Wisconsin Case Commentaries

WCA § 426.110(4)(c) Bars Damages Class Actions Upon an “Appropriate Remedy” Offered to the Named Plaintiff (Not the Putative Class)

Date: Mar 7, 2026

WCA § 426.110(4)(c) Bars Damages Class Actions Upon an “Appropriate Remedy” Offered to the Named Plaintiff (Not the Putative Class) 1) Introduction In Heather Gudex v. Franklin Collection Service,...

Domestic-Violence Misdemeanor Convictions Are Professional Misconduct, but Extraordinary Rehabilitation and OLR Delay May Justify a Public Reprimand (Office of Lawyer Regulation v. Doherty)

Date: Mar 6, 2026

Domestic-Violence Misdemeanor Convictions Are Professional Misconduct, but Extraordinary Rehabilitation and OLR Delay May Justify a Public Reprimand Office of Lawyer Regulation v. Ryan V. Doherty...

State v. J.D.B. (2026 WI 5): Appellate Review of Sell Factors—De Novo for Governmental Interest; Clear Error for Factors 2–4; No Mandatory “Green” Checklist

Date: Feb 27, 2026

State v. J.D.B. (2026 WI 5): Appellate Review of Sell Factors—De Novo for Governmental Interest; Clear Error for Factors 2–4; No Mandatory “Green” Checklist I. Introduction Parties and posture. The...

State v. J.D.B. (2026 WI 5): Appellate Review Framework for Sell Orders—Factor One De Novo; Factors Two–Four Clearly Erroneous; Green Checklist Rejected

Date: Feb 27, 2026

State v. J.D.B. (2026 WI 5): Appellate Review Framework for Sell Orders—Factor One De Novo; Factors Two–Four Clearly Erroneous; Green Checklist Rejected I. Introduction Case: State v. J.D.B., 2026 WI...

Wisconsin Clarifies the “Instrument or Agent” Test: ESP CSAM Scanning Remains a Private Search Under a Totality-of-the-Circumstances Analysis

Date: Feb 27, 2026

Wisconsin Clarifies the “Instrument or Agent” Test: ESP CSAM Scanning Remains a Private Search Under a Totality-of-the-Circumstances Analysis Introduction State v. Andreas W. Rauch Sharak (2026 WI 4)...

ESPs Remain Private Actors When Scanning for CSAM; Payano-Roman Factors Are Non-Dispositive Under a Totality Test

Date: Feb 26, 2026

ESPs Remain Private Actors When Scanning for CSAM; Payano-Roman Factors Are Non-Dispositive Under a Totality Test I. Introduction In State v. Andreas W. Rauch Sharak (2026 WI 4), the Wisconsin...

Wisconsin Adopts Virtual-Certainty Private-Search Rule for Hash-Flagged CSAM Files

Date: Jan 17, 2026

Wisconsin Adopts Virtual-Certainty Private-Search Rule for Hash-Flagged CSAM Files Introduction State v. Michael Joseph Gasper (2026 WI 3) presented the Wisconsin Supreme Court with a recurring...

Hash-Scan Private Search Doctrine: Government Viewing of a PhotoDNA-Flagged CSAM File Does Not Exceed the Private Search

Date: Jan 17, 2026

Hash-Scan Private Search Doctrine: Government Viewing of a PhotoDNA-Flagged CSAM File Does Not Exceed the Private Search Case: State v. Michael Joseph Gasper, 2026 WI 3 (Wis. Jan. 14, 2026) Court:...

Prolonged Probate Neglect Violates SCR 20:1.3, but Mitigation May Support Public Reprimand (and Full Costs Absent “Exceptional Circumstances”)

Date: Jan 11, 2026

Prolonged Probate Neglect Violates SCR 20:1.3, but Mitigation May Support Public Reprimand (and Full Costs Absent “Exceptional Circumstances”) 1. Introduction Office of Lawyer Regulation v. Bryant H....

Public Reprimand for Prolonged Probate Neglect Under SCR 20:1.3; Full Costs Required Absent Exceptional Circumstances

Date: Jan 11, 2026

Public Reprimand for Prolonged Probate Neglect Under SCR 20:1.3; Full Costs Required Absent Exceptional Circumstances Introduction Office of Lawyer Regulation v. Bryant H. Klos (2026 WI 1) is a...

