Texas Case Commentaries

“Remove From the Docket” Is Not Unmistakable Finality: Dismissal-Style Language Alone Does Not Create a Final Judgment Under Lehmann

Date: Mar 15, 2025

“Remove From the Docket” Is Not Unmistakable Finality: Dismissal-Style Language Alone Does Not Create a Final Judgment Under Lehmann 1. Introduction Case: In the Interest of C.K.M., a Child, No....

Texas De Novo Tax-Refund Suits Apply a Preponderance Standard; Private Prison Contractors Are Not “Government Instrumentalities” for Sales/Use Tax Exemption

Date: Mar 15, 2025

Texas De Novo Tax-Refund Suits Apply a Preponderance Standard; Private Prison Contractors Are Not “Government Instrumentalities” for Sales/Use Tax Exemption Introduction In THE GEO GROUP, INC. AND...

Bertucci v. Watkins: No Briefing-Waiver of Perfected Derivative Appeal Absent Clear Failure to Present Derivative Arguments

Date: Mar 15, 2025

Bertucci v. Watkins: No Briefing-Waiver of Perfected Derivative Appeal Absent Clear Failure to Present Derivative Arguments I. Introduction Case: CHRISTOPHER F. BERTUCCI, AS OF THE ESTATE OF ANTHONY...

Death-Penalty Discovery Sanctions Require Proof of Flagrant Bad Faith and a Tested, On-the-Record Consideration of Lesser Sanctions

Date: Mar 15, 2025

Death-Penalty Discovery Sanctions Require Proof of Flagrant Bad Faith and a Tested, On-the-Record Consideration of Lesser Sanctions Case: In re Newkirk Logistics, Inc., No. 24-0255 (Tex. May 16,...

Establishing the Boundaries of Derivative Appeals and Fiduciary Duties in Partnership Disputes: The Bertucci-Watkins Precedent

Date: Mar 15, 2025

Establishing the Boundaries of Derivative Appeals and Fiduciary Duties in Partnership Disputes: The Bertucci-Watkins Precedent I. Introduction The case of Christopher F. Bertucci, acting as executor...

Texas Narrows Interlocutory Venue Appeals: Section 15.003(b) Applies Only When a Plaintiff’s Independent Venue Showing Is Actually at Issue

Date: Mar 14, 2025

Texas Narrows Interlocutory Venue Appeals: Section 15.003(b) Applies Only When a Plaintiff’s Independent Venue Showing Is Actually at Issue I. Introduction Rush Truck Centers of Texas, L.P. AND BLUE...

Redundant-Remedies Doctrine Turns on Remedies, Not Claims: Ultra Vires and As-Applied Constitutional Suits May Proceed Beyond APA Order-Reversal

Date: Mar 14, 2025

Redundant-Remedies Doctrine Turns on Remedies, Not Claims: Ultra Vires and As-Applied Constitutional Suits May Proceed Beyond APA Order-Reversal Case: REYNALDO "REY" GONZALEZ, JR., M.D., J.D. v....

Minor Briefing Defects Do Not Forfeit Derivative Appeals; Rule 38.9(b) Is the Proper Remedy

Date: Mar 13, 2025

Minor Briefing Defects Do Not Forfeit Derivative Appeals; Rule 38.9(b) Is the Proper Remedy Supreme Court of Texas — CHRISTOPHER F. BERTUCCI, AS OF THE ESTATE OF ANTHONY R. BERTUCCI, AND DERIVATIVELY...

Foreclosure Judgment Validating a Lien Does Not Bar a Later JOA Cost-Sharing Breach Claim When the Foreclosure Court Did Not Necessarily Decide It (and the Lienholder Previously Urged No Jurisdiction)

Date: Mar 13, 2025

Foreclosure Judgment Validating a Lien Does Not Bar a Later JOA Cost-Sharing Breach Claim When the Foreclosure Court Did Not Necessarily Decide It (and the Lienholder Previously Urged No...

Passive-Voice Habendum Clauses Do Not Imply a “Produced by the Lessee” Requirement

Date: Mar 13, 2025

Passive-Voice Habendum Clauses Do Not Imply a “Produced by the Lessee” Requirement I. Introduction In DAVID W. CROMWELL v. ANADARKO E&P ONSHORE, LLC, the Supreme Court of Texas addressed a recurring...

