Bombay High Court Case Commentaries

Twisting and Texturising POY as Manufacturing: Establishing a Precedent under Section 80IA

Date: Feb 28, 2008

Twisting and Texturising POY as Manufacturing: Establishing a Precedent under Section 80IA Introduction In the landmark case of The Commissioner Of Income Tax v. Emptee Poly Yarn Pvt. Ltd., decided...

Priority of Secured Creditors under SARFAESI Act over Government Excise Claims: Tata Metaliks Ltd. v. Union of India

Date: Feb 21, 2008

Priority of Secured Creditors under SARFAESI Act over Government Excise Claims: Tata Metaliks Ltd. v. Union of India Introduction Tata Metaliks Limited & Anr. v. Union Of India & Ors. is a landmark...

Interpretation of Lump Sum Contracts and Arbitrator's Jurisdiction in Construction Disputes: Insights from Mumbai Metropolitan Region Development Authority v. Unity Infraproject Ltd.

Date: Feb 16, 2008

Interpretation of Lump Sum Contracts and Arbitrator's Jurisdiction in Construction Disputes: Insights from Mumbai Metropolitan Region Development Authority v. Unity Infraproject Ltd. Introduction The...

Reaffirmation of the 'Full and True Disclosure' Principle in Section 147 Reassessment: Idea Cellular Ltd. vs. DC of Income-Tax

Date: Feb 14, 2008

Reaffirmation of the 'Full and True Disclosure' Principle in Section 147 Reassessment: Idea Cellular Ltd. vs. Deputy Commissioner Of Income-Tax Introduction The case of Idea Cellular Ltd. vs. Deputy...

UCO Bank v. Kanji Manji Kothari: Clarifying Limitation Periods and the Applicability of the Limitation Act under the NPA Act

Date: Feb 13, 2008

UCO Bank v. Kanji Manji Kothari: Clarifying Limitation Periods and the Applicability of the Limitation Act under the NPA Act 1. Introduction The case of UCO Bank, Mumbai v. M/S Kanji Manji Kothari...

Delegation of Appellate Powers under the Bombay Village Panchayat Act: Analysis of Atmaram Chapa v. Shamshadbi Shah Fakir

Date: Feb 9, 2008

Delegation of Appellate Powers under the Bombay Village Panchayat Act: Analysis of Atmaram Chapa v. Shamshadbi Shah Fakir Introduction The case of Atmaram Chapa Sandanshiv And Another v. Shamshadbi...

Priority of Secured Creditors over Government Tax Dues: Insights from Krishna Lifestyle Technologies Ltd. v. Union Of India & Ors.

Date: Feb 6, 2008

Priority of Secured Creditors over Government Tax Dues: Insights from Krishna Lifestyle Technologies Ltd. v. Union Of India & Ors. Introduction The case of Krishna Lifestyle Technologies Ltd. v....

The Applicability of Section 16(2) in Reassessments Under Section 17: Insights from Commissioner Of Wealth Tax v. Huf Of H.H. Late Shri. J.M. Scindia

Date: Feb 6, 2008

The Applicability of Section 16(2) in Reassessments Under Section 17: Insights from Commissioner Of Wealth Tax v. Huf Of H.H. Late Shri. J.M. Scindia Introduction The case of The Commissioner Of...

Special Power of Attorney Cannot Substitute Original Complainant in Section 138 Cases: Insights from Roy Joseph Creado v. Sk. Tamisuddin

Date: Feb 2, 2008

Special Power of Attorney Cannot Substitute Original Complainant in Section 138 Cases: Insights from Roy Joseph Creado v. Sk. Tamisuddin Introduction The case of Roy Joseph Creado v. Sk. Tamisuddin...

Determining Workman's Status: Bombay High Court's Interpretation under Section 2(s) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947

Date: Feb 1, 2008

Determining Workman's Status: Bombay High Court's Interpretation under Section 2(s) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 Introduction The case of Somnath Tulshiram Galande v. Presiding Officer, Iind...