Campaign Criticism and Judicial Recusal: Office of Lawyer Regulation v. Gableman and the Limits of “Appearance of Bias” in Wisconsin

Date: Dec 6, 2025

Campaign Criticism and Judicial Recusal: Office of Lawyer Regulation v. Michael J. Gableman and the Limits of “Appearance of Bias” in Wisconsin I. Introduction This commentary analyzes the December...

Broadening “Apportionment” in Wisconsin: Three‑Judge Panels for All Congressional and Legislative Redistricting Challenges After Bothfeld v. WEC

Date: Nov 30, 2025

Broadening “Apportionment” in Wisconsin: Three‑Judge Panels for All Congressional and Legislative Redistricting Challenges After Bothfeld v. Wisconsin Elections Commission I. Introduction The...

Broad Construction of “Apportionment” and Mandatory Three‑Judge Panels in Wisconsin Redistricting Challenges: Commentary on Wisconsin Business Leaders for Democracy v. WEC

Date: Nov 30, 2025

Broad Construction of “Apportionment” and Mandatory Three‑Judge Panels in Wisconsin Redistricting Challenges Commentary on Wisconsin Business Leaders for Democracy v. Wisconsin Elections Commission,...

Identical Discipline Under SCR 22.22: Minnesota Disbarment Equals Wisconsin Revocation, Not Suspension

Date: Nov 15, 2025

Identical Discipline Under SCR 22.22: Minnesota Disbarment Equals Wisconsin Revocation, Not Suspension Introduction In Office of Lawyer Regulation v. Michael B. Padden, 2025 WI 47, the Wisconsin...

Reciprocal Discipline Clarified: Wisconsin Revocation Is the Identical Sanction to Minnesota Disbarment, Despite Reinstatement Differences

Date: Nov 15, 2025

Reciprocal Discipline Clarified: Wisconsin Revocation Is the Identical Sanction to Minnesota Disbarment, Despite Reinstatement Differences Introduction In Office of Lawyer Regulation v. Michael B....

Reinstatement Is Not a Silo: Wisconsin Supreme Court Imposes an Affirmative Duty to Disclose Concurrent Discipline and Confirms the Expansive Scope of SCR 22.305 (Office of Lawyer Regulation v. Steven D. Johnson, 2025 WI 45)

Date: Oct 13, 2025

Reinstatement Is Not a Silo: Wisconsin Supreme Court Imposes an Affirmative Duty to Disclose Concurrent Discipline and Confirms the Expansive Scope of SCR 22.305 Case: Office of Lawyer Regulation v....

“Reinstatement Is Not a Silo”: Wisconsin Supreme Court mandates disclosure of intervening discipline and reaffirms the far‑ranging scope of reinstatement inquiries under SCR 22.305, SCR 22.29(4), and SCR 22.40

Date: Oct 13, 2025

“Reinstatement Is Not a Silo”: Wisconsin Supreme Court mandates disclosure of intervening discipline and reaffirms the far‑ranging scope of reinstatement inquiries under SCR 22.305, SCR 22.29(4), and...

Tribal Bar Admission Is Not “Admission in a State, Territory, or D.C.” Under SCR 40.04(1); Exam-Eligibility Denials Are Reviewable Under the Court’s Supervisory Authority

Date: Oct 10, 2025

Tribal Bar Admission Is Not “Admission in a State, Territory, or D.C.” Under SCR 40.04(1); Exam-Eligibility Denials Are Reviewable Under the Court’s Supervisory Authority Introduction In Joy Morris...

Gatekeeping the Three‑Judge Panel: Wisconsin Supreme Court Requires Threshold Showing that a Redistricting Suit Is an “Apportionment” Challenge Before § 751.035 Is Triggered

Date: Sep 27, 2025

Gatekeeping the Three‑Judge Panel: Wisconsin Supreme Court Requires Threshold Showing that a Redistricting Suit Is an “Apportionment” Challenge Before § 751.035 Is Triggered Introduction In a...

Gatekeeping Before Appointing Three‑Judge Redistricting Panels: Wisconsin Supreme Court to Decide What Counts as an “Apportionment” Challenge Under Wis. Stat. § 801.50(4m)

Date: Sep 27, 2025

Gatekeeping Before Appointing Three‑Judge Redistricting Panels: Wisconsin Supreme Court to Decide What Counts as an “Apportionment” Challenge Under Wis. Stat. § 801.50(4m) Introduction In Wisconsin...