Mandamus May Compel a PEIA Hearing Without Triggering Sovereign Immunity
Case: Air Evac EMS, Inc. v. Brent Wolfinbarger and Members of the Public Employees Insurance Agency Finance Board
Court: Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia
Decision: November 10, 2026
Case number: 24-452
Disposition: Writ of mandamus granted; Intermediate Court of Appeals decision reversed; remanded with instructions.
1. Introduction
This decision distinguishes a demand that the State pay money from a demand that state officials provide an administrative hearing. Although Air Evac EMS, Inc. sought more than $4 million in additional reimbursement for air ambulance transports, the Supreme Court of Appeals identified the immediate legal wrong as the Public Employees Insurance Agency’s refusal to provide a hearing under its existing rules.
The Court treated Air Evac’s purported administrative appeal as a petition for mandamus. Because the relief granted required only a hearing—not payment from the State treasury—sovereign immunity did not bar the proceeding. The Court also held that PEIA’s contested-case hearing rules remained effective despite statutory provisions exempting certain agency activities from the Administrative Procedures Act.
The decision therefore secures a procedural opportunity, not a monetary recovery. It does not determine how much PEIA owes Air Evac or establish that federal preemption entitles an air ambulance provider to payment of its full billed charges.
2. Background and Procedural History
The reimbursement dispute
Air Evac is a federally regulated air ambulance carrier. West Virginia law requires it to provide service without regard to a patient’s insurance status. PEIA administers health insurance coverage for eligible public employees and establishes rules governing its plans.
Before 2011, PEIA reimbursed Air Evac’s billed charges. Beginning in 2011, PEIA imposed fee schedules capping reimbursement at the Medicare Rural Rate. In 2016, the Legislature adopted legislation limiting air ambulance charges to the federal Medicare rate and prohibiting providers from collecting the unpaid balance directly from PEIA insureds.
Air Evac successfully challenged those restrictions in federal court under the Airline Deregulation Act of 1978. The federal district court held that the mandatory fee schedules and balance-billing prohibition were preempted, and the Fourth Circuit affirmed.
In 2019, the Legislature retained the Medicare Rural Rate payment requirement but removed the balance-billing prohibition. The present dispute concerns 115 transports provided between June 9, 2016, when Air Evac filed its federal action, and June 4, 2019, when the removal of the balance-billing prohibition became effective.
- Total charges: $4,773,034.
- Payment: PEIA reimbursed the transports at the Medicare Rural Rate.
- Claimed unpaid balance: $4,018,046.
These figures describe Air Evac’s claim; the Supreme Court did not adjudicate the amount legally owed.
The denied hearing
On October 24, 2019, Air Evac demanded a contested-case hearing under West Virginia Code of State Rules §§ 151-3-1 through -14. PEIA responded twenty days later that the hearing rules did not apply because subsequently enacted statutes exempted relevant reimbursement decisions from the Administrative Procedures Act. PEIA suggested that Air Evac could pursue available remedies in the Circuit Court of Kanawha County or file a claim with the Legislative Claims Commission.
Air Evac filed a “Petition for Appeal” in circuit court, challenging both the denial of a hearing and PEIA’s refusal to pay the disputed charges.
The lower courts’ decisions
The circuit court rejected PEIA’s sovereign-immunity defense and concluded that the agency’s hearing rules remained binding. It remanded for administrative proceedings. Nevertheless, it also addressed the reimbursement merits, concluding that Air Evac was not entitled to full payment and directing the parties to negotiate the amount owed.
Both parties appealed. The Intermediate Court of Appeals held that sovereign immunity barred the action and directed dismissal with prejudice. It did not decide whether the proceeding was properly reviewable as a contested case under the Administrative Procedures Act. Chief Judge Scarr dissented, emphasizing due process and the possibility of treating the action as mandamus.
3. Summary of the Supreme Court’s Decision
The Supreme Court unanimously reversed and granted narrowly defined relief:
- The proceeding was substantively mandamus, not an administrative appeal. Air Evac sought a hearing that PEIA had refused to provide. Under the authorities applied by the Court, there was not yet a contested case from which to take the asserted administrative appeal.
