federal Case Commentaries

Sixth Circuit Adopts Probable-Cause Standard for the “Serious Reasons for Believing” Serious-Nonpolitical-Crime Bar

Date: Aug 8, 2026

Sixth Circuit Adopts Probable-Cause Standard for the “Serious Reasons for Believing” Serious-Nonpolitical-Crime Bar I. Introduction In Leandro Spindola v. Todd Blanche (6th Cir. Aug. 7, 2026), the...

Patient “Cost-Support” Fax Can Be a TCPA Advertisement Even with Informational Content: S.A.S.B. CORP v. Johnson & Johnson Health Care Systems Inc.

Date: Aug 8, 2026

Patient “Cost-Support” Fax Can Be a TCPA Advertisement Even with Informational Content 1. Introduction In S.A.S.B. CORP v. Johnson & Johnson Health Care Systems Inc. (3d Cir. Aug. 7, 2026), S.A.S.B....

Guidelines Robbery After the 2023 Amendment: No Implied Mens Rea; California Penal Code § 211 Categorically Qualifies

Date: Aug 8, 2026

Guidelines Robbery After the 2023 Amendment: No Implied Mens Rea; California Penal Code § 211 Categorically Qualifies Case: United States v. Williams (5th Cir. Aug. 7, 2026) | Court: U.S. Court of...

Qualified Immunity and Fourth Amendment Reasonableness: Probable Cause, Inventory Searches, and Obstruction Arrests Despite Policy Imperfections

Date: Aug 8, 2026

Qualified Immunity and Fourth Amendment Reasonableness: Probable Cause, Inventory Searches, and Obstruction Arrests Despite Policy Imperfections 1. Introduction Cody Henderson v. Village of New...

Unconditional Prevailing-Party Fee Shifting Under TBCC § 28.08(c) in Credit-Reporting Suits (No FCRA Preemption) and Forfeiture Limits on Fee Challenges

Date: Aug 8, 2026

Unconditional Prevailing-Party Fee Shifting Under TBCC § 28.08(c) in Credit-Reporting Suits (No FCRA Preemption) and Forfeiture Limits on Fee Challenges I. Introduction Gore v. Higher Educ Loan Auth...

18 U.S.C. §§ 111 & 1114: Subcontracted Private Personnel Assisting Federal Detention Functions Are Protected Without a Direct Federal Contract

Date: Aug 8, 2026

18 U.S.C. §§ 111 & 1114: Subcontracted Private Personnel Assisting Federal Detention Functions Are Protected Without a Direct Federal Contract Case: United States v. Hernandez (No. 25-2084) Court:...

Rule 404(b) Prior Drug-Conspiracy Convictions Admissible to Prove Knowledge and Intent; Any Error Harmless Where Mandatory Minimum Controls

Date: Aug 7, 2026

Rule 404(b) Prior Drug-Conspiracy Convictions Admissible to Prove Knowledge and Intent; Any Error Harmless Where Mandatory Minimum Controls Introduction In United States v. Christopher Spider...

Rule 56(d) Relief Requires a Proper Motion and Specific Showing; Default Sanctions and Fee Awards Stand Where Party-Driven Delay Is Clear

Date: Aug 7, 2026

Rule 56(d) Relief Requires a Proper Motion and Specific Showing; Default Sanctions and Fee Awards Stand Where Party-Driven Delay Is Clear I. Introduction Sixela Investment Group v. Hope Federal...

PLRA Exhaustion for Newly Added Claims Is Measured When the Claim Is First Pleaded

Date: Aug 7, 2026

PLRA Exhaustion for Newly Added Claims Is Measured When the Claim Is First Pleaded 1. Introduction In Benjamin Carter v. Beth Cabell (4th Cir. Aug. 4, 2026), incarcerated plaintiff Benjamin Forrest...

Third Circuit: Arbitrators May Clarify an Ambiguous Merits Award (Even After Issuance) When AAA Rules Delegate Functus Officio Boundaries

Date: Aug 7, 2026

Third Circuit: Arbitrators May Clarify an Ambiguous Merits Award (Even After Issuance) When AAA Rules Delegate Functus Officio Boundaries 1. Introduction In Prospect Capital Management L.P. v....

