Pennsylvania Case Commentaries

Probable Cause Standard for Pre-Complaint Discovery Established in McNEIL v. JORDAN

Date: Mar 22, 2006

Probable Cause Standard for Pre-Complaint Discovery Established in McNEIL v. JORDAN Introduction The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania, in the landmark case Henry McNeil, Jr., Appellant v. Barbara McNeil...

Clarifying the 'Newly Discovered Evidence' Exception under the Post Conviction Relief Act: Commonwealth v. Chester

Date: Mar 22, 2006

Clarifying the 'Newly Discovered Evidence' Exception under the Post Conviction Relief Act: Commonwealth v. Chester Introduction In the landmark case of Commonwealth v. Chester, the Supreme Court of...

Credibility Determinations in Workers' Compensation: Dorsey v. Workers' Compensation Appeal Board

Date: Feb 25, 2006

Credibility Determinations in Workers' Compensation: Dorsey v. Workers' Compensation Appeal Board Introduction The case Robert Dorsey v. Workers' Compensation Appeal Board (Crossing Construction...

Limitation on State Constitutional Remedies for Excessive Force: Jones v. City of Philadelphia

Date: Jan 26, 2006

No Separate Monetary Cause of Action for Excessive Force under Pennsylvania's Constitution Introduction Thomas Jones v. City of Philadelphia is a landmark case adjudicated by the Commonwealth Court...

Reaffirmation of the Bright-Line Rule for Waiver Under Pa.R.A.P. 1925(b) in Commonwealth v. Castillo

Date: Dec 30, 2005

Reaffirmation of the Bright-Line Rule for Waiver Under Pa.R.A.P. 1925(b) in Commonwealth v. Castillo Introduction Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Hector Castillo, 585 Pa. 395 (2005), represents a...

Strict Compliance with Pa.R.A.P. 1925(b) Ensures Fair Appellate Review: Insights from Commonwealth v. Schofield

Date: Dec 30, 2005

Strict Compliance with Pa.R.A.P. 1925(b) Ensures Fair Appellate Review: Insights from Commonwealth v. Schofield Introduction In Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Schofield, 585 Pa. 389 (2005), the...

Flexible Application of the Lamp Rule for Good Faith Efforts in Service of Process in McCreesh v. City of Philadelphia

Date: Dec 29, 2005

Flexible Application of the Lamp Rule for Good Faith Efforts in Service of Process in McCreesh v. City of Philadelphia Introduction Charles F. McCreesh initiated a civil action against the City of...

Reinforcing Traditional Standing Requirements in Constitutional Challenges: Insights from Pittsburgh Palisades Park, LLC v. Commonwealth of Pennsylvania

Date: Dec 29, 2005

Reinforcing Traditional Standing Requirements in Constitutional Challenges: Insights from Pittsburgh Palisades Park, LLC v. Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Introduction The case of Pittsburgh Palisades...

Establishing Duty of Care in State Negligence Claims Against Fundraising Entities: R.W. and C.W. v. Fundraising Entities

Date: Dec 29, 2005

Establishing Duty of Care in State Negligence Claims Against Fundraising Entities Introduction In the landmark case of R.W. and C.W., Indi v. dually and as the Parents and Natural Guardians of L.W.,...

Interpretation of Section 511.2(1) of the Pennsylvania Workers' Compensation Act: Mandatory Timing Requirements for IRE Requests

Date: Dec 29, 2005

Interpretation of Section 511.2(1) of the Pennsylvania Workers' Compensation Act: Mandatory Timing Requirements for IRE Requests Introduction The case of Gardner v. Workers' Compensation Appeal Board...

Distinguishing Ineffective Assistance of Counsel Claims under Pennsylvania’s Post-Conviction Relief Act

Date: Dec 28, 2005

Distinguishing Ineffective Assistance of Counsel Claims under Pennsylvania’s Post-Conviction Relief Act Introduction In the landmark case of Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Ronald Collins, decided on...

Offensive Application of Collateral Estoppel in Disciplinary Proceedings: Analysis of Office of Disciplinary Counsel v. Kiesewetter

Date: Dec 28, 2005

Offensive Application of Collateral Estoppel in Disciplinary Proceedings: Analysis of Office of Disciplinary Counsel v. William B. Kiesewetter, Jr. Introduction The case of Office of Disciplinary...

Reaffirming the Strict Timeliness of PCRA Petitions: COMMONWEALTH v. WHARTON

Date: Nov 29, 2005

Reaffirming the Strict Timeliness of PCRA Petitions: COMMONWEALTH v. WHARTON Introduction Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Robert Wharton, 584 Pa. 576 (2005), is a pivotal case adjudicated by the...

MVFRL Section 1714 Bars First-Party Benefit Recovery for Registered but Uninsured Vehicle Owners

Date: Sep 30, 2005

MVFRL Section 1714 Bars First-Party Benefit Recovery for Registered but Uninsured Vehicle Owners Swords v. Harleysville Insurance Companies, 584 Pa. 382 (2005) Introduction The case of Wayne Swords...

Enhancing Protections Against Employer Retaliation: Rothrock v. Rothrock Motor Sales

Date: Sep 29, 2005

Enhancing Protections Against Employer Retaliation: Rothrock v. Rothrock Motor Sales Introduction The case of Theodore C. Rothrock and Douglas Rothrock, Appellees v. Rothrock Motor Sales, Inc.,...

Statutory Construction in Successive Amendments and Predicate Conviction Requirements: Insights from Commonwealth v. Magliocco

Date: Sep 29, 2005

Statutory Construction in Successive Amendments and Predicate Conviction Requirements: Insights from Commonwealth v. Magliocco Introduction Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Eric J. Magliocco, decided...

PHILLIPS v. CRICKET LIGHTERS: Clarifying Implied Warranty and Punitive Damages in Product Liability

Date: Sep 29, 2005

PHILLIPS v. CRICKET LIGHTERS: Clarifying Implied Warranty and Punitive Damages in Product Liability Introduction PHILLIPS v. CRICKET LIGHTERS is a landmark case decided by the Supreme Court of...

Affirmation of Dual Prosecution Under Catastrophe Risk Statutes in Commonwealth v. Karetny

Date: Aug 16, 2005

Affirmation of Dual Prosecution Under Catastrophe Risk Statutes in Commonwealth v. Karetny Introduction Case: Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Eli Karetny, Michael Asbell Court: Supreme Court of...

Sequential Application of Pennsylvania's Three Strikes Law: Commonwealth v. Shiffler

Date: Jul 23, 2005

Sequential Application of Pennsylvania's Three Strikes Law: Commonwealth v. Shiffler Introduction Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Albert S. Shiffler (583 Pa. 478), adjudicated by the Supreme Court of...

Broad Interpretation of 'Collapse' in Insurance Policies: Affirmation in 401 Fourth Street, Inc. v. Investors Insurance Group

Date: Jul 21, 2005

Broad Interpretation of 'Collapse' in Insurance Policies: Affirmation in 401 Fourth Street, Inc. v. Investors Insurance Group Introduction The case 401 Fourth Street, Inc. v. Investors Insurance...