Texas Case Commentaries

Texas Limits Interlocutory Venue Appeals: Section 15.003(b) Applies Only When a Plaintiff’s Independent Venue Showing Is Actually at Issue

Date: Mar 19, 2025

Texas Limits Interlocutory Venue Appeals: Section 15.003(b) Applies Only When a Plaintiff’s Independent Venue Showing Is Actually at Issue Case: RUSH TRUCK CENTERS OF TEXAS, L.P. AND BLUE BIRD BODY...

Texas Supreme Court Narrows § 15.003(b): No Interlocutory Venue Appeal When Multiple Plaintiffs Share Identical Venue Facts

Date: Mar 19, 2025

Texas Supreme Court Narrows § 15.003(b): No Interlocutory Venue Appeal When Multiple Plaintiffs Share Identical Venue Facts 1. Introduction In Rush Truck Centers of Texas, L.P. AND Blue Bird Body...

Rule 52.10 Temporary Relief Must “Preserve the Parties’ Rights”: Merits and Irreparable-Harm Balancing, Not “Status Quo” Wordplay

Date: Mar 19, 2025

Rule 52.10 Temporary Relief Must “Preserve the Parties’ Rights”: Merits and Irreparable-Harm Balancing, Not “Status Quo” Wordplay 1. Introduction In re The State of Texas arises from a dispute...

Rule 52.10 Temporary Relief Must Preserve the Parties’ Rights—Requiring a Preliminary Merits Inquiry and an Irreparable-Harm/Equities Balance

Date: Mar 19, 2025

Rule 52.10 Temporary Relief Must Preserve the Parties’ Rights—Requiring a Preliminary Merits Inquiry and an Irreparable-Harm/Equities Balance 1. Introduction In re The State of Texas arises from...

Minor Briefing Defects Do Not Forfeit Derivative Appeals; Courts Should Favor Merits Review and Use Supplemental Briefing

Date: Mar 19, 2025

Minor Briefing Defects Do Not Forfeit Derivative Appeals; Courts Should Favor Merits Review and Use Supplemental Briefing Supreme Court of Texas — CHRISTOPHER F. BERTUCCI, AS OF THE ESTATE OF ANTHONY...

Texas Recognizes a Narrow Equitable “Delay-Expense” Award Incident to Specific Performance in Real-Property Sale Contracts

Date: Mar 19, 2025

Texas Recognizes a Narrow Equitable “Delay-Expense” Award Incident to Specific Performance in Real-Property Sale Contracts I. Introduction In WHITE KNIGHT DEVELOPMENT, LLC v. DICK B. SIMMONS, SR.,...

Default Rule: Oil-and-Gas Conveyances Include Possession and Control of Incidentally Produced Groundwater as Waste Byproduct (Absent Express Lease Terms)

Date: Mar 19, 2025

Default Rule: Oil-and-Gas Conveyances Include Possession and Control of Incidentally Produced Groundwater as Waste Byproduct (Absent Express Lease Terms) Introduction In Cactus Water Services, LLC v....

Default Rule: Hydrocarbon Leases Convey Control of “Incidentally Produced” Groundwater as Liquid-Waste Byproduct Unless the Lease Says Otherwise

Date: Mar 19, 2025

Default Rule: Hydrocarbon Leases Convey Control of “Incidentally Produced” Groundwater as Liquid-Waste Byproduct Unless the Lease Says Otherwise I. Introduction In Cactus Water Services, LLC v. COG...

Texas Recognizes a Narrow “Equitable Delay-Expense” Monetary Award Incident to Specific Performance in Real-Property Sale Contracts

Date: Mar 19, 2025

Texas Recognizes a Narrow “Equitable Delay-Expense” Monetary Award Incident to Specific Performance in Real-Property Sale Contracts I. Introduction Case: WHITE KNIGHT DEVELOPMENT, LLC v. DICK B....

Texas PIA–FERPA Rule: §552.026 Makes FERPA-Permitted Disclosures Discretionary and Eliminates the OAG-Decision Requirement for Withholding Education Records

Date: Mar 18, 2025

Texas PIA–FERPA Rule: §552.026 Makes FERPA-Permitted Disclosures Discretionary and Eliminates the OAG-Decision Requirement for Withholding Education Records 1. Introduction This Texas Supreme Court...

