state Case Commentaries

Approved Ethics Rule: Third-Party Vendors May Pursue Nonparty Document Production Only Under Lawyer Supervision and Independent Professional Judgment

Date: Aug 12, 2026

Approved Ethics Rule: Third-Party Vendors May Pursue Nonparty Document Production Only Under Lawyer Supervision and Independent Professional Judgment 1. Introduction In In Re: Formal Advisory Opinion...

Recreational Property Act Immunity Depends on the Landowner’s General Invitation, Not the Plaintiff’s Moment-of-Injury Activity

Date: Aug 12, 2026

Recreational Property Act Immunity Depends on the Landowner’s General Invitation, Not the Plaintiff’s Moment-of-Injury Activity I. Introduction McLamb v. Mayor and Aldermen of the City of Savannah...

Goodell v. Moulton: Pavesich Balancing (Not Strict Scrutiny) Governs Georgia Constitutional Medical-Privacy Objections to Civil Discovery

Date: Aug 12, 2026

Goodell v. Moulton: Pavesich Balancing (Not Strict Scrutiny) Governs Georgia Constitutional Medical-Privacy Objections to Civil Discovery Court: Supreme Court of Georgia | Date: August 11, 2026 |...

Civil Jury Selection in Georgia: A Party’s Right to a 24-Person Panel of “Competent and Impartial” Jurors Is Violated (and Presumptively Harmed) When an Insurance-Defense Attorney for the Defendant’s Insurer Is Not Struck for Cause

Date: Aug 12, 2026

Civil Jury Selection in Georgia: A Party’s Right to a 24-Person Panel of “Competent and Impartial” Jurors Is Violated (and Presumptively Harmed) When an Insurance-Defense Attorney for the Defendant’s...

Civil Appeals in Georgia: A Pro Se Notice of Appeal Filed While Counsel Remains of Record Is a Nullity and Cannot Confer Appellate Jurisdiction

Date: Aug 12, 2026

Civil Appeals in Georgia: A Pro Se Notice of Appeal Filed While Counsel Remains of Record Is a Nullity and Cannot Confer Appellate Jurisdiction 1. Introduction Muhammad et al. v. Clayton County et...

App.R. 26(B) Reopening Requires a “Genuine Issue” of Ineffective Appellate Counsel; Court Will Not Revisit Aggregate-Consecutive-Sentence Proportionality After Polizzi

Date: Aug 12, 2026

App.R. 26(B) Reopening Requires a “Genuine Issue” of Ineffective Appellate Counsel; Court Will Not Revisit Aggregate-Consecutive-Sentence Proportionality After Polizzi 1. Introduction In 08/11/2026...

Mandamus Compels Lift of Stay for Insurer Duty-to-Defend Declaratory Judgment While Allowing Continued Stay on Indemnity Issues

Date: Aug 11, 2026

Mandamus Compels Lift of Stay for Insurer Duty-to-Defend Declaratory Judgment While Allowing Continued Stay on Indemnity Issues 1. Introduction In Ex parte Association of County Commissions of...

Withdrawn Consent Mid-Procedure: Mississippi Adopts the “Medical Feasibility” Expert-Testimony Requirement for Medical Battery

Date: Aug 11, 2026

Withdrawn Consent Mid-Procedure: Mississippi Adopts the “Medical Feasibility” Expert-Testimony Requirement for Medical Battery Case: Shani M. Brown v. Dr. Barbara Davey-Sullivan and The Woman's...

Waiver Rule in Medical Malpractice: Unobjected-to Standard-of-Care Testimony (Even If Not Tendered as Expert) Must Be Considered on Sufficiency Review

Date: Aug 11, 2026

Waiver Rule in Medical Malpractice: Unobjected-to Standard-of-Care Testimony (Even If Not Tendered as Expert) Must Be Considered on Sufficiency Review Case: Mary Margaret Upchurch and Rickie Upchurch...

Recklessness for Felony Evasion Under Miss. Code § 97-9-72(2): Dangerous Flight—Not Speed Alone—Supports Conviction

Date: Aug 10, 2026

Recklessness for Felony Evasion Under Miss. Code § 97-9-72(2): Dangerous Flight—Not Speed Alone—Supports Conviction 1. Introduction In Elizabeth Ann Bozard a/k/a Elizabeth A. Jones a/k/a Elizabeth...

