All High Courts Case Commentaries

Bail in Suicide-Abetment Allegations: Mere Threat in a Familial Dispute and Absence of Proximate Overt Act as Key Factors

Date: Aug 6, 2026

Bail in Suicide-Abetment Allegations: Mere Threat in a Familial Dispute and Absence of Proximate Overt Act as Key Factors 1. Introduction The Gujarat High Court, in JAVEDKHAN SORAMKHAN MANDORI v....

Family Pension as a Statutory Right of the Legally Wedded Widow: Nomination or Affidavit Cannot Defeat Entitlement Absent Divorce

Date: Aug 5, 2026

Family Pension as a Statutory Right of the Legally Wedded Widow: Nomination or Affidavit Cannot Defeat Entitlement Absent Divorce 1. Introduction The Gujarat High Court (per Niral R. Mehta J.)...

Article 226 Cannot Be Used to Restore a YouTube Channel: Contractual Platform Disputes Lie Outside Writ Jurisdiction

Date: Aug 5, 2026

Article 226 Cannot Be Used to Restore a YouTube Channel: Contractual Platform Disputes Lie Outside Writ Jurisdiction 1. Introduction In SWATI ALIAS SMRITI NEGI v. UNION OF INDIA (2026 UHC 6805),...

Section 44(1)(c) PMLA Committal Requires Prior Cognizance by the Special Court; Late-Stage Transfer Must Yield to Speedy Trial

Date: Aug 5, 2026

Section 44(1)(c) PMLA Committal Requires Prior Cognizance by the Special Court; Late-Stage Transfer Must Yield to Speedy Trial Case: The Assistant Director v. Additional Superintendent of Police...

No Vested Right to Retain Government Quarters Against Redevelopment Policy: Limited Judicial Review and Time-Bound Vacation

Date: Aug 5, 2026

No Vested Right to Retain Government Quarters Against Redevelopment Policy: Limited Judicial Review and Time-Bound Vacation 1. Introduction Case: Ms Mary Megu v. The State of AP and 5 Ors (Gauhati...

Voluntary dissolution under Section 13 Societies Registration Act permits transfer of assets to a Section 25 (now Section 8) company; Government-consent proviso applies only on proof of Government contribution/interest; belated challenges barred by laches

Date: Aug 4, 2026

Voluntary Dissolution Under Section 13 SRA, 1860: Asset Transfer to a Section 25 (Now Section 8) Company Upheld; Government-Consent Proviso Requires Proof of State Contribution/Interest; Belated Writ...

Bar on Multiple FIRs for a Single Continuous Procession Across Jurisdictions (Section 188 IPC) and Double Jeopardy After Prior Conviction

Date: Aug 4, 2026

Bar on Multiple FIRs for a Single Continuous Procession Across Jurisdictions (Section 188 IPC) and Double Jeopardy After Prior Conviction Case: KULDEEP KUMAR v. STATE NCT OF DELHI (2026 DHC 6236)...

Demolition-Apprehension Petitions: Disposal on Statement and Mandatory Due-Process Notice Before Coercive Action

Date: Aug 4, 2026

Demolition-Apprehension Petitions: Disposal on Statement and Mandatory Due-Process Notice Before Coercive Action Case: SHAIKH HUSAIN AJIJ v. THE STATE OF GUJARAT Court: Gujarat High Court Date:...

Quashing under Section 528 BNSS in Section 138 NI Act Complaints: “Lost Cheque/Stop-Payment” Defence Must Go to Trial Once Prima Facie Ingredients and Section 139 Presumption Are Triggered

Date: Aug 4, 2026

Quashing under Section 528 BNSS in Section 138 NI Act Complaints: “Lost Cheque/Stop-Payment” Defence Must Go to Trial Once Prima Facie Ingredients and Section 139 Presumption Are Triggered 1....

Non-Recovery of Ticket Not Fatal: Burden-Shifting and Liberal Proof of “Untoward Incident” in Railway Death Claims

Date: Aug 2, 2026

Non-Recovery of Ticket Not Fatal: Burden-Shifting and Liberal Proof of “Untoward Incident” in Railway Death Claims Case: PHILIPS AND ANR v. UNION OF INDIA Court: Punjab & Haryana High Court Date:...

