South Dakota Case Commentaries

SDCL 44-9-42 Authorizes Attorney Fees for Defending Intertwined Counterclaims in Mechanic’s Lien Actions; Law-of-the-Case Controls Fee Decisions on Remand

Date: Jun 12, 2025

SDCL 44-9-42 Authorizes Attorney Fees for Defending Intertwined Counterclaims in Mechanic’s Lien Actions; Law-of-the-Case Controls Fee Decisions on Remand Introduction In Smith Masonry v. WIPI Group...

Targeted SI‑Joint Diagnostics Prevail Over Degenerative MRI Findings in Establishing “A Major Contributing Cause”; Odd‑Lot PTD Demands a Reasonable Job Search

Date: Apr 17, 2025

Targeted SI‑Joint Diagnostics Prevail Over Degenerative MRI Findings in Establishing “A Major Contributing Cause”; Odd‑Lot PTD Demands a Reasonable Job Search Case: Brewer v. Tectum Holdings, Inc.,...

Substance Over Form and the Anti‑Clogging Rule: Unambiguous Sale–Leaseback Papers May Be Recast as an Equitable Mortgage Without Extrinsic Evidence

Date: Apr 17, 2025

Substance Over Form and the Anti‑Clogging Rule: Unambiguous Sale–Leaseback Papers May Be Recast as an Equitable Mortgage Without Extrinsic Evidence Case: Sturzenbecher v. Sioux County Ranch, LLC,...

Dual-Status Technicians Earn Paid Military Leave While on Title 10 Duty; No Antimilitary Animus Needed for USERRA Claims Involving Military-Only Benefits

Date: Apr 17, 2025

Dual-Status Technicians Earn Paid Military Leave While on Title 10 Duty; No Antimilitary Animus Needed for USERRA Claims Involving Military-Only Benefits Case: Christiansen v. Major General Morrell,...

De Novo Review and the Presumption of Validity in Municipal Special Assessment Appeals

Date: Apr 10, 2025

De Novo Review and the Presumption of Validity in Municipal Special Assessment Appeals Introduction KJD, LLC v. City of Tea, 2025 S.D. 22, is a Supreme Court of South Dakota decision addressing a...

State v. Holy: Limits on Unrelated Contraband Interrogations During Traffic Stops

Date: Mar 27, 2025

State v. Holy: Limits on Unrelated Contraband Interrogations During Traffic Stops Introduction In State v. Holy (2025 S.D. 19), the Supreme Court of South Dakota addressed whether a routine traffic...

Underinsured Motorist Coverage Follows the Insured: Public Policy Bars “Owned But Not Insured” Exclusions

Date: Mar 27, 2025

Underinsured Motorist Coverage Follows the Insured: Public Policy Bars “Owned But Not Insured” Exclusions Introduction The Supreme Court of South Dakota’s decision in Earll v. Farmers Mutual...

Restricting Guardianship and Conservatorship to Qualified Nonprofit Entities: Clarification of SDCL 29A-5-110

Date: Mar 27, 2025

Restricting Guardianship and Conservatorship to Qualified Nonprofit Entities: Clarification of SDCL 29A-5-110 Introduction This case arises from competing petitions for guardianship and...

State v. Tuopeh (2025 S.D. 16) Commentary

Date: Mar 13, 2025

No Requirement for “Alternative Counts” Homicide Instructions; Double-Jeopardy Is Cured by Entering Judgment on Only One Count Case: State v. Tuopeh, 2025 S.D. 16 (S.D. Mar. 12, 2025) Court: Supreme...

Limiting the Economic Loss Doctrine to UCC and Product Liability: A New Precedent in Construction Negligence Claims

Date: Mar 13, 2025

Limiting the Economic Loss Doctrine to UCC and Product Liability: A New Precedent in Construction Negligence Claims Introduction In the case of James and Amber May v. First Rate Excavate, Inc. (2025...