Minutes-Rule Bar to Equitable Pay Claims for Unapproved School-District Coaching Stipends (and Interlocutory Review Under MRAP 5)

Date: Aug 10, 2026

Minutes-Rule Bar to Equitable Pay Claims for Unapproved School-District Coaching Stipends (and Interlocutory Review Under MRAP 5) Introduction In Coahoma County School District Board of Education,...

Patient Suspicion Starts MTCA Discovery-Rule Clock Without Second Opinion

Date: Aug 10, 2026

Patient Suspicion Starts MTCA Discovery-Rule Clock Without Second Opinion 1. Introduction In University of Mississippi Medical Center v. Corlexia Carter (Miss. Aug. 6, 2026), the Supreme Court of...

Cellebrite Cell-Phone Extractions as Non-Expert “Operator” Evidence: No Rule 702 Reliability Finding Required

Date: Aug 10, 2026

Cellebrite Cell-Phone Extractions as Non-Expert “Operator” Evidence: No Rule 702 Reliability Finding Required Joseph David Heard v. State of Mississippi (Miss. Aug. 6, 2026) — Capital murder...

Adverse-Possession Claimants Have Standing to Challenge Tax Sales; § 29-1-21 Is Not a Standing Bar

Date: Aug 10, 2026

Adverse-Possession Claimants Have Standing to Challenge Tax Sales; § 29-1-21 Is Not a Standing Bar Case: Jermille Johnson v. Elizabeth Cleveland, et al. Court: Supreme Court of Mississippi Date:...

State v. Bekkum: Post-Conviction Charging Challenges Apply the Motta/Wells Presumption—No “Fair Notice” Dismissal Absent Prejudice or Failure to Allege a Crime

Date: Aug 9, 2026

State v. Bekkum: Post-Conviction Charging Challenges Apply the Motta/Wells Presumption—No “Fair Notice” Dismissal Absent Prejudice or Failure to Allege a Crime I. Introduction State v. Bekkum (Haw....

HRS § 91-7 Authorizes Facial Declaratory Challenges to Tax Rules; HRS § 91-7(a) Is Venue (Not Jurisdiction), Overruling Befitel

Date: Aug 9, 2026

HRS § 91-7 Authorizes Facial Declaratory Challenges to Tax Rules; HRS § 91-7(a) Is Venue (Not Jurisdiction), Overruling Hawaii Home Infusion Associates v. Befitel I. Introduction In Booking.com B.V....

Schuemann v. Timperley (321 Neb. 955): Expert Proof of Proximate Cause Remains Essential in Informed-Consent Malpractice—Even When Breach Is Factually Disputed

Date: Aug 9, 2026

Schuemann v. Timperley (321 Neb. 955): Expert Proof of Proximate Cause Remains Essential in Informed-Consent Malpractice—Even When Breach Is Factually Disputed I. Introduction Case: Schuemann v....

Ohio Mandamus: Municipal Fiscal Officers Must Certify Referendum Petitions Unless an Emergency Clause States Specific Reasons—and They Cannot Decide “Administrative vs. Legislative”

Date: Aug 9, 2026

Ohio Mandamus: Municipal Fiscal Officers Must Certify Referendum Petitions Unless an Emergency Clause States Specific Reasons—and They Cannot Decide “Administrative vs. Legislative” I. Introduction...

Roth v. Marcoe (321 Neb. 983): Implied “More Appropriate Forum” Determination Under § 42-364(5) and the Limits of Incarceration/Contact Barriers as “Just Cause” Against Abandonment

Date: Aug 9, 2026

Roth v. Marcoe (321 Neb. 983): Implied “More Appropriate Forum” Determination Under § 42-364(5) and the Limits of Incarceration/Contact Barriers as “Just Cause” Against Abandonment I. Introduction...

“Warrant and Defend” Is Not a Standalone Duty: No Attorney-Fee Reimbursement Absent Eviction Under Paramount Title

Date: Aug 8, 2026

“Warrant and Defend” Is Not a Standalone Duty: No Attorney-Fee Reimbursement Absent Eviction Under Paramount Title Case: Morris v. Dall, 321 Neb. 972 (Neb. Aug. 7, 2026) Court: Supreme Court of...