Independent Counsel Under Illinois Law Requires an Actual Insurer–Insured Conflict; Co-Insured Adversity Alone Is Insufficient

Date: Aug 7, 2026

Independent Counsel Under Illinois Law Requires an Actual Insurer–Insured Conflict; Co-Insured Adversity Alone Is Insufficient 1. Introduction Consolidated Chassis Management LLC v. Northland...

Rule 41(b) Dismissal-with-Prejudice Requires More Than a Short-Deadline Misstep by a Pro Se Conventional Filer

Date: Aug 7, 2026

Rule 41(b) Dismissal-with-Prejudice Requires More Than a Short-Deadline Misstep by a Pro Se Conventional Filer Case: Michelle Maupin v. School Board of Miami-Dade County (11th Cir. Aug. 5, 2026) (per...

Death Pending Appeal Abates Prosecution Ab Initio and Requires Vacatur and Dismissal, While Co-Defendant Convictions Stand on Sufficient Evidence and 404(b) Knowledge/Intent Proof

Date: Aug 7, 2026

Death Pending Appeal Abates Prosecution Ab Initio and Requires Vacatur and Dismissal, While Co-Defendant Convictions Stand on Sufficient Evidence and 404(b) Knowledge/Intent Proof I. Introduction...

Fifth Circuit: Minor Inconsistencies, Demeanor, and Plausibility Sustain Adverse Credibility; No IJ Duty to Re-Raise Noticed Inconsistencies; CAT Requires Particularized, Independent Proof Beyond General Country Conditions

Date: Aug 7, 2026

Fifth Circuit: Minor Inconsistencies, Demeanor, and Plausibility Sustain Adverse Credibility; No IJ Duty to Re-Raise Noticed Inconsistencies; CAT Requires Particularized, Independent Proof Beyond...

Garrett v. Davis: Eighth Amendment Sleep-Deprivation Claims Require Proof of Substantial Risk (Not Causation), No Numeric Sleep Threshold, and a Duration-Sensitive Totality Analysis

Date: Aug 7, 2026

Garrett v. Davis: Eighth Amendment Sleep-Deprivation Claims Require Proof of Substantial Risk (Not Causation), No Numeric Sleep Threshold, and a Duration-Sensitive Totality Analysis Court: U.S. Court...

Fifth Circuit: No Rule 56(d) Relief Without a Proper Motion; Late-Stage Withdrawal and Default Sanctions Sustained for Client-Driven Delay

Date: Aug 7, 2026

Fifth Circuit: No Rule 56(d) Relief Without a Proper Motion; Late-Stage Withdrawal and Default Sanctions Sustained for Client-Driven Delay I. Introduction Sixela Investment Group v. Hope Federal...

Rule 56(d) Relief Requires a Proper Motion and Diligent Discovery; Late-Stage Withdrawal and Default Sanctions Upheld for Client-Driven Delay (Sixela v. Hope Federal Credit Union)

Date: Aug 7, 2026

Rule 56(d) Relief Requires a Proper Motion and Diligent Discovery; Late-Stage Withdrawal and Default Sanctions Upheld for Client-Driven Delay Case: Sixela Investment Group v. Hope Federal Credit...

Adjacency-Based Professional Licensure Restrictions Likely Violate Article IV Privileges and Immunities

Date: Aug 7, 2026

Adjacency-Based Professional Licensure Restrictions Likely Violate Article IV Privileges and Immunities I. Introduction In Polk v. Crawford (5th Cir. Aug. 4, 2026), Geoffrey Polk—an attorney licensed...

Fifth Circuit: Damages Experts Cannot Assume Maximum Commissions; Untimely Rebuttal Disclosures Are Excluded

Date: Aug 7, 2026

Fifth Circuit: Damages Experts Cannot Assume Maximum Commissions; Untimely Rebuttal Disclosures Are Excluded 1. Introduction Finite Utility Consulting, L.L.C. v. Tawa (5th Cir. Aug. 4, 2026) arises...

Fourth Circuit Rule: No Compelled CIA Operational-File Search Absent Completed Withholding and Sworn Evidence; Detailed CIA Affidavits Sustain FOIA (b)(1)/(b)(3) Redactions

Date: Aug 7, 2026

Fourth Circuit Rule: No Compelled CIA Operational-File Search Absent Completed Withholding and Sworn Evidence; Detailed CIA Affidavits Sustain FOIA (b)(1)/(b)(3) Redactions Case: Michael Driggs v....