Enhanced Compensation Mechanism in Land Acquisition: Insights from Genu Bhivaji Rao v. SLAO, Upper Godavari

Date: Feb 1, 2008

Enhanced Compensation Mechanism in Land Acquisition: Insights from Genu Bhivaji Rao v. SLAO, Upper Godavari Introduction The case of Genu Bhivaji Rao v. Special Land Acquisition Officer (SLAO), Upper...

Exclusive Jurisdiction of Small Causes Courts Over Arbitration in Licensor-Licensee Disputes: Ing Vysya Bank Ltd. v. Modern India Ltd.

Date: Jan 31, 2008

Exclusive Jurisdiction of Small Causes Courts Over Arbitration in Licensor-Licensee Disputes: Ing Vysya Bank Ltd. v. Modern India Ltd. And Another Introduction The case of Ing Vysya Bank Ltd. v....

Importance of Properly Authenticated Evidence: Analysis of Bank of India v. Allibhoy Mohammed & Ors.

Date: Jan 30, 2008

Importance of Properly Authenticated Evidence: Analysis of Bank of India v. Allibhoy Mohammed & Ors. Introduction The case of Bank of India v. Allibhoy Mohammed & Ors. adjudicated by the Bombay High...

Comprehensive Commentary on Shamlata v. Vishweshwara Tukaram Giripunje

Date: Jan 30, 2008

Establishing Accurate Land Measurement Standards: Insights from Shamlata v. Vishweshwara Tukaram Giripunje Introduction The case of Shamlata v. Vishweshwara Tukaram Giripunje adjudicated by the...

Strict Scrutiny in Deceptive Similarity for Pharmaceutical Trademarks: Wyeth Holdings vs. Burnet Pharmaceuticals

Date: Jan 26, 2008

Strict Scrutiny in Deceptive Similarity for Pharmaceutical Trademarks: Wyeth Holdings vs. Burnet Pharmaceuticals Introduction The case of Wyeth Holdings Corporation & Anr. v. Burnet Pharmaceuticals...

Adherence to Procedural Requirements in Employee Resignation Under MEPS Act: A Comprehensive Analysis of Chandramani Devraj Tiwari v. Secretary, Smt. R.B Tiwari Sanskrutik Kendra And Others

Date: Jan 26, 2008

Adherence to Procedural Requirements in Employee Resignation Under MEPS Act: A Comprehensive Analysis of Chandramani Devraj Tiwari v. Secretary, Smt. R.B Tiwari Sanskrutik Kendra And Others...

Hindustan Lever Ltd. v. Ramkrishna Bhikha Dushane: Clarifying Employer's Disciplinary Powers Under Section 33 of the Industrial Disputes Act

Date: Jan 26, 2008

Hindustan Lever Ltd. v. Ramkrishna Bhikha Dushane: Clarifying Employer's Disciplinary Powers Under Section 33 of the Industrial Disputes Act Introduction The case of Hindustan Lever Ltd. v....

SICA Prevails Over Companies Act in Sick Industrial Companies: Insights from Ashok Organic Industries Ltd. v. A.R.C.I.L.

Date: Jan 26, 2008

SICA Prevails Over Companies Act in Sick Industrial Companies: Insights from Ashok Organic Industries Ltd. v. Asset Reconstruction Company (India) Limited Intervener Introduction The judgment in...

Reaffirming Prosecution's Primacy in Tendering Pardon under Sections 306/307 CrPC: Al-Saleha Beig v. State

Date: Jan 25, 2008

Reaffirming Prosecution's Primacy in Tendering Pardon under Sections 306/307 CrPC: Al-Saleha Beig v. State 1. Introduction The case of Al-Saleha Beig v. State adjudicated by the Bombay High Court on...

Parke-Davis (India) Ltd. v. Mahadev Bhiku Jadhav And Others: Establishing Rights of Temporary Workers

Date: Jan 19, 2008

Parke-Davis (India) Ltd. v. Mahadev Bhiku Jadhav And Others: Establishing Rights of Temporary Workers Introduction The case of Parke-Davis (India) Ltd. v. Mahadev Bhiku Jadhav And Others adjudicated...