARC cases.
5.4 The additional ₹125 crore was a settlement figure, not a declared interest entitlement
The Court identified the report’s highest benchmark of 15%, elapsed time, and the assignee’s costs and expenses as considerations supporting the additional amount. However, it did not provide an itemised calculation reproducing ₹125 crore from the payment history.
The sound reading is therefore that ₹125 crore was a composite amount fixed to end the dispute. It was not a ruling that the contractual interest rate was 15%, that this rate was universally reasonable, or that a particular capitalisation method governed ARC recoveries.
There is also a chronological discrepancy in the text: paragraph 42 refers to more than 18 months having passed since the report, although the report is dated 9 July 2025 and the judgment 26 October 2026. The report’s calculations themselves ran to 1 March 2025. This discrepancy does not alter the unambiguous operative payment direction, but it reinforces the difficulty of treating the judgment as a precise interest-computation precedent.
5.5 Relief was conditional, not an unconditional write-down
The Court expressly described itself as a court of law and equity acting to do complete justice. Although the supplied judgment does not expressly cite Article 142, its reasoning is framed in complete-justice terms rather than as a general reinterpretation of the lending contract.
The strict default clause is consequently essential. Atibir obtained a defined route to discharge, but only by timely performance. Non-payment within 12 weeks removes the judgment’s benefit and permits revival of proceedings; the Court did not provide an automatic grace period or a substitute late-payment interest mechanism.
6. Potential Impact
6.1 For borrowers
The judgment shows that genuine disputes over regulatory compliance, substantial payments, preservation of an operating enterprise and broader livelihood concerns may together support exceptional relief. It does not allow a borrower to demand settlement at the price an ARC paid for its debt.
It also demonstrates the risk of conditional relief: earlier indulgence over instalments did not prevent the Court from imposing a final, strict compliance deadline.
6.2 For banks and asset reconstruction companies
The decision does not prohibit discounted debt purchases, third-party acquisition funding or complementary recovery proceedings. It nevertheless highlights the practical importance of transparent documentation when a court examines acquisition funding, commercial returns or alleged competitor involvement.
The assignee’s withholding of requested financial information left the report to estimate an appropriate return. That is a significant practical lesson, even though the judgment establishes no general disclosure rule for every assignment.
6.3 For future courts
The judgment is most useful as an illustration of tailored equitable resolution, not as authority resolving the underlying banking-law questions. It does not settle:
- Whether the pandemic moratorium restarted or merely affected the computation of the relevant default period;
- When retrospective NPA classification is permissible;
- The precise borrower-wise consequences of default across different facilities;
- The conditions governing every Section 5 transfer; or
- The general measure of an assignee’s recoverable debt.
Those matters remain governed by the applicable statutes, RBI directions, contractual terms and relevant precedents.
7. Complex Concepts Simplified
- Non-performing asset
- A regulatory classification applied when a loan or credit facility meets specified default conditions. The relevant tests can differ between term loans and cash-credit facilities.
- Moratorium
- A temporary postponement or relaxation of specified payment obligations. It is not automatically a cancellation of debt or interest.
- Borrower-wise classification
- An approach under which the status of one facility can affect the classification of other facilities provided to the same borrower. The Division Bench applied this approach; the Supreme Court did not finally adjudicate its application here.
- Assignment
- A transfer of the creditor’s debt-related rights to another entity. Ordinarily, it changes the creditor, not automatically the amount owed.
- Debt value and acquisition value
- Debt value is the amount claimed under the lending relationship. Acquisition value is the price paid to buy that debt. They can differ substantially.
- Section 5 and Section 13 of the SARFAESI Act
- Section 5 concerns acquisition of financial assets by an asset reconstruction company. Section 13 concerns enforcement of security interests. Transferring a debt and enforcing its security are distinct legal acts.
- One-time settlement
- An arrangement to discharge a debt on agreed terms, often for a reduced amount. A borrower’s proposal alone does not compel the lender to accept it.
- Pari passu security
- Security ranking equally with specified other creditors’ security, subject to the governing arrangements.
- Full and final settlement
- A definitive discharge of the claims covered by the arrangement once its conditions are fulfilled. Here, release of the existing securities and guarantees follows receipt of the additional payment.
8. Conclusion
The Supreme Court brought a prolonged debt dispute to a conditional financial conclusion: ₹125 crore more, following ₹250 crore already paid, would discharge the assigned debt, trigger release of securities and guarantees, and conclude the identified recovery and insolvency proceedings.
The essential caution is that this was exceptional equitable relief, not a general cap on ARC recovery. The Court expressly left NPA validity, assignment legality and the debt-value-versus-acquisition-value question undecided. Its lasting significance lies in the careful distinction between a binding settlement for the parties and a broadly applicable rule of banking law.