South Dakota Case Commentaries

Per Diem Pain-and-Suffering Arguments Are Permissible—Subject to Trial Court Discretion: Weiland v. Bumann (2025 S.D. 9)

Date: Feb 20, 2025

Per Diem Pain-and-Suffering Arguments Are Permissible—Subject to Trial Court Discretion: Weiland v. Bumann (2025 S.D. 9) Introduction In Weiland v. Bumann, 2025 S.D. 9, the Supreme Court of South...

Refining Judicial Admissions: Clarifying Causation and Liability in Personal Injury Cases

Date: Feb 19, 2025

Refining Judicial Admissions: Clarifying Causation and Liability in Personal Injury Cases Introduction The case of Breyanna Geerdes v. Denise Likness, adjudicated by the Supreme Court of South Dakota...

Establishing Appellate Jurisdiction and Procedural Notice Requirements in Agricultural Lease Disputes: A Landmark Decision

Date: Feb 19, 2025

Establishing Appellate Jurisdiction and Procedural Notice Requirements in Agricultural Lease Disputes: A Landmark Decision Introduction The Supreme Court of South Dakota’s decision in "RONALD STOCK...

Extraordinary Relief in Probate Distributions: Reassessing Attorney Fiduciary Obligations Under Rule 60(b)(6)

Date: Feb 19, 2025

Extraordinary Relief in Probate Distributions: Reassessing Attorney Fiduciary Obligations Under Rule 60(b)(6) Introduction In this case, the Supreme Court of South Dakota considered an appeal...

Limiting Variance Grants: Ensuring Compliance with Statutory and Ordinance Requirements

Date: Feb 19, 2025

Limiting Variance Grants: Ensuring Compliance with Statutory and Ordinance Requirements Introduction In the case of GREG DECRAMER and PATRICIA DECRAMER v. ROD DORALE and MCCOOK COUNTY BOARD OF...

Clarifying Reemployment Assistance Liability: Redefining Employee vs. Independent Contractor Status Under SDCL 61-1-11

Date: Feb 19, 2025

Clarifying Reemployment Assistance Liability: Redefining Employee vs. Independent Contractor Status Under SDCL 61-1-11 Introduction The case of Black Hills Adventure Lodging, LLC v. South Dakota...

Expedited Procedures in Forcible Entry and Detainer (FED) Actions: Insights from VOR, Inc. v. Estate of Paul O'Farrell

Date: Feb 11, 2025

Expedited Procedures in Forcible Entry and Detainer (FED) Actions: Insights from VOR, Inc. v. Estate of Paul O'Farrell Introduction The case of VOR, Inc., and Grand Valley Hutterian Brethren, Inc. v....

Establishing Duty of Care: South Dakota Supreme Court Affirms Physicians' Limited Liability to Third Parties

Date: Feb 11, 2025

Establishing Duty of Care: South Dakota Supreme Court Affirms Physicians' Limited Liability to Third Parties Introduction In the case of LONNIE TWO EAGLE, SR., Plaintiff and Appellant versus AVEL...

Application of Residential Property Disclosure Statutes to Mixed-Use Real Estate Transactions

Date: Jan 3, 2025

Application of Residential Property Disclosure Statutes to Mixed-Use Real Estate Transactions Introduction The case of 2025 S.D. 1 v. Wild Bill's Campground and Resort, LLC, Keith Grimm addresses...

Strict Foundation Required for Business Records Admission: Braun v. Wollman

Date: Jan 1, 2025

Strict Foundation Required for Business Records Admission: Braun v. Wollman Introduction Samanta Braun vs. Radena Wollman is a pivotal case decided by the Supreme Court of South Dakota on December...

South Dakota Supreme Court Establishes Strict Adherence to SDCL 15-12 in Change of Judge Requests

Date: Dec 23, 2024

South Dakota Supreme Court Establishes Strict Adherence to SDCL 15-12 in Change of Judge Requests Introduction The case of The Estate of Paul O'Farrell v. Grand Valley Hutterian Brethren, Inc....

Strict Compliance Required for Notice of Appeal: Implications from Dittus v. Black Hills Care

Date: Dec 23, 2024

Strict Compliance Required for Notice of Appeal: Implications from Dittus v. Black Hills Care Introduction The case of Krista Dittus v. Black Hills Care and Rehabilitation Center, LLC, adjudicated by...

Implied Weight of DNA Evidence and Jury Instruction Standards in Sexual Assault Cases: Analysis of State v. Belt

Date: Dec 23, 2024

Implied Weight of DNA Evidence and Jury Instruction Standards in Sexual Assault Cases: Analysis of State v. Belt Introduction State of South Dakota v. William Charles Belt is a landmark case...

Supreme Court of South Dakota Establishes Clear Distinction Between Preliminary Breath Tests and Chemical Analyses in CDL Disqualification Cases

Date: Dec 18, 2024

Supreme Court of South Dakota Establishes Clear Distinction Between Preliminary Breath Tests and Chemical Analyses in CDL Disqualification Cases Introduction The case of Donald William Blazer v....

Clarifying Miranda Waiver and Right to Counsel: Insights from State v. Rudloff

Date: Dec 18, 2024

Clarifying Miranda Waiver and Right to Counsel: Insights from State v. Rudloff Introduction In the case of State of South Dakota v. Scott Martin Rudloff, decided by the Supreme Court of South Dakota...

Supreme Court of South Dakota Upholds At-Will Employment while Allowing Retaliation Claims to Proceed in Matta v. Dakota Provisions

Date: Dec 18, 2024

Supreme Court of South Dakota Upholds At-Will Employment while Allowing Retaliation Claims to Proceed in Matta v. Dakota Provisions Introduction In Angel Matta v. Dakota Provisions, the Supreme Court...

Declaratory Judgment as Legal Action in Contract Disputes: Analysis of CAL SD, LLC v. Interwest Leasing, LLC

Date: Dec 18, 2024

Declaratory Judgment as Legal Action in Contract Disputes: Analysis of CAL SD, LLC v. Interwest Leasing, LLC Introduction The case of CAL SD, LLC v. Interwest Leasing, LLC, decided by the Supreme...

South Dakota Supreme Court Limits Prosecutorial Discovery Obligations under Brady in State v. Antuna

Date: Dec 18, 2024

South Dakota Supreme Court Limits Prosecutorial Discovery Obligations under Brady in State v. Antuna Introduction In the landmark case of State of South Dakota v. Nathan Antuna, the Supreme Court of...

Supreme Court Upholds 75-Year Sentence in First-Degree Manslaughter Case: Implications for Eighth Amendment Analysis

Date: Dec 18, 2024

Supreme Court Upholds 75-Year Sentence in First-Degree Manslaughter Case: Implications for Eighth Amendment Analysis Introduction The Supreme Court of South Dakota, in the case of State of South...

State Court Authority in Parental Cooperation for Minor's Passport Applications: South Dakota Supreme Court Affirmation

Date: Dec 18, 2024

State Court Authority in Parental Cooperation for Minor's Passport Applications: South Dakota Supreme Court Affirmation Introduction The case of Nicholas E. Wasilk v. Heather L. Wasilk presents a...