Supreme Court Case Commentaries

Unit‑Wise COD, Firm Power Entitlement, and Regulatory Override of Unapproved PPAs: Commentary on TANGEDCO v. Penna Electricity Ltd.

Date: Dec 16, 2025

Unit‑Wise COD, Firm Power Entitlement, and Regulatory Override of Unapproved PPAs: Commentary on TAMIL NADU GENERATION AND DISTRIBUTION CORPORATION LTD. v. M/s PENNA ELECTRICITY LIMITED (2025 INSC...

Irretrievable Breakdown, Long Separation and Mutual Cruelty as Grounds for Divorce under Article 142: Commentary on Nayan Bhowmick v. Aparna Chakraborty

Date: Dec 16, 2025

Irretrievable Breakdown, Long Separation and Mutual Cruelty as Grounds for Divorce under Article 142: Commentary on Nayan Bhowmick v. Aparna Chakraborty 1. Introduction The Supreme Court of India’s...

Dowry Eradication as a Constitutional Imperative and Humanitarian Sentencing for the Very Elderly: Commentary on State of U.P. v. Ajmal Beg

Date: Dec 15, 2025

Dowry Eradication as a Constitutional Imperative and Humanitarian Sentencing for the Very Elderly: Commentary on State of U.P. v. Ajmal Beg I. Introduction The Supreme Court’s decision in State of...

Section 44C Recast: Supreme Court Holds Head Office Expenditure Cap Applies to Both Common and Exclusive Foreign Expenses

Date: Dec 15, 2025

Section 44C Recast: Supreme Court Holds Head Office Expenditure Cap Applies to Both Common and Exclusive Foreign Expenses Table of Contents 1. Introduction 2. Background and Factual Matrix 3. Summary...

Structured Evidence Charts and Scrutiny of Circumstantial Evidence in Child Sexual Offence Trials: Commentary on Manojbhai Jethabhai Parmar (Rohit) v. State of Gujarat

Date: Dec 15, 2025

Structured Evidence Charts and Scrutiny of Circumstantial Evidence in Child Sexual Offence Trials: Commentary on Manojbhai Jethabhai Parmar (Rohit) v. State of Gujarat, 2025 INSC 1433 I. Introduction...

Supreme Court on Vendor’s Duty to Disclose Encumbrances and the Limited Evidentiary Value of Isolated Cross‑Examination Admissions – Commentary on Moideenkutty v. Abraham George (2025 INSC 1428)

Date: Dec 15, 2025

Supreme Court on Vendor’s Duty to Disclose Encumbrances and the Limited Evidentiary Value of Isolated Cross‑Examination Admissions Commentary on Moideenkutty v. Abraham George, 2025 INSC 1428...

Objects vs Area of Operation: Supreme Court Narrows Deemed Conversion to Multi-State Cooperative Societies under Section 103, MSCS Act, 2002

Date: Dec 15, 2025

Objects vs Area of Operation: Supreme Court Narrows Deemed Conversion to Multi-State Cooperative Societies under Section 103, Multi-State Cooperative Societies Act, 2002 I. Introduction The Supreme...

Doctrine of Lis Pendens and the Closed Architecture of Order XXI CPC: Commentary on Danesh Singh v. Har Pyari (2025 INSC 1434)

Date: Dec 15, 2025

Doctrine of Lis Pendens and the Closed Architecture of Order XXI CPC: Commentary on Danesh Singh v. Har Pyari (2025 INSC 1434) I. Introduction The Supreme Court’s decision in Danesh Singh & Ors v....

Reaffirming the Evidentiary Burden to Prove Vehicle Involvement in Motor Accident Claims: Commentary on Sithara N.S. v. Sai Ram General Insurance Co. Ltd., 2025 INSC 1425

Date: Dec 12, 2025

Reaffirming the Evidentiary Burden to Prove Vehicle Involvement in Motor Accident Claims and Limits on Supreme Court Interference with Concurrent Findings: A Commentary on Sithara N.S. v. Sai Ram...

Finality of Compassionate Appointment: No Right to Upgradation, No “Endless Compassion”, and No Negative Equality

Date: Dec 12, 2025

Finality of Compassionate Appointment: No Right to Upgradation, No “Endless Compassion”, and No Negative Equality I. Introduction The Supreme Court of India in The Director of Town Panchayat & Ors....

