All High Courts Case Commentaries

Consistency and Documentary Substantiation as the Core of “Bona Fide Requirement” under Section 14(1)(e) DRC Act

Date: Jan 10, 2026

Consistency and Documentary Substantiation as the Core of “Bona Fide Requirement” under Section 14(1)(e) DRC Act: No Eviction Where Alternative Accommodation and Need Remain Unproved (Limited...

Finality over “Liberty”: Re-litigation by Government-land encroachers barred; no right to seek assignment/exchange against State’s prison-policy decision

Date: Jan 10, 2026

Finality over “Liberty”: Re-litigation by Government-land encroachers barred; no right to seek assignment/exchange against State’s prison-policy decision 1. Introduction This decision of the Madras...

Charitable-Trust-Funded Treatment Not Payable as “Medical Expenses” to Claimants; Consortium Payable Per Dependant per Pranay Shethi

Date: Jan 9, 2026

Charitable-Trust-Funded Treatment Not Payable as “Medical Expenses” to Claimants; Consortium Payable Per Dependant per Pranay Shethi 1. Introduction This first appeal under Section 173 of the Motor...

Section 498A/DP Act FIRs Must Not Criminalise “Daily Wear and Tear” of Marriage: Quashing Vague, Omnibus Matrimonial Allegations and Caution Against Coercive Look Out Circulars

Date: Jan 9, 2026

Section 498A/DP Act FIRs Must Not Criminalise “Daily Wear and Tear” of Marriage: Quashing Vague, Omnibus Matrimonial Allegations and Caution Against Coercive Look Out Circulars 1. Introduction Case:...

Fixed-pay recruitment to regular State posts is unconstitutional: regular pay from initial appointment under “equal pay for equal work”

Date: Jan 9, 2026

Fixed-pay recruitment to regular State posts is unconstitutional: regular pay from initial appointment under “equal pay for equal work” 1. Introduction This common judgment of the Tripura High Court...

Lok Adalat Settlements Require Party Presence/Free Consent; Counsel Must Hold Written Authority to Compromise

Date: Jan 9, 2026

Lok Adalat Settlements Require Party Presence/Free Consent; Counsel Must Hold Written Authority to Compromise 1. Introduction In MAHINDRA AND MAHINDRA FINANCIAL SERVICES LTD v. HAKIM UDDIN AND ANR...

Family Pension Entitlement of a “Nata Patni”: Nomination Not Determinative When Marital Status is Established

Date: Jan 9, 2026

Family Pension Entitlement of a “Nata Patni”: Nomination Not Determinative When Marital Status is Established 1. Introduction The decision in RAM PYARI SUMAN W/O LATE SHRI PURAN LAL SAINI v. THE...

Rule 9 CCS (Pension) Rules: Pension Withholding Requires Proven “Grave Misconduct”; Prior Departmental Knowledge Negates “Misrepresentation”

Date: Jan 8, 2026

Rule 9 CCS (Pension) Rules: Pension Withholding Requires Proven “Grave Misconduct”; Prior Departmental Knowledge Negates “Misrepresentation” Case: Birendra Singh Kunwar v. Union of India through...

“Immediate” Forwarding Under Section 19(2) PMLA Means Reasonable Promptness: Holidays/After-Hours Delay Not Fatal; Writ Review Confined to Statutory Safeguards

Date: Jan 8, 2026

“Immediate” Forwarding Under Section 19(2) PMLA Means Reasonable Promptness: Holidays/After-Hours Delay Not Fatal; Writ Review Confined to Statutory Safeguards 1. Introduction In Yogesh Dua v/s....

Section 25B(8) DRC Act: Revisional Review Confined to “According to Law” in Leave-to-Defend Evictions

Date: Jan 8, 2026

Section 25B(8) DRC Act: Revisional Review Confined to “According to Law” in Leave-to-Defend Evictions (Bona Fide Need Not Revisited Like an Appeal) 1. Introduction In SATISH KUMAR GUPTA v. SUSHIL...

