Supreme Court Case Commentaries

Nominated Municipal Members Cannot Vote in Legislative Council Elections from Local Authorities Constituencies

Date: Jul 18, 2026

Nominated Municipal Members Cannot Vote in Legislative Council Elections from Local Authorities Constituencies Introduction In PRANESH M K v. A V GAYATHRI SHANTHEGOWDA, the Supreme Court of India...

Owner’s Risk Railway Consignments: Section 97 Overrides General Carrier Liability and Requires Proof of Negligence

Date: Jul 18, 2026

Owner’s Risk Railway Consignments: Section 97 Overrides General Carrier Liability and Requires Proof of Negligence 1. Introduction The Supreme Court of India in M/S BAJAJ TRADING COMPANY v. UNION OF...

Order XXII CPC: Delay Beyond Abatement Requires Separate Section 5 Application, but Restoration May Survive on Proven Sufficient Cause

Date: Jul 18, 2026

Order XXII CPC: Delay Beyond Abatement Requires Separate Section 5 Application, but Restoration May Survive on Proven Sufficient Cause 1. Introduction In Bishen Prasad Tiwari v. Sheela Devi, 2026...

Dignity Behind Bars: Compassionate Release Policy for Elderly and Terminally Ill Prisoners

Date: Jul 17, 2026

Dignity Behind Bars: Supreme Court Mandates Compassionate Release Framework for Elderly and Terminally Ill Prisoners 1. Introduction In National Legal Services Authority v. Union of India, 2026 INSC...

Public-Funded Madrasah Appointments Must Follow Open, Lawful Recruitment; Post-Stay Appointments Without Supreme Court Leave Are Void

Date: Jul 17, 2026

Public-Funded Madrasah Appointments Must Follow Open, Lawful Recruitment; Post-Stay Appointments Without Supreme Court Leave Are Void Introduction In NAJMA KHATUN v. THE STATE OF WEST BENGAL, the...

Defence Evidence Deserves Equal Judicial Scrutiny: Dowry Death Convictions Cannot Rest on Suspicion Alone

Date: Jul 17, 2026

Defence Evidence Deserves Equal Judicial Scrutiny: Dowry Death Convictions Cannot Rest on Suspicion Alone 1. Introduction In Brajesh Kumar @ Birjesh Kumar Singh v. The State of Bihar, 2026 INSC 695,...

Reasoned Reversal in First Appeals and Judicial Restraint in Remarks Against Trial Judges

Date: Jul 16, 2026

Reasoned Reversal in First Appeals and Judicial Restraint in Remarks Against Trial Judges 1. Introduction In LAKSHMI v. GOPI, 2026 INSC 709, the Supreme Court of India dealt with a dispute arising...

Statutory Mining Leases Carry Implied Power to Revise Royalty and Dead Rent Despite Silence in Lease Deed

Date: Jul 16, 2026

Statutory Mining Leases Carry Implied Power to Revise Royalty and Dead Rent Despite Silence in Lease Deed 1. Introduction In THE STATE OF HARYANA v. M/S FARIDABAD GURGAON MINERALS, 2026 INSC 690,...

Section 5A Hearing Right in Land Acquisition Is Mandatory, but May Be Abandoned by Conduct

Date: Jul 16, 2026

Section 5A Hearing Right in Land Acquisition Is Mandatory, but May Be Abandoned by Conduct Introduction In ALOK KOTAHWALA v. JAIPUR METRO RAIL CORPORATION LTD, the Supreme Court of India considered...

Inclusion of Royalty, DMF and NMET in Mineral Sale Value for ASP Computation Upheld as a Valid Anti-Evasion Measure

Date: Jul 16, 2026

Inclusion of Royalty, DMF and NMET in Mineral Sale Value for ASP Computation Upheld as a Valid Anti-Evasion Measure 1. Introduction In KIRLOSKAR FERROUS INDUSTRIES LIMITED v. UNION OF INDIA, the...

