state Case Commentaries

State v. Morrissey Jr.: “Evidence as a Whole” Supports Denial of Directed Verdict Where Victim’s “Same Spot” Testimony Permits Inferences of Sexual Contact and Knowing Mental State

Date: Jul 31, 2026

State v. Morrissey Jr.: “Evidence as a Whole” Supports Denial of Directed Verdict Where Victim’s “Same Spot” Testimony Permits Inferences of Sexual Contact and Knowing Mental State 1. Introduction In...

Orders of Protection Must Defer to Existing Parenting Plans While Permitting Only Logistics-Limited Contact

Date: Jul 31, 2026

Orders of Protection Must Defer to Existing Parenting Plans While Permitting Only Logistics-Limited Contact 1. Introduction Gemar v. Gemar (Mont. 2026 MT 173N) concerns whether a district court...

Platted Express Easements Cannot Be “Supplanted” by a Non‑Signatory Easement Agreement; Obstruction Remedies Must Be Precisely Tied to Proven Encroachments

Date: Jul 31, 2026

Platted Express Easements Cannot Be “Supplanted” by a Non‑Signatory Easement Agreement; Obstruction Remedies Must Be Precisely Tied to Proven Encroachments Introduction Vicevich v. Kultgen (2026 MT...

State v. Veltkamp — SANE Reports Are Not “Medical Diagnosis” Hearsay; Jury-Room Access Is Error but May Be Harmless When Cumulative

Date: Jul 31, 2026

State v. Veltkamp (2026 MT 169): SANE Reports Are Not “Medical Diagnosis” Hearsay; Jury-Room Access Is Error but May Be Harmless When Cumulative 1. Introduction In State v. Veltkamp, the Montana...

State Tortfeasor Cannot Use Interpleader to Impose the Tort Claims Act Cap; Constitutional Challenges to § 2-9-108, MCA, Are Unripe Absent a Filed Tort Action and Excess Damages Determination

Date: Jul 31, 2026

State Tortfeasor Cannot Use Interpleader to Impose the Tort Claims Act Cap; Constitutional Challenges to § 2-9-108, MCA, Are Unripe Absent a Filed Tort Action and Excess Damages Determination 1....

Montana Lawyer Discipline: Felony Drug Convictions Trigger Rule 8.4 Charges, While Interim Suspension Requires a Separate Rule 23(B) Showing

Date: Jul 31, 2026

Montana Lawyer Discipline: Felony Drug Convictions Trigger Rule 8.4 Charges, While Interim Suspension Requires a Separate Rule 23(B) Showing 1. Introduction Matter of Kenneth B. Cotter arises from...

Service of Notice of Appeal Is Nonjurisdictional; Late Expert Declarations Cannot Be Wholly Excluded When Substantially Justified/Harmless and Supporting Properly Disclosed Malpractice Opinions

Date: Jul 31, 2026

Service of Notice of Appeal Is Nonjurisdictional; Late Expert Declarations Cannot Be Wholly Excluded When Substantially Justified/Harmless and Supporting Properly Disclosed Malpractice Opinions...

Utah Adoption Act: Termination to Facilitate Adoption Requires a “Strictly Necessary” Best-Interest Analysis Grounded in Case-Specific Stability Needs

Date: Jul 31, 2026

Utah Adoption Act: Termination to Facilitate Adoption Requires a “Strictly Necessary” Best-Interest Analysis Grounded in Case-Specific Stability Needs Introduction In re Adoption of B.C., 2026 UT 23,...

Sua Sponte Discussion Does Not Preserve an Unraised Appellate Issue Unless It Serves Judicial Economy and Fairness

Date: Jul 31, 2026

Sua Sponte Discussion Does Not Preserve an Unraised Appellate Issue Unless It Serves Judicial Economy and Fairness Introduction In Abu-Ulba v. Ananda Scientific, Inc., 2026 UT 24, the Utah Supreme...

Rencher v. State of Mississippi Commentary

Date: Jul 30, 2026

Rencher v. State of Mississippi: Meta/AT&T Records Are Self-Authenticating Under MRE 902(11), and “Google Earth” Coordinate Plotting May Be Proven by Lay Testimony Introduction In Rencher v. State of...

