Vermont Case Commentaries

Extension of Vermont Anti-Stalking Orders Turns on Protective Necessity—Not New Stalking—and Pro Se Filings Risk Rule 11 Sanctions for Fake Authority

Date: Jul 16, 2026

Extension of Vermont Anti-Stalking Orders Turns on Protective Necessity—Not New Stalking—and Pro Se Filings Risk Rule 11 Sanctions for Fake Authority 1. Introduction In Cheryl O'Donnell v. Hope...

Termination at Initial Disposition: Recent Sobriety and Housing Gains Do Not Defeat TPR Absent a Child-Timed Path to Resuming Parenting

Date: Jul 16, 2026

Termination at Initial Disposition: Recent Sobriety and Housing Gains Do Not Defeat TPR Absent a Child-Timed Path to Resuming Parenting Introduction Case: In re L.H., Juvenile (K.M., Mother*) (Vt....

Clarification (Not Modification) of Summer Parent-Child Contact: “Separate Weeks” May Be Added to Alternating Weekends Without Changed Circumstances

Date: Jul 16, 2026

Clarification (Not Modification) of Summer Parent-Child Contact: “Separate Weeks” May Be Added to Alternating Weekends Without Changed Circumstances Patrick McElroy v. Mandi Theberge, Vermont Supreme...

State v. Terrell Jackson — Circumstantial-Evidence Sufficiency and Plain-Error Limits on Sua Sponte Acquittal in Vermont Larceny Cases

Date: Jul 16, 2026

Circumstantial-Evidence Sufficiency and Plain-Error Limits on Sua Sponte Acquittal in Vermont Larceny Cases Introduction State v. Terrell Jackson (Vt. Sup. Ct., July 10, 2026) is an entry order...

Equitable Denial of Contractual/Statutory Attorney’s Fees in Eviction Cases Where Landlord Habitability Failures and a Mixed Result Make Fee-Shifting Unwarranted

Date: Jul 16, 2026

Equitable Denial of Contractual/Statutory Attorney’s Fees in Eviction Cases Where Landlord Habitability Failures and a Mixed Result Make Fee-Shifting Unwarranted Introduction In CMRT Holdings, LLC v....

Waiver of Factual Challenges for Missing Transcripts in Vermont Anti‑Stalking Appeals (and Appellate Counsel’s Duty of Accurate Authority)

Date: Jul 16, 2026

Waiver of Factual Challenges for Missing Transcripts in Vermont Anti‑Stalking Appeals (and Appellate Counsel’s Duty of Accurate Authority) Case: Jessica Cover v. Susan Tyrell / Jessica Cover v....

Welch v. Rivers: Pleading Actual Injury and More Than Isolated Interference to State a Prison-Mail § 1983 Claim

Date: Jul 16, 2026

Welch v. Rivers: Pleading Actual Injury and More Than Isolated Interference to State a Prison-Mail § 1983 Claim Introduction In Richard Welch, Jr. v. Austin Rivers (Vt. Sup. Ct. July 10, 2026) (Entry...

Rule 25 Substitution After Death Requires an Estate-Based “Proper Party”; “Distributee” Is Not an Open-Ended Category

Date: Jul 3, 2026

Rule 25 Substitution After Death Requires an Estate-Based “Proper Party”; “Distributee” Is Not an Open-Ended Category 1. Introduction In Human Rights Commission v. Homer Durkee (2026 VT 27), the...

Settlement Stipulation and Acquiescence Can Establish Common-Law Dedication of a Public Trail

Date: Jun 19, 2026

Settlement Stipulation and Acquiescence Can Establish Common-Law Dedication of a Public Trail 1. Introduction In John Gerlach and Debra Gerlach v. Town of Chittenden (2026 VT 25), the Vermont Supreme...

State v. Lovejoy: “Open and Gross Lewdness” Is Not a Lesser-Included Offense of § 2602(a)(1), and “Lewd or Lascivious” Is Disjunctive

Date: Jun 19, 2026

State v. Lovejoy (2026 VT 26): “Open and Gross Lewdness” Is Not a Lesser-Included Offense of § 2602(a)(1), and “Lewd or Lascivious” Is Disjunctive I. Introduction In State v. Dean A. Lovejoy, the...

