Supreme Court Case Commentaries

Judicially-Supervised River Restoration: Committee Directions as Interim Supreme Court Orders, ZLD Enforcement, and Special Courts for Jojari–Bandi–Luni Pollution

Date: Mar 19, 2026

Judicially-Supervised River Restoration: Committee Directions as Interim Supreme Court Orders, ZLD Enforcement, and Special Courts for Jojari–Bandi–Luni Pollution 1. Introduction This suo motu...

Notice-to-Convict Protocol When Appointing Amicus in Long-Pending Criminal Appeals

Date: Mar 18, 2026

Notice-to-Convict Protocol When Appointing Amicus in Long-Pending Criminal Appeals (Bail Misuse Mitigation) Case: BHOLA MAHTO v. THE STATE OF JHARKHAND Citation: 2026 INSC 257 (Supreme Court of...

Freight-Retention “Corporate Guarantee” Enforceable as Contract of Guarantee; Bank Must Indemnify Customer via Third-Party Procedure for Erroneous Remittance Contrary to Mandate

Date: Mar 18, 2026

Freight-Retention “Corporate Guarantee” Enforceable as Contract of Guarantee; Bank Must Indemnify Customer via Third-Party Procedure for Erroneous Remittance Contrary to Mandate 1. Introduction...

Post-facto shareholder ratification cannot cure fraudulent diversion of preferential-issue proceeds under SEBI law

Date: Mar 18, 2026

Post-facto Shareholder Ratification Cannot Cure Fraudulent Diversion of Preferential-Issue Proceeds (PFUTP); Distinct SEBI WTM Directions and AO Penalties May Co-exist 1) Introduction In SECURITIES...

Section 319 CrPC: “Strong and Cogent” Means No Mini‑Trial; Evidence Must Be Assessed Cumulatively

Date: Mar 18, 2026

Section 319 CrPC: “Strong and Cogent” Means No Mini‑Trial; Evidence Must Be Assessed Cumulatively 1. Introduction Case: MOHAMMAD KALEEM v. THE STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH & ORS., 2026 INSC 251 (Supreme...

Premature Quashing Under Section 482 CrPC Is Impermissible When Forensic Verification of Alleged Forgery Is Pending

Date: Mar 18, 2026

Premature Quashing Under Section 482 CrPC Is Impermissible When Forensic Verification of Alleged Forgery Is Pending Case: SHARLA BAZLIEL v. BALDEV THAKUR AND OTHERS Citation: 2026 INSC 252 (Supreme...

Doctor-Certified Police-Recorded Dying Declaration and Eyewitness Child Testimony as Sufficient Basis to Reverse Acquittal in a Burn-Homicide

Date: Mar 18, 2026

Doctor-Certified Police-Recorded Dying Declaration and Eyewitness Child Testimony as Sufficient Basis to Reverse Acquittal in a Burn-Homicide 1. Introduction SUBRAMANI … APPELLANT VERSUS STATE OF...

Adoptive Maternity Benefit Cannot Be Age-Capped: Section 60(4) Read Down to Remove the Three-Month Limit

Date: Mar 18, 2026

Adoptive Maternity Benefit Cannot Be Age-Capped: Section 60(4) Read Down to Remove the Three-Month Limit I. Introduction In HAMSAANANDINI NANDURI v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS. (2026 INSC 246), the Supreme...

No Partial Relief in Fraud-Tainted Insurance Claims: Fraud Vitiates the Entire Claim and Mandates Total Repudiation

Date: Mar 18, 2026

No Partial Relief in Fraud-Tainted Insurance Claims: Fraud Vitiates the Entire Claim and Mandates Total Repudiation 1. Introduction United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Sayona Colors Pvt. Ltd. (2026...

ICDS Supervisor Recruitment: Graduate Anganwadi Workers May Compete in SSLC-Experience Stream Despite Separate Graduate Earmarking

Date: Mar 17, 2026

ICDS Supervisor Recruitment: Graduate Anganwadi Workers May Compete in SSLC-Experience Stream Despite Separate Graduate Earmarking 1. Introduction The Supreme Court of India in Shiny C.J v. Shalini...

