Supreme Court Case Commentaries

Temple Management Is Not Proof of Title: Plaintiffs Must Prove Vesting/Endowment to Succeed in Possession Suits

Date: Apr 10, 2026

Temple Management Is Not Proof of Title: Plaintiffs Must Prove Vesting/Endowment to Succeed in Possession Suits 1. Introduction In KISHAN CHAND (DEAD) THROUGH LRS v. GAUTAM GAUR HITKARAK SABHA, KOTA...

Executing Courts Cannot Re-write Compromise Decrees: Section 47 CPC Limits Execution to the Decree’s Terms

Date: Apr 9, 2026

Executing Courts Cannot Re-write Compromise Decrees: Section 47 CPC Limits Execution to the Decree’s Terms Case: MAURICE W. INNIS v. LILY KAZROONI @ LILY ARIF SHAIKH Citation: 2026 INSC 340 (Supreme...

Lis Pendens Transfers Declared “Non Est” Against a Decree, and Rebuttable Adverse Inference from Plaintiff’s Non-Appearance in Specific Performance Suits

Date: Apr 9, 2026

Lis Pendens Transfers Declared “Non Est” Against a Decree, and Rebuttable Adverse Inference from Plaintiff’s Non-Appearance in Specific Performance Suits 1. Introduction Russi Fisheries P. Ltd. &...

Limitation under Section 468 CrPC Runs from Initiation of Proceedings (Complaint/FIR), Not Cognizance — and Applies Equally to Police-Report Cases

Date: Apr 9, 2026

Limitation under Section 468 CrPC Runs from Initiation of Proceedings (Complaint/FIR), Not Cognizance — and Applies Equally to Police-Report Cases 1. Introduction Case: ROMA AHUJA v. THE STATE, 2026...

Extraordinary Pension Requires Governor’s Sanction: Writ Courts Should Not Substitute Statutory Discretion

Date: Apr 9, 2026

Extraordinary Pension Requires Governor’s Sanction: Writ Courts Should Not Substitute Statutory Discretion 1. Introduction Case: THE STATE OF UTTARAKHAND v. SARITA SINGH AND ORS. (Supreme Court of...

Third-Party Impleadment in Writ Proceedings When an Interim Order Produces Direct Civil Consequences

Date: Apr 9, 2026

Third-Party Impleadment in Writ Proceedings When an Interim Order Produces Direct Civil Consequences Case: M/S CHOPRA HOTELS PRIVATE LIMITED v. HARBINDER SINGH SEKHON & ORS. Citation: 2026 INSC 335...

Concurrent NDPS Sentencing: Separate Punishments for Sections 20, 25 & 29 Permissible, but Fine Cannot be Duplicated When Sentences Run Concurrently

Date: Apr 9, 2026

Concurrent NDPS Sentencing: Separate Punishments for Sections 20, 25 & 29 Permissible, but Fine Cannot be Duplicated When Sentences Run Concurrently 1. Introduction In HEM RAJ v. STATE OF HIMACHAL...

Voluntary Abandonment Is Not “Retirement” for SBI Pension: Qualifying Service Counts from Confirmation/Admission to Fund

Date: Apr 9, 2026

Voluntary Abandonment Is Not “Retirement” for SBI Pension: Qualifying Service Counts from Confirmation/Admission to Fund 1. Introduction In K. G. SESHADRI v. THE TRUSTEES OF STATE BANK OF INDIA AND...

Article 142 “Complete Justice” in Matrimonial Warfare: Irretrievable Breakdown Divorce with Global Quashing of Inter Se Proceedings (Including Lawyer-Targeting Complaints) and Lump-Sum Settlement

Date: Apr 8, 2026

Article 142 “Complete Justice” in Matrimonial Warfare: Irretrievable Breakdown Divorce with Global Quashing of Inter Se Proceedings (Including Lawyer-Targeting Complaints) and Lump-Sum Settlement 1....

Natural Justice in RBI Fraud Classification: No Mandatory Personal Hearing; Mandatory Disclosure of Forensic Audit Reports (Subject to Narrow Redaction)

Date: Apr 8, 2026

Natural Justice in RBI Fraud Classification: No Mandatory Personal Hearing; Mandatory Disclosure of Forensic Audit Reports (Subject to Narrow Redaction) 1. Introduction State Bank of India v. Amit...

