Pennsylvania Case Commentaries

Clarification on After-Discovered Evidence: Non-Cumulative Evidence May Warrant a New Trial – Commonwealth v. Small

Date: Jul 19, 2018

Clarification on After-Discovered Evidence: Non-Cumulative Evidence May Warrant a New Trial Case: Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Eric Eugene Small Court: Supreme Court of Pennsylvania, Middle...

Strict Adherence to Preliminary Injunction Standards in Environmental Regulation Enforcement

Date: Jun 2, 2018

Strict Adherence to Preliminary Injunction Standards in Environmental Regulation Enforcement Introduction The case of The Marcellus Shale Coalition (MSC) v. Department of Environmental Protection...

Affidavit Errors and Probable Cause: Analysis of Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Leed

Date: Jun 2, 2018

Affidavit Errors and Probable Cause: Analysis of Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Leed Introduction Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Eric Jay Leed, Appellate Case 186 A.3d 405, adjudicated by the...

Separate Notices of Appeal Required for Orders Affecting Multiple Dockets: Analysis of Commonwealth v. Walker

Date: Jun 2, 2018

Separate Notices of Appeal Required for Orders Affecting Multiple Dockets: Analysis of Commonwealth v. Walker Introduction In Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Walker, the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania...

Reaffirming Warrant Requirement for Warrantless Cell Phone Searches: Commonwealth v. Fulton

Date: Feb 22, 2018

Reaffirming Warrant Requirement for Warrantless Cell Phone Searches: Commonwealth v. Fulton Introduction In the landmark case Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. I. Dean Fulton (179 A.3d 475), decided on...

League of Women Voters of Pennsylvania v. Commonwealth of Pennsylvania: Upholding the Free and Equal Elections Clause Against Partisan Gerrymandering

Date: Feb 8, 2018

League of Women Voters of Pennsylvania v. Commonwealth of Pennsylvania: Upholding the Free and Equal Elections Clause Against Partisan Gerrymandering Introduction In the landmark case League of Women...

Disbarment for Judicial Misconduct: The Pozonsky Case

Date: Jan 19, 2018

Disbarment for Judicial Misconduct: The Pozonsky Case Introduction In Office of Disciplinary Counsel v. Paul Michael Pozonsky (177 A.3d 830), the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania addressed a severe...

Right to Counsel During Neuropsychological Examinations: Shearer v. Hafer Establishes New Precedent

Date: Jan 19, 2018

Right to Counsel During Neuropsychological Examinations: Shearer v. Hafer Establishes New Precedent Introduction Shearer v. Hafer, 177 A.3d 850 (Pa. 2018), is a pivotal case decided by the Supreme...

Affirmation of Procedural Standards in PCRA Petition Dismissal

Date: Jan 12, 2018

Affirmation of Procedural Standards in PCRA Petition Dismissal Introduction In Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Ernest Wholaver Jr., 177 A.3d 136 (Pa. Sup. Ct. 2018), the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania...

Limiting the Automobile Exception: Warrantless Seizure of Vehicles from Residential Driveways in Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Loughnane (2017)

Date: Nov 23, 2017

Limiting the Automobile Exception: Warrantless Seizure of Vehicles from Residential Driveways in Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Loughnane (2017) Introduction In Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v....

Severability and Uniformity in Corporate Tax Law: Insights from Nextel Communications v. Commonwealth of Pennsylvania

Date: Oct 19, 2017

Severability and Uniformity in Corporate Tax Law: Insights from Nextel Communications v. Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Introduction In Nextel Communications of the Mid-Atlantic, Inc. v. Commonwealth...

Limitations on PCRA's Newly-Recognized Constitutional Right Exception in State Sentencing: Commonwealth v. Spotz

Date: Oct 19, 2017

Limitations on PCRA's Newly-Recognized Constitutional Right Exception in State Sentencing: Commonwealth v. Spotz Introduction The case of Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Mark Newton Spotz, decided by...

Commonwealth v. Jacoby: Establishing Reliability and Admissibility Standards for Y-STR DNA Evidence in Pennsylvania

Date: Sep 29, 2017

Commonwealth v. Jacoby: Establishing Reliability and Admissibility Standards for Y-STR DNA Evidence in Pennsylvania Introduction Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Timothy Matthew Jacoby is a landmark...

Clarifying Bad Faith Insurance Claims: Two-Pronged Test without Motive Requirement Under 42 Pa.C.S. §8371

Date: Sep 29, 2017

Clarifying Bad Faith Insurance Claims: Two-Pronged Test without Motive Requirement Under 42 Pa.C.S. §8371 Introduction The case of Matthew Rancosky, Administrator DBN of the Estate of Leann Rancosky...

Suppressing Evidence as Fruit of the Poisonous Tree: Insights from Commonwealth v. Shabezz

Date: Jul 20, 2017

Suppressing Evidence as Fruit of the Poisonous Tree: Insights from Commonwealth v. Shabezz Introduction Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Saleem Shabezz, 166 A.3d 278 (Pa. 2017), is a landmark decision...

Pennsylvania Supreme Court Rules SORNA's Retroactive Registration Unconstitutional under Ex Post Facto Clauses

Date: Jul 20, 2017

Pennsylvania Supreme Court Rules SORNA's Retroactive Registration Unconstitutional under Ex Post Facto Clauses Introduction In the landmark case of Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Jose M. Muniz, the...

Exclusive Jurisdiction of Section 7766 Over Section 7740.1 in Trustee Removal

Date: Jul 20, 2017

Exclusive Jurisdiction of Section 7766 Over Section 7740.1 in Trustee Removal Introduction In the case of Trust Under Agreement of Edward Winslow Taylor Appeal of: Wells Fargo Bank, the Supreme Court...

Presumption Against Life Without Parole for Juvenile Offenders: Commonwealth v. Batts

Date: Jun 27, 2017

Presumption Against Life Without Parole for Juvenile Offenders: Commonwealth v. Batts Introduction Case: Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, Appellee v. Qu'eed Batts, Appellant Court: Supreme Court of...

Environmental Trust and Public Resource Management: Insights from PENNSYLVANIA ENVIRONMENTAL DEFENSE FOUNDATION v. COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA

Date: Jun 21, 2017

Environmental Trust and Public Resource Management: Insights from PENNSYLVANIA ENVIRONMENTAL DEFENSE FOUNDATION v. COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA Introduction The case of PENNSYLVANIA ENVIRONMENTAL...

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania Upholds Act 111: Limits on Home Rule Charters in Collective Bargaining

Date: May 23, 2017

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania Upholds Act 111: Limits on Home Rule Charters in Collective Bargaining Introduction The landmark case City of Pittsburgh, Appellee v. Fraternal Order of Police, Fort...