All High Courts Case Commentaries

Election Petitions Under the Representation of the People Act, 1951: “Proper Parties” Are Impermissible; Misjoinder Is Curable by Striking Out Non-Candidates

Date: Apr 21, 2026

Election Petitions Under the Representation of the People Act, 1951: “Proper Parties” Are Impermissible; Misjoinder Is Curable by Striking Out Non-Candidates Case: HARSH DEV SINGH v. UT OF J AND K TH...

Section 482 Cr.P.C. Cannot Function as a “Second Revision” to Reappreciate Concurrent Findings; Complaints Based on Uncorroborated High-Value Cash Property Payments Fail at Summoning Stage

Date: Apr 21, 2026

Section 482 Cr.P.C. Cannot Function as a “Second Revision” to Reappreciate Concurrent Findings; Complaints Based on Uncorroborated High-Value Cash Property Payments Fail at Summoning Stage 1....

Writ Bar Against Section 6 Eviction Notices and State Regulation of Grama Natham (Commercial Use Impermissible)

Date: Apr 21, 2026

Writ Bar Against Section 6 Eviction Notices and State Regulation of Grama Natham (Commercial Use Impermissible) Case: Selvakumar v. The Additional Chief Secretary to Government, 2026 MHC 1572 (Madras...

Recusal Cannot Be Manufactured: Objective “Reasonable Apprehension” Test, Interim Prima Facie Orders, and Non-Lis Associations Do Not Disqualify a Judge

Date: Apr 21, 2026

Recusal Cannot Be Manufactured: Objective “Reasonable Apprehension” Test, Interim Prima Facie Orders, and Non-Lis Associations Do Not Disqualify a Judge 1. Introduction The decision in CENTRAL BUREAU...

Article 226 Limits: No Writ Adjudication of Decades-Old Public Works Payment Claims When Records Are Unverifiable

Date: Apr 21, 2026

Article 226 Limits: No Writ Adjudication of Decades-Old Public Works Payment Claims When Records Are Unverifiable 1. Introduction The Delhi High Court (Division Bench) in JL WALI & ORS v. UNION OF...

Deployment Under Odisha’s 31.01.2018 Hi-Tech Survey Policy Creates a Continuing Lien and Bars Repatriation as “Deputation”

Date: Apr 21, 2026

Deployment Under Odisha’s 31.01.2018 Hi-Tech Survey Policy Creates a Continuing Lien and Bars Repatriation as “Deputation” Case: SMRUTI RANJAN MOHAPATRA v. STATE OF ODISHA Court: Orissa High Court...

Third-Party Writs/PILs on Alleged Hate Speech in Election Campaigns Are Not Maintainable; Remedy Lies with Aggrieved Persons Under Election Law

Date: Apr 21, 2026

Third-Party Writs/PILs on Alleged Hate Speech in Election Campaigns Are Not Maintainable; Remedy Lies with Aggrieved Persons Under Election Law Case: VA PUGAZHENDI v. THE CHIEF ELECTION COMMISSIONER...

Section 482 Cr.PC/Section 528 BNSS: FIR Not Determinative; Quashing of Murder Charge Impermissible Where Charge-sheet, Eyewitness Support and Post-mortem Show Prima Facie Causation

Date: Apr 19, 2026

Section 482 Cr.PC/Section 528 BNSS: FIR Not Determinative; Quashing of Murder Charge Impermissible Where Charge-sheet, Eyewitness Support and Post-mortem Show Prima Facie Causation Case: MANGA RAM v....

Cancellation of Caste Certificate Requires Formal Show-Cause Notice: Telephone Call Is Not an Effective Hearing

Date: Apr 18, 2026

Cancellation of Caste Certificate Requires Formal Show-Cause Notice: Telephone Call Is Not an Effective Hearing 1. Introduction In MOHD DANISH v. STATE OF UTTARAKHAND (Uttarakhand High Court, decided...

Death Sentence Cannot Stand Where Circumstantial Chain is “Shattered”: Strict Scrutiny of Extra-Judicial Confession, Section 27 Discovery, and Contradictions in a Section 366 CrPC Reference

Date: Apr 18, 2026

Death Sentence Cannot Stand Where Circumstantial Chain is “Shattered”: Strict Scrutiny of Extra-Judicial Confession, Section 27 Discovery, and Contradictions in a Section 366 CrPC Reference 1....