State v. Rogers (2025 S.D. 18): SDCL 23A-37-15 Violations Do Not Create Due Process or Spoliation Relief Absent Apparent Exculpatory Value or Bad Faith

Date: Mar 13, 2025

State v. Rogers (2025 S.D. 18): SDCL 23A-37-15 Violations Do Not Create Due Process or Spoliation Relief Absent Apparent Exculpatory Value or Bad Faith Court: Supreme Court of South Dakota Date:...

State v. Tuopeh: Multiple Homicide Counts Need Not Be Submitted as Alternatives; Double Jeopardy Is Avoided at Judgment by Entering Only One Conviction

Date: Mar 13, 2025

State v. Tuopeh: Multiple Homicide Counts Need Not Be Submitted as Alternatives; Double Jeopardy Is Avoided at Judgment by Entering Only One Conviction Introduction State v. Tuopeh (2025 S.D. 16)...

State v. Tuopeh — Double Jeopardy Is Avoided by Entering Judgment on Only One Homicide Count; No Right to an Alternative-Counts Instruction

Date: Mar 13, 2025

State v. Tuopeh (2025 S.D. 16): Double Jeopardy Is Avoided by Entering Judgment on Only One Homicide Count; No Right to an Alternative-Counts Instruction 1. Introduction State v. Tuopeh arises from...

South Dakota Limits the Economic Loss Doctrine to UCC/Product-Liability Claims and Rejects Its Use to Bar Construction-Services Negligence Absent Privity

Date: Mar 13, 2025

South Dakota Limits the Economic Loss Doctrine to UCC/Product-Liability Claims and Rejects Its Use to Bar Construction-Services Negligence Absent Privity 1. Introduction In May v. First Rate...

State v. Martin (2025 S.D. 15) Commentary

Date: Mar 13, 2025

Sentencing Courts May Consider Uncharged Conduct Without Explicit “Preponderance” Findings When the Record Supports It and the Defendant Can Contest It 1. Introduction In State v. Martin, 2025 S.D....

Evidentiary Preservation and Due Process in Electronic Evidence: Precedent in State v. Rogers

Date: Mar 13, 2025

Evidentiary Preservation and Due Process in Electronic Evidence: Precedent in State v. Rogers The Supreme Court of South Dakota’s decision in State of South Dakota v. Dreau Lester Rogers (2025 S.D....

Equitable Abandonment of Restrictive Covenants: Voiding Enforcement in the Face of Pervasive Non-Compliance

Date: Mar 11, 2025

Equitable Abandonment of Restrictive Covenants: Voiding Enforcement in the Face of Pervasive Non-Compliance Introduction This commentary examines the seminal decision in Robert and Melissa Hood,...

Clarifying “Occupied” and Digital Evidence Authentication: A Landmark Decision in South Dakota Firearm Cases

Date: Mar 11, 2025

Clarifying “Occupied” and Digital Evidence Authentication: A Landmark Decision in South Dakota Firearm Cases Introduction In the case of State of South Dakota v. Lydelle Edmond Turner, the Supreme...

Redefining Vicinage and Jury District Composition: Gonzales v. Markland and the Proper Scope of “County or District” under the South Dakota Constitution

Date: Mar 6, 2025

Redefining Vicinage and Jury District Composition: Gonzales v. Markland and the Proper Scope of “County or District” under the South Dakota Constitution Introduction The case of Donika Rae Gonzales...

“Must Be Awarded” Means Mandatory: South Dakota DOH Must Issue Vacated Medical Cannabis Certificates to Next Lottery Waitlist Applicant Without Reapplication; Mandamus Lies for Agency Inaction Absent an Available Administrative Remedy

Date: Feb 20, 2025

“Must Be Awarded” Means Mandatory: South Dakota DOH Must Issue Vacated Medical Cannabis Certificates to Next Lottery Waitlist Applicant Without Reapplication; Mandamus Lies for Agency Inaction Absent...