- Sovereign immunity did not bar an order requiring a hearing. The writ compelled prospective performance of an official duty and did not direct payment from state funds.
- PEIA’s existing hearing rules remained effective. West Virginia Code § 5-16-24 preserves the agency’s rules until amended or replaced. The relevant hearing rules had not been amended or replaced.
- PEIA had not invoked either permitted ground for refusing the hearing. Its rules allow refusal when a hearing would exceed lawful authority or serve no useful purpose. PEIA instead maintained that the rules were inapplicable.
The Court directed the circuit court to enter an order compelling PEIA to hold a contested-case hearing under its rules. It issued a memorandum decision under Rule 21(d), stating that the appeal presented no substantial question of law. The ruling is accordingly best understood as an application of established principles to this procedural setting, rather than a wholesale reconstruction of sovereign-immunity or administrative-review doctrine.
4. Precedents Cited and Their Influence
Federal preemption background
Air Evac EMS, Inc. v. Cheatham, No. 2:16-cv-5224, 2017 WL 4765966 (S.D. W. Va. October 20, 2017)
The federal district court held that the challenged mandatory fee schedules and balance-billing prohibition had the force and effect of law and were preempted by the Airline Deregulation Act. Its decision explains why Air Evac contested reimbursement during the relevant period. The opinion also cites this case for the state-law requirement that Air Evac serve patients regardless of insurance status.
Its role here is contextual: invalidation of the challenged state restrictions did not itself resolve the separate question of PEIA’s payment obligation for each transport.
Air Evac EMS, Inc. v. Cheatham, 910 F.3d 751 (4th Cir. 2018)
The Fourth Circuit affirmed the federal district court’s preemption decision. That affirmance established the federal litigation’s outcome, but the Supreme Court did not treat it as establishing an entitlement to the full amount Air Evac billed. The present ruling concerns the process for addressing that remaining dispute.
The decision under review and standard of review
Cunningham v. Air Evac, 250 W. Va. 200, 902 S.E.2d 532 (Ct. App. 2024)
This was the Intermediate Court of Appeals decision being reviewed, not an authority the Supreme Court followed. Its majority treated Air Evac’s action as barred by sovereign immunity because of the monetary relief sought. The Supreme Court rejected that characterization by focusing on PEIA’s refusal to provide a hearing and the limited relief necessary to correct it.
Chief Judge Scarr’s dissent anticipated the mandamus approach. Although the Supreme Court noted his due-process concerns, its holding rested on procedural characterization, the mandamus exception to sovereign immunity, and PEIA’s binding rules—not an independently developed constitutional due-process holding.
Chrystal R.M. v. Charlie A.L., 194 W. Va. 138, 459 S.E.2d 415 (1995)
Syllabus point 1 supplies de novo review for questions of law and statutory interpretation. This standard allowed the Supreme Court to independently determine the nature of Air Evac’s proceeding, the application of sovereign immunity, and the continuing effect of PEIA’s rules, without deferring to the lower courts’ legal conclusions.
Recharacterizing an administrative appeal as mandamus
Williams v. W. Va. Div. of Motor Vehicles, 226 W. Va. 562, 703 S.E.2d 533 (2010)
Williams established that the label attached to a filing does not determine whether it is an administrative appeal or a request for extraordinary relief. In that case, a challenge to agency action taken without a hearing was substantively a request for extraordinary relief rather than an appeal from a contested case.
The Supreme Court applied the same distinction to Air Evac. Its petition challenged the agency’s refusal to supply the hearing needed to create the administrative proceeding. Calling the filing an appeal could not create a contested case that had not occurred.
State ex rel. Frazier v. McGraw, 243 W. Va. 721, 850 S.E.2d 720 (2020)
Frazier reinforced this approach: where there had been no hearing on the merits and thus no contested case, the circuit court lacked jurisdiction to entertain the matter as the asserted administrative appeal. The proceeding was instead effectively a mandamus petition.
Together, Williams and Frazier supplied the direct basis for converting Air Evac’s filing. The conversion was decisive because it identified a judicial remedy that could compel the missing administrative process without ordering monetary relief.