Eacholes v. State of Mississippi: Verified Warrant Reliance and “Substantial Basis” Review of Probable Cause Despite No Preliminary Hearing Record

Date: Jul 30, 2026

Verified Warrant Reliance and “Substantial Basis” Review: Lack of a Preliminary-Hearing Record Does Not Undermine a Facially Valid Arrest Warrant 1. Introduction In Eacholes v. State of Mississippi...

Sanders v. State of Mississippi — Waiver of Late-Disclosed Expert/Discovery Claims Absent a Continuance Request; Timeline Uncertainty Does Not Defeat Child Sex-Offense Proof

Date: Jul 30, 2026

Waiver of Late-Disclosed Expert/Discovery Claims Without a Continuance Request; Timeline Uncertainty Does Not Defeat Child Sex-Offense Proof Case: Sanders v. State of Mississippi (No....

Certified MDH HIV Surveillance Records Are Nontestimonial; § 97-27-14(1) Requires No Proof of Viral Load or Transmission Likelihood

Date: Jul 30, 2026

Certified MDH HIV Surveillance Records Are Nontestimonial; § 97-27-14(1) Requires No Proof of Viral Load or Transmission Likelihood Case: Sims v. State of Mississippi, Supreme Court of Mississippi...

Strategic Open-Plea Advice Is Not Ineffective Assistance Absent Unreasonableness; Unpreserved Rule 43 Claims Are Not Reviewed

Date: Jul 29, 2026

Strategic Open-Plea Advice Is Not Ineffective Assistance Absent Unreasonableness; Unpreserved Rule 43 Claims Are Not Reviewed 1. Introduction In Paola v. State, 2026 ND 151, Tayven Lynn Paola sought...

Childers v. Childers (2026 ND 150): Stipulated Post-Hearing Income Submissions Permit Supplemental Evidence, but Income Imputation Requires a Purpose Finding and Effective-Date Explanation

Date: Jul 29, 2026

Stipulated Post-Hearing Income Submissions Permit Supplemental Evidence, but Income Imputation Requires a Purpose Finding and Effective-Date Explanation 1. Introduction Childers v. Childers, 2026 ND...

Res Judicata Does Not Bar Later “Offset” Claims After a Default Judgment; CPLR 205(a) May Save Refiled Former Counterclaims

Date: Jul 29, 2026

Res Judicata Does Not Bar Later “Offset” Claims After a Default Judgment; CPLR 205(a) May Save Refiled Former Counterclaims Case: Vince's Pizza Plus, Inc. v. Dion DeFedericis, 2026 NY Slip Op 04598...

RPTL 497(2) Makes NYSERDA Filing Non-Precondition to Effectiveness of RPTL 487 Solar-Exemption Opt-Out Laws (and Applies Retroactively)

Date: Jul 29, 2026

RPTL 497(2) Makes NYSERDA Filing Non-Precondition to Effectiveness of RPTL 487 Solar-Exemption Opt-Out Laws (and Applies Retroactively) 1. Introduction Matter of Solar Advocate Dev., LLC v Assessor...

Excess Insurers Cannot Demur Solely for Non-Exhaustion: Declaratory Relief and Bad-Faith Claims May Proceed Upon Adequate Allegations of Covered Loss and Likely Attachment

Date: Jul 29, 2026

Excess Insurers Cannot Demur Solely for Non-Exhaustion: Declaratory Relief and Bad-Faith Claims May Proceed Upon Adequate Allegations of Covered Loss and Likely Attachment Case: Fox Paine & Co, LLC...

DVSJA “Significant Contributing Factor” Requires Evidence Linking Abuse to the Criminal Act—Childhood Trauma Alone Is Insufficient

Date: Jul 29, 2026

DVSJA “Significant Contributing Factor” Requires Evidence Linking Abuse to the Criminal Act—Childhood Trauma Alone Is Insufficient 1. Introduction People v Sean S. (Appellate Division, Fourth...

State v. Keaton: An Unqualified “No Objection” Waives Confrontation and Right-to-Counsel Claims and Limits Supervisory Relief

Date: Jul 29, 2026

An Unqualified “No Objection” Waives Confrontation and Right-to-Counsel Claims and Limits Supervisory Relief 1. Introduction In State v. Keaton (Conn. July 28, 2026), the Supreme Court of Connecticut...