state Case Commentaries

State v. Sliger: “Foreign Substances” in Breath Testing Means Substances Capable of Affecting Reliability; Expert Testimony May Be Required in Debatable Cases

Date: Aug 14, 2026

State v. Sliger: “Foreign Substances” in Breath Testing Means Substances Capable of Affecting Reliability; Expert Testimony May Be Required in Debatable Cases 1. Introduction Case: State v. Sliger,...

People v. Hernandez — § 1473.7 “Error” Turns on Subjective Understanding Under the Totality of Circumstances; § 1016.5 Advisements Are Relevant but Not Dispositive

Date: Aug 14, 2026

§ 1473.7(a)(1) Relief: “Error” Is Measured by the Defendant’s Subjective Understanding Under the Totality of Circumstances—A § 1016.5 Advisement (Even Signed and Initialed) Is Not Dispositive Case:...

Mansfield v. State: No Sua Sponte Rule 403 “Pruning” of Graphic Evidence Absent Objection Under Plain-Error Review

Date: Aug 14, 2026

Mansfield v. State: No Sua Sponte Rule 403 “Pruning” of Graphic Evidence Absent Objection Under Plain-Error Review Introduction Case: Mansfield v. State, Supreme Court of Georgia (Aug. 13, 2026)....

Social Media Posts and 911 CAD Logs as “Original Documentary Evidence” (Continuing Witness Rule); Gang-Nexus Mischarge Requires Prejudice on Plain-Error Review

Date: Aug 14, 2026

Social Media Posts and 911 CAD Logs as “Original Documentary Evidence” (Continuing Witness Rule); Gang-Nexus Mischarge Requires Prejudice on Plain-Error Review 1. Introduction In CLIFTON v. THE STATE...

People v. Shove: Hybrid Batson/Wheeler Review Permits Stage-One Analysis for an Unexplained Strike While Applying Stage-Three Review to Other Explained Strikes

Date: Aug 14, 2026

People v. Shove: Hybrid Batson/Wheeler Review Permits Stage-One Analysis for an Unexplained Strike While Applying Stage-Three Review to Other Explained Strikes 1. Introduction People v. Shove (Cal....

Plain-Error Limits on “Stand Your Ground” and Reconstituted-Jury Instructions After Alternate Substitution

Date: Aug 14, 2026

Plain-Error Limits on “Stand Your Ground” and Reconstituted-Jury Instructions After Alternate Substitution Case: Sanders v. State (Supreme Court of Georgia, Aug. 13, 2026) Core takeaway: Absent...

Wisconsin Supreme Court Signals Willingness to Fast-Track Petitions for Review in Election Cases Through Accelerated Response and Amicus Deadlines

Date: Aug 14, 2026

Wisconsin Supreme Court Signals Willingness to Fast-Track Petitions for Review in Election Cases Through Accelerated Response and Amicus Deadlines 1. Introduction Case: Democratic National Committee...

Regressive, Apportioned Financial-Institutions Tax Survives Dormant Commerce Clause Internal-Consistency Review

Date: Aug 14, 2026

Regressive, Apportioned Financial-Institutions Tax Survives Dormant Commerce Clause Internal-Consistency Review Case: Dollar Bank, FSB v. Harris, Slip Opinion No. 2026-Ohio-3069 (Ohio Aug. 13, 2026)...

Coleman v. State — Prospective End to Automatic Supreme Court Review of Non-Death-Penalty Murder Appeals (Docketed After July 1, 2027)

Date: Aug 14, 2026

Prospective End to Automatic Supreme Court Review of Non-Death-Penalty Murder Appeals (Docketed After July 1, 2027) 1. Introduction Case: Coleman v. State, Supreme Court of Georgia (Decided August...

Minor v. State: Rule 701 Familiarity-Based Video Identifications and Harmless-Error Review of Unconstitutional (But Hidden) Shackling

Date: Aug 14, 2026

Minor v. State: Rule 701 Familiarity-Based Video Identifications and Harmless-Error Review of Unconstitutional (But Hidden) Shackling 1. Introduction In Minor v. State (Supreme Court of Georgia, Aug....