Uploading Interim Orders Is Mandatory and Independent of Process Fee; Uploading Is Not Service

Date: Aug 1, 2026

Uploading Interim Orders Is Mandatory and Independent of Process Fee; Uploading Is Not Service (Kerala High Court JPP No.5/2025) 1. Introduction This decision of the Kerala High Court (Soumen Sen,...

Sports Quota Recognition: “Taekwondo” in Notification Includes Poomsae Absent an Express Differentiation; Article 227 Review Remains Narrow

Date: Aug 1, 2026

Sports Quota Recognition: “Taekwondo” in Notification Includes Poomsae Absent an Express Differentiation; Article 227 Review Remains Narrow 1. Introduction Case: STATE OF KERALA v. Ranjith K (2026...

Propagation vs. Unlawful Conversion: Prima Facie “Undue Influence/Fraudulent Means” Bars Quashment Under Section 528 BNSS

Date: Aug 1, 2026

Propagation vs. Unlawful Conversion: Prima Facie “Undue Influence/Fraudulent Means” Bars Quashment Under Section 528 BNSS Case: NAMRATABEN GORDHANBHAI MACWAN v. STATE OF GUJARAT Court: Gujarat High...

Section 197 CrPC Sanction: When Nexus with Official Duty is Disputed, the Issue May Be Deferred Until After Evidence

Date: Aug 1, 2026

Section 197 CrPC Sanction: When Nexus with Official Duty is Disputed, the Issue May Be Deferred Until After Evidence Case: MIDHUN. M v. STATE OF KERALA (Kerala High Court, G. Girish J.) Citation:...

Court-Directed Consideration under the Proviso to Section 11 Is Not Barred by Limitation, and a Delegated Collector Cannot Challenge the Government’s Revisional Order

Date: Aug 1, 2026

Court-Directed Consideration under the Proviso to Section 11 Is Not Barred by Limitation, and a Delegated Collector Cannot Challenge the Government’s Revisional Order Case: Greater Visakhapatnam...

Circumstantial Conviction for Familial “Honor Killing”: Section 8 Evidence Act Conduct, Medical Refutation of Suicide, and Concealment of Bodies as a Complete Chain

Date: Jul 31, 2026

Circumstantial Conviction for Familial “Honor Killing”: Section 8 Evidence Act Conduct, Medical Refutation of Suicide, and Concealment of Bodies as a Complete Chain 1. Introduction Case: Ram Prasad...

Unproved Social-Media Video and “No Evidence” Findings in Departmental Enquiries: High Court’s Duty to Interfere in Judicial Review

Date: Jul 31, 2026

Unproved Social-Media Video and “No Evidence” Findings in Departmental Enquiries: High Court’s Duty to Interfere in Judicial Review Case: STATE OF CHHATTISGARH v. LAKHAN LAL JAISWAL (2026 CGHC...

Subordinate Courts Must First Decide Maintainability When Directed by the High Court: Judicial Discipline in Section 138 NI Act Proceedings

Date: Jul 31, 2026

Subordinate Courts Must First Decide Maintainability When Directed by the High Court: Judicial Discipline in Section 138 NI Act Proceedings 1. Introduction In RANJIT SAHOO @ RANJEET KUMAR SAHOO v....

Section 22 of the Senior Citizens Act Cannot Be Used to Evict Tenants: Tenancy Law Remedy and Jurisdictional Limits of the SDM

Date: Jul 31, 2026

Section 22 of the Senior Citizens Act Cannot Be Used to Evict Tenants: Tenancy Law Remedy and Jurisdictional Limits of the SDM 1. Introduction In ANNA SING @ ANAN SINGHA v. SASWATI MALLICK (Calcutta...

Inordinate Unexplained FIR Delay and Unproven Homicidal Death: Benefit of Doubt in Circumstantial Murder Prosecutions

Date: Jul 31, 2026

Inordinate Unexplained FIR Delay and Unproven Homicidal Death: Benefit of Doubt in Circumstantial Murder Prosecutions 1. Introduction In Triveni And Other v. State (Allahabad High Court, decided on...