Rule 35(a) Does Not Permit Collateral Attacks on Convictions or Statutes; “Illegal Sentence” Means Statutorily Unauthorized Sentence

Date: Jun 13, 2026

Rule 35(a) Does Not Permit Collateral Attacks on Convictions or Statutes; “Illegal Sentence” Means Statutorily Unauthorized Sentence Introduction State v. Travis Smith (2026 VT 22) is a Vermont...

State v. Hirzel (2026 VT 24): No Binding Plea Agreement Without Rule 11(e)(3) Advisement; Extra-Record Victim-Impact Allegations Disclaimed Are Not “Considered”; Curfew Cannot Reduce Jail Time Under § 7031(b)

Date: Jun 13, 2026

State v. Hirzel (2026 VT 24): No Binding Plea Agreement Without Rule 11(e)(3) Advisement; Extra-Record Victim-Impact Allegations Disclaimed Are Not “Considered”; Curfew Cannot Reduce Jail Time Under...

LCAR Certified Objection Shifts the Full § 842(c)(2) Burden to the Agency (Without Raising the Standard of Proof)

Date: Jun 13, 2026

LCAR Certified Objection Shifts the Full § 842(c)(2) Burden to the Agency (Without Raising the Standard of Proof) Case: Protect Our Wildlife, a nonprofit 501(c)(3) organization v. Fish and Wildlife...

Recipient Testimony Plus Distinctive Context Can Authenticate Messenger Messages and Sustain an RFA-Violation Conviction

Date: Jun 6, 2026

Recipient Testimony Plus Distinctive Context Can Authenticate Messenger Messages and Sustain an RFA-Violation Conviction 1. Introduction State v. Jeremy Amidon (Vt. Sup. Ct., June 5, 2026) arises...

Probable-Cause Presumption Bars Malicious Prosecution Absent Improper Evidence, and Prosecutor’s Later Charge Amendment Is Not Attributable Without Defendant Involvement (Billewicz v. Humphries)

Date: Jun 6, 2026

Probable-Cause Presumption Bars Malicious Prosecution Absent Improper Evidence, and Prosecutor’s Later Charge Amendment Is Not Attributable Without Defendant Involvement Introduction In Johnathan...

Vermont Reaffirms No Duty to Child Trespassers; Attractive-Nuisance Change Reserved to the Legislature

Date: Jun 6, 2026

Vermont Reaffirms No Duty to Child Trespassers; Attractive-Nuisance Change Reserved to the Legislature 1. Introduction In Ian Treadway v. Green Mountain Power Corporation (2026 VT 20), the Vermont...

In re W.M.: Termination Affirmed Despite Mental-Health Medication Nonadherence Where Services Were Extensive and Parenting Capacity Stagnated

Date: Jun 6, 2026

In re W.M.: Termination Affirmed Despite Mental-Health Medication Nonadherence Where Services Were Extensive and Parenting Capacity Stagnated 1. Introduction Case: In re W.M., Juvenile (C.M.,...

Maintenance Must Be Based on Accurate, Current Income Findings; Clearly Erroneous Income Findings Require Remand and May Reopen Property Division

Date: Jun 6, 2026

Maintenance Must Be Based on Accurate, Current Income Findings; Clearly Erroneous Income Findings Require Remand and May Reopen Property Division Anne Goodrich v. Jeffrey Goodrich, Vermont Supreme...

Refusal to Permit DCF Assessment and Safety Planning, Combined with Substance-Use Indicators and Unsafe Caregivers, Supports CHINS Risk-of-Harm Finding

Date: Jun 6, 2026

Refusal to Permit DCF Assessment and Safety Planning, Combined with Substance-Use Indicators and Unsafe Caregivers, Supports CHINS Risk-of-Harm Finding 1. Introduction Case: In re L.M., L.M., L.M.,...

Constructive Visitation Alone Does Not Defeat Termination: Refusal to Cooperate with Home/Safety Assessment and Substance-Use Evaluation Supports “Stagnation” and Best-Interests Findings

Date: Jun 6, 2026

Constructive Visitation Alone Does Not Defeat Termination: Refusal to Cooperate with Home/Safety Assessment and Substance-Use Evaluation Supports “Stagnation” and Best-Interests Findings Case: In re...