Substantial Compliance with Section 52‑A NDPS Act and Validity of On‑Spot Sampling: Commentary on Jothi @ Nagajothi v. State

Date: Dec 12, 2025

Substantial Compliance with Section 52‑A NDPS Act and Validity of On‑Spot Sampling: Commentary on Jothi @ Nagajothi v. State Case: JOTHI @ NAGAJOTHI v. THE STATE, REP. BY THE INSPECTOR OF POLICE...

Supremacy of the Public Premises Act over State Rent Control Laws and Reinforcement of Stare Decisis: Commentary on LIC v. Vita (2025 INSC 1419)

Date: Dec 12, 2025

Supremacy of the Public Premises Act Over State Rent Control Laws Irrespective of Tenancy Commencement, and a Strong Reassertion of Stare Decisis – Commentary on Life Insurance Corporation of India &...

Constitutional Safeguards in Reverse-Burden Terrorism Trials and the Limits of Section 436‑A CrPC: Commentary on CBI v. Dayamoy Mahato

Date: Dec 12, 2025

Constitutional Safeguards in Reverse-Burden Terrorism Trials and the Limits of Section 436‑A CrPC: Commentary on CBI v. Dayamoy Mahato 1. Introduction The Supreme Court of India’s decision in Central...

Requisitioning of Private Doctors Under COVID-19 Emergency Regulations as Sufficient for PMGKY Insurance Coverage – Commentary on Pradeep Arora v. Director, Health Department

Date: Dec 12, 2025

Requisitioning of Private Doctors Under COVID-19 Emergency Regulations as Sufficient for PMGKY Insurance Coverage 1. Introduction The Supreme Court of India’s decision in Pradeep Arora & Ors. v....

Inter‑Departmental Jurisdiction of Internal Complaints Committees under the POSH Act: Commentary on Dr. Sohail Malik v. Union of India (2025 INSC 1415)

Date: Dec 11, 2025

Inter‑Departmental Jurisdiction of Internal Complaints Committees under the POSH Act: Commentary on Dr. Sohail Malik v. Union of India (2025 INSC 1415) I. Introduction The Supreme Court of India’s...

Ring‑fencing Section 36(1)(viii): Strict “Derived From” Test for Long‑Term Finance Deductions in NCDC v. ACIT

Date: Dec 11, 2025

Ring‑fencing Section 36(1)(viii): Strict “Derived From” Test for Long‑Term Finance Deductions in National Cooperative Development Corporation v. Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax I. Introduction...

Co-existence of Section 102 CrPC Seizure Powers with Section 18A PC Act Attachment: Commentary on State of West Bengal v. Anil Kumar Dey (2025 INSC 1413)

Date: Dec 11, 2025

Co-existence of Section 102 CrPC Seizure Powers with Section 18A PC Act Attachment: Commentary on State of West Bengal v. Anil Kumar Dey (2025 INSC 1413) 1. Introduction The Supreme Court of India’s...

Remand Observations Do Not Freeze the Law; No Cross-Appeal Bars Challenge to Operative Relief; Compounding on Carrying Cost Turns on Facts

Date: Dec 11, 2025

Remand Observations Do Not Freeze the Law; No Cross-Appeal Bars Challenge to Operative Relief; Compounding on Carrying Cost Turns on Facts 1. Introduction RattanIndia Power Limited (“RPL”,...

Judicial Forfeiture Clauses in IBC Liquidation Sales: Commentary on M/s Shri Karshni Alloys Pvt Ltd v. Ramakrishnan Sadasivan

Date: Dec 10, 2025

Judicially-Imposed Forfeiture in IBC Liquidation Sales Is Not a Contractual Penalty: A Commentary on M/s Shri Karshni Alloys Pvt. Ltd. v. Ramakrishnan Sadasivan, 2025 INSC 1411 1. Introduction The...

Expiry of Arbitral Mandate and Mandatory Substitution under Section 29A(6): Commentary on Mohan Lal Fatehpuria v. M/s Bharat Textiles

Date: Dec 10, 2025

Expiry of Arbitral Mandate and Mandatory Substitution under Section 29A(6): Commentary on Mohan Lal Fatehpuria v. M/s Bharat Textiles & Ors., 2025 INSC 1409 I. Introduction The Supreme Court’s...