UR(PWD-LV) Vacancies Must Be Filled on Merit by Any PWD-LV Candidate Irrespective of Vertical Category (Migration to Unreserved Horizontal Seats)

Date: Apr 8, 2026

UR(PWD-LV) Vacancies Must Be Filled on Merit by Any PWD-LV Candidate Irrespective of Vertical Category (Migration to Unreserved Horizontal Seats) 1) Introduction This Supreme Court decision in THE...

Section 138 N.I. Act: Statutory Presumption under Section 139 Cannot Be “Dislodged” at the Process-Issuance Stage

Date: Apr 8, 2026

Section 138 N.I. Act: Statutory Presumption under Section 139 Cannot Be “Dislodged” at the Process-Issuance Stage 1. Introduction In RENUKA v. THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA (2026 INSC 327), the Supreme...

Deemed Acceptance of Voluntary Retirement Under UCO Bank Pension Regulation 29(2): Refusal Must Be Ordered (and in Time) to Block Automatic Retirement

Date: Apr 8, 2026

Deemed Acceptance of Voluntary Retirement Under UCO Bank Pension Regulation 29(2): Refusal Must Be Ordered (and in Time) to Block Automatic Retirement 1) Introduction Case: UCO BANK v. SK SHRIVASTAVA...

Parity and Reliability Threshold in Circumstantial Murder Cases

Date: Apr 8, 2026

Parity and Reliability Threshold in Circumstantial Murder Cases: Weak “Last-Seen”, Tainted Recoveries, and Benefit of Doubt under Article 136 1. Introduction Gautam Satnami v. The State of...

Strict Enforcement of Industrial Plot Utilisation Timelines: No Equitable Restoration Under Article 136 for Prolonged Non-Use

Date: Apr 7, 2026

Strict Enforcement of Industrial Plot Utilisation Timelines: No Equitable Restoration Under Article 136 for Prolonged Non-Use 1) Introduction M/S. PIAGGIO VEHICLES PVT.LTD. v. THE STATE OF UTTAR...

Section 482 CrPC: Criminal Prosecution Against a Surgeon May Be Quashed Where Alleged Consent-Form Interpolation Lacks Prima Facie Material and the Procedure Was a Recognised Medical Alternative

Date: Apr 7, 2026

Section 482 CrPC: Criminal Prosecution Against a Surgeon May Be Quashed Where Alleged Consent-Form Interpolation Lacks Prima Facie Material and the Procedure Was a Recognised Medical Alternative 1....

Quashing on Prosecution CCTV Evidence: Applying the Four-Step Test to Prevent Abuse of Process

Date: Apr 7, 2026

Quashing on Prosecution CCTV Evidence: Applying the Four-Step Test to Prevent Abuse of Process 1. Introduction In SAJAL BOSE v. THE STATE OF WEST BENGAL (Supreme Court of India, 06-04-2026; 2026 INSC...

Vulgarity ≠ Obscenity under Section 294(b) IPC; Section 34 Common Intention Cannot Be Presumed from Participation Alone

Date: Apr 7, 2026

Vulgarity ≠ Obscenity under Section 294(b) IPC; Section 34 Common Intention Cannot Be Presumed from Participation Alone Case: SIVAKUMAR v. STATE REP BY THE INSPECTOR OF POLICE (2026 INSC 318) Court:...

Procurement Opacity, Missing Records, and Conflict-of-Interest Allegations as Grounds for Court-Directed CBI Investigation under Article 32

Date: Apr 7, 2026

Procurement Opacity, Missing Records, and Conflict-of-Interest Allegations as Grounds for Court-Directed CBI Investigation under Article 32 Case: SAVE MON REGION FEDERATION v. THE STATE OF ARUNACHAL...

Mandatory Immediate Transfer of a Declared Juvenile from Regular Jail and Strict Compliance with Sections 15/18/19 JJ Act Before “Adult Trial” Assumptions

Date: Apr 7, 2026

Mandatory Immediate Transfer of a Declared Juvenile from Regular Jail and Strict Compliance with Sections 15/18/19 JJ Act Before “Adult Trial” Assumptions 1. Introduction In JUVENILE DELINQUENT v....