Oregon Case Commentaries

“Dwelling” for Home-Occupation Permits Must Independently Qualify as an Allowed Category of Dwelling in the Zone – Friends of Yamhill County v. Yamhill County (373 Or 790)

Date: Jul 5, 2025

“Dwelling” for Home-Occupation Permits Must Independently Qualify as an Allowed Category of Dwelling in the Zone – Friends of Yamhill County v. Yamhill County, 373 Or 790 (2025) 1. Introduction In...

Crosbie v. Asante: Remand-Scope Orders Are Not Immediately Appealable under ORS 19.205(3)

Date: Jun 30, 2025

Crosbie v. Asante: Remand-Scope Orders Are Not Immediately Appealable under ORS 19.205(3) 1. Introduction In Crosbie v. Asante, 373 Or 773 (2025), the Oregon Supreme Court confronted a recurring...

The Burton Rule: Defense Counsel’s Latitude to Emphasize the Absence of Testimony in Closing Argument

Date: Jun 30, 2025

The Burton Rule: Defense Counsel’s Latitude to Emphasize the Absence of Testimony in Closing Argument Introduction In State v. Burton, 373 Or 750 (2025), the Oregon Supreme Court clarified the...

State v. Worsham: Plain-Error Limits on Unrequested Supplemental Jury Instructions

Date: Jun 30, 2025

State v. Worsham (373 Or 739, 2025): Plain-Error Limits on Unrequested Supplemental Jury Instructions Introduction State v. Worsham presented the Supreme Court of Oregon with a deceptively narrow...

Stipulating ‘Court May Impose’ Consecutive Sentences: Resolving Ambiguities in Oregon Plea Agreements

Date: Jun 10, 2025

Stipulating ‘Court May Impose’ Consecutive Sentences: Resolving Ambiguities in Oregon Plea Agreements Introduction In State of Oregon v. James Clare Walsh IV (373 Or 712, June 5, 2025), the Oregon...

“The Walsh Protocol”: Judicial Duties When a Plea Agreement Is Ambiguous at Sentencing

Date: Jun 4, 2025

“The Walsh Protocol”: Judicial Duties When a Plea Agreement Is Ambiguous at Sentencing Introduction State v. Walsh, 373 Or 714 (2025), confronts a recurring but seldom-resolved problem: what must a...

Tenant’s Statutory Right to Cure Violations under ORS 90.392: Mandatory Notice Requirement

Date: May 16, 2025

Tenant’s Statutory Right to Cure Violations under ORS 90.392: Mandatory Notice Requirement Introduction KKMH Properties, LLC v. Shire, 373 Or 676 (2025), is a residential eviction case decided by the...

Plain-Error Review of Prosecutorial Jury Argument: Clarifying the Chitwood Framework in State v. Perez

Date: May 2, 2025

Plain-Error Review of Prosecutorial Jury Argument: Clarifying the Chitwood Framework in State v. Perez Introduction State v. Perez, 373 Or 591 (2025), is the Oregon Supreme Court’s latest guidance on...

Limitation of the Article I, Section 11 Right to Counsel to Formal Charges: Precharging Interrogation Excluded—State v. Kilby

Date: May 2, 2025

Limitation of the Article I, Section 11 Right to Counsel to Formal Charges: Precharging Interrogation Excluded—State v. Kilby Introduction In State of Oregon v. Randall Richard Kilby (373 Or 557, May...

Expanding “Wrongful Taking” under ORS 124.110(1)(a): Improper Motive, Improper Means and Elder Abuse Liability

Date: May 2, 2025

Expanding “Wrongful Taking” under ORS 124.110(1)(a): Improper Motive, Improper Means and Elder Abuse Liability 1. Introduction Adelsperger v. Elkside Development LLC, 373 Or 621 (2025), arises from a...

State v. Lee: Statutory Prohibition of Anticipatory Warrants Under ORS 133.545(6)

Date: Apr 25, 2025

State v. Lee: Statutory Prohibition of Anticipatory Warrants Under ORS 133.545(6) Introduction In State v. Lee, 373 Or 555 (2025), the Supreme Court of Oregon considered whether Oregon’s statutory...

State v. Akins: Permitting Delayed-Disclosure Expert Testimony and Child-Declarant Hearsay Exception under OEC 803(18a)(b)

Date: Apr 18, 2025

State v. Akins: Permitting Delayed-Disclosure Expert Testimony and Child-Declarant Hearsay Exception under OEC 803(18a)(b) Introduction State v. Akins, 373 Or 506 (2025), is a decision of the Supreme...

Tortious Basis Required for “Accident” Under CGL Policies: Twigg v. Admiral Insurance Co.

Date: Apr 18, 2025

Tortious Basis Required for “Accident” Under CGL Policies: Twigg v. Admiral Insurance Co. Introduction Twigg v. Admiral Insurance Company is a 2025 decision of the Supreme Court of Oregon that...

Community Workforce Agreements as “Rules”: ODOT Must Follow Oregon APA Notice-and-Comment Procedures

Date: Apr 11, 2025

Community Workforce Agreements as “Rules”: ODOT Must Follow Oregon APA Notice-and-Comment Procedures Introduction This case, Oregon-Columbia Chapter AGC of America v. Department of Transportation...

Ensuring Valid Waiver of Right to Counsel: New Remand Standard in State v. Cotter

Date: Apr 11, 2025

Ensuring Valid Waiver of Right to Counsel: New Remand Standard in State v. Cotter Introduction State v. Cotter, 373 Or 381 (2025), is a landmark decision by the Supreme Court of Oregon concerning a...

Clarifying the Contribution Bar under ORS 465.480(4)(a): Settlement of the Same Environmental Claim Required to Extinguish Contribution Rights

Date: Apr 11, 2025

Clarifying the Contribution Bar under ORS 465.480(4)(a): Settlement of the Same Environmental Claim Required to Extinguish Contribution Rights Introduction Continental Casualty Co. v. Argonaut Ins....

Director-Approved Language Determines Insurers’ Compliance with ORS 746.290(2)

Date: Apr 4, 2025

Director-Approved Language Determines Insurers’ Compliance with ORS 746.290(2) 1. Introduction This commentary examines the Oregon Supreme Court’s decision in Bellshaw v. Farmers Insurance Company of...

Premium-Price and Illegal-Product UTPA Theories Free from Reliance Requirement – Bohr v. Tillamook County Creamery

Date: Apr 4, 2025

Premium-Price and Illegal-Product UTPA Theories Free from Reliance Requirement – Bohr v. Tillamook County Creamery Introduction In Bohr v. Tillamook County Creamery Assn., 373 Or 343 (2025), the...

Gilbert / March v. Dept. of Energy: Jurisdiction and Contested Case Standards for Amending Energy Facility Site Certificates

Date: Mar 28, 2025

Gilbert / March v. Dept. of Energy: Jurisdiction and Contested Case Standards for Amending Energy Facility Site Certificates Introduction In Gilbert / March v. Department of Energy, 373 Or 289...

Clarifying Double Jeopardy Protections in Indistinct Indictments: Oregon Supreme Court's Decision in State v. Dodge

Date: Jan 23, 2025

Clarifying Double Jeopardy Protections in Indistinct Indictments: Oregon Supreme Court's Decision in State of Oregon v. Dodge Introduction In the landmark case of State of Oregon v. Darron Duane...