Accommodation of PwBD Candidates as per 04.01.2021 Identification Notification: SSC Duty to Forward Dossiers; CAG to Appoint Against Suitable Group ‘C’ Posts with Supernumerary Creation if Needed

Date: Mar 14, 2026

Accommodation of PwBD Candidates as per 04.01.2021 Identification Notification: SSC Duty to Forward Dossiers; CAG to Appoint Against Suitable Group ‘C’ Posts with Supernumerary Creation if Needed 1....

Article 32 Laches Recast: “Unexplained Delay” as the Operative Test and State-Induced Expectation as a Ground to Hear Decades-Old Fundamental Rights Claims

Date: Mar 14, 2026

Article 32 Laches Recast: “Unexplained Delay” as the Operative Test and State-Induced Expectation as a Ground to Hear Decades-Old Fundamental Rights Claims Case: MIZO CHIEF COUNCIL MIZORAM THR....

Confirmed DRT Auction Sales Are Not Immune from Limited Judicial Scrutiny on Valuation

Date: Mar 13, 2026

Confirmed DRT Auction Sales Are Not Immune from Limited Judicial Scrutiny on Valuation 1. Introduction Case: OM SAKTHI SEKAR v. V SUKUMAR & ORS. (2026 INSC 237), Supreme Court of India, decided on...

Objective-Material Threshold for Article 311(2)(b): Presumptions of Witness Intimidation Cannot Justify Dispensing with Departmental Inquiry

Date: Mar 13, 2026

Objective-Material Threshold for Article 311(2)(b): Presumptions of Witness Intimidation Cannot Justify Dispensing with Departmental Inquiry 1) Introduction Manohar Lal v. Commissioner of Police &...

Compulsory Armed-Forces Welfare Insurance Societies as “State” under Article 12 Despite Self-Funding: The AFGIS Rule

Date: Mar 13, 2026

Compulsory Armed-Forces Welfare Insurance Societies as “State” under Article 12 Despite Self-Funding: The AFGIS Rule Case: RAVI KHOKHAR v. UNION OF INDIA (2026 INSC 233) Court: Supreme Court of India...

Formal Closure of Long-Running Environmental PILs: Pending Air-Pollution Issues to Continue Through Thematic Suo Motu Proceedings

Date: Mar 13, 2026

Formal Closure of Long-Running Environmental PILs: Pending Air-Pollution Issues to Continue Through Thematic Suo Motu Proceedings 1. Introduction In M.C. MEHTA v. UNION OF INDIA, 2026 INSC 383, the...

Benefit-of-Doubt Acquittal Is Not “Honourable” for Police Recruitment: Screening Committee Primacy and Limited Judicial Review

Date: Mar 12, 2026

Benefit-of-Doubt Acquittal Is Not “Honourable” for Police Recruitment: Screening Committee Primacy and Limited Judicial Review 1) Introduction In THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH v. RAJKUMAR YADAV (2026...

Seniority Under TNEB Service Regulations: Appointment and “Duty” Commence on Joining for Training, Not on Probation

Date: Mar 12, 2026

Seniority Under TNEB Service Regulations: Appointment and “Duty” Commence on Joining for Training, Not on Probation 1. Introduction M. THANIGIVELU v. TAMIL NADU ELECTRICITY BOARD TAMIL NADU...

Clarificatory Letters Cannot Amend OBC Creamy Layer Norms: Salary-Only Exclusion Invalid and Parity Required for PSU/Private and Government Employees

Date: Mar 12, 2026

Clarificatory Letters Cannot Amend OBC Creamy Layer Norms: Salary-Only Exclusion Invalid and Parity Required for PSU/Private and Government Employees 1. Introduction UNION OF INDIA v. ROHIT NATHAN...

CANH via PEG Is “Medical Treatment”: Best-Interests Framework and Operationalisation of Common Cause for Home-Based PVS Patients

Date: Mar 12, 2026

CANH via PEG Is “Medical Treatment”: Best-Interests Framework and Operationalisation of Common Cause for Home-Based PVS Patients Case: HARISH RANA v. UNION OF INDIA Citation: 2026 INSC 222 Court &...