Sovereign immunity and relief against public officials
Gribben v. Kirk, 195 W. Va. 488, 466 S.E.2d 147 (1995)
Gribben recognizes that the apparently absolute language of Article VI, section 35 of the West Virginia Constitution does not foreclose every action affecting state government or even potentially affecting state finances. The Supreme Court relied on this principle to reject a categorical approach based solely on PEIA’s status as a state agency.
W. Va. Univ. v. Graf, 205 W. Va. 118, 516 S.E.2d 741 (1998)
Graf identifies mandamus compelling state officers to perform their lawful duties as an exception to sovereign immunity. It provided the specific doctrinal route for requiring PEIA officials to comply with their hearing obligations. The obligation enforced was to conduct the proceeding, not to decide it in Air Evac’s favor.
W. Va. Lottery v. A-1 Amusement, Inc., 240 W. Va. 89, 807 S.E.2d 760 (2017)
This case supplied the proposition that sovereign immunity is not triggered when the remedy sought does not require expenditure of state funds. Applied here, the judicial command required a contested-case hearing rather than payment of reimbursement arrears.
The distinction concerns the decree actually issued. The possibility that an administrative proceeding might later have financial consequences did not transform this hearing order into a judgment directing payment from the treasury.
The nature of the claim and requirements for mandamus
Mullins v. Green, 145 W. Va. 469, 115 S.E.2d 320 (1960)
Mullins explains that relief must be supported by the pleaded facts and the nature of the case; a prayer for relief cannot independently justify a decree. The Supreme Court used this principle to explain why Air Evac’s request for money did not settle the characterization of the proceeding.
The lower courts first needed to identify the actionable conduct and the corresponding jurisdictional basis. Here, the denied hearing supported procedural relief even though Air Evac had also requested substantive payment relief.
State ex rel. Kucera v. City of Wheeling, 153 W. Va. 538, 170 S.E.2d 367 (1969)
Syllabus point 2 states the three requirements for mandamus: a clear legal right in the petitioner, a corresponding legal duty in the respondent, and no other adequate remedy. The Court cited this test when granting the writ.
Air Evac’s right and PEIA’s duty arose from the still-effective hearing rules. The unavailable contested-case appeal explained the need for extraordinary relief. Although the opinion does not separately analyze every proposed alternative remedy, its grant of mandamus necessarily reflects its conclusion that the required elements were satisfied.
5. Legal Reasoning
A. Substance controlled over the pleading’s label
The Court began with the event that precipitated litigation: PEIA’s denial of a hearing. The circuit court had treated the filing as an administrative appeal while simultaneously ordering the agency to undertake the administrative proceedings that had not yet occurred.
That sequence revealed the jurisdictional problem. In the circumstances presented, the court was not reviewing an already developed contested case; it was being asked to require the agency to create the missing process. Mandamus supplied the appropriate procedural vehicle.
This does not mean that every agency decision made without a hearing automatically becomes a mandamus action. The Court applied precedents concerning the particular asserted appeal and the substance of the relief requested.
B. A hearing order is distinct from a treasury-payment order
Article VI, section 35 provides that the State “shall never be made defendant in any court of law or equity.” Nevertheless, existing doctrine permits mandamus to compel officials to perform lawful duties.
PEIA argued that the exception should not apply because Air Evac’s ultimate objective was retroactive monetary recovery. The Court separated that objective from the immediate judicial remedy. The writ required only a hearing: prospective, ministerial compliance with an existing procedural duty.
The ministerial character of that duty is important. The Court compelled PEIA to hold a proceeding; it did not characterize the agency’s eventual reimbursement determination as ministerial or dictate its outcome. Nor did it establish that a later request for payment would necessarily escape sovereign immunity.
C. Statutory exemptions did not extinguish PEIA’s hearing rules
PEIA relied on later statutes concerning reasonable and customary expenses, healthcare cost-management tools, payment negotiations, and the amounts its plans would pay for covered services. It argued that exemptions associated with these activities rendered its contested-case rules inapplicable.
The Court rejected that inference because West Virginia Code § 5-16-24 expressly provides that PEIA rules remain in force until amended or replaced. The contested-case rules had not undergone either change.