No “Public-Interest Exception” to Mootness in Texas: Moot Cases Must Be Dismissed as Constitutionally Nonjusticiable

Date: Mar 18, 2025

No “Public-Interest Exception” to Mootness in Texas: Moot Cases Must Be Dismissed as Constitutionally Nonjusticiable I. Introduction In TEXAS DEPARTMENT OF FAMILY AND PROTECTIVE SERVICES; STEPHANIE...

Default Rule: Oil-and-Gas Conveyances Include Incidentally Produced Groundwater and Grant the Lessee Control of Produced-Water Disposition Absent Express Lease Language

Date: Mar 18, 2025

Default Rule: Oil-and-Gas Conveyances Include Incidentally Produced Groundwater and Grant the Lessee Control of Produced-Water Disposition Absent Express Lease Language 1) Introduction Case: Cactus...

PIA § 552.321(b) Is a Venue Rule—It Does Not Expand District-Court Mandamus Jurisdiction Over Constitutional Executive Officers

Date: Mar 18, 2025

PIA § 552.321(b) Is a Venue Rule—It Does Not Expand District-Court Mandamus Jurisdiction Over Constitutional Executive Officers I. Introduction In Ken Paxton, in his Official Capacity as Attorney...

Texas PIA Does Not Mandate Release of FERPA-Permissive “Final Results” Records; Universities May Withhold Without an OAG Decision

Date: Mar 18, 2025

Texas PIA Does Not Mandate Release of FERPA-Permissive “Final Results” Records; Universities May Withhold Without an OAG Decision I. Introduction Case: The University of Texas at Austin and Jay...

PIA Mandamus Against Constitutional Executive Officers: §552.321(b) Sets Venue, Not District-Court Jurisdiction

Date: Mar 18, 2025

PIA Mandamus Against Constitutional Executive Officers: §552.321(b) Sets Venue, Not District-Court Jurisdiction I. Introduction In KEN PAXTON, IN HIS OFFICIAL CAPACITY AS ATTORNEY GENERAL OF TEXAS,...

No Public-Interest Exception to Mootness in Texas: Courts Must Dismiss Moot Cases as Unconstitutional Advisory Opinions

Date: Mar 18, 2025

No Public-Interest Exception to Mootness in Texas: Courts Must Dismiss Moot Cases as Unconstitutional Advisory Opinions Case: TEXAS DEPARTMENT OF FAMILY AND PROTECTIVE SERVICES; STEPHANIE MUTH, IN...

Default Rule in Texas: Silent Oil-and-Gas Leases Convey Possession and Control of Incidentally Produced Groundwater (Produced-Water Byproduct) to the Mineral Lessee

Date: Mar 18, 2025

Default Rule in Texas: Silent Oil-and-Gas Leases Convey Possession and Control of Incidentally Produced Groundwater (Produced-Water Byproduct) to the Mineral Lessee I. Introduction In Cactus Water...

Clarifying Finality in Consolidated Cases: The Limits of Dismissal Orders in Texas Family Law

Date: Mar 15, 2025

Clarifying Finality in Consolidated Cases: The Limits of Dismissal Orders in Texas Family Law Introduction This Judgment, rendered by the Supreme Court of Texas on March 14, 2025, in the case titled...

Clarifying Standards of Proof and Instrumentality in Tax Refund Cases

Date: Mar 15, 2025

Clarifying Standards of Proof and Instrumentality in Tax Refund Cases Introduction In a landmark decision, the Supreme Court of Texas addressed a critical question in tax law: whether a private,...

Default Rule: Oil-and-Gas Conveyances Include Control of Incidentally Produced Groundwater as Liquid-Waste Byproduct (Absent Contrary Lease Language)

Date: Mar 15, 2025

Default Rule: Oil-and-Gas Conveyances Include Control of Incidentally Produced Groundwater as Liquid-Waste Byproduct (Absent Contrary Lease Language) 1. Introduction Cactus Water Services, LLC v. COG...