Pre-2016 DRT Recovery Certificate Cannot Sustain an Insolvency Notice under Section 9(2) of the Presidency Towns Insolvency Act

Date: Jul 16, 2026

Pre-2016 DRT Recovery Certificate Cannot Sustain an Insolvency Notice under Section 9(2) of the Presidency Towns Insolvency Act Introduction In H.D.F.C. Bank Limited v. Kishore K. Mehta (Dead) Thr....

Cumulative Investigative Infirmities Can Render an FIR Post-Investigation and Entitle Accused to Benefit of Doubt

Date: Jul 16, 2026

Cumulative Investigative Infirmities Can Render an FIR Post-Investigation and Entitle Accused to Benefit of Doubt Introduction In DEO PRASAD v. THE STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH, 2026 INSC 707, the Supreme...

Refund of Earnest Money Does Not Bar Specific Performance Unless It Creates a True Option to Pay Instead of Perform

Date: Jul 16, 2026

Refund of Earnest Money Does Not Bar Specific Performance Unless It Creates a True Option to Pay Instead of Perform 1. Introduction In JASPAL SINGH v. ASHWANI KUMAR, 2026 INSC 700, the Supreme Court...

Article 227 Review of Section 16 Arbitration Orders Permissible Only on a Prima Facie Finding of Patent Lack of Inherent Jurisdiction

Date: Jul 16, 2026

Article 227 Review of Section 16 Arbitration Orders Permissible Only on a Prima Facie Finding of Patent Lack of Inherent Jurisdiction Introduction In MANASH KAMAL BEZBORUAH v. M/S BOKAHOLA TEA...

Seasonal Fishing Restrictions Do Not Shorten Multi-Year Grants or Defeat Lease Stamp Duty

Date: Jul 16, 2026

Seasonal Fishing Restrictions Do Not Shorten Multi-Year Grants or Defeat Lease Stamp Duty Case: Zaki Ullah Khan v. State Of U.P.AND ORS. Citation: 2026 INSC 827 Court: Supreme Court of India Bench:...

Photographs Taken Later Cannot Override Injured Eyewitness Testimony in Motor Accident Claims

Date: Jul 15, 2026

Photographs Taken Later Cannot Override Injured Eyewitness Testimony in Motor Accident Claims Introduction In MANJU SINGH v. AVINASH SINGH, the Supreme Court of India considered appeals arising from...

Security Deposits Carry No Interest Where Contract So Provides, But Interest Accrues After Contractual Refund Period

Date: Jul 15, 2026

Security Deposits Carry No Interest Where Contract So Provides, But Interest Accrues After Contractual Refund Period Introduction In THE STATE OF HARYANA v. M/S JAI DURGAA FINVEST P.LTD., the Supreme...

Section 22 of the Hindu Succession Act Applies to Agricultural Land as a Succession-Based Preferential Right

Date: Jul 15, 2026

Section 22 of the Hindu Succession Act Applies to Agricultural Land as a Succession-Based Preferential Right Introduction In MAHINDER v. PURAN SINGH, the Supreme Court of India decided a significant...

Retrospective Withdrawal of Tax Exemption Is Valid, But Penalty and Pre-Demand Interest Cannot Follow Where Dealers Relied on the Earlier Exemption

Date: Jul 15, 2026

Retrospective Withdrawal of Tax Exemption Is Valid, But Penalty and Pre-Demand Interest Cannot Follow Where Dealers Relied on the Earlier Exemption 1. Introduction In ASIA SUGAR AND CHEMICAL CO.,...

Mandatory Section 19(1) Order by Children’s Court: Failure Vitiates Adult Trial of a Child in Conflict with Law

Date: Jul 15, 2026

Mandatory Section 19(1) Order by Children’s Court: Failure Vitiates Adult Trial of a Child in Conflict with Law 1. Introduction In Sagar v. The State of Haryana, 2026 INSC 692, the Supreme Court of...