state Case Commentaries

Limited Rehearing Review in Montana: Reframed Probate and Malpractice Arguments Do Not Justify Reconsideration

Date: Oct 22, 2026

Limited Rehearing Review in Montana: Reframed Probate and Malpractice Arguments Do Not Justify Reconsideration Case: Engellant v. Crowley Fleck Court: Supreme Court of Montana Case number: DA 24-0485...

Substantial Mitigation Does Not Preclude Disbarment for Client-Fund Misappropriation

Date: Oct 22, 2026

Substantial Mitigation Does Not Preclude Disbarment for Client-Fund Misappropriation Case: In the Matter of Jason F. Taylor Court: Supreme Court of South Carolina Opinion: No. 28353, filed October...

Exclusive Child-Protection Jurisdiction and Discretionary Intervention to Review Relative-Placement Compliance

Date: Oct 21, 2026

Exclusive Child-Protection Jurisdiction and Discretionary Intervention to Review Relative-Placement Compliance Case: Ellman v. Charron Court: Supreme Court of Idaho Opinion filed: October 20, 2026...

Never-Registered Contractors Cannot Use Unjust Enrichment to Recover from Idaho Homeowners

Date: Oct 21, 2026

Never-Registered Contractors Cannot Use Unjust Enrichment to Recover from Idaho Homeowners Case: Samuel Lee Services LLC v. Heather Bangeman Court: Supreme Court of Idaho Opinion filed: October 20,...

State v. Pierre: Rebutting a Recanting Witness’s Denial and Crediting Court-Ordered Residential Treatment

Date: Oct 21, 2026

State v. Pierre: Rebutting a Recanting Witness’s Denial and Crediting Court-Ordered Residential Treatment Supreme Court of Montana | 2026 MT 250 | October 20, 2026 1. Introduction In State v. Pierre,...

Alabama Rule 56 Requires Notice and a Meaningful Opportunity to Respond Before Summary Judgment

Date: Oct 21, 2026

Alabama Rule 56 Requires Notice and a Meaningful Opportunity to Respond Before Summary Judgment Case: McConico v. Haynes, No. SC-2026-0410 Court: Supreme Court of Alabama Decision date: October 16,...

Late Summary-Judgment Responses Are Not Automatically Revived by a Later Hearing, and Rule 54(b) Certification Does Not Dismiss Pending Claims

Date: Oct 21, 2026

Late Summary-Judgment Responses Are Not Automatically Revived by a Later Hearing, and Rule 54(b) Certification Does Not Dismiss Pending Claims Case: Commercial Properties, Inc. v. Charalambidou...

Phillips v. Ivey: Declaratory Relief Cannot Replace Certiorari Review of Parole and Prison-Administration Decisions

Date: Oct 21, 2026

Phillips v. Ivey: Declaratory Relief Cannot Replace Certiorari Review of Parole and Prison-Administration Decisions Court: Supreme Court of Alabama Date: October 16, 2026 Case number: SC-2026-0100...

Venue Challenges Require Prompt Resolution Before Merits Discovery, Even Without a Trial Deadline

Date: Oct 21, 2026

Venue Challenges Require Prompt Resolution Before Merits Discovery, Even Without a Trial Deadline Case: Ex parte UOP, LLC; Honeywell International, Inc.; and Mark Smith Underlying action: Southern...

Police Officers’ Defense-of-Persons Immunity Must Be Assessed Under § 13A-3-23

Date: Oct 21, 2026

Police Officers’ Defense-of-Persons Immunity Must Be Assessed Under § 13A-3-23 Case: Ex parte Mac Bailey Marquette, in re: State of Alabama v. Mac Bailey Marquette Court: Supreme Court of Alabama...

Routine Police Patrol Qualifies for State-Agent Immunity Under Alabama’s Pre-2025 Framework

Date: Oct 21, 2026

Routine Police Patrol Qualifies for State-Agent Immunity Under Alabama’s Pre-2025 Framework Case: Ex parte Alonzo Cornelius Coleman IV and The City of Birmingham, arising from Angel Morales Cuin’s...

Retaliatory Discharge: Disputed Decisionmaking and Evidence of Fabricated Grounds Can Defeat Judgment as a Matter of Law

Date: Oct 21, 2026

Retaliatory Discharge: Disputed Decisionmaking and Evidence of Fabricated Grounds Can Defeat Judgment as a Matter of Law Case: Envoy Air, Inc. v. Jada Creagh, SC-2025-0022 Court: Supreme Court of...

Unexplained Invoice Dates Do Not Satisfy Mississippi’s Construction-Lien Date Requirement

Date: Oct 21, 2026

Unexplained Invoice Dates Do Not Satisfy Mississippi’s Construction-Lien Date Requirement Case: Cuevas Machine Company, Inc. v. Calgon Carbon Corporation Court: Supreme Court of Mississippi Decided:...

Conservatorships Survive Adulthood Without a Termination Order, but Participation Can Waive Defective Service

Date: Oct 21, 2026

Conservatorships Survive Adulthood Without a Termination Order, but Participation Can Waive Defective Service Case: E.K.W. v. Prentiss County Department of Child Protection Services Court: Supreme...

No Manifest Injustice Where a Later Continuance Allows a Second Mental-Health Evaluation

Date: Oct 21, 2026

No Manifest Injustice Where a Later Continuance Allows a Second Mental-Health Evaluation Commentary on Howard v. State of Mississippi Supreme Court of Mississippi · No. 2025-KA-01355-SCT · October...

Missing Written Jury Instructions Do Not Alone Require Reversal When a Supplemented Record Establishes Complete Instructions

Date: Oct 21, 2026

Missing Written Jury Instructions Do Not Alone Require Reversal When a Supplemented Record Establishes Complete Instructions Case: Carr v. State of Mississippi Court: Supreme Court of Mississippi...

Premises-Safety Experts Must Demonstrate Field-Specific Expertise and Reliable Methods

Date: Oct 21, 2026

Premises-Safety Experts Must Demonstrate Field-Specific Expertise and Reliable Methods Case: Park Wind Apartments, LLC v. Mayze Court: Supreme Court of Mississippi, en banc Decision: October 15, 2026...

Expressly Protected Third-Party Beneficiaries May Enforce Arbitration Without Signing the Agreement

Date: Oct 21, 2026

Expressly Protected Third-Party Beneficiaries May Enforce Arbitration Without Signing the Agreement Case: UATP Management, LLC; UATP IP, LLC; UA Attractions, LLC; Rachelle Nurse-Goodly; and Joseph...

Physicians and Physician Assistants Practice in Substantially Similar Fields Under Iowa’s Medical-Expert Qualification Statute

Date: Oct 19, 2026

Physicians and Physician Assistants Practice in Substantially Similar Fields Under Iowa’s Medical-Expert Qualification Statute Case: Joshua Davenport v. Nathanael K. Fuller Court: Supreme Court of...

Specific Attorney-Discipline Confidentiality Rules Prevail over Iowa’s General Open Records Requirements

Date: Oct 19, 2026

Specific Attorney-Discipline Confidentiality Rules Prevail over Iowa’s General Open Records Requirements Case: Robert Teig v. Iowa Judicial Branch, Molly Weber, Robert Gast, Nicholas Critelli, Iowa...