Lenon v. State — Commentary

Date: Aug 14, 2026

No Ineffective Assistance for Failing to Challenge “Complete Forensic Extraction” Cell-Phone Warrants Absent Binding Overbreadth Precedent 1. Introduction In Lenon v. State (Supreme Court of Georgia,...

Bentley v. State: Unpreserved Faretta-Error Claims and No Ineffective Assistance for Failing to Object to “Irrevocable” Self-Representation Warnings

Date: Aug 14, 2026

Bentley v. State: Unpreserved Faretta-Error Claims and No Ineffective Assistance for Failing to Object to “Irrevocable” Self-Representation Warnings Introduction In Bentley v. State (Supreme Court of...

Allen v. State (Ga. 2026): Prepared Co-Counsel May Complete Trial Without Violating the Sixth Amendment; Drug-Use Motive Evidence Admissible Under the Old Evidence Code

Date: Aug 14, 2026

Prepared Co-Counsel May Complete Trial Without Violating the Sixth Amendment; Drug-Use Motive Evidence Admissible Under the Old Evidence Code Introduction In Allen v. State (Supreme Court of Georgia,...

Browne v. State — “Prima Facie Case” Language in Jury Charges Is Clear Error but Assessed for Harm Under Whole-Charge Review

Date: Aug 14, 2026

“Prima Facie Case” Language in Jury Charges Is Clear Error but Assessed for Harm Under Whole-Charge Review 1. Introduction Browne v. State (Supreme Court of Georgia, Aug. 13, 2026) affirmed Theodore...

Appellate-Delay Due Process in Georgia: “Actual Prejudice” Required; Loss of Trial File Alone Is Insufficient

Date: Aug 14, 2026

Appellate-Delay Due Process in Georgia: “Actual Prejudice” Required; Loss of Trial File Alone Is Insufficient Case: Kelly v. State (Supreme Court of Georgia, Aug. 13, 2026) Posture: Appeal from...

No Strickland Prejudice from Omitted Justification Charge When Evidence of Intentional Killing Is Overwhelming

Date: Aug 14, 2026

No Strickland Prejudice from Omitted Justification Charge When Evidence of Intentional Killing Is Overwhelming 1. Introduction In Lafargue v. State (Supreme Court of Georgia, Aug. 13, 2026), Ricky...

NRS 52.325 Is Not the Exclusive Method to Authenticate Medical Records Produced in Discovery; Incompleteness Goes to Weight, and Medical Liens Are Admissible to Show Bias

Date: Aug 14, 2026

NRS 52.325 Is Not the Exclusive Method to Authenticate Medical Records Produced in Discovery; Incompleteness Goes to Weight, and Medical Liens Are Admissible to Show Bias 1. Introduction Case:...

Parker v. The Borsello Companies, Inc.: Deferential “Substantial Evidence” Review, Flexible Evidence Rules Before the IAB, and Strict Issue Preservation on Appeal

Date: Aug 13, 2026

Parker v. The Borsello Companies, Inc.: Deferential “Substantial Evidence” Review, Flexible Evidence Rules Before the IAB, and Strict Issue Preservation on Appeal 1. Introduction Prince Parker...

Tapia Limits Do Not Govern Delaware VOP Sentencing; VOP Admissions Waive Contested Hearing

Date: Aug 13, 2026

Tapia Limits Do Not Govern Delaware VOP Sentencing; VOP Admissions Waive Contested Hearing 1. Introduction In Banks v. State (Del. Supr. Aug. 10, 2026), the Delaware Supreme Court affirmed a Superior...

Turner v. Commissioner of Correction: Ineffective Assistance for Failing to Challenge Misleading CSLI “GeoTime” Visualizations Under § 4-3

Date: Aug 13, 2026

Turner v. Commissioner of Correction: Ineffective Assistance for Failing to Challenge Misleading CSLI “GeoTime” Visualizations Under § 4-3 1. Introduction In Turner v. Commissioner of Correction...