The decision thus distinguishes exemption from particular APA requirements from elimination of an agency’s existing procedural rules. It does not hold that PEIA is subject to the APA in every respect, or that an administrative rule can override a conflicting statute. Rather, the statutory provisions invoked here did not displace the hearing mechanism that remained formally effective.
D. The permitted grounds for refusal mattered
Under West Virginia Code of State Rules § 151-3-4.2, PEIA may refuse a demanded hearing if it would:
- involve authority exceeding that available under law; or
- serve no useful purpose.
PEIA responded within the rule’s twenty-day period but invoked neither ground. Its position was instead that the rules did not apply. Once the Court rejected that premise, PEIA’s stated refusal lacked support under the operative rules.
The Court noted the agency’s compliance with the response deadline while denying the rules’ applicability. That observation reinforced the factual context; the holding did not depend on treating timely correspondence as an independent waiver or estoppel.
E. The plan-review argument did not defeat relief
PEIA also argued below that Air Evac should have used a multistep benefits-review process in its Plan document, a process that did not provide a hearing. The Supreme Court noted that PEIA had not given that reason when denying Air Evac’s demand.
The circuit court had found the argument waived and the Plan process inapplicable. The Supreme Court reported those conclusions but did not develop a general rule governing every conflict between PEIA’s Plan procedures and its hearing rules. Its operative holding remained that Air Evac was entitled to the requested hearing under the rules applicable here.
6. Potential Impact and Limits
Access to administrative process
The decision prevents an agency’s refusal to provide a required hearing from becoming an insurmountable procedural barrier. When the absence of a contested case defeats the asserted administrative appeal, mandamus may provide a route to compel the missing proceeding.
Accountability under existing rules
Agencies cannot simply assume that statutory exemptions from aspects of administrative procedure erase their own surviving rules. Where legislation preserves those rules until amendment or replacement, officials must account for their continuing force. Regulated parties may therefore have enforceable procedural rights even when an agency retains substantial discretion over the underlying substantive decision.
Careful separation of remedies
The ruling encourages courts and litigants to distinguish procedural enforcement from monetary recovery. A filing containing both requests should not necessarily be treated as an indivisible damages action. Equally, describing a payment demand as mandamus will not automatically overcome immunity: the nature of the duty and the relief actually ordered remain decisive.
Questions left unresolved
- Whether Air Evac is entitled to additional reimbursement.
- How any legally payable amount should be calculated.
- Whether full billed charges are recoverable.
- What defenses or immunity questions might arise from a later demand for monetary relief.
- The broader validity or effect of the 2019 reimbursement framework.
The Court also did not adopt a freestanding constitutional rule requiring hearings in all provider-payment disputes. The hearing entitlement here rested on PEIA’s own effective rules.
7. Complex Concepts Simplified
- Contested-case hearing
- A formal agency proceeding for resolving a dispute affecting legal rights or duties. Here, it supplies the administrative process Air Evac requested before seeking substantive review.
- Mandamus
- An extraordinary court order requiring a public official to perform a legally required duty. It can compel the hearing without directing who must win.
- Ministerial duty
- A required act rather than a discretionary choice. Providing the hearing was the duty enforced; deciding the reimbursement dispute was a separate matter.
- Sovereign immunity
- The State’s constitutional protection against suit, subject to recognized doctrinal exceptions, including appropriate mandamus proceedings against officials.
- Prospective procedural relief
- An order directing future compliance with a procedural obligation. A hearing held now can concern old bills without itself becoming an award of those bills.
- Federal preemption
- The displacement of state law by controlling federal law. Invalidating a state price restriction does not necessarily establish the amount a particular insurer must pay.
- Balance-billing
- Seeking the difference between a provider’s charge and the insurer’s payment directly from the patient.
- De novo review
- Independent appellate consideration of a legal question, without deference to the lower court’s legal conclusion.
8. Conclusion
The central principle is narrow but consequential: sovereign immunity does not bar mandamus compelling PEIA officials to provide a hearing required by still-effective rules when the decree orders no payment from the State treasury.
By looking beyond the pleading’s label and monetary demand, the Court restored the administrative process without deciding the reimbursement merits. The decision reinforces both agency compliance with binding procedural rules and the distinction between obtaining a lawful hearing and establishing a right to public funds.