Unregistered Customary Marriage Can Be Tested Under Section 27 of the Special Marriage Act: Registration Under Section 15 Is Not a Precondition for Divorce

Date: Apr 18, 2026

Unregistered Customary Marriage Can Be Tested Under Section 27 of the Special Marriage Act: Registration Under Section 15 Is Not a Precondition for Divorce 1. Introduction In Smt. Rathna P v. Sri....

Acquittal in 498-A Does Not Bar Section 125 Maintenance; Maintenance to Run from Date of Application; Section 340 Cr.P.C. Requires “Expedient in the Interest of Justice” Threshold

Date: Apr 18, 2026

Acquittal in 498-A Does Not Bar Section 125 Maintenance; Maintenance to Run from Date of Application; Section 340 Cr.P.C. Requires “Expedient in the Interest of Justice” Threshold 1. Introduction...

Industrial Traffic Must Not Disproportionately Occupy Public Roads: Strict Enforcement of Internal Parking (Rule 41, Jharkhand Building Bye-laws, 2016) and State Duty to Ensure Trauma Care as Article 21 Compliance

Date: Apr 17, 2026

Industrial Traffic Must Not Disproportionately Occupy Public Roads: Strict Enforcement of Internal Parking (Rule 41, Jharkhand Building Bye-laws, 2016) and State Duty to Ensure Trauma Care as Article...

Allowances and Family-Benefit Perks Form Part of “Income” for Motor Accident Dependency Compensation

Date: Apr 17, 2026

Allowances and Family-Benefit Perks Form Part of “Income” for Motor Accident Dependency Compensation Case: PRIYANKA AND OTHERS v. SWARN SINGH AND OTHERS, [2026:RJ-JP:15844] Court: Rajasthan High...

De Facto Arrest Starts the 24-Hour Clock: Section 58 BNSS/Article 22(2) Runs from First Coercive Restraint, Not Arrest Memo Time

Date: Apr 17, 2026

De Facto Arrest Starts the 24-Hour Clock: Section 58 BNSS/Article 22(2) Runs from First Coercive Restraint, Not Arrest Memo Time 1) Introduction In ANUJ KUMAR SINGH v. UNION OF INDIA (Punjab &...

Continuity-of-Eligibility Principle in ART/Surrogacy: Age Limit Assessed with Reference to Timely Initiation and Completed Cryopreservation

Date: Apr 17, 2026

Continuity-of-Eligibility Principle in ART/Surrogacy: Age Limit Assessed with Reference to Timely Initiation and Completed Cryopreservation 1. Introduction In SANGITA RAHA AND ANR. v. THE STATE OF...

Dismissal of BSF Personnel by Show-Cause (Without Security Force Court Trial) When Trial is Inexpedient/Impracticable Due to Civilian Involvement

Date: Apr 16, 2026

Dismissal of BSF Personnel by Show-Cause (Without Security Force Court Trial) When Trial is Inexpedient/Impracticable Due to Civilian Involvement 1. Introduction In Md. Farhad Zaman Vs. Union of...

Quashing 498A/406/506 Proceedings Against In-Laws on Omnibus Allegations and Medical Improbability: Section 482 Scrutiny Beyond the FIR

Date: Apr 16, 2026

Quashing 498A/406/506 Proceedings Against In-Laws on Omnibus Allegations and Medical Improbability: Section 482 Scrutiny Beyond the FIR Case: MRIGESH KANTI NATH AND OTHERS v. STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND...

CAPF Superannuation Enhancement: Pension Notional-Benefit Cut-off at “Under 60 as on 31.01.2019”

Date: Apr 16, 2026

CAPF Superannuation Enhancement: Pension Notional-Benefit Cut-off at “Under 60 as on 31.01.2019” 1. Introduction This batch decision of the Delhi High Court (Division Bench: Anil Kshetarpal, J. and...

Liquor Licences: No Vested Right to Renewal; Lapsed Licences May Be Auctioned with Government-Fixed Reservation Norms; Interim Stay on Subordinate Legislation Requires a Strong Prima Facie Case

Date: Apr 16, 2026

Liquor Licences: No Vested Right to Renewal; Lapsed Licences May Be Auctioned with Government-Fixed Reservation Norms; Interim Stay on Subordinate Legislation Requires a Strong Prima Facie Case Case:...