Disclosure/Blackmail Using a Spouse’s Private Photographs Constitutes “Mental Cruelty”

Date: Jan 8, 2026

Disclosure/Blackmail Using a Spouse’s Private Photographs Constitutes “Mental Cruelty” Under Section 13(1)(i-a) of the Hindu Marriage Act 1. Introduction In DEBLEENA DUTTA v. SUMAN KUMAR RUJ (2026...

Departmental Dismissal Cannot Stand on Unalleged Misconduct or “No Evidence”; Reinstatement/Benefits Not Automatic Where Intervening Conviction Exists

Date: Jan 8, 2026

Departmental Dismissal Cannot Stand on Unalleged Misconduct or “No Evidence”; Reinstatement/Benefits Not Automatic Where Intervening Conviction Exists 1. Introduction In DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF POLICE...

Election Disputes of Bar Council of Delhi Must Be Taken to the Supreme Court-Constituted Special Committee, Not Entertained in Writ Jurisdiction

Date: Jan 8, 2026

Election Disputes of Bar Council of Delhi Must Be Taken to the Supreme Court-Constituted Special Committee, Not Entertained in Writ Jurisdiction 1. Introduction In UMESH KUMAR & ORS. v. UNION OF...

Section 24 MRC Act: “Purpose of Licence” Must Be Determined from a Holistic Reading of the Registered Agreement; Collateral Claims and Actual User Cannot Defeat Summary Eviction

Date: Jan 8, 2026

Section 24 MRC Act: “Purpose of Licence” Must Be Determined from a Holistic Reading of the Registered Agreement; Collateral Claims and Actual User Cannot Defeat Summary Eviction Court: Bombay High...

Rule 11 Delhi Police Rules: No Enhanced Punishment After Partial Appellate Relief Where Department Already Penalised the Same Conviction

Date: Jan 8, 2026

Rule 11 Delhi Police Rules: No Enhanced Punishment After Partial Appellate Relief Where Department Already Penalised the Same Conviction 1. Introduction In ASHOK KUMAR v. COMMISSIONER OF POLICE AND...

ICC Inquiries Under CCS(CCA) Rule 14(2): “As Far as Practicable” Cannot Dilute Core Natural Justice; No Reinstatement Pending Fresh ICC Inquiry

Date: Jan 8, 2026

ICC Inquiries Under CCS(CCA) Rule 14(2): “As Far as Practicable” Cannot Dilute Core Natural Justice; No Reinstatement Pending Fresh ICC Inquiry 1. Introduction In UNION OF INDIA & ORS. v. NARESH...

Suspension of Sentence for Fixed-Term Convictions: When Acquittal on Forgery/Cheating Undermines a Section 409 IPC Conviction

Date: Jan 8, 2026

Suspension of Sentence for Fixed-Term Convictions: When Acquittal on Forgery/Cheating Undermines a Section 409 IPC Conviction Case: Sumeet Suri v. State (NCT of Delhi), 2026 DHC 89 (Delhi High Court)...

“Victim” Under Section 372 CrPC Requires Loss/Injury Caused by the Charged Offence: Co-owner Lacks Locus to Appeal Acquittal in Police-Report Case

Date: Jan 7, 2026

“Victim” Under Section 372 CrPC Requires Loss/Injury Caused by the Charged Offence: Co-owner Lacks Locus to Appeal Acquittal in Police-Report Case 1. Introduction In SMT SUDHA SHARMA v. STATE NCT OF...

MCOCA Bail: Section 21(4) Twin-Condition Rigour Prevails Despite Intermediate NDPS Quantity and Post-Chargesheet Further Investigation

Date: Jan 7, 2026

MCOCA Bail: Section 21(4) Twin-Condition Rigour Prevails Despite Intermediate NDPS Quantity and Post-Chargesheet Further Investigation 1. Introduction In ANURADHA @ CHIKU v. STATE (NCT OF DELHI)...

Quasi‑Judicial Admission Supervisory Committee Lacks Standing to Appeal: Not an “Aggrieved Person” Under Act 15 of 2017

Date: Jan 7, 2026

Quasi‑Judicial Admission Supervisory Committee Lacks Standing to Appeal: Not an “Aggrieved Person” Under Act 15 of 2017 Case: THE ADMISSION SUPERVISORY COMMITTEE FOR MEDICAL EDUCATION IN KERALA v....