Default Rule: Oil-and-Gas Conveyance Includes Control of Incidentally Produced Groundwater in Liquid-Waste Byproduct Unless Expressly Reserved

Date: Mar 13, 2025

Default Rule: Oil-and-Gas Conveyance Includes Control of Incidentally Produced Groundwater in Liquid-Waste Byproduct Unless Expressly Reserved 1. Introduction Cactus Water Services, LLC v. COG...

Death-Penalty Discovery Sanctions Require Proof of Possession/Control and Flagrant Bad Faith, Plus Consideration of Lesser Sanctions

Date: Mar 12, 2025

Death-Penalty Discovery Sanctions Require Proof of Possession/Control and Flagrant Bad Faith, Plus Consideration of Lesser Sanctions I. Introduction In re Newkirk Logistics, Inc. is a Texas Supreme...

Texas Appellate Briefing Waiver: Courts Must Avoid Overly Technical Forfeitures and Reach Derivative-Claim Merits When Briefing Fairly Presents the Issues

Date: Mar 12, 2025

Texas Appellate Briefing Waiver: Courts Must Avoid Overly Technical Forfeitures and Reach Derivative-Claim Merits When Briefing Fairly Presents the Issues 1) Introduction Case: CHRISTOPHER F....

Foreclosure Judgments Do Not Bar Later Contract Claims Not Necessarily Decided—Especially When the Foreclosing Party Previously Defeated Jurisdiction Over the Contract Dispute

Date: Mar 11, 2025

Foreclosure Judgments Do Not Bar Later Contract Claims Not Necessarily Decided—Especially When the Foreclosing Party Previously Defeated Jurisdiction Over the Contract Dispute Court: Supreme Court of...

DTPA Civil Investigative Demands Must Be Statutorily Clear, Discovery-Limited, and Cannot Compel Third-Party Sworn Statements or Associationally Protected Member Identities

Date: Mar 11, 2025

DTPA Civil Investigative Demands Must Be Statutorily Clear, Discovery-Limited, and Cannot Compel Third-Party Sworn Statements or Associationally Protected Member Identities Decision commented on:...

Default Rule: Oil-and-Gas Leases Convey Control of Incidentally Produced Groundwater (Produced Water) Absent Express Reservation

Date: Mar 11, 2025

Default Rule: Oil-and-Gas Leases Convey Control of Incidentally Produced Groundwater (Produced Water) Absent Express Reservation 1. Introduction Case: Cactus Water Services, LLC v. COG Operating,...

DFPS’s Unequivocal Trial Withdrawal of Termination Bars a Termination Judgment Absent Clear Repudiation

Date: Mar 11, 2025

DFPS’s Unequivocal Trial Withdrawal of Termination Bars a Termination Judgment Absent Clear Repudiation I. Introduction In D.V. v. Texas Department of Family and Protective Services, the Supreme...

Section 15.003(b) Interlocutory Venue Appeals Require an Actual “Independent Venue” Determination, Not Merely Multiple Plaintiffs

Date: Mar 11, 2025

Section 15.003(b) Interlocutory Venue Appeals Require an Actual “Independent Venue” Determination, Not Merely Multiple Plaintiffs I. Introduction Case: Rush Truck Centers of Texas, L.P. and Blue Bird...

Texas DTPA Investigative Demands Must State a Clear Statutory Basis and Subject Matter, Seek Only Discoverable Information, and Limit Sworn-Statement Demands to DTPA Targets

Date: Mar 11, 2025

Texas DTPA Investigative Demands Must State a Clear Statutory Basis and Subject Matter, Seek Only Discoverable Information, and Limit Sworn-Statement Demands to DTPA Targets I. Introduction This...

Religious Conference May Sue to Enforce Control Rights Under BOC § 22.207 and Assert Third-Party-Beneficiary Contract Claim Based on Nonprofit Articles

Date: Mar 11, 2025

Religious Conference May Sue to Enforce Control Rights Under BOC § 22.207 and Assert Third-Party-Beneficiary Contract Claim Based on Nonprofit Articles I. Introduction